Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is renting a complete waste of money?!

69 replies

shelly101x · 24/07/2022 19:01

I’m 25 and now living with my parents. I was living with my ex but we split up recently. Thing is, I really value my own space and really dream of living somewhere alone.

However in my area a decent 1 bedroom flat is at least £900/£1000 a month and then bills/food on top of that. It’s extortionate. However I am nowhere near ready to buy (I only have about 5k saved) and I don’t want to get in a relationship anytime soon, so buying/joining a mortgage is no option right now.
I earn about £2200 a month so I can afford it but I’d be saving next to nothing.

I just don’t know if it’s worth it or not…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ConsuelaHammock · 25/07/2022 19:15

Stay at home until you have a deposit. If you really want your own place.

HernamewasMary · 25/07/2022 18:29

I chose to rent and get repairs dealt with by someone else rather than buy leaving no money to do anything to the house but then I am nearing retirement. Pros and cons either way

Dreamstate · 25/07/2022 11:14

I would be doing some serious saving and I mean serious as in right back to bare minimum to spend so I could save as much as possible. I was in your situation and I was on £1800 and I saved £1500 a month. Leaving me £300 to cover rent (£100) phone (£20) and gym (£20) and rest for whatever spending. Meant I was only living with my parents max 2yrs and had enough to also buy furniture without having to save up. So stay for 1-3yrs or however long it takes to save up what you need including some basic furniture and appliances because this is the best time and only time you'll be able to save so much money.

The more you save the quicker it'll be so save hard

Butteryflakycrust83 · 25/07/2022 10:52

No, its not a waste of money. BUT. Do you want to move out?

Sometimes the independence in itself justifies paying rent.

If you are happy at home and committed to saving, I would be throwing as much as I could into a savings account now with a clear goal in mind.

RewildingAmbridge · 25/07/2022 10:32

When i graduated I moved home, worked full time and had a second job in a restaurant (tips are a great addition if you work somewhere that attracts them).
Saved like mad for two years and bought a flat.

Tinkerblonde1 · 25/07/2022 10:30

Misslola1999 · 25/07/2022 08:30

I've done both.
Had no choice but to leave a mortgaged house and now I rent.
To be honest I prefer renting. So far I've had a broken boiler and leaking washing machine that flooded the kitchen. So new washer and flooring in the kitchen.
None of which cost me a penny because I rent. If I still lived in my mortgaged house I would have the spare cash to replace.
So in my circumstances renting is ideal

Which is fine in the interim when we are younger and not rich and I do know a mortgage is initially interest only. But your rent payment could pay for that boiler or floor several times over. Though sadly lots do not have any choice which I understand.

However this is just my situation. I know rent is more expensive elsewhere.

House 200k mortgage.

Mortgage( 3.5 percent ) could be cheaper.
£1000 pcm. Total repayment circa £300k. At the end of 25 years. I am 100k down but maybe not as the house price will have increased. Now my £1000 is my own to spend.

Renting in same street. £800 pcm. Over 25 year period, not accounting for price increase, thats £240k. At the end of 25 years I am 240k down and I need to still pay rent.

I understand its a privilege so if you can then buy op.

HalfBrick · 25/07/2022 10:27

Don't rent if you don't need to. In your situation (and age) I'd work my day job, save like mad and probably get an evening job in a pub/cinema/restaurant to 1. get that deposit quicker and 2. get away from my parents of an evening!

Ebonyhorse · 25/07/2022 10:19

You’ll never be able to save as much as you are able to living at home and working. Suck it up now and you’ll be so happy you did when you buy your first place.

shootfromthehip145 · 25/07/2022 10:19

Misslola1999 · 25/07/2022 08:30

I've done both.
Had no choice but to leave a mortgaged house and now I rent.
To be honest I prefer renting. So far I've had a broken boiler and leaking washing machine that flooded the kitchen. So new washer and flooring in the kitchen.
None of which cost me a penny because I rent. If I still lived in my mortgaged house I would have the spare cash to replace.
So in my circumstances renting is ideal

Sorry I'm struggling to understand where you are coming from with this post. If your washer breaks and ruins your floor this would usually come under contents insurance which you should have as both a renter and home owner. Landlords will usually cover Buildings insurance which is different. Many rentals are not furnished also so the cost will be on the renter, in these circumstances.

Also with boilers etc. are cover with boiler and central heating cover is only like £5-7 a month hardly anything to boast about not having to pay any more.

Tinkerblonde1 · 25/07/2022 10:17

Ebonyhorse · 25/07/2022 10:00

Renting is fine when you’re young but what do you do in old age? I’m in London, one of my mum’s friends is paying £1400 a month rent and is nearly 70, she’s exhausted and wants to retire but can’t.

That was my worry. I see some advantages of renting but what about long term.

SarahSissions · 25/07/2022 10:14

I’d knuckle down and hardcore save for 18 months and live with parents. If you want your own space it’s fine to rent, but you can’t moan in 2 years time that you still aren’t in a position to buy. The middle ground would be to rent in a house share and maybe have room mates who are less intrusive than family but you’d be there for a little longer.

Blossomtoes · 25/07/2022 10:12

If you can't do that why not stay at your parents' and claim overcrowding and get a council home that is cheap, permanent, and secure?

😂😂😂😂😂

Swizandswap · 25/07/2022 10:10

Ggu · 24/07/2022 21:04

Yes it is, you are paying someone else's life or mortgage.

Why does no one ever say this about going to the pub?

Quite simply going to the pub is a choice, needing some where to live is not. 🙄

DenholmElliot1 · 25/07/2022 10:09

luxxlisbon · 24/07/2022 19:10

You should be saving at least the equivalent £1000 a month while living at home and you can put that towards a deposit.

This!

BarbaraofSeville · 25/07/2022 10:06

If you're over state pension age, you're entitled to help with housing costs if you rent and don't have £16k in savings @Ebonyhorse

Has your DMs friend done a benefit check to see what help she'd be entitled to if she did stop working?

She'll have her state pension, workplace pension(?) and likely some benefits on top.

If it's not enough, she needs to think about whether she can move somewhere less expensive because on the surface it looks like she's continuing to work to pay to live in an expensive location, so if she really wants to stop work, she probably can, but she might not be able to afford to continue to live where she does.

Ebonyhorse · 25/07/2022 10:00

Renting is fine when you’re young but what do you do in old age? I’m in London, one of my mum’s friends is paying £1400 a month rent and is nearly 70, she’s exhausted and wants to retire but can’t.

LIZS · 25/07/2022 08:35

It would be cheaper to flatshare a two or three bed and split bills. With renting you don't have same maintenance costs as owning.

Misslola1999 · 25/07/2022 08:30

I've done both.
Had no choice but to leave a mortgaged house and now I rent.
To be honest I prefer renting. So far I've had a broken boiler and leaking washing machine that flooded the kitchen. So new washer and flooring in the kitchen.
None of which cost me a penny because I rent. If I still lived in my mortgaged house I would have the spare cash to replace.
So in my circumstances renting is ideal

TheLoftHatch · 25/07/2022 08:26

Well it sort of is a waste, but for many it's their only choice! If you are completely desperate to move, you could look into shared ownership but if not, I'd stay right where you are and save, save, save.

BarbaraofSeville · 25/07/2022 07:20

Renting a 'decent 1 bed flat' in your circumstances is a luxury and only you can decide whether it's worth the money to you. If you want to live alone would a studio in a slightly cheaper area cost significantly less? Bills would be lower too.

Or you could plan to stay with your parents for a couple of years and save like mad, with your current savings, LISA bonus and interest, you could see your deposit grow to nearly 10 times what it is now and you'd be in a great position to buy.

Due to worries about inflation and rising interest rates etc it's probably a bad time to buy right now. If there was a property price downturn, you'd literally see your hard saved deposit evaporate and you could even be in negative equity, but once prices have stabilised at a lower level, you'd be in a really good position to buy.

sjxoxo · 25/07/2022 07:00

In your situation I’d stay at home as long as possible and work like a dog to save a deposit. Don’t throw your money down the drain for some indépendance now; because if you get stuck renting long term because you don’t have a deposit it will be the opposite of freedom. Think long term & save save save xxx

Tumbleweed101 · 25/07/2022 06:59

I rent a council property so the rent is reasonable, the tenancy is secure and I get repairs on the bigger and structural stuff done by the council.

In my situation I don’t consider renting dead money. I’ve never been in a position to buy as my income level is too low and I am a single parent.

Private rental is a different thing. I think it’s considered dead money because of the lack of security around the tenancy. You are never able to feel like you can make it a long term home.

In your situation you need to balance independence against the chance to save. Personally I think you need to start life at some point away from home. My adult daughter is staying with me to save but is getting frustrated at the lack of private space for her and her boyfriend without me and her siblings having our own things to do in the house.

Tinkerblonde1 · 25/07/2022 06:56

I have been in your situation and had to move back in with my parents after I splt with my daughters Dad.

I remember writing a similar post on Money saving expert a few years ago.

I stayed there nearly 4 years but I am currently typing from my own home. I thought I would only ever be able to afford a 2 bed terrace with a yard but I actually have a 3 bed semi with a huge garden thanks to those 4 years and my parents.

At the time it felt like a life time. But it actually passed surprisingly quickly. Some days it felt like I wasn't getting anywhere and I was constantly looking at rentals on Right move. My parents are lovely people but my Mother can be controlling and often undermined me with my child which was hard. Other times it was great as I had a live in baby sitter and it allowed me to progress in my career. I think we had about 6 major arguments which we laugh about now.
It was hard not being able to cook when I wanted and the lack of fridge space. Loada of other niggles. Like 500 questions a day. Even my daughter said at age 6. Grandma and Grandpa ask so many questions.

If I had to do it again,I would absolutely think I made the right choice. Looking at the house I have now and security for my daughter. I would save more in hindsight as I wasted a lot on takeaways and a few breaks away. My parents are amazing and I am grateful to them.
If I rented I would probably be in debt. Not have enough money for any treats and not be able to decorate how I have.
Definitely grit your teeth and dig in. Unless of course as a pp says there is any abuse but that doesn't seem like the case.

MushMonster · 25/07/2022 06:54

Stay with your parents and save for your own home. Do not buy anything too expensive. The mortgage should be around a third of your income, not half.

pinkfondu · 25/07/2022 06:54

Save the money you would spend on renting somewhere and stay put. It will be worth it. You'll never have the opportunity to save like this if you move out.