Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For thinking SAHMs are making themselves financially vulnerable

655 replies

PeasOff · 24/07/2022 18:25

Would or do you depend on your partner financially?

Do you have a backup in place in case of breakup or for your retirement?

OP posts:
MrsBwced · 26/07/2022 21:47

Oh behave.
I am.

Alarming my arse.

Its entirely reasonable to question why people stop caring about control and precious time they can't get back when the kid hits school age.

Its not about the child's development which obviously changes as they grow but why attitudes around parenting change so much
I don't think it's that they stop caring or the time with their child is less precious! Although you must admit they change far more quickly when they're little.

It's the law that children have to have a full time education, reasonably easy for most people to provide at home for younger children but I imagine not many parents feel confident they could provide that at home for older children. If they want to get a place at school it's easier to get them in from the start.
I do think it can also be to do with development. As I said two of mine probably wouldn't have settled in a busy childcare setting but pretty much had grown out of that by the time they were due to start school. By that stage they were ready for friendships and peer to peer learning etc, things that I couldn't necessarily provide at home.

Kids need more time and input as they get older, ime, not less.
Totally agree with this. One of the benefits to me staying at home with my younger ones is that I had lots of time with my older ones.

Topgub · 26/07/2022 21:12

@MrsBwced

Oh behave.

Alarming my arse.

Its entirely reasonable to question why people stop caring about control and precious time they can't get back when the kid hits school age.

Its not about the child's development which obviously changes as they grow but why attitudes around parenting change so much

Kids need more time and input as they get older, ime, not less.

MrsBwced · 26/07/2022 21:06

No I'm not.

I've literally not said anything about what other people do in regards to childcare.

I asked why pre school age and not after and said I didn't need total control.

Well you kinda are. Given the topic is about SAHM.
You know those other people, who stay at home to provide care for their children.
The ones you've posted repeatedly about.

Including the poster who said they'd tried a CM and decided it wasn't for them as they wanted more control.

As a parent and someone who has worked in a nursery it's quite alarming you don't recognise that a baby might have different needs to a school aged child.

Mamai90 · 26/07/2022 21:05

I do have a fall back. But even if I didn't I wholeheartedly trust my DH, he is a good person and even if I didn't have a back up it wouldn't matter, I'd still make the same choice. Time with my baby is more important to me than my career, a job is a job but I waited years to become a mother and I don't want to waste this precious time.

The negativity that SAHPs get on here is excessive. I've genuinely never come across it in my career nor has anyone ever questioned my choice to stay at home.

My mum was an accountant who took a career break between my sister and I. She went back to work when I was 6 months old and says she still feels guilty now even almost 40 years on. The thing is her choice to go back to work has left me in a position that I don't have to as her and my dad had well paid careers and made good investments.

I really don't see why people don't mind their own business, I couldn't give a shiny shite what other parents decide to do, their decisions don't impact my life in any way. I'm sure they have the mental capacity to weigh up the pros and cons and then make a decision.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 26/07/2022 20:56

I was, for some years.

Our finances were always joint, though, still are, and we’ve been married for a very long time.

Topgub · 26/07/2022 20:53

@MrsBwced

No I'm not.

I've literally not said anything about what other people do in regards to childcare.

I asked why pre school age and not after and said I didn't need total control.

MrsBwced · 26/07/2022 20:51

Topgub · 26/07/2022 20:17

@MrsBwced

Aww, c'mon!

Using a nursery or childminder doesn't mean you don't even have a degree of control over your children's upbringing

Ffs

Your the one arguing with people who want more control over their own children's care.

SglodionPysgod · 26/07/2022 20:49

@edel2 I think PP raises a fair point. A lot more men run off with (younger) women. A lot more men financially abuse their partners, try to control their partner and abuse their partners in general.

You only have to read a few threads on here to illustrate how many men do whatever it takes to get out of paying or pay minimal child maintenance. You only have to read a few threads to find a couple of men who let their wives have no access to family finances. Of course it’s Mumsnet so the data is going to be skewed but it’s scary how often these topics come up.

Some women are arses yes, but we can’t compete with men in that respect!

I don’t hate men, I am married to one whom I believe to be honest and kind. I still appreciate that I need a back up plan though.

edel2 · 26/07/2022 20:24

Bowtique · 24/07/2022 19:08

I really don’t get it either.

So many marriages break down, so many men are arses.

I also think women (& men) need educating as to what the workplace looks like after you’ve taken 5,10 years out. IME people think they can take a ‘career’ break to be a SAHM. Intending to go back and telling their DP they’ll go back and contribute financially to the family pot again. Lovely in theory but getting back into most careers is nigh on impossible as skills and tech moves on.

"So many men are arses" - some women are too, surely?!!!! It is NOT always the man's fault that a marriage breaks down.....my God!!!!!!

TartanGirl1 · 26/07/2022 20:22

blueshoes · 26/07/2022 19:03

A few posters mentioned well paid jobs that women can walk back into even after a break of more than a few years.

Can someone elaborate because they would be good jobs for dds to go into.

Considering stats show how many people struggle to get back into the workplace after a career break it is quite impressive!

Topgub · 26/07/2022 20:17

@MrsBwced

Aww, c'mon!

Using a nursery or childminder doesn't mean you don't even have a degree of control over your children's upbringing

Ffs

MrsBwced · 26/07/2022 20:15

@Topgub
I worked in nurseries. I do have experience of them.
Not of using them for your own child though.

It read to me like pp had decided she needed that control without even using childcare. It wasn't a reaction to a problem in childcare
Perhaps we're thinking of a different poster. I thought you were replying to the one who wrote
I planned to return to work, had some practice runs with a childminder, and realised I simply didn't want to do it...
Either way I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting some degree of control over your child's upbringing.

Topgub · 26/07/2022 19:34

@SglodionPysgod

Or if they stopped viewing it as a cost against the woman's wage.

Or as an unnecessary expense.

No one ever says, oh, the mortgage is more than my wage but dh can pay for all bills on his own anyway

It makes absolutely no sense

SglodionPysgod · 26/07/2022 19:32

For many people (myself included) the ‘wages would be less than childcare issue’ could be negated if people waited slightly more than the socially acceptable norm of 2-3 years between children. There are pros to having 2 close together (especially if there is advanced maternal age) but there are also pros to having a bigger gap. These aren’t widely talked about, having 2 close together is presented as aspirational.

Nursery is very expensive, that’s a widely known fact but for most (not all, there will always be exceptions) childcare costs go down substantially once DC1 is in full time school aged 4. I have a 5 year gap for this reason and I am an absolute outlier among my peers.

Mynotsoperfectlittlefamily · 26/07/2022 19:19

I am a SAHM. realistically extremely vulnerable position financially. However childcare would outstrip my wage by hundreds a month. I cannot afford to return to work whilst my children are young. My earning capability is 1300 possibly 1400 a month childcare would be over 2000. Its quite simple math for some SAHMs. I volunteer for a charity, I volunteer in the community and I volunteer in the PTFA, and I attend college to keep skills up to date. I am financially dependent on my husband who will die a significant amount of time before me if I don't get a terminal illness. But life is life got to do what we got to do.

blueshoes · 26/07/2022 19:03

A few posters mentioned well paid jobs that women can walk back into even after a break of more than a few years.

Can someone elaborate because they would be good jobs for dds to go into.

Topgub · 26/07/2022 18:37

@MrsBwced

I worked in nurseries. I do have experience of them.

It read to me like pp had decided she needed that control without even using childcare. It wasn't a reaction to a problem in childcare

MrsBwced · 26/07/2022 18:19

But regardless what would you need/want more control just up to school age?
I suppose there's lots of reasons.
My Sister and her DH changed their working hours and pulled DN1 out of nursery because the nursery wanted him to drop his nap and not have a dummy.
I'm pretty confident one probably two of my DC would have hated nursery. They didn't enjoy being around lots of other children or lots of noise etc, hated toddler groups and school nursery at three.
By 4/5 they were really different and both settled at school really well. Children do grow up so what they might need at 2 isn't what they need for the rest or their lives!

We did always plan to share childcare. Thats why didn't need paid childcare. But if we had, we'd have had no issue using it.
If you didn't have to use it how do you know there'd have been no issues?
It's a bit off to be questioning others who tried it and decided it wasn't for them when you've had no experience of it.

Snoredoeurve · 26/07/2022 18:05

Darbs76 · 26/07/2022 17:05

I guess many women are prepared to take the risk. I personally wouldn’t put myself in a vulnerable position of having no income, no pension or limited pension etc. Each to their own.

According to the Chartered Insitute of Insurers women are often not aware of the risks.
Very sobering link here.

www.brightnetwork.co.uk/employer-advice/chartered-insurance-institute/cii-report-womens-risk-life/

The women I work with either never expected to divorce or just didnt think about their own pensions.

Darbs76 · 26/07/2022 17:05

I guess many women are prepared to take the risk. I personally wouldn’t put myself in a vulnerable position of having no income, no pension or limited pension etc. Each to their own.

Topgub · 26/07/2022 17:00

@MrsBwced

School age kids can still be little. P1 to p3 is called infants

But regardless what would you need/want more control just up to school age?

We did always plan to share childcare. Thats why didn't need paid childcare. But if we had, we'd have had no issue using it.

MrsBwced · 26/07/2022 16:01

@Topgub
Does control mean not use paid childcare?
No, but it's pretty obvious that in a childminder or nursery setting you have less say on how your child's day goes. Just like with school. It's not a bad thing but it's not wrong to want more input either.

I've always shared care. With dh. With family members. With school.

The pp didn't specify preschool only, which is why I asked how long she wanted complete control for.

PP said little ones...

We didn't purposefully avoid using paid childcare so we could have complete control. We just didn't need it.
I thought you said before that you planned to share childcare.

Topgub · 26/07/2022 15:29

@MrsBwced

Does control mean not use paid childcare?

I've always shared care. With dh. With family members. With school.

The pp didn't specify preschool only, which is why I asked how long she wanted complete control for.

We didn't purposefully avoid using paid childcare so we could have complete control. We just didn't need it.

They went to preschool nursery at 3.

scissorsandsellotape · 26/07/2022 15:18

PeasOff · 24/07/2022 18:25

Would or do you depend on your partner financially?

Do you have a backup in place in case of breakup or for your retirement?

Yes. I depend almost entirely on him
He makes x 3/4 what I do: I work pt as look after the kids the rest of the time

MrsBwced · 26/07/2022 15:14

Topgub · 26/07/2022 13:41

@CecilyP

Its still upbringing even if its everyday life.

The pp said they wanted control so couldn't work.

I dont see the need for control or not to work.

🤷‍♀️

You haven't had to use paid childcare though so to that extent you've had the control the pp was talking about.