Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For thinking SAHMs are making themselves financially vulnerable

655 replies

PeasOff · 24/07/2022 18:25

Would or do you depend on your partner financially?

Do you have a backup in place in case of breakup or for your retirement?

OP posts:
TartanGirl1 · 24/07/2022 20:21

SaltyCrisp · 24/07/2022 20:05

Would or do you depend on your partner financially?

I wouldn't depend on a partner financially but my husband was the sole earner when DC were small. Wouldn't dream of putting very young children in child care - personal choice before anyone takes offence.

Do you have a backup in place in case of breakup

Yes, a marriage certificate.

People get screwed over in divorces all the time!

malika3 · 24/07/2022 20:20

"You are naive if you think marrying a rich man protects you in a divorce."

Can you not imagine any possible ways that families can mitigate against this?

No SAHM I know is naive. It's the exact opposite.

If their marriages ended tomorrow, they know they would walk away with more than they could have earned in their lifetime. Or, at the very least, they would be no worse off.

This is precisely why they SAH! Otherwise they would never have left their jobs would they?

On MN, SAHMs HAVE to be financially vulnerable or heads start spinning.

But it's not necessarily true. Far from it.

Topgub · 24/07/2022 20:17

@saraclara

What does bf have to do with being a sahp?

If you presume most women take a years mat leave and most women have stopped bf by 6 weeks?

And even if still bf by a year the kid could surely cope throughout the day?

If being a sahp doesn't make you vulnerable or harm your career, why is it almost always the woman who does it?

sjxoxo · 24/07/2022 20:16

This has been done to death on this site..

I am a SAHM. Income is shared. We both have separate savings for the short term & long term. I have a ‘float’ in my current account of about 6 months pay (based on my last salary. We pay voluntary NI contributions for me in the UK. RE pensions; we have investments that are accessible to both of us and an investment plan that will give a good return by retirement age that we can live off the interest. In the country we currently live in, I would be entitled to 54% of DH’s state pension if he passed away. I don’t feel financially vulnerable as I have a good career history and a great education so in reality if I had to go back to work I could and still be fine. I think it’s totally fine to have one person at home or whatever set up works for your family, but I would say if you are going to rely on one income, you need to be quite financially secure with savings and make sure legally you are clued up. X

Icedbannoffee · 24/07/2022 20:16

Well of course, but for some it's worth it although some are naieve to it. @malika3 I'm not sure what your point is, there are SAHMs across the board. Those who are forced out of the workplace due to childcare costs, those whose partner works a job which doesn't allow them both to work very easily ie military, and those who choose to- which spans across income groups. Anyone relying on someone else's income without an independent income stream of their own is more vulnerable in their own right than someone who has their own salary coming in irrespective of how much is coming into the family unit. People presume in event of divorce they'd get x, y or z but lots of the time people with assets know how to protect them, and in many cases its only until the children are 18 for anything substantial.

MrsBwced · 24/07/2022 20:16

It's a risk obviously.
If a family decides a parent is going to give up work they should put as much as possible in place to minimise the risk. Marriage, insurances, financial transparency, joint accounts etc as well as ensuring both parties are completely on board with the situation and expectations of each other

saraclara · 24/07/2022 20:16

saraclara · 24/07/2022 20:12

My husband absolutely would have. He actively wanted to in fact. But I was the one with the boobs, and expressing wasn't a thing back then, outside emergencies.
I did feel bad about that sometimes.

Genuinely, I don't think that many mothers would be prepared to give up being the primary caregiver though. Some will (and do) of course. But they're probably as rare as the dads like my late husband.

Cleothecat75 · 24/07/2022 20:16

What do you propose I do then? I did work, full time until last year. But I have a disabled dc who currently can no longer attend school or any kind of childcare. Either dh or I had to give up work to care for them. Dh earns far more than me and I am naturally better at the caring responsibilities (not because I am female, but because I am a naturally more caring person). Even if we had both gone part time, we would have been financially worse off as the difference in incomes was so great.

A condition of me finishing work was that we still used family money to pay into my pension each month. We are also married and majority of savings are in my name.

I am curious what you think we should have done in this situation though?

PeasOff · 24/07/2022 20:13

@malika3 I was a SAHM for 4 years living in SW London so think I might know a little about being a SAHM. Also, new to MN as of today!

Those are the SAHMs you know. What about other SAHMs in less affluent areas or in poorer financial situations - would you not think them financially vulnerable?

OP posts:
saraclara · 24/07/2022 20:12

Topgub · 24/07/2022 20:00

@saraclara

Why do you think men don't choose it?

My husband absolutely would have. He actively wanted to in fact. But I was the one with the boobs, and expressing wasn't a thing back then, outside emergencies.
I did feel bad about that sometimes.

Topgub · 24/07/2022 20:12

@malika3

That's not true.

A lot of sahms aren't sahms by choice.

(Well, if you consider its not a choice its them and not their oh)

They are sahms because they think they can't afford to work.

Needmorelego · 24/07/2022 20:09

I could go back to work but who would take care of my daughter who has autism and other health issues? Should I put her in home away from society so I can have my 'own' money and not have to 'live off' my husband?
Many women's lives are in the now - not the future so can't even think about pensions and retirement etc.
It scares me sometimes but what can I do?

prepared101 · 24/07/2022 20:09

malika3 · 24/07/2022 20:07

YABU.

The SAHMs I know are possibly some of the least financially vulnerable women in the U.K.

If you live in a house worth £2/£3/£5/£10 million, you are hardly financially vulnerable are you? Even if you only get £1m or £500k or £200k, compared to the average woman in the U.K., they are are hardly poor.

So much misunderstanding in MN about SAHMs, but can I please make this clear -

SAHMS DO NOT MAKE THEMSELVES INCOME DEPENDENT. IT IS ABOUT FAMILY WEALTH AND ASSETS. A CERTAIN LEVEL OF WEALTH AND ASSETS MEAN YOU DON'T NEED TWO WORKING PARENTS - AKA YOU CAN AFFORD TO BE A SAHM.

Sorry to shout, but I don't understand why people on MN can't grasp this.

Where are there thousands upon thousands of SAHMs? Not surprisingly, they are highly concentrated in places like Chelsea, Kensington, Notting Hill, Hampstead, Highgate, Chiswick, South West London and out into Richmond and on into places like Esther and Oxshott. That's just.a few areas I know where is very common to be a SAHM. Where I live, it's more common than not. Nobody is financially vulnerable. It's the opposite - and this is precisely why the can be a SAHM! Thousands upon thousands of women. There will be loads of other similar areas in and around London and beyond. This is the reality. None of them need concern on MN, I can assure you of that.

You are naive if you think marrying a rich man protects you in a divorce.

Very rich men can afford very good lawyers and accountants 59 hide their assets.

malika3 · 24/07/2022 20:07

YABU.

The SAHMs I know are possibly some of the least financially vulnerable women in the U.K.

If you live in a house worth £2/£3/£5/£10 million, you are hardly financially vulnerable are you? Even if you only get £1m or £500k or £200k, compared to the average woman in the U.K., they are are hardly poor.

So much misunderstanding in MN about SAHMs, but can I please make this clear -

SAHMS DO NOT MAKE THEMSELVES INCOME DEPENDENT. IT IS ABOUT FAMILY WEALTH AND ASSETS. A CERTAIN LEVEL OF WEALTH AND ASSETS MEAN YOU DON'T NEED TWO WORKING PARENTS - AKA YOU CAN AFFORD TO BE A SAHM.

Sorry to shout, but I don't understand why people on MN can't grasp this.

Where are there thousands upon thousands of SAHMs? Not surprisingly, they are highly concentrated in places like Chelsea, Kensington, Notting Hill, Hampstead, Highgate, Chiswick, South West London and out into Richmond and on into places like Esther and Oxshott. That's just.a few areas I know where is very common to be a SAHM. Where I live, it's more common than not. Nobody is financially vulnerable. It's the opposite - and this is precisely why the can be a SAHM! Thousands upon thousands of women. There will be loads of other similar areas in and around London and beyond. This is the reality. None of them need concern on MN, I can assure you of that.

SaltyCrisp · 24/07/2022 20:05

Would or do you depend on your partner financially?

I wouldn't depend on a partner financially but my husband was the sole earner when DC were small. Wouldn't dream of putting very young children in child care - personal choice before anyone takes offence.

Do you have a backup in place in case of breakup

Yes, a marriage certificate.

PeasOff · 24/07/2022 20:03

@Allmarbleslost Because I can't be arsed to and doubt the threads would be very active now.

@MakkaPakkas Feel free to scroll on if you don't want to engage!

OP posts:
Surgarblossom · 24/07/2022 20:02

Topgub · 24/07/2022 19:09

I dont and never have depended on my partner. Financially or otherwise.

This

Topgub · 24/07/2022 20:00

@saraclara

Why do you think men don't choose it?

C0mfyChairP0se · 24/07/2022 20:00

If they divorce they will have some entitlement to their x's pension(s) or they'll be an adult dependent on their H's state pension.

I think the trouble is where the man just disappears or decides not to pay a cent.

WillitFit · 24/07/2022 20:00

Rwealere · 24/07/2022 19:55

If you’re in a relationship with anyone you can you can make yourself financially vulnerable just stop and think about it, but no, why do that let’s just go with the stereotype that all SAHMs are air heads or gold diggers, much simpler.

I don't think that's the suggestion at all. Far from being gold diggers I think SAMHs often get themselves into difficulties by not worrying about money at all.

saraclara · 24/07/2022 19:59

I was a SAHM for a few years and I thought it through very carefully. I weighed up the pros and cons, I knew I could get occasional supply work if I needed a cash top up (I was a teacher) and I knew I could get a job again very easily if the chips were down.
It was a lovely time, I kept in touch with schools I knew, and went straight back into part time or temporary contracts when my youngest started school. I liked keeping that bit of control over my life at that point. Then when I was established at a school that I liked, I went permanent when they offered me a contract.

Yes, my pension was affected to a point, but that's the only downside. And we saved hard to make sure that our retirements would be comfortable enough.

I don't know why you assume that SAHMs don't think this stuff through. I imagine that most will these days.

NerrSnerr · 24/07/2022 19:57

It depends on the situation. Some people are able to protect themselves to some extent for example I have friends who are nurses who do a small amount of bank/ agency to keep their registration so they'll have work to fall back on if and when is needed.

Others clearly are very vulnerable, you see many posts on here from women who want to leave their partners, don't have a penny to their name, can't work as their partner won't contribute to childcare etc.

Rwealere · 24/07/2022 19:55

If you’re in a relationship with anyone you can you can make yourself financially vulnerable just stop and think about it, but no, why do that let’s just go with the stereotype that all SAHMs are air heads or gold diggers, much simpler.

nca · 24/07/2022 19:48

I was.

It screwed me over for years post divorce and I'm only getting out of it now in my 50s.

I would tell any woman not to do it

WillitFit · 24/07/2022 19:48

It's not even just break ups. To have the whole family dependent on one job always seemed risky to me and for that reason, I kept my career up, albeit part time, but I knew I could go back FT if I needed to.

Which is just as well because DH had 3 months out of work following a disciplinary thing, then years later in a different job was diagnosed with cancer and was off work for a year for treatment, then the cancer returned and he died. Me and DC would have been well and truly stuffed if I'd let my career go when they were young and wasn't able to support us.

Swipe left for the next trending thread