Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For thinking SAHMs are making themselves financially vulnerable

655 replies

PeasOff · 24/07/2022 18:25

Would or do you depend on your partner financially?

Do you have a backup in place in case of breakup or for your retirement?

OP posts:
prepared101 · 24/07/2022 20:43

worriedatthistime · 24/07/2022 20:34

@prepared101 why can't you accept that some do want to stay home though and thats fine its not for you but it is for others
Yes you look after your kids when you work but not 24/7 so its not exactly the same
But just because you didn't want to do it doesn't mean people who have are lesser than you

Wanting something doesn't remove the risk.

I have daughters and honestly, I'd be gutted if they didn't work or if they married a partner who didn't want to work.

It's my opinion (and why people post on here; to gather others' opinions...!)

worriedatthistime · 24/07/2022 20:42

Also some of you come from too privileged a position, you realise many couples can't actually pay into private pensions with both working etc or save for a rainy day as they can just about cover the bills
Universal credit is majority claimed by working parents to help top up and live
Years back when the kids were little and I was back in work ,if myself and dh had split up the reality is both of us would have nothing as we had just had enough to live and pay essentials give the kids nice things
We aren't all in six figure jobs with lots of money around us

Bowtique · 24/07/2022 20:42

@worriedatthistime

Absolutely not but this is a very real issue and I’ve seen this happen time and time again, to some very intelligent friends of mine. I’m an academic and have lots of friends in academia and healthcare. Friends who thought they’d keep up with CPD when being a SAHM but of course it fell at the wayside.

The biggest contributor is men, men who, upon getting a SAHW absolve themselves of any parental responsibility at all because that is her job. Meaning that women have no time to be anything other than a wife and mother. That doesn’t happen if you work and split child/home responsibilities. It has other foibles of course but I think time away from your children/husband is important. For me, using my brain in ways that I don’t when with my children is also important. I’m not allowed to say that but don’t find playing and entertaining my kids (which I do very well) intellectually stimulating enough to keep me sane.

I also think that being a SAHP can be a very stressful and lonely existence and I have seen friends lose confidence. That lack of confidence has a big impact on their ability to regain employment.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 24/07/2022 20:41

I was a SAHM.
I looked after the children and did much of the daily chores.
I went back to work when children went to school.

It never occurred to us that one earned all the money and that the other one was reliant.
No parental help due to living too far away.
No wrap around care as it didn't exist.

However, people don't generally stay married anymore, for whatever reason, so it makes financial sense to ensure that you can take care of yourself.

Different times and different attitudes to relationships.

springisaroundthecorner · 24/07/2022 20:37

I have no choice. A teenager with SEN and my mum's needs . Carer allowance of £69.a week means I have no pension or savings in

Topgub · 24/07/2022 20:36

@malika3

But you're essentially saying all the sahms you know had no interest in ever being financially independent or having a career.

They just had to marry someone well off to do the earning for you.

Job done.

Its a bit embarrassing

tiggergoesbounce · 24/07/2022 20:35

Lets see how long before a particular poster starts misquoting people, saying how the role has no value, saying you cant be a feminist etc etc

They are obsesed in a bad way with these posts.

WillitFit · 24/07/2022 20:35

For me the risk is more the "all eggs in one basket" with the family being dependent on one income if there's job loss or long term illness etc. I don't think married SAHMs are that vulnerable to divorce. Unmarried SAHMs are very vulnerable though.

worriedatthistime · 24/07/2022 20:34

@prepared101 why can't you accept that some do want to stay home though and thats fine its not for you but it is for others
Yes you look after your kids when you work but not 24/7 so its not exactly the same
But just because you didn't want to do it doesn't mean people who have are lesser than you

rainrelief · 24/07/2022 20:34

tiggergoesbounce · 24/07/2022 20:25

I think most SAHM who have done so out of choice, absolutely do think of the consequences but roll the dice. Its ridiculous to think otherwise.

They put themselves in the best position they can, they weigh up the risks and decide thats its worth the risk for them.

Most i know have access to all the families money, there husband value and appreciate what they do. Obviously if they split (if) they had no savings then they would have to start again with the value of half the assets and get back out to work.

Even if i didn't have my own financial security i still would have risked being in the half that stay married to be a SAHM.

Yeah this. I personally would not recommend it, but for those it works out for, it leads to a much more pleasant life. It’s a risk, and the risk is ALL on the woman (or SAHP). If you are going to do it, make sure your H sets up as much financial protection for you as possible, and that he pays a good amount into a decent pension for you.

malika3 · 24/07/2022 20:34

"You're not painting a very good picture of sahms really"

Yes that's because the only picture you see is the one you want to see.

But it's not true. Come to where I am and I'll show you it's not true.

If a family can afford to have one person working part-time or SAH, then they may well do that. It's not rocket science.

If a woman has the choice to SAH, she may well take it. Again, not rocket science. She looks at the financial circumstances of her family. For some women, SAH will be something if a risk, but nevertheless, it's a risk they're prepared to take. Simple as that. But equally, for other women, it's not a risk at all and this is how and why they do it.

If I thought being a SAHM round have rendered me, or more importantly my children, at financial risk, I would never have done it! It really is as simple as that. As it is, I am less financially vulnerable for having been a SAHM than if I'd been working these last 20 years or so. And so are my children.

tiggergoesbounce · 24/07/2022 20:33

Youdoyoutoday · 24/07/2022 20:25

This topic again?
Can MNHQ set up a topic/thread for those that feel the need to discuss this every freaking day?? But I honestly mean this specific topic!!
Every day...... find each other..... please!

I know and the same goady nonsense commenters appear slowly with the same nonsense. Its fine if its not your choice, but they must understand it can easily be others choice.

I always post as i stupidly think that maybe, just maybe people might understand that most SAHM do think about the consequences, that all people are wired differently so happily make different choices, its Just so narrow minded to think otherwise or claim to not understand.

worriedatthistime · 24/07/2022 20:31

@KosherDill how can you say that and speak for others
The best years for me were the 4 years I had at home with my kids , priceless to me
Might not be others choice but if its a wanted choice who cares its no one elses business and maybe people should judge a little less

worriedatthistime · 24/07/2022 20:29

@Bowtique do you think sahm are all thick and don't realise this ?
I was a sahm got back in the workforce and had to make it back up a bit but could go a lot further if i want now , but I just dob't
A career is not the most important thing to me
Also for some in min wage job time out won't make a huge difference to their work / job progress
Women can make a choice , yes its a risk but so is many things in life , none of us can predict the future we can only try and safeguard
So for me we shared the bank account their was no his or my money , we paid the bills and shared what was left over and could save or spend as we wished
People do know the sacrifices but some of us think its worth it and thats ok

FunDragon · 24/07/2022 20:28

I’m not sure it does really. I’m not spectacularly naive, I’ve read the threads where women are trapped with abusive men, they’ve left their minimum wage jobs due to the cost of childcare, and they can’t get back into the workforce because the husband won’t give them money for a bus into town let alone childcare. But what made those women vulnerable wasn’t the decision to be a SAHM - that decision was made for then really by the cost of childcare. What made them vulnerable was having a low paying job and the cost of childcare. They’d be vulnerable even if they’d managed to stay in work.

Otherwise, when I look around at my (admittedly MC) social circle, and the divorces I’ve seen take place, I don’t think the SAHMs are particularly vulnerable at all - I actually think their husbands are more vulnerable. Being the sole provider looks hugely stressful in itself, particularly during a cost of living crisis and impending recession. I would hate to be sole provider, knowing that my performance at work is all that stands between my family and ruin. And then in the event of a divorce they’ll (rightly) be ordered to pay child maintenance, along with a sum that reflects the impact of being a SAHM on the wife’s career.

Like a PP, I’ve advised my sons to marry ambitious women.

rainrelief · 24/07/2022 20:28

TeenDivided · 24/07/2022 19:20

It is much more of an issue if the SAHP isn't married to the partner they are dependent on.

Yup. One of the saddest posts I read was from a devastated non- working, home schooling, unmarried mum of four kids. Her partner had just announced he was leaving her.

Snoredoeurve · 24/07/2022 20:26

But Having a SAHP also reduces stress as there is someone there when children are ill, and in the summer holidays, and to get jobs done in the week freeing up more relaxing time at the weekend.

I just see this a facilitating men to duck out of parenting.
Whilst ruining your own retirement.
Im at the opposite end of parenting and am surrounded by women who now cant retire until 67 while their DH/ ex DH swans off at 60 and several have now decided that their pension is theirs despite the fact they are still married.
Rage doesnt begin to describe these women and they all regret it !

TartanGirl1 · 24/07/2022 20:26

Youdoyoutoday · 24/07/2022 20:25

This topic again?
Can MNHQ set up a topic/thread for those that feel the need to discuss this every freaking day?? But I honestly mean this specific topic!!
Every day...... find each other..... please!

Yet you are helping this thread by commenting...

stayathomer · 24/07/2022 20:25

i know a lot of sahds. I myself left work because I earned significantly less than dh and we paid hundreds more than my wage on childcare and travel to work. We had no family to help with childcare and both regularly got into trouble when the kids were sick. Parental leave was not a thing in either of our jobs. I laugh that people on mn think you just decide one day to be a kept person and ignore possible consequences-we talked about it for years. I’m back to work now but am glad we did it, kudos to those who can juggle it all but we couldn’t.

tiggergoesbounce · 24/07/2022 20:25

I think most SAHM who have done so out of choice, absolutely do think of the consequences but roll the dice. Its ridiculous to think otherwise.

They put themselves in the best position they can, they weigh up the risks and decide thats its worth the risk for them.

Most i know have access to all the families money, there husband value and appreciate what they do. Obviously if they split (if) they had no savings then they would have to start again with the value of half the assets and get back out to work.

Even if i didn't have my own financial security i still would have risked being in the half that stay married to be a SAHM.

Youdoyoutoday · 24/07/2022 20:25

This topic again?
Can MNHQ set up a topic/thread for those that feel the need to discuss this every freaking day?? But I honestly mean this specific topic!!
Every day...... find each other..... please!

Topgub · 24/07/2022 20:24

@malika3

You're not painting a very good picture of sahms really

oviraptor21 · 24/07/2022 20:23

I took 20 years out. Not a problem.

DreamingofItaly2023 · 24/07/2022 20:22

I am a SAHM and am financially dependent on my DH. I used to work but my mental health led to multiple breakdowns and left me unable to work. If I weren’t dependent on my DH I would be dependent on benefits. With lots of therapy and retraining I hope to reenter the workforce sometime in the next 5 years. Realistically I will probably never work full time and will always be financially dependent on DH or if he leaves benefits. We have a very happy marriage however.

oviraptor21 · 24/07/2022 20:22

PeasOff · 24/07/2022 18:25

Would or do you depend on your partner financially?

Do you have a backup in place in case of breakup or for your retirement?

Yep. All sorted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread