Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can have a great career without a degree

64 replies

Allotment123 · 24/07/2022 17:03

DD looking at an extended diploma in the creative industries instead of A levels . In general we have 5 to 6 different careers before we retire. Uni is expensive and there is an apprenticeship option. Will she regret not getting a degree later? She is bright and has a great work ethic, but had considerable anxiety in GCSEs.

How much does a degree really matter? Especially if you may have a career change later when you get fed up of being paid a pittance for unsociable hours?

OP posts:
DeadbeatYoda · 24/07/2022 17:59

I don't have a degree and it has really restricted the jobs I have had. I did do pretty well in my twenties ( earning pretty good salaries for the roles I was doing) but they were always support roles. The directors / managers I worked for were frequently no brighter than I was but they had degrees so they could apply for more senior roles.
However, it's completely dependent on industry. Corporate world... I would venture that its best to have one.
However, there are loads of different walks of life where it may not matter so much.

EATmum · 24/07/2022 17:37

The theory always used to be that a degree added an average £100K to your lifetime earnings. While that value will have changed over time, a 100K value is very quickly offset against three years of earnings, plus student loans. And being three years ahead of your peers.

I loved uni, and one of my DDs is loving hers - but unless they really want to do it, I don't think there's a strong financial argument in the majority of sectors. Obviously it's an absolute bar to entry/progress in some.

Eunorition · 24/07/2022 17:32

If she picks an industry that values experience and pays very well, then she'll be fine.

Avoid caring professions, childcare, teaching, social work etc. Get into banking, tech, finance and so on.

MajorCarolDanvers · 24/07/2022 17:31

My husband did fine without a degree until his mid 30s. That's when he hit a level in his career where all promotion opportunities required a degree.

He ended up having to do one on the OU. He missed out on quite a few great jobs in the meantime and a number of years later is now playing catch up.

Denny53 · 24/07/2022 17:30

My two youngest sons don’t have degrees but one works in finance for NHS (started as an apprentice) and earns £65,000. Youngest is a software developer and earns around the same. Eldest did go to uni but got a third class degree and is a millionaire with several businesses !!

MojoMoon · 24/07/2022 17:27

Well, most highly paid people have degrees.

That doesn't mean everyone needs to have one.

If she is bright and getting good GCSEs, I'd advise A levels over an extended diploma though.
Most employers have no idea what an extended diploma is and it will undoubtedly get rebranded and changed at some point as they always do with vocational courses.

A levels in English Literature, Theatre Studies and Art or A foreign language or History would keep her options much more open for longer and be recognised by a wider range of employers in the future. It would also make it much easier to go to uni in the future if she wished to do so.

SchoolTie · 24/07/2022 17:25

Name changed.

I did this.

I started university at 16 (skipped a class when I was 5) which was far, far too young. I was in classes with mainly 18/19 year olds and struggled with the social aspect and general maturity, plus didn’t have much academic support at home. I dropped out before the end of my first year and started working in low wage jobs (retail, call centre etc) but job-hopped a lot, and had periods of unemployment.

Eventually I found an industry I liked in my mid 20s, through sheer coincidence, and not having a degree went against me. I worked my way up and then started to gain qualifications in my line of work but it took a lot of hard work to prove myself in the early years and there were so many paths closed to me simply because I didn’t meet the minimum criteria of having a degree.

I’m now 38 and my salary is £130k plus another £20-30k in bonuses, so I’ve definitely done well but, if I had my time over, I’d have taken a more traditional path and completed my education first.

MadMadMadamMim · 24/07/2022 17:23

Agree with others that it depends on the industry. However, I would be worried that nowadays - when such a high percentage of the population DO go onto uni - that she might find herself disadvantaged when applying for jobs.

I think if you've 20 years industry experience behind you and a solid CV then employers might not care much. No degree, little experience and it might be a different matter.

alfagirl73 · 24/07/2022 17:23

I'm earning just shy of £60k + substantial benefits and I don't have a degree - although I have done a lot of qualifications in my field. You don't need a degree to be successful at all and I'm a big believer in experience being just as important as qualifications. That said I do wish I had done a degree - not straight out of school - but at some point (OU or something) - just because it opens up options - particularly later on in life if you want to explore a career change or even just pursue other qualifications. But that's just me.

ChuckBerrysBoots · 24/07/2022 17:22

Of my two siblings without degrees, one is already out-earning me despite being 10 years younger and one isn’t far behind. They may reach a ceiling point where a degree becomes necessary but with the job market as it is I think their experience will serve them pretty well. DH struggled to progress without a degree for a while but is now in project management where other relevant qualifications seem to hold greater sway. I’ve got a non-specialist degree and earn a decent wage in a job I enjoy, and my student debt is paid off, so it was worth it for me but I wouldn’t necessarily be encouraging our own children to go to university of there are other routes to their desired career.

Simonjt · 24/07/2022 17:21

It does depend on the industry, apprenticeships however continue to improve. My husband hasn’t been to university, we’re both actuaries, I did the uni and training route, he did the apprenticeship route. If we look at education years he was qualified almost three years before me, but obviously he was earning money from day one, where as I wasn’t for three years due to being at university.

We’re both educated to level 7, just different routes.

Hollahere · 24/07/2022 17:16

I know an awful lot more people with degrees earning not much more than minimum wage, than those with degrees earning £50k+.

CallmeMrsPricklepants · 24/07/2022 17:07

Networking is everything. Fine, don't do a degree but make sure she can attend every event going that's related to her field. Teach her how to sell her work, talk confidently and create authentic bonds with people to forge working relationships. If she can do that she can do anything.

elzober · 24/07/2022 17:05

I think it all depends on the industry. Some careers require it but others are more flexible with different routes in like apprenticeships etc.