Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
MajorCarolDanvers · 24/07/2022 12:44

Yes she absolutely can.

You could always use the money you've saved not going private to pay for a tutor later on if she needs extra help.

BlueWhaleBay · 24/07/2022 12:43

Of course she could. Grades are not the issue, it’s the experience of daily life in the environment.

If the state school is well run, great. If not, I would be looking elsewhere.

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 12:41

To be fair, I think most schools are much hotter on bullying than they were back in the day. I’m not claiming they’ve all got it right but am a bit uneasy with the assumption that state school = horrid louts who will kick the shit out of anyone who looks at a book.

I has a truly gifted student last year. He’d have got all 9s wherever he was because he was cleverer than the teachers. He answered the question on The Merchant of Venice, even though we’d studied Macbeth. You can’t argue with that sort of intelligence; it’s just a gift.

The ones I think miss out are clever and quick but not gifted. Bright but not amazing. Keen but not sponges. They should get 7s and 8s; they get 5s and 6s, a lot of the time.

A lot of state schools do struggle to recruit as well, and this is an issue for maths and science especially.

Also, not all schools set. Most do but some don’t.

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 12:37

maddy68 · 24/07/2022 12:30

I'm a secondary teacher. I have worked in both state schools and private. Yes she can get just as high grades in a state school. It depends on her work ethic (in both schools!)
She will be out into sets so she will be with the same ability students.

It's fine.

So you seriously think that the only criteria is the pupil's "work ethic" do you?

No other factors affect it at all? Not bullying? Not numerous teachers off sick? Not a general acceptance of poor behaviour? Not a general low level of ability across the school in a deprived location?

maddy68 · 24/07/2022 12:30

I'm a secondary teacher. I have worked in both state schools and private. Yes she can get just as high grades in a state school. It depends on her work ethic (in both schools!)
She will be out into sets so she will be with the same ability students.

It's fine.

EssexCat · 24/07/2022 12:27

Absolutely she can. But as others have said she will probably have to work harder on her own as the state comp will be more stretched for teachers and resources.

We did a mix of (lovely but very normal) state for gcse and (very selective) private for a levels for one of ours (due to a doing a niche Alevel) and he’s now going to a very similar uni as many of his friends who stayed in state.

You can always supplement with tutors if necessary- which is considerably cheaper than private school!

User367259791 · 24/07/2022 12:27

Of course she can. Save the money, use the difference to enjoy your lives together, go on holidays, let her pursue outside interests (music, art, drama, sport - this is what you actually pay for with private, and the “network” which really only applies to a small proportion of private schools).

If it turns out down the line she is super-academic and wants to get into a top university, you can always get a bit of tutoring just to be sure of the grades. Also, if it turns out that it’s not the right school for her, you’d still have that option to go private.

Discovereads · 24/07/2022 12:25

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 12:21

@redskyatnight

What she does have is a very strong work ethic and is extremely self motivated. She's also had a supportive peer group.

But if you're bullied literally every day, not just verbally, but also physically, having your property damaged/stolen, then it really doesn't matter how strong is your work ethic or motivation. Bullying just sucks it all out of you. That's what happened to me. As soon as I left school, I basically taught myself to recoup the damage!

Yes, we moved our DC from a comp that had been rated average when our DD saw a kid pushed through a plate glass window, smashing it and sending him to the hospital. Fights, drugs and creepy men tooling around in cars accosting girls on the walk home from school was common place. We ended up paying more rent, but was worth it to get them in area for an outstanding comp in a nice quiet village. Not everyone can afford to move and/or pay more rent though.

Comtesse · 24/07/2022 12:24

I went to a crap comp that later was in special measures for ages then taken over. I got AAAB at A levels then went to Oxbridge as did my 2 siblings. Family support/ emphasis on learning counts for a LOT. My theory is that water rises to its own level for the most part as long as the school isn’t actively awful.

easyday · 24/07/2022 12:23

Whether state or private it's her that will have to put in the work.
She may have to get some tutoring if things aren't up to scratch in some areas but if you could almost afford private that seems within your budget.
Keep communication with school open and help support where you can. But ultimately she's the one taking the exam and needs to be focussed when the time comes.

Discovereads · 24/07/2022 12:22

redskyatnight · 24/07/2022 12:12

But I think YABU thinking your child can get top grades if she just works as hard or harder than she is now. Your child got “near top of class” in primary, so I think your expectations are too high tbh. It is likely she will remain “near top of class” at the comp where-ever that is for it. Could be a 6 or 7.

this very much depends on the child. DD was "near top of class" in primary and is on track to get top grades (just taken GCSEs) from her "average comp". And she's not had any tutoring.
What she does have is a very strong work ethic and is extremely self motivated. She's also had a supportive peer group.

If OP's DD is like that, she will do well.

DS was "near top of class" at primary and started to lose interest in education somewhere around Year 8, finishing with above average but not top grades. Would he have done better in a private school? It's possible he may have been pushed more, but without intrinsic motivation to do well, a child is eventually going to run out of steam - there's only so much a school can do. Plus, in the long term does getting 8s and 9s rather than 6s and 7s really make a difference?

It’s not all on the child though is it?

It also depends on the teacher as well. Average comps it is a lottery as to whether your DC will get a decent teacher or not in the different subjects. My DD went to an outstanding comp and even then not all the teachers were good. Her DT teacher for example was an incompetent twat and several DC failed their GCSE design projects because he approved designs for impossible projects…so when they went to build according to the designs he had approved, they could not. (He was also sexist judging by some of the comments he wrote on her work).

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 12:21

@redskyatnight

What she does have is a very strong work ethic and is extremely self motivated. She's also had a supportive peer group.

But if you're bullied literally every day, not just verbally, but also physically, having your property damaged/stolen, then it really doesn't matter how strong is your work ethic or motivation. Bullying just sucks it all out of you. That's what happened to me. As soon as I left school, I basically taught myself to recoup the damage!

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 12:18

Of course it's possible, but I think the probability is greatly reduced.

I was a straight A pupil at the end of primary, but left secondary school 5 years later without a single O level!

That was due to a general malaise amongst many teachers, high staff sickness/absence rates and persistent bullying. I attended every single day and every single lesson, but the whole place wasn't a suitable learning environment. Teachers would set homework, I'd do it, but it wasn't marked, so I'd stop doing it as there was no point!

Once I left, I did a mix of evening classes at the local college and self-teaching, alongside a full time job, to get my O levels, then A levels and eventually my chartered accountancy qualifications, so I wasn't "thick" or unmotivated. It was simply being stuck in a crap comp for 5 years!

Having said all, I had a friend who was a neighbour, same age, same primary school, same secondary school, who was similar ability to me at primary, who flew at the same comp and got a string of top grades. But, different forms, different sets, different teachers, different friends, etc. Sometimes, it really is just luck of the draw as to which teachers you get, whether the bullies are in your form, etc.

bigTillyMint · 24/07/2022 12:17

Of course it’s possible - both mine did, as so thousands of others each year. As @lightisnotwhite said - they went to the same top unis as the privately educated kids.

Teach her perseverance, resilience and self-motivation rather than trying to micro-manage her. Be supportive and observant so that you can step in where necessary. Spend any money you have on her chosen sport/instrument, etc, and doing stuff to enrich her “cultural capital”

TheSmallAssassin · 24/07/2022 12:16

She will be fine, if you are supportive and she continues to apply herself. One of mine got all 9s bar one last year at a below average comprehensive, the other got a pretty good number of 8s and 9s at a slightly better comprehensive three years ago. They also got/will get contextual offers from universities because we live in the lowest quintile for participation in higher education at both schools were below average on results.

redskyatnight · 24/07/2022 12:12

But I think YABU thinking your child can get top grades if she just works as hard or harder than she is now. Your child got “near top of class” in primary, so I think your expectations are too high tbh. It is likely she will remain “near top of class” at the comp where-ever that is for it. Could be a 6 or 7.

this very much depends on the child. DD was "near top of class" in primary and is on track to get top grades (just taken GCSEs) from her "average comp". And she's not had any tutoring.
What she does have is a very strong work ethic and is extremely self motivated. She's also had a supportive peer group.

If OP's DD is like that, she will do well.

DS was "near top of class" at primary and started to lose interest in education somewhere around Year 8, finishing with above average but not top grades. Would he have done better in a private school? It's possible he may have been pushed more, but without intrinsic motivation to do well, a child is eventually going to run out of steam - there's only so much a school can do. Plus, in the long term does getting 8s and 9s rather than 6s and 7s really make a difference?

alwayslearning789 · 24/07/2022 12:12

redskyatnight · 24/07/2022 12:05

An awful lot of children get top grades at my DC's averagely performing comp.
Remember in this context "average" often relates to intake. Private schools are all selective (even if just on parents' income) so will automatically have better results.

And this^

Hoppinggreen · 24/07/2022 12:10

It’s possible but not certain, but then it’s not certain she would get top grades at Private either (probably more likely though). A lot can happen between 11 and 16
There are a lot of variables and you being engaged and supportive will go a long way but if she gets bad teachers or a tricky cohort it will have an effect.
At the end of the day you have decided you can’t afford Private so you need to work with the option you have

alwayslearning789 · 24/07/2022 12:10

Yes she can - but you will both have to work hard.

Her - To work at it consistently, in order to get the grades and make the most of the education she is getting within the school environment.

You - to keep on top of ensuring she is supported in her learning journey, eg tutors if required, as well as identifying opportunities outside of the school environment. Mumsnet is a good source of this information and support in the Education threads.

Both keeping watch on the Peer Groups.

Also benefits learning to deal with people from all walks of life which might be increasingly important in future.

And as PP suggested could be revisited at Y9 or Y12 if need be. Best Wishes for your journey.

lightisnotwhite · 24/07/2022 12:06

I’m not sure it even matters as much as parents think at the end of the day.

My son is off to Uni this year. As are his privately educated friends. They are all going to the same ones to study the same things. The Durhams, Bristol, UCL’s are there for state and private and with luck your daughter may stand a better chance of getting in with a contextual offer.

skippy67 · 24/07/2022 12:06

Yes, she can if she applies herself. Both DCs went to the local comp and got excellent grades. One went on to get a first class law degree and is now on a great salary at a London firm. The other got the same A level grades and is currently on course to scrape a degree in thier chosen subject. Different kids, same school, with different work ethic. 😅

MatildaTheCat · 24/07/2022 12:05

Yes she can but you might need to supplement the teaching with a tutor in some subjects to boosts her grades. DS was very academic but his comp was focused of getting as many students to a C grade as possible rather than getting the Bplus students to an A. They were completely open about it.

At A level it was better but we still had a tutor for maths. He got AAA plus AA at AS level. It was before A* existed.

redskyatnight · 24/07/2022 12:05

An awful lot of children get top grades at my DC's averagely performing comp.
Remember in this context "average" often relates to intake. Private schools are all selective (even if just on parents' income) so will automatically have better results.

Discovereads · 24/07/2022 12:03

Yes a very bright child that also works hard can get top grades at an average comprehensive school. It’s not impossible. Although, studies have shown that many children who get top grades at average comps are those whose parents paid for private tutors.

But I think YABU thinking your child can get top grades if she just works as hard or harder than she is now. Your child got “near top of class” in primary, so I think your expectations are too high tbh. It is likely she will remain “near top of class” at the comp where-ever that is for it. Could be a 6 or 7.

Top grades (8-9 in GCSEs) is like a three legged stool. You need intelligence, hard work and good teachers. You knock out one of those legs and it’s a lot less likely that top grades will be attainable. If you’re going to send her to the local comp, you will probably need to pay for a few private tutors for her to get top grades. This would still be far cheaper than a fee paying school, and quite a few parents who cannot afford private do go down this route.

riotlady · 24/07/2022 12:03

Of course she can.

Its 10 years since I did this myself but I think what made the difference for me was supplementary learning. Not loads, she doesn’t have to read the FT cover to cover if she’s studying economics, but a few extra YouTube videos, a documentary on something that interests her, reading the news now and again- that gives the extra little bit of depth that helps hit the top marks imo. My teachers were very focused on making sure everyone hit the basics properly, so I needed to find the extra stretch myself