Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
SortingOffice · 24/07/2022 13:41

My two bright DC went to a very average rural comp.
They got mostly A at GCSE, all A at A level and both got 1sts at top unis in maths and science.
So yes, it can be done.
You need to put some effort in yourself. Always be engaged with school work and extend it outside the curriculum.

Make sure they don't fall in with a bad crowd.
Use the money to help by all means, tutor if they have a weak subject.

JoeMaplin · 24/07/2022 13:39

Of course with the right support and motivation possibly with some supplementation.. My daughter got mainly 9s in gcse and AAA in hard subjects at a level. It really will come down to her motivation though.

pointythings · 24/07/2022 13:35

I think the points about peer support are very well made. Both my DDs were part of a small, close-knit group of girls who made it their business to work hard and support each other to achieve. They had the strength to stay away from the 'populars' and get on with theire work.

Mischance · 24/07/2022 13:28

Of course she can, if she knows what she wants to do and works hard she can get the grades she wants. - they are too young to be expected to know what they want to do.

Mischance · 24/07/2022 13:26

My GSs are at a private secondary school - why? .... because there it is not seen as uncool to apply yourself to subjects and to throw yourself into all the brilliant extra-curricular stuff. The local comp has a "learning is uncool" ethos among the pupils. At an age when friends are so important and the need is to be with the in-crowd, their attitudes matter a lot. I feel sorry for the teachers at the comp - they truly are doing their best and are dedicated to helping the pupils get on, but it is like rolling a boulder uphill.

RudsyFarmer · 24/07/2022 13:22

My son is achieving very well in his outstanding primary and I’m a little concerned about the catchment secondary but I plan on being very involved and well use tutors if necessary.

ChilliPB · 24/07/2022 13:19

Of course she can! I went to a local state comp, straight A*s and As at GCSEs, then went to the local further education college for A Levels and on to Oxford. Plenty of people I know did really well from comps.
You can support her by engaging with her on what she’s doing, helping her with her homework and if she needs it thinking about tutoring.

WinniePig · 24/07/2022 13:18

Yes of course she can. I went to an average comp and did v well (Warwick uni, training contract with City firm). I had a small group of bright, motivated and conscientious friends. We also expected to go to uni and get graduate jobs. There were plenty of bright kids at my school who did less well in their exams. I would say that school / education was just not a priority for them (and possibly not their parents). That’s not to say they are not doing well now though.

2pinkginsplease · 24/07/2022 13:15

Of course she can, if she knows what she wants to do and works hard she can get the grades she wants.

My 2 went to a regular high school in our area and came out with the grades they wanted and worked towards.

Mamansparkles · 24/07/2022 13:13

I'm a teacher who has taught in lots of different types of schools across the sectors.
Yes, of course bright pupils can get good grades in a state school. But it isn't always as easy depending on the school.

In private, even with class sizes creeping up teachers are contracted to put in extra hours of support in a way that they arent in state. Many still do in state, but some don't.

In private, yes there is violence and fights do happen but the perpetrators can be removed after just a couple of incidents: they can have zero tolerance policies. It is very difficult to remove pupils from state.

Even in private schools that don't select on ability (there are some) and have a full range of abilities including mild-moderate learning difficulties like was imagined for a comprehensive school, they are able to turn away pupils who they can't look after or educate (eg those with severe SEND who should really not be in mainstream education but are due to the shortage of SEND places). Comps can't cope with them either but have to. These pupils need more attention from the teacher, leaving less for the others. No one wins in this scenario but there is a severe shortage of SEND placements and funding.

Private schools are judged on their grades for individual children. If children aren't achieving, their parents complain and other parents don't send kids there. Some state schools will be graded on how many kids get Cs and above so will not be fussed about making sure little Jimmy gets an 8 rather than a 7.

Private schools mostly (although this is changing with the teacher retention crisis) have subject specialists so if your child is gifted at, say, Physics, their Physics teacher can support that. In state schools often pupils are not taught by subject specialists. This is changing though as the private sector is struggling with staff recruitment and retention too.

These things do make a difference. Bullying can happen anywhere in any school. I would say there are four factors to educational success (by which I mean achieving that pupil's best which might be a 9 or might be a 4!)

  1. The pupil themselves - do they work hard, act on feedback, ask for extra help when they need it.

  2. Peer environment; this can't be underestimated. If the ethos at a school amongst a friendship group is it isnt cool to work that will hold all pupils back.

  3. Home support

  4. School environment (see above,some of this is almost always better in private because they would close otherwise but there are also some great state schools too).

OP, you know your DD, you can do home support. The things you can't control are peer influence and school environment.

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 24/07/2022 13:12

Our local school is on the verge of special measures. In my daughter's final year (2019/2020) pupils were offered places in Cambridge, St Andrews, Russell Group and one had a full scholarship to the USA.

Another of my daughter's was in a cohort where a quarter of the A level pupils went on to get 1st Class degrees across a wide spectrum of subjects because the pupils were taught to study, not to pass exams.

Jun345 · 24/07/2022 13:12

I was probably your daughter, top of class at primary. Went to very average non fee paying / non exam entry secondary school just the average high school round the corner from my parents. Applied myself throughout high school, got straight As and A*s. Went on to get 3 As at college (again, a non fee paying normal catchment area sixth form college) and then onto university (Nottingham). I am now in a successful high earning job in London (just turned 30) where my counterpart is 4 older than me, but went to one of the best fee paying girl’s schools in the country and then went on to Cambridge. We both ended up in the same job but with very different routes there.

Iwannerbeyourslave · 24/07/2022 13:12

Thanks to the pandemic there is a full set of lessons for every topic and year at secondary on Oak Academy. Some brilliant, some a bit average. All in all enough to get anyone through GCSE's without decent teachers, private schools or expensive tutors. Just takes a bit of effort. If my daughter (in her average comp) doesn't understand something, that's where we go. I am also a big believer in the saying "birds of a feather flock together" - wherever she goes she will hopefully find a friendship group of like-minded souls who will support each other. Doesn't always work like that but, as an ex-teacher, I saw it time and time again.

FreyaStorm · 24/07/2022 13:11

From my experience, top grades aren’t the be all and end all. No point getting into Oxford or Cambridge if you don’t have the social and cultural capital to do well there.
If you can scrape together the funds for private school I certainly would. Not only will she be better resourced to make the top grades, but she will also meet the right sort of people to ensure she gets on in life.
What I missed out on by going to state schools was meeting like minded people.

Bouledepetanque · 24/07/2022 13:03

I went to a very average comp and achieved 9 As at GCSE and 4 As at A level (sciences and maths). It is possible.
But I think it depends very much on the individual.

Factors in my case:

  • I had a supportive family and a quiet space to work
  • I was independent and conscientious and did homework willingly without reminders
  • I had a group of similarly nerdy friends and our social outings were occasional shopping or cinema...very rarely pubs or clubs
  • I didn't have a boyfriend before finishing A levels (no romantic distractions)
  • I had a part time job on and off but never more than a few hours a week.
  • I generally loved school (all subjects) and loved exams
  • I had ambition. I wanted to travel and work and be independent. I actively wanted a good (and well paid!) job from my mid teens. I prioritised success over relationships.

Those are the things I can think of!

Delatron · 24/07/2022 13:03

Our local comp gets great results. Definitely lots of children coming out with top grades. No poor behaviour (or no more than the grammar - in fact the grammar has issues with bullying and drugs)

EtnaVesuvius · 24/07/2022 13:02

Loads of kids get top grades at my dc’s school, which is a large comp. Some of them passed the 11+ but chose not to go to grammar school, so there’s a cohort of very clever kids.

Back in the day (25 years ago 😬) I got 7 A*s and 3 As at GCSE (quite rare then) and AAA at A level despite going to a rough secondary comp. Went to Oxbridge. I was very self-motivated.

She will do well if SHE wants to do well. It doesn’t have as much to do with the school or parenting as people think - she has to be driven.

pointythings · 24/07/2022 13:01

It's perfectly doable with hard work from her and support from you. Both my DDs got good GCSEs (not all 8s and 9s, but what they got reflected their ability) and A levels. And they both had periods when they didn't have the greatest teachers for some subjects - DD2 basically taught herself the entire Yr 9 and 10 syllabus, as acknowledged by her Yr11 teacher, and got an 8.

It is important to look at the ethos of the school though - our local comp is average in its results, but looking at a more granular level it's clear that the 'A C/4 is good enough' ethos isn't part of how it works - it pushes to maximise everyone's performance and is let down by a small cohort of students whose families are just not engaged with education at all.

Discovereads · 24/07/2022 12:58

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 12:48

Tbh it's not possible to know whether she's 'top' or top quartile at primary as they don't rank the children or give them exams as such. She's seems very capable though.

I put her into the private school entrance exam because it was/is an option. I'm not sure it's worth £100k+ for five years education though, when it would put a lot of pressure on me and mean few holidays etc, the money could be spent on uni or helping her in other ways.

Ah I was going to say “was she put in for level 6 SATS and did she pass them?” As that’s how we knew our DC were top of the class in primary. But I’ve just looked it up, and it says they stopped level 6 SATS in 2015.

Thats too bad because it means you’re right, you don’t have a way of knowing.

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 12:51

@Ifyoudid

Also, not all schools set. Most do but some don’t.

Even those who do set, often don't have lots of different ability groups. We had 9 forms in my year. You'd have thought that there'd be several different standards of "sets". But no. The forms were grouped into 3 groups of 3 forms, and there was a top, middle and bottom set for Maths and English in each group. So 3 "top" groups, 3 "middle" groups and 3 "bottom" groups. I was in a "top" group for Maths, but only half that group were doing the higher level Maths exams and half were doing the lower level, so even within a "top" group, there was a massive variation in ability.

There were also exam year subjects which weren't popular, say, only 20 pupils across the entire year, so all were in the same class, whatever ability level and whichever exam they were taking.

WhiteFire · 24/07/2022 12:51

My children are doing fine at their run of the mill comp. I'm pleased that they are at a school that values all the children's achievements.

WhiteFire · 24/07/2022 12:48

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 12:21

@redskyatnight

What she does have is a very strong work ethic and is extremely self motivated. She's also had a supportive peer group.

But if you're bullied literally every day, not just verbally, but also physically, having your property damaged/stolen, then it really doesn't matter how strong is your work ethic or motivation. Bullying just sucks it all out of you. That's what happened to me. As soon as I left school, I basically taught myself to recoup the damage!

That could happen at a private school too.

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 12:48

Tbh it's not possible to know whether she's 'top' or top quartile at primary as they don't rank the children or give them exams as such. She's seems very capable though.

I put her into the private school entrance exam because it was/is an option. I'm not sure it's worth £100k+ for five years education though, when it would put a lot of pressure on me and mean few holidays etc, the money could be spent on uni or helping her in other ways.

OP posts:
SarahSissions · 24/07/2022 12:47

She can, but there is a better chance she will at the private school. BUT as an employer I find that there is a lot of inverse snobbery around private schools now which if it continues may not help her in the long run

MolkosTeenageAngst · 24/07/2022 12:45

Of course she can, plenty of state schools have a high number students achieving top grades. That said, obviously it does depend on the school and the peer group; some state schools will be better at helping high-achieving students do well than others.

Usually information about individual school’s GCSE/ A-level results is available to find so that you can see the percentage of students who have achieved top grades.

Swipe left for the next trending thread