Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
SuperCamp · 24/07/2022 14:28

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 11:53

Everyone is going to reply insisting that she can.

I hope she can. But the odds aren’t in her favour.

Its obviously wrong to say no child who attends a state school doesn’t get top grades but tbh not many do. Plenty will get 5s and 6s that should have been 7s and 8s, but they still passed, so all is well in education.

Please provide evidence for ‘not many do’. Evidence related specifically to high achievers at primary level, not the cohort as a whole.

OP, my Dc went into secondary as high ability, as did many friends. They all did really well and are on academic Uni courses at top reputation places.

lanthanum · 24/07/2022 14:26

Have a look at the comp's GCSE results. Is there a reasonable number of 8/9s in each subject? If so, I wouldn't worry - that shows that it can be done, and it sounds as if your daughter would be one of that top bunch. You're obviously a supportive parent, and that matters more. Saving on the school fees means there's a bit of money for tuition if she needs it.

mamaduckbone · 24/07/2022 14:22

Yes she absolutely can.
I achieved 8 As in a very average secondary school
Ds1 is predicted mostly 8s and 9s (took his GCSEs this year)
The only thing I would say he missed out on was help with his DT practical as the class size was too big.

ZandathePanda · 24/07/2022 14:19

P.s. Dd had a grand total of 2 hours of extra tuition for a science GCSE as the teacher left.

thing47 · 24/07/2022 14:19

If you're looking for a positive story, @HotCaterpillar, DD2 went to a poor-performing secondary modern school (grammar school area so no comps).

This week we went to her graduation ceremony to see her receive her first-class Masters degree. She obtained this from a university ranked 2 in the UK for her particular STEM subject.

She has achieved her academic success by sheer hard work (no tutoring) and when she had a weak teacher, she had the determination and resilience to teach herself. So yes, it absolutely can be done.

ZandathePanda · 24/07/2022 14:18

Dd got two A stars and A at A level and just graduated with a first from university. Her comp was above average but it’s the individual teachers that make a difference at A Level.

minticelime · 24/07/2022 14:17

Of course it's possible to go to any school and get all 9s. The issue is how much more likely this is In one school as opposed to another. I do agree with the pp above that parental support / expectations are probably the greatest determinator, regardless of the school. However, I do also think that all to often in state schools, there is an insidious culture of mediocrity. Children are too frequently told they are amazing and even 'gifted' and put in 'G and T' streams, only to come out with a 7 when exams are marked at a national level. You have to wonder if some teachers know what a 9 looks like! Children are given a false sense of their ability because they are being measured against others in the class who are likely to scrape a 4 at best. Teachers sometimes don't have the time to differentiate enough within classes. Also, the peer culture issue - teens will do anything to fit in and if it's not cool to be conscientious, they won't be.

I think all you can do is give the school a go OP. Your DD might make some great friends and be doing really well. If not, you can revisit moving her going into Year 9 (or earlier if you're not happy with the school).

Ilikecheesycrackers · 24/07/2022 14:12

Both of my (now adult) kids did. I think it depends on whether they can find a supportive peer group within the school.

DigitalGoat · 24/07/2022 14:09

My daughter got straight A*s in her GCSEs and A levels at a standard comprehensive, and has just graduated with a first class Masters from a top university. But she was helped by having a studious group of friends, and being personally highly motivated. She did notice early on that when put in one of the lower sets for her weakest subject (computing) she wasn't learning much - kids were unmotivated and teaching not as good.

faffadoodledo · 24/07/2022 14:09

Look. You may not even need tuition. Mine didn't, and nor did any of their friends. It's a Mn myth that if you go comp you access a different kind of privilege by getting tuition. Honestly most parents either don't, or can't afford it.

Appleblum · 24/07/2022 14:07

Of course she can. But I so think it'll be easier for her to reach her potential in a good private school.

Ganymedemoon · 24/07/2022 14:07

I am a a year away from the same scenario. We cannot afford private, but we can afford some tuition. Which is probably what we'll do to give my DD that extra that she may well not get in the comp.

itssquidstella · 24/07/2022 14:05

I got excellent grades at a pretty crap comp, but I had a miserable time there and I certainly wasn't stretched by the majority of my teachers. In fact, I distinctly remember going to speak to the head of French about how to maximise my chance of getting an A star at GCSE: she scoffed and said the only person who'd managed it in the last few years was her daughter. Equally, in my top set Maths class, half the set were entered for the Intermediate paper (where a B was the top grade available) rather than the Higher. It wasn't an environment where learning was encouraged, and it definitely wasn't cool to be clever (although I did have a couple of excellent and inspirational teachers who made my time there just about bearable).

If it's a school where there's a significant cohort of able and motivated pupils - leading to top sets where all or the majority of pupils are aiming for grade 8/9 - then I think a bright child has a very good chance of getting top grades, as well as having a positive educational experience. But where there are few pupils in that position, even a motivated child will have to show unusual determination and resilience to do well, and to rise above their peers.

Nottheholygrail · 24/07/2022 14:03

Name changed for obvious reasons. My DD attends a super selective indie in London. She’s had 3 English teachers changed in her GCSE course. In one actual GCSE exam subject this year, the department wrongly decided to advise the kids what was going to be ‘low tariff’ questions and therefore less likely to come up on the paper as worth less than 5% overall. They were wrong. Cue the entire year having a meltdown as 20% of the paper was on a ‘low tariff’ topic and many of them wanted to study the subject at a level for which they need a top grade. The head is out of touch and writes letters to parents leaving everyone wondering what on earth she’s on about, the SLT leader in charge of education thinks they are the cleverest person on god’s earth and will not accept that they’ve got some matters very wrong. I’ve still had to employ tutors one for maths and two of the sciences on top of the fees.

That said, during lockdown the difference between my DD’s access to lessons versus the kids next door or were not at an indie was vastly different. Had all the kids had the same access I’m not sure that their results would be all that different but there is unlikely to be another pandemic 🤞.

So, in short, not the holy grail. If I had my time again, I’d probably not bother with the £125k I’ve spent but would’ve supplemented with tutors and extra curricular instead and paid for uni fees instead.

harriethoyle · 24/07/2022 14:01

She definitely can. I got As/Bs at GCSE, all As at A levels and went to Oxbridge. A lot of that was definitely my attitude though... used free periods for school work instead of driving lessons. Mind you, I didn't end up taking my driving test until I was late 30s so you can't have it all! 🤣🙈

Blossomtoes · 24/07/2022 13:59

No point getting into Oxford or Cambridge if you don’t have the social and cultural capital

Really? Over 60% of Oxbridge students are from state schools. This isn’t the 1920s.

shiningstar2 · 24/07/2022 13:52

A lot depends n the teachers she gets. Not just how well they teach but also their classroom management skills. Even top sets in 'aversge' state secondary schools can have disruptive pupils in them who stop the learning of a very one else
Also the culture of homework as she gets older. Is it set and marked regularly. Are their consequences for not handing it in or is this just passed over as too many kids aren't bothering? Even kids who have been very hard working in primary can fall off the learning wagon if others around then aren't bothering or if success isn't 'cool' with her peers.

Newnormal99 · 24/07/2022 13:51

My daughter goes to a comp and has just been predicted 8's and 9's for next year

They have added an extra lesson 2 days a week in the timetable for them from
next year and I think she will get plenty of support.

She is also however quite studious and organised and will look up past papers etc herself.

Her friendship group are also the same and I believe they are generally all looking at high grades.

Lovemusic33 · 24/07/2022 13:51

My dd did.
we did consider going for scholarship but dd chose which school she wanted to go too and chose a local comp with average ofstead reports.

She got all 8’s and 9’s in GCSE and is now awaiting A level results, she has a offer for a top uni (which she has turned down in favour of another uni). She has always been able to decide for herself where to go, where she feels most comfortable and has always achieved high.

TessBeth · 24/07/2022 13:50

I did - went to an average comprehensive, had an awful home life and no tutoring or anything, just worked hard and of course, in retrospect must have had good teachers.

AhNowTed · 24/07/2022 13:48

Absolutely.

Ultimately your attitude and expectations at home have a far bigger impact on your daughter than any school.

Both mine went to a very mixed school, looked down on by the favoured catchment. They both thrived.

In fact I would say that smart kids do really well at average schools they stand out and teachers will really encourage them.

SortingOffice · 24/07/2022 13:46

And if Oxbridge or Med school turns out to be an ambition please seek extra advice
This is true. Not only was there no preparation or help available DS1 was actually discouraged from applying to Oxbridge as not for the likes of us. I had to counter that.

DorritLittle · 24/07/2022 13:44

My relative is an Oxbridge academic and went to a state school but I wouldn't say that it was an average one. They are proof that top grades don't have to mean private school though.

SortingOffice · 24/07/2022 13:43

Star failure there. My dc got A stars at gcse and a level. DC1 actually got 5 A stars at A level.

faffadoodledo · 24/07/2022 13:42

Yes she can. Both mine did, and the comp wasn't even average! In fact it's just gone into Special Measures and had the Head removed. They both achieved all A stars in the old GCSEs, and the same in A levels. And weren't alone. But I would say that some who entered the school at the same level but without the same MC family background didn't reach their potential.
i'd also say prepare yourself for sone good old fashioned 'swot' bullying. It can take real strength of character to keep pushing on when others are trying to bring you down. That said bullying happens in all kinds of schools and takes on all kinds of hues.
So keep you eye on peer group, and everything in fact!
And if Oxbridge or Med school turns out to be an ambition please seek extra advice. My DC's school was useless. No extra help in the entrance exams or for interview. Compare and contrast with the local private school who devoted whole Weds afternoons to the endeavour in 6th form.
Eyes wide open!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread