Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
GreenLeavesRustling · 24/07/2022 15:33

She can.

and it will be down to her own hard work and effort, rather than mummy and daddy’s millions

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:32

I actually agree.

my children go private (scholarships) and I am aghast at the difference to state. And appalled.

i don’t think there should be a two tier for anything as important as health and education.

but I am the ultimate hypocrite as my children are privately educated and I pay a fortune for private health care

Mammyloveswine · 24/07/2022 15:32

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:30

@Mammyloveswine

Your hellish experience of teaching in the state system…

Since going back in September I am a mess. I have a really challenging class, my new role is double the workload yet still on a part time salary. Assessment arrangements keep changing so I'm constantly playing catch up and I feel so utterly overwhelmed.

I have spoken to my gp who has referred me for counselling but I am waking up vomiting with anxiety every night. My heart is constantly racing, I feel on the edge of tears constantly!

I feel like I'm losing my mind!

I know that I probably need to take some time off but that terrifies me!

I just want to run away ☹️

is practically unheard of as the teaching experience in the private sector

Wow, using my post from almost two years ago when I was on the verge of a nervous breakdown...

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 15:31

I think there are probably elements of the new national curriculum that don’t work so well, but I don’t mind the reforms in my subject, I must admit.

Mammyloveswine · 24/07/2022 15:30

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:23

@Mammyloveswine

I would NEVER send my child to private school even if I could afford it, I am vehemently against a two tier education system and think private schools are a breeding ground for snobbery and self-entitlement.

I went to the worst comprehensive in my home city..,I got top grades at GCSE then went to the local college and got As and Bs.

do you think you may have a rather different perspective if your experience has been very different? I suspect so

Well I mean I could just look at the privately educated government...

I am opposed to a two tier education system as I think it is so so important that EVERY child receives a top quality education..

I don't agree with how the tories have "reformed" the national curriculum and actually the narrowing of the curriculum and "teach to the test" does not provide a rounded education..

But op asked if her daughter could get top grades and of course she can! Op clearly values education and those values will pass to her daughter.

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:30

@Mammyloveswine

Your hellish experience of teaching in the state system…

Since going back in September I am a mess. I have a really challenging class, my new role is double the workload yet still on a part time salary. Assessment arrangements keep changing so I'm constantly playing catch up and I feel so utterly overwhelmed.

I have spoken to my gp who has referred me for counselling but I am waking up vomiting with anxiety every night. My heart is constantly racing, I feel on the edge of tears constantly!

I feel like I'm losing my mind!

I know that I probably need to take some time off but that terrifies me!

I just want to run away ☹️

is practically unheard of as the teaching experience in the private sector

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 15:28

And - if you did your GCSEs before 2017, it’s not really comparable anyway. I got an A* in French in 1997, but even I have to concede my French isn’t marvellous.

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 15:27

The thing is, I’ve been teaching a long time, and while there are some unsupportive parents, it’s rare that you meet parents who really don’t give a shit.

Most parents want to support their child’s learning, but it often tapers off regardless. Why is that?

Its too easy to assume that most state secondary schools are crammed full of students who have parents who just don’t care, apart from your child, of course, and a handful of their friends, but it doesn’t make much sense, does it?

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:25

You know that worst comp in my city that you went to and got amazing results.

you saw it as “worst” because presumably most kids got piss poor results.

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:23

@Mammyloveswine

I would NEVER send my child to private school even if I could afford it, I am vehemently against a two tier education system and think private schools are a breeding ground for snobbery and self-entitlement.

I went to the worst comprehensive in my home city..,I got top grades at GCSE then went to the local college and got As and Bs.

do you think you may have a rather different perspective if your experience has been very different? I suspect so

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 15:22

Of course it isn’t ignorant. Statistically, children who go to private schools are twice as likely to get the top grades (7, 8, 9) than their state school counterparts.

How on earth is that ignorant? It’s a fact. It doesn’t mean no one who goes to a state school will get brilliant results, but it isn’t as likely.

rnsaslkih · 24/07/2022 15:21

Either way it’s a lottery IMO. You’ll have to keep an eye on what’s going on.

Plenty of private schools are flogging teachers half to death. My kids are at a private school and my dd has had about 50% of her biology lessons as cover lessons this year. When the teacher turns up, the lessons are great. Otherwise my dd teaches herself whilst a succession of random (non biology) staff cover the class. Obviously some kids are not motivated or savvy enough to teach themselves. But my dd realises that this is GCSE content without which, she will be fucked.

Mammyloveswine · 24/07/2022 15:18

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 11:53

Everyone is going to reply insisting that she can.

I hope she can. But the odds aren’t in her favour.

Its obviously wrong to say no child who attends a state school doesn’t get top grades but tbh not many do. Plenty will get 5s and 6s that should have been 7s and 8s, but they still passed, so all is well in education.

What a ridiculous and ignorant comment!!!

Yes op of course your daughter is likely to do well!

I would NEVER send my child to private school even if I could afford it, I am vehemently against a two tier education system and think private schools are a breeding ground for snobbery and self-entitlement.

I went to the worst comprehensive in my home city..,I got top grades at GCSE then went to the local college and got As and Bs. I got a first class degree and am now a teacher myself in one of the most significantly deprived schools in the entire country, I am unbelievably proud of teaching where I teach and of the pupils I teach and I despise the way that in this country young people and children are written off before they even stand a chance!

fatlazycow · 24/07/2022 15:14

Yes of course, mumsnet can seem like a different world sometimes. I only know people who went to ‘average comps.’

padsi1975 · 24/07/2022 15:11

Don't 93% of the nation's children go to state school? Is there a culture of mediocrity holding back the vast majority of the country's students? This seems so unlikely. I wish I'd known about the snobbery in UK schooling before I moved here. It's one thing that baffles me and makes me wish I was raising my children elsewhere.

Purplepatsy · 24/07/2022 15:08

I would say she can get top grades providing she works hard and has a good memory for facts.

You can see how she gets on and if necessary, pay for tutoring.

Please also remember that the top universities are increasingly more likely to offer places to students from the state sector.

ZandathePanda · 24/07/2022 15:00

@SuperCamp snap!

ZandathePanda · 24/07/2022 14:58

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 14:38

here are the percentages with a breakdown of grades. 12% with 7, 9.1% with 8 and 7.4% with 9.

But as you can see from this link, “61.2 per cent of privately educated pupils’ results were at grades 7, 8 or 9, the second highest performance behind the 68.4 per cent secured by pupils at selective schools.”

guardian link here

for balance a Mail link

Of course, it’s hard because the last two years have been disruptive. But I do find on these threads there’s a lot of defensiveness, which is weird, because on threads about education generally everyone agrees it’s underfunded, teachers are struggling, etc. But then if you suggest this just might have an adverse effect on children, people bite your head off and tell you about their own DCs success.

But you are not comparing like for like, especially in 2021 when private school grades inflation jumped a lot higher than state school grades.

My Dd got good SATS at primary. The other children her age getting similar results went to private school. She got higher grades at A Level than they did.

The biggest factor in making sure your children does well is a supportive family environment. Parents at private school will have an interest in their child doing well (not least as they are paying for it) and expect a return for their money. As a cohort, these children will be fed well, have technology and text books to help them succeed. Take away the children that don’t have all these at a state school, then compare the numbers.

Skidaramink · 24/07/2022 14:53

I did, OP. And the great thing is that these days you have a much better chance of getting into Oxbridge from a state school, as they apply positive bias, quite rightly.

SuperCamp · 24/07/2022 14:44

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 14:38

here are the percentages with a breakdown of grades. 12% with 7, 9.1% with 8 and 7.4% with 9.

But as you can see from this link, “61.2 per cent of privately educated pupils’ results were at grades 7, 8 or 9, the second highest performance behind the 68.4 per cent secured by pupils at selective schools.”

guardian link here

for balance a Mail link

Of course, it’s hard because the last two years have been disruptive. But I do find on these threads there’s a lot of defensiveness, which is weird, because on threads about education generally everyone agrees it’s underfunded, teachers are struggling, etc. But then if you suggest this just might have an adverse effect on children, people bite your head off and tell you about their own DCs success.

Privately educated and state grammar students are ‘selected’, and there are many reasons why their percentage of higher grades may be proportionately higher. Greater number of motivated supportive parents, more individual attention at school, better facilities, more ‘enrichment’ etc that come with these opportunities.

And yes state education needs greater funding.

But your stats do not add up to ‘not many’ do well and the ‘odds being not in her favour’ given that she is very bright and has a motivated supportive Mum.

brighteyesburninglikefire · 24/07/2022 14:44

Yes my son went to a state comp, got all 9s and 8s, and 3 A* atA level. He had excellent teachers. A lot of the other students all did exceptionally well. Although, the school is selective at 6th form, but many are.

Essie274 · 24/07/2022 14:39

OF COURSE SHE CAN.

Especially if you could have scraped enough to pay for private school fees, as that means you can easily afford to give her a well-rounded education through extra curricular activities, pursue her interests and tutors outside of the state comp.

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 14:38

here are the percentages with a breakdown of grades. 12% with 7, 9.1% with 8 and 7.4% with 9.

But as you can see from this link, “61.2 per cent of privately educated pupils’ results were at grades 7, 8 or 9, the second highest performance behind the 68.4 per cent secured by pupils at selective schools.”

guardian link here

for balance a Mail link

Of course, it’s hard because the last two years have been disruptive. But I do find on these threads there’s a lot of defensiveness, which is weird, because on threads about education generally everyone agrees it’s underfunded, teachers are struggling, etc. But then if you suggest this just might have an adverse effect on children, people bite your head off and tell you about their own DCs success.

Shortbread49 · 24/07/2022 14:37

If she is bright and motivated she will do well wherever she goes the key is to go to the right environment for her where she feels happy and settled . I went to a not working good comprehensive where university was not a concept that existed and the aim was to get everyone on a YTS scheme (remember those 😀). I got the best o levels but not straight As as in some subjects we had a succession of different teachers and for physics no teacher. Then I went to sixth form in a girls grammar and didn’t work as I felt I didn’t fit in so the right environment is important

2bazookas · 24/07/2022 14:33

My sons attended a rural comp, enjoyed a fantastic social grounding, achieved the very highest exam grades (sciences) and went to top universities.

Where they couldn't help noticing that both socially and academically they were better prepared than some of their class mates from top private boarding schools.