Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 24/07/2022 17:16

State school means you can afford for her to have tutors and have holidays and a life.

Private school isnt worth making huge sacrifices in lifestyle

TheWayoftheLeaf · 24/07/2022 17:12

My sister did. And I did. My cousin didnt.

We're not geniuses but were conscientious, curious and wanted to earn good grades.

Depends on the kid.

lightisnotwhite · 24/07/2022 17:02

Of course it’s a numbers game. All the private schools near me ( small market town in SE and we have three) require exams to enter.

93% go to state school and that’s with 7% of kids who are selected for grammar or private gone. The state school top results are only half as good but with many percentage more kids, of all abilities.

I’d say consider private for the middling children. The ones that will get lost in the state school system but pushed in private. The clever ones will be fine at state school as long as they put the work in. But as I also said before they all end up at the same Unis .

And sport.

Notasyoungasiwas · 24/07/2022 16:42

Absolutely! My daughter went to an 'average' comp and achieved top grades in her GCSEs and A Levels. She's currently reading law at uni.

whumpthereitis · 24/07/2022 16:32

It’s possible, but statistically less likely. A lot of it depends on parental involvement, how motivated the child is, and the ethos of the school. I had a friend who went to a comp and there was an issue of smart kids being bullied for being engaged, and teachers having to spend a good proportion of lesson time dealing with the troublemakers as opposed to actually teaching. Conversely, I went to a private school, and the students there wanted to work hard and achieve. Some kids are resilient and will succeed regardless of what school they attend, but others will be, to their benefit or their detriment, heavily influenced by their environment.

not all comps are like this of course, and not all private schools are wonderful, but yes, in terms of outcome there is a stark results gap between independent and state schools and it’s one that’s grown in the last few years.

MsTSwift · 24/07/2022 16:14

Some of my dds state teachers have been incredible. Very impressive. Can’t see how they could have been better in any other sector. Their school is state but academic it’s cool to do well. Their results are just as good as the all girls private school my friend analysed them.

Minimalme · 24/07/2022 16:12

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:46

Apologise for what?

her experience of teaching in a state school sounds almost suicidally bad.

you don’t think that it is relevant?

My best friend teaches in a private school - she has a relentless stream of parents who constantly demand more because they are paying.

If she could get the same pay in a state school, she'd go back like a shot.

pd339 · 24/07/2022 16:12

I got straight A*s back when that was the highest grade you could get, in a pretty bad comp. Yes of course it is possible.

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 16:11

Mammyloveswine · 24/07/2022 16:07

I am a very productive and enthusiastic teacher...my pupils have NEVER suffered as I give my all during the hours I teach them, teaching is a performance.

I am sure there are teachers in private schools who have struggled mentally, struggled with the pressure, struggled with the workload..

I sought support for my mental health and I am back to my old self again. In fact this year has been one of my absolute favourite years of teaching despite the challenges and impact of covid and I am looking forward to next year! Teaching is hard, there are times I question why I do it but seeing the pupils I teach make the progress they do makes it absolutely worth it!

That is great news!

Longlostfamilial · 24/07/2022 16:10

She most definitely can. My children went to a comprehensive rated good when they started, and failing by the time they finished. Both did well, first child was always middle of the road to top half of the year in results, went to a good university and got a first. Second child was always very bright, did have some minor bullying issues at school (mainly as bright, seen as nerdy, and bit sporty) but sailed through 4 a levels and got two A* and two A, first at RGuniversity in maths and now earning a whopping salary at 29. And to the bullying, the child I knew who was most bullied was at a very highly regarded single sex expensive private school, so it happens everywhere.

Mammyloveswine · 24/07/2022 16:07

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:47

good grief I am not criticising her.

but pointing out the environment is a heck of a lot more conducive to productive and enthusiastic teaching in the private sector than the state.

I am a very productive and enthusiastic teacher...my pupils have NEVER suffered as I give my all during the hours I teach them, teaching is a performance.

I am sure there are teachers in private schools who have struggled mentally, struggled with the pressure, struggled with the workload..

I sought support for my mental health and I am back to my old self again. In fact this year has been one of my absolute favourite years of teaching despite the challenges and impact of covid and I am looking forward to next year! Teaching is hard, there are times I question why I do it but seeing the pupils I teach make the progress they do makes it absolutely worth it!

MsTSwift · 24/07/2022 16:06

Always seems so silly to compare private and state results. Only about 7% go to private school and they are the wealthiest families in the country. No shit their results are better than the general population who take all children! They jolly well should be! Op if she is motivated and makes some nice friends she will fulfil her potential.

Holly60 · 24/07/2022 16:01

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:47

good grief I am not criticising her.

but pointing out the environment is a heck of a lot more conducive to productive and enthusiastic teaching in the private sector than the state.

There are different pressures and different motivations for teachers in each sector.

On balance I think I'd rather my children were taught by individuals who were there because they really felt they wanted to make a difference, rather than someone thinks they've chosen the easy option.

Mammyloveswine · 24/07/2022 16:00

Minimalme · 24/07/2022 15:44

@Ohthatsexciting you should apologise for that, it was a cheap shot.

@Mammyloveswine is more qualified than anyone else on this thread - her opinion on state schooling comes from a place of professional experience.

My son's secondary just got it's first "Good" Ofsted rating in 63 years. It is a school that has a higher than average number of children with SEN, behavioural difficulties and deprivation.

He is going into year 9 and in on target to get top GCSEs. He is naturally very smart and loves learning. He is proud of his school and if he gets to University, will be much more rounded in the art of real life than many of his privately schooled counterparts.

I will let you know how he gets on.

Thank you @Minimalme

Good luck to your son! I'm sure he will be amazing!

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 15:55

I’m a teacher in the state sector too. But I’m not more qualified, because no one agrees with me Grin

‘tis true though. Start a thread about how bad teaching is, how awful the government is, how poor recruitment and retention is, everyone agrees.

But apparently it makes NO DIFFERENCE to kids performance in exams Hmm remarkable really!

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:48

Minimalme · 24/07/2022 15:46

Aghast and appalled? You need to get out more.

“Getting put more” not in this heat. Me and kids staying put in the garden 😂

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:47

good grief I am not criticising her.

but pointing out the environment is a heck of a lot more conducive to productive and enthusiastic teaching in the private sector than the state.

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:46

Apologise for what?

her experience of teaching in a state school sounds almost suicidally bad.

you don’t think that it is relevant?

Minimalme · 24/07/2022 15:46

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:32

I actually agree.

my children go private (scholarships) and I am aghast at the difference to state. And appalled.

i don’t think there should be a two tier for anything as important as health and education.

but I am the ultimate hypocrite as my children are privately educated and I pay a fortune for private health care

Aghast and appalled? You need to get out more.

Minimalme · 24/07/2022 15:44

@Ohthatsexciting you should apologise for that, it was a cheap shot.

@Mammyloveswine is more qualified than anyone else on this thread - her opinion on state schooling comes from a place of professional experience.

My son's secondary just got it's first "Good" Ofsted rating in 63 years. It is a school that has a higher than average number of children with SEN, behavioural difficulties and deprivation.

He is going into year 9 and in on target to get top GCSEs. He is naturally very smart and loves learning. He is proud of his school and if he gets to University, will be much more rounded in the art of real life than many of his privately schooled counterparts.

I will let you know how he gets on.

Holly60 · 24/07/2022 15:39

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 15:22

Of course it isn’t ignorant. Statistically, children who go to private schools are twice as likely to get the top grades (7, 8, 9) than their state school counterparts.

How on earth is that ignorant? It’s a fact. It doesn’t mean no one who goes to a state school will get brilliant results, but it isn’t as likely.

Yes but put those same kids in state school, with all the same money, parental support, extra curricular and experiences, and they'd probably do just as well.

It is not the school they maketh the man but the man that maketh the school.

CashmereMutt · 24/07/2022 15:37

Dh went to a pretty crap comp - he was the first kid from there to go to Cambridge...it still hasn't improved much. He did lots of work independently and a teacher at the school who had attended Oxbridge coached him on the application process.

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:35

As for the question the op asks, utterly ridiculous. Does she never read the papers, research schools results??!

Holly60 · 24/07/2022 15:34

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 11:53

Everyone is going to reply insisting that she can.

I hope she can. But the odds aren’t in her favour.

Its obviously wrong to say no child who attends a state school doesn’t get top grades but tbh not many do. Plenty will get 5s and 6s that should have been 7s and 8s, but they still passed, so all is well in education.

That is literally not how it works at all. All students get predicted grades based on their prior attainment data from primary and socio economic information and the thrashers and school are judged by how well that student does against their individual target.

If she works hard and has high FFT data she will do really well.

Ohthatsexciting · 24/07/2022 15:34

Mammyloveswine · 24/07/2022 15:32

Wow, using my post from almost two years ago when I was on the verge of a nervous breakdown...

There’s more recent.

But that is not the point.

it sounded hellish, truly hellish and that must have impacted your teaching. I don’t see how it couldn’t. And that is NO criticism of you.