Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
AntlerRose · 26/07/2022 07:42

I think you should look at the results for this particular comp. You can see if any children are getting top grades there and that gives you an idea whether they are teaching some to that level and what sort of proprtion. You want a class worth of pupils with higher grades. I also think the progress 8 is a goods.

Fairislefandango · 26/07/2022 07:28

I've taught for over 25 years and have worked in comps and private schools. I'd very much agree that a child has a much better chance of getting top grades in a private school. Obviously some students in comps get top grades, but imo they have to have a level of motivation and determination to do it, which would be less necessary in a good private school (not necessarily in a mediocre or crap one though!).

I have a very bright dd currein year 12. I would have sent her privately if we cpuld have afforded it. Her GCSE grades were good, but I have no doubt she could have got all 8s and 9s.

Pottedpalm · 26/07/2022 07:24

Newnormal99 · 26/07/2022 07:10

My daughters comp did class reading time first thing every morning until recently. They have now switched to morning maths every day.

At the recent prep for y11 meeting they were very keen to point out that it is important for the children to turn up for this and that if people were paying for GCSE tutoring for that extra time it would be nearly £100 a week!

This sounds admirable. Is the session taught? By maths teachers? Great though it is , it can’t have the same effect as an
hour of one to one tuition, I think.

MintyCedricRidesAgain · 26/07/2022 07:18

My DD went to a good state secondary.

Her entire 5 years there were an absolute shitshow on a personal level, encompassing divorce, issues with her father, body image issues, friendship issues, dgp on end of life care/dying halfway through exams, and of course the bloody pandemic!

She got 7/8/9 in 9 out of 10 of her GCSEs (less for French as she opted for the lower paper).

On target for AAA in A-levels and hopefully Russell Group uni to study law next year. Tutors have urged her to apply to Oxbridge but she wants to be London based.

There is absolutely no reason your daughter can't do well at an average state school of she puts her mind to it and has your support.

Newnormal99 · 26/07/2022 07:10

My daughters comp did class reading time first thing every morning until recently. They have now switched to morning maths every day.

At the recent prep for y11 meeting they were very keen to point out that it is important for the children to turn up for this and that if people were paying for GCSE tutoring for that extra time it would be nearly £100 a week!

Iamnotthe1 · 26/07/2022 07:03

I suspect the studies to which you refer don't exist but if they do, a private tutor for a couple of hours a week will be far cheaper than a private school

Especially when you factor in that many parents of private school children also end up getting a tutor anyway.

Darbs76 · 26/07/2022 07:01

Perfectly possible. My son got 9x9’s and is predicted 3 A*’s (result next month, he thinks he has achieved that) in an ordinary comp. He didn’t get into a grammar school. But he put it 100% and some effort, he worked so hard for that. So I’d say it depends on how she applies herself and if she changes etc.

MsTSwift · 26/07/2022 06:57

Such a tiny minority of the population go to a private school as a country we would be stuffed it was only them succeeding!

SnackSizeRaisin · 26/07/2022 06:54

Discovereads · 24/07/2022 12:03

Yes a very bright child that also works hard can get top grades at an average comprehensive school. It’s not impossible. Although, studies have shown that many children who get top grades at average comps are those whose parents paid for private tutors.

But I think YABU thinking your child can get top grades if she just works as hard or harder than she is now. Your child got “near top of class” in primary, so I think your expectations are too high tbh. It is likely she will remain “near top of class” at the comp where-ever that is for it. Could be a 6 or 7.

Top grades (8-9 in GCSEs) is like a three legged stool. You need intelligence, hard work and good teachers. You knock out one of those legs and it’s a lot less likely that top grades will be attainable. If you’re going to send her to the local comp, you will probably need to pay for a few private tutors for her to get top grades. This would still be far cheaper than a fee paying school, and quite a few parents who cannot afford private do go down this route.

Which of the legs do you think is missing in a state school? The teachers are likely to be just as good or better. The intelligence is unchanged. The hard work is the bit that may fail, depending on peer group, parenting and the child herself.
To be honest a highly intelligent child can get top grades as GCSE without doing too much work. It's A level where it gets more challenging.
I suspect the studies to which you refer don't exist but if they do, a private tutor for a couple of hours a week will be far cheaper than a private school

SnackSizeRaisin · 26/07/2022 06:46

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 11:53

Everyone is going to reply insisting that she can.

I hope she can. But the odds aren’t in her favour.

Its obviously wrong to say no child who attends a state school doesn’t get top grades but tbh not many do. Plenty will get 5s and 6s that should have been 7s and 8s, but they still passed, so all is well in education.

This is complete rubbish. Lots of children do well in state schools as you can see if you look at published results.

Parental support is the biggest predictor of good exam results. You can always get a private tutor for exams if need be.

Valeriekat · 26/07/2022 06:40

The biggest barrier to success in a (decent) comp is the bright students not realising who they are competing against. Which is the rest of the world.
Work ethic comes from home and parents not school. It isn't about grades it is about aspiration.
Oxbridge/imperial/Med School.
They need to plan from early on.
Get a Maths tutor if the school isn't setting for Maths

lightisnotwhite · 24/07/2022 23:06

@Ifyoudid no rich kids aren’t cleverer than poor ones but they have educational advantages. Usually why it’s the better off middle class kids in comps getting the grades rather than the equally bright but disadvantaged poorer kids. Hard to do homework if you live in overcrowded housing, you can only get the school transport in and out so can’t study later or earlier, you have to work at weekends to buy your stuff et etc..
Selective state schools do better than private. Of course grades will be lower when there’s zero choice over who you are teaching.

whumpthereitis · 24/07/2022 19:28

Bednobsbroomsticks · 24/07/2022 17:28

My daughter went to a troubles school in a deprived area and just got her degree at Warwick. You can put a kid who doesn't want to learn in a private school and they can fail. It's the kid not the school

It’s a combination of factors. A kid can want to learn, but can have that desire bullied out of them in a poor school. Environment matters.

some kids will do well everywhere, but others will absolutely sink despite of their potential.

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 18:46

@2bazookas i haven’t argued otherwise. The teachers are as good, the curriculum (at exam level) the same, but private school students are still outperforming their state school counterparts. Since I don’t believe rich children are cleverer than poorer ones, I do think there are reasons for that.

EtnaVesuvius · 24/07/2022 18:39

Mamansparkles · 24/07/2022 13:13

I'm a teacher who has taught in lots of different types of schools across the sectors.
Yes, of course bright pupils can get good grades in a state school. But it isn't always as easy depending on the school.

In private, even with class sizes creeping up teachers are contracted to put in extra hours of support in a way that they arent in state. Many still do in state, but some don't.

In private, yes there is violence and fights do happen but the perpetrators can be removed after just a couple of incidents: they can have zero tolerance policies. It is very difficult to remove pupils from state.

Even in private schools that don't select on ability (there are some) and have a full range of abilities including mild-moderate learning difficulties like was imagined for a comprehensive school, they are able to turn away pupils who they can't look after or educate (eg those with severe SEND who should really not be in mainstream education but are due to the shortage of SEND places). Comps can't cope with them either but have to. These pupils need more attention from the teacher, leaving less for the others. No one wins in this scenario but there is a severe shortage of SEND placements and funding.

Private schools are judged on their grades for individual children. If children aren't achieving, their parents complain and other parents don't send kids there. Some state schools will be graded on how many kids get Cs and above so will not be fussed about making sure little Jimmy gets an 8 rather than a 7.

Private schools mostly (although this is changing with the teacher retention crisis) have subject specialists so if your child is gifted at, say, Physics, their Physics teacher can support that. In state schools often pupils are not taught by subject specialists. This is changing though as the private sector is struggling with staff recruitment and retention too.

These things do make a difference. Bullying can happen anywhere in any school. I would say there are four factors to educational success (by which I mean achieving that pupil's best which might be a 9 or might be a 4!)

  1. The pupil themselves - do they work hard, act on feedback, ask for extra help when they need it.

  2. Peer environment; this can't be underestimated. If the ethos at a school amongst a friendship group is it isnt cool to work that will hold all pupils back.

  3. Home support

  4. School environment (see above,some of this is almost always better in private because they would close otherwise but there are also some great state schools too).

OP, you know your DD, you can do home support. The things you can't control are peer influence and school environment.

This is all true. I remember bad behaviour being really disruptive at school, and it’s the same now for my DCs’ school. It’s frustrating when they want to learn. Teachers have to spend a lot more time dealing with ‘problem’ pupils in state schools.

Which is why I think the single most important factor is the child’s attitude. If she’s really driven, none of that will matter.

2bazookas · 24/07/2022 18:37

Ifyoudid · 24/07/2022 15:22

Of course it isn’t ignorant. Statistically, children who go to private schools are twice as likely to get the top grades (7, 8, 9) than their state school counterparts.

How on earth is that ignorant? It’s a fact. It doesn’t mean no one who goes to a state school will get brilliant results, but it isn’t as likely.

ALL private schools interview test and select their entry (and remove any who interfere with lessons, other pupils learning etc) . The fees are a social selector of parents. So private schools are teaching a very different cohort .

Comprehensives are non selective so contain the entire range of intelligence, behaviour and social backgrounds.

That's the "statistic* that drives the difference in exam grades.

redskyatnight · 24/07/2022 18:15

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 12:21

@redskyatnight

What she does have is a very strong work ethic and is extremely self motivated. She's also had a supportive peer group.

But if you're bullied literally every day, not just verbally, but also physically, having your property damaged/stolen, then it really doesn't matter how strong is your work ethic or motivation. Bullying just sucks it all out of you. That's what happened to me. As soon as I left school, I basically taught myself to recoup the damage!

Being horrendously bullied at private school (who didn't care as long as I was still getting decent results) is one reason my children are in state.
it took me years as an adult to recoup the damage.

redskyatnight · 24/07/2022 18:13

MsTSwift · 24/07/2022 16:06

Always seems so silly to compare private and state results. Only about 7% go to private school and they are the wealthiest families in the country. No shit their results are better than the general population who take all children! They jolly well should be! Op if she is motivated and makes some nice friends she will fulfil her potential.

Not to mention that a large number of private schools only select the most able children in the first place. Frankly it's not really a surprise that a school that selects the top 10% of the ability range gets in the top 10% of results. I'd be more impressed with private schools if they had the same intake as your average comp and still got better results.

thing47 · 24/07/2022 18:04

Actually most of the pedagogic evidence shows that the quality of teaching (and of teacher) is a far more significant factor in educational achievement than class size per se. It's better to be in a large class with a great teacher than a small class with an average one.

So thank you all the teachers on here Flowers

RuthW · 24/07/2022 17:45

If she is prepared to but the work in then she will get good grades anywhere.

faffadoodledo · 24/07/2022 17:38

faffadoodledo · 24/07/2022 17:26

Yes but @lightisnotwhite there are entrance exams and entrance exams. Frankly the ones at our local rural private school are pretty rinky dink. It has a rep for taking kids who would get 'lost' or 'eaten alive' in a comp and helping them to better grades though small class sizes. It's not a briny I take that gets grades; it's class size

It's not a 'brain it takes';

cestlavielife · 24/07/2022 17:31

Does the comp have at least one kid each year getting a* a levels? Then of course she can too

Bednobsbroomsticks · 24/07/2022 17:28

My daughter went to a troubles school in a deprived area and just got her degree at Warwick. You can put a kid who doesn't want to learn in a private school and they can fail. It's the kid not the school

faffadoodledo · 24/07/2022 17:26

Yes but @lightisnotwhite there are entrance exams and entrance exams. Frankly the ones at our local rural private school are pretty rinky dink. It has a rep for taking kids who would get 'lost' or 'eaten alive' in a comp and helping them to better grades though small class sizes. It's not a briny I take that gets grades; it's class size

SoftSheen · 24/07/2022 17:25

YANBU. But she will need to be highly self-motivated, hard-working and independent, with plenty of support from you. Most recently, 70% of Oxbridge offers have gone to state school applicants.