Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
Ohthatsexciting · 26/07/2022 13:17

Adversity · 26/07/2022 13:07

DS got all top grades at a well below average school. He was in top set for everything, the kids were well behaved. I think if you have a child who will be in lower sets that’s where the more disruptive behaviour is.

I was put in lower sets by accident. The results given by my middle school for me were incorrect. After 2 weeks the teachers apologised and I was moved. The way the class behaved, the difference was night and day.

What made it “below average”?

well behaved and streaming doesn’t sound “below average”

Goesbothways · 26/07/2022 13:15

I got good grades at GCSE and A Level and I was focussed but I'm certain I'd have done better at private school.

I moved my son from private for year 7 onwards, everyone said how he'd be top of the class for everything in the "outstanding" comp I sent him to. Was simply not true. But he still came out with 144 UCAS points.

Adversity · 26/07/2022 13:07

DS got all top grades at a well below average school. He was in top set for everything, the kids were well behaved. I think if you have a child who will be in lower sets that’s where the more disruptive behaviour is.

I was put in lower sets by accident. The results given by my middle school for me were incorrect. After 2 weeks the teachers apologised and I was moved. The way the class behaved, the difference was night and day.

RealBecca · 26/07/2022 13:00

Not all state schools are equal and that's the bite for me. My school was failing, still is 20 years later. Kids did coke in the toilets. Drank vodka on water bottles. Fights. Lots of teen pregnancy. My husband doesnt recognise this as anything like his state school. Guess who got straight As and who didn't. 100% agree with previous poster who said a lot depends on pupil interest in learning, who their friends are, home life. My husband parents were very involved. Mine didn't attend parents evenings and nor did friends. Not even through a lack of interest, they were just working all hours to make ends meet.

SafelySoftly · 26/07/2022 12:44

Of course she can, lots of my contemporaries at Oxbridge went to regular state secondaries. Agree unless you’re made of money it’s ludicrous to fork out for school fees.

Newrumpus · 26/07/2022 12:42

Of course she can. Secondary is very different from primary though and requires more holistic skills. Academic kids can find a wealth of opportunities available at a comprehensive/high school that might not be available to them in a selective environment.

Fairislefandango · 26/07/2022 12:37

I agree with you here @Fairislefandango but this isn't a bad thing. And in fact it may account for why DCs from comps go on to do better at university than DCs from private schools with the same grades (on average), because they are accustomed to having to do it for themselves, which is more the style of learning required at university.

I do think it's a bad thing. I didn't mean that private school students are spoonfed - far from it. In the private schools I've worked in, the students were generally very capable of independent learning tbh.

What I meant was that students striving for top grades at comps often need a lot of determination to resist the apathy, lack of aspiration, reverse intellectual snobbery and poor behaviour which they might be surrounded by. Not to mention the lack of resources and high teacher turnover.

I have often looked at my bright pupils in comps and wondered what they could have achieved in the excellent private schools I worked in.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 26/07/2022 12:29

RuthW · 24/07/2022 17:45

If she is prepared to but the work in then she will get good grades anywhere.

^this
My DCs went to a local comp, did reasonably well then excelled at university with 1st Class BScs and MScs (Distinction)
I went to a private school, was hideously bullied, barely scraped through O and A levels. That experience made me vow to never send my DCs to private schools.
If your child is motivated they will do well anywhere.

thing47 · 26/07/2022 12:18

Obviously some students in comps get top grades, but imo they have to have a level of motivation and determination to do it

I agree with you here @Fairislefandango but this isn't a bad thing. And in fact it may account for why DCs from comps go on to do better at university than DCs from private schools with the same grades (on average), because they are accustomed to having to do it for themselves, which is more the style of learning required at university.

DD2, who went to a shit secondary modern, would tell you she isn't especially clever, but she is focused, motivated and very hard-working. She has a first-class MSc from a top 2 university (for her subject), all her own work, no tutoring, no parental help beyond general support, just sheer determination.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 26/07/2022 12:16

I went to the local shitty comp and got excellent grades.

RockandRollsuicide · 26/07/2022 12:13

Red sky the "parent's navigating the hoops" is interesting and probably doesn't just apply to parents getting DC into private.
I think any parents navigating hoops and seeking and searching out the best they can will reflect and says something about those parents doesn't it.

Whether it's private school or state school. It shows an interest?

Andante57 · 26/07/2022 11:52

Redskyatnight thank you for answering my question.

redskyatnight · 26/07/2022 09:32

Andante57 · 26/07/2022 09:06

Private schools are all selective (even if just on parents' income) so will automatically have better results

RedSky - why would schools which select just on parents’ income automatically have better results?

Many, many studies on the links between parental income and educational attainment. (feel free to google)

There's also the softer link that actually, in most cases, you don't just get into a private school by filling in a form and sending a cheque. There's a certain amount of navigating of the "system" needed (see very many threads on MN from people who hope to get their children into private school who have no experience of the sector) which requires research and a certain number of hoops to be jumped through. This implicitly selects parents who are more involved and interested, which also in itself means their children will have had better educational outcomes, regardless of school attended.

Andante57 · 26/07/2022 09:06

Private schools are all selective (even if just on parents' income) so will automatically have better results

RedSky - why would schools which select just on parents’ income automatically have better results?

QuebecBagnet · 26/07/2022 08:48

I thought this with dd. I mean she did ok but it was grades5-7. With most been 6. This was a kid who is bright and passed her 11plus

she got 2 for both English mocks. Probably due to a constant stream of changing supply teachers. So I got her a tutor and she got 7s in those two (her only 7s). Seems like nobody had told them how to answer the exam questions and once the tutor spent time explaining that she was fine.

so no she probably won’t do as well as she could but is likely to do ok.

obsessedwithsleep · 26/07/2022 08:47

Yes she can. Especially if she's in top sets where behaviour doesn't tend to be an issue to learning. She'll probably need to do a bit of extra studying to get 8s and 9s and anything you can do to widen her cultural capital etc (eg take her to the theatre) will help.

RockandRollsuicide · 26/07/2022 08:44

Tutors are a brilliant addition to any learning and I hope the dreadul uk stigma goes away over tutors.

Most DC wouldn't need them all the time just as and when they struggle with something and our school system can't go over it

faffadoodledo · 26/07/2022 08:40

Mine never had tutors either at their below average comp. It's often claimed on MN that all state schoolers have tutors. Really not true ime. And of course private pupils also get extra tuition in some circumstances!
MN is a funny place, very economically skewed. Reading it you'd think closer to 50 per cent of children went private rather than the oft-stated 7 per cent.

RockandRollsuicide · 26/07/2022 08:39

Agree with discovereads and also about power of friend group.

If you definitely don't want to send her private then accepting you maybe paying for tutors is a great idea.

Tutors are wonderful because they get to know your DC and tailor bespoke to them.
Probably better than private school and cheaper!

RedHelenB · 26/07/2022 08:36

And I've never used tutors or even taught them myself beyond reading with them and doing their spellings with them at Primary.

RedHelenB · 26/07/2022 08:32

Drs both graduated from Russell group unis this summer with top marks. Both went to an average comp. Didn't work excessively hard, did plenty of other extra curricular stuff but completed the work they were asked to. a

Also, some in their primary school who maybe weren't considered bright also went to similar comps and got good grades by putting the effort in. Teachers want their pupils to succeed contrary to mumsnet wisdom, they do value the hard working kuds.

Glitternails1 · 26/07/2022 08:25

@HotCaterpillar she will get good grades by paying attention in class and broadening her knowledge (including reading widely) outside the classroom.

However, don’t under estimate the impact of mental health. I went to a state school and got straight As. I was an over achiever and put too much stress on myself during my A Levels. I burnt out. I was depressed and anxious. My mental health plummeted and so did my grades. Predicted AAA but ended up with ABC. My Mh a improved at Uni and I got a first class degree with hons.

Newnormal99 · 26/07/2022 07:55

@Pottedpalm

Yes I believe it is taught by maths teachers. I don't think they were trying to say it could replace tutoring it was more trying to make the point that they were putting on all this extra stuff for them at no cost so take advantage of it. They have also put an extra period on the timetable 2 days a week meaning they won't finish until 4. Plus about 50 hours of work for the summer holidays

I feel like they are supporting them ready for the exams.

Cliff1975 · 26/07/2022 07:46

My three children have all attended the local comp. DS1 is at Cambridge, DS2 is in sixth form and applying to conservatoires, DD1 is in year 8 and expected or above expected for everything and on track for good GCSEs. All three work but not as much as they could and all have good social skills and outside interests. Absolutely the sky is the limit.

dizzydizzydizzy · 26/07/2022 07:43

DD got 4x A* for A Levels in a bog standard comp. She is now studying a STEM subject at a top Uni. She is bright and motivated. She had very good relationships with the teachers and grabbed every opportunity that came her way, Also, she reads endlessly.