Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 02/09/2022 21:53

Whilst lots of children get top grades every year in an average type Comp, as a proportion of students, it is obviously a far lower number than in a selective or private school.

This means your DD COULD get top grades in the average Comp, but is MORE likely to in the other schools. Whether she WILL cannot be foreseen.

My DC were pretty bright but not exceptional - think 125 type Midyis or Cat4 scores. They went to a selective private school and came out with a long string of top grades. The things I think that helped were the fact that there was stable teaching - people weren’t leaving mid-year and in almost all cases, they had the same teacher through their 2 year A Levels and 3 year GCSE courses. Probably more important was the friendship group. The vast majority were hard workers. I’d say all of the students had high aspirations, even if they weren’t the hardest workers and knuckled down hard at the end and worked very hard. My DC found their tribe of slightly nerdy and hardworking kids. There were heaps of them. It was cool to work hard, to do well, and when the schools talks about grades 8/9 and A/A* as the norm, and those around you are aiming for it, you do too.

People often say you get similar in state selective schools and can get it too in Comps in the top sets if they set in enough subjects. Kids do naturally veer towards those similar to themselves mostly anyway. But I think what can vary is whether there is a critical mass or bright kids who are highly motivated. My kids were swept along with their able and hardworking peers. They wanted to keep up, and success fed a taste for it.

Of course most Comps will have someone or a couple who get all 9s at GCSE. They might have between 10 and 20 getting all 8/9 grades. Will your DD be in the couple who get the top grades….maybe, but probably not statistically. In the selective orivate school, perhaps 25-35 will get all 9s and maybe 75 will get all 8/9 out if a smaller cohort than the Comp. Of course these kids have all passed exams to get in, but having done that, statistically they are more likely to get the top grades in those schools. If you like there is less ‘risk’ than being in the Comp and hoping you’ll be in the top 0.5%, than being in the top half of the independent.

Final thought, re the independent school, they are absolutely not all equal. How selective is the orivate you had a place at? How good are their results? Sometimes they aren’t much better than the Comp or sometimes worse. Unless a child has SEN or other needs which mean private is better, for an academic child and when funds in the family are tight, I’d only pay for a really top school.

Wavygravy1 · 27/07/2022 19:40

I think so. My kids have just finished year 9 and 10. Eldest didn’t pass the grammar exam, younger one didn’t sit it. Both in top sets. My eldest has just sit English Lit and RE GCSEs as they do those subjects a year early. She’s predicted 6/7 in RE and a 7/8 in English Lit. We shall see!

redskyatnight · 27/07/2022 19:38

I have a close friend who went to one of the worst state schools in the area (not even an average comp). As the school was an 11-16 school she moved to a private school for sixth form. She very nearly left after the first week because so many of the private school students thought she must be lying as she'd got better GCSE results than they had, and treated her absolutely abysmally. Not really a good advert for private schools.

Ganymedemoon · 27/07/2022 18:54

mackthepony · 27/07/2022 00:15

Er, no.

Peers.

Call the fee paying school back. From a kid who wanted to thrive, please make it so.

My peers at my fee paying secondary school were bloody awful! Most did abysmally. Once I had the option to leave I went to a state 6th form college, thrived with a bunch on wonderful friends who all came from shock horror state schools!

Lilifer · 27/07/2022 08:17

OP my daughter went to our local comp and got 3 A* at a Level and is now studying law at new college Oxford. Her teachers at secondary school we dedicated to their pupils and really encouraged her from day one so from my own experience I would say yes, if there are some good teachers and your daughter is bright and motivated she will do very well.

mackthepony · 27/07/2022 00:15

Er, no.

Peers.

Call the fee paying school back. From a kid who wanted to thrive, please make it so.

Herbaceousborder · 27/07/2022 00:06

The same range of subjects may not be available ie: my daughter who attended a grammar school could study single sciences and her cousin at a comprehensive couldn't. The comprehensive had a tendency to swap around awarding bodies to try and improve their results and this often had disastrous results because the teachers just weren't able to keep up. Additional maths wasn't available as a subject choice at the comprehensive.
A lot of these things may never affect your child as it depends on their subject choices etc.

WendellGeez · 27/07/2022 00:00

It will depend on how much you want to help her above what the school can offer.

Splicebaked · 26/07/2022 23:46

See how she gets on and if you change your mind then move her in year 9

RewildingAmbridge · 26/07/2022 23:38

I did, but actually read largely ignored by teachers at school, RWA is fine let her get on with it, because too be fair they had their hands full with nightmare students, parents, social care, police etc.
I've done very well, but the advice I needed about career progression and planning wasn't there when I was young. I was the first in my family to go to uni etc and teachers just weren't used to students like me. It helped I was sporty and extroverted, so had friends. Comments like, "I can't believe you're so clever, you're well alright" were common in my first couple of years. Some of my set peers were terrorised for being 'geeks'. I also had teachers telling me I should choose my social circle differently (ie hang out with the people being bullied because that's where I belonged....). I had to be socially smart more than academically just to survive really.
We moved out of a grammar area just as I was about to go into secondary having been put in for my 11+ by a keen primary teacher, with no prep. I got in to the highly selective grammar but then we moved and my parents thought the same as you, she'll be ok wherever she goes, and I was. Would I have been stretched more, had more focus on academia at the grammar definitely, but learning to navigate an East London comp definitely gave me life skills!

Topseyt123 · 26/07/2022 23:30

AppleKatie · 26/07/2022 14:01

How come she moved?

quite.

As already explained, she got the grades needed to get into the girls'grammar school and she wanted to go there. Why not? It was a great opportunity for her.

The courses on offer were also far better. The comp was offering a more restricted choice due to staffing shortages.

HollaHolla · 26/07/2022 23:24

She's 12. I think you are possibly getting overly worried about something which could change significantly in 2-3 years.

I unfortunately don't have kids, but I do work in education. What does she want to do? Is it Uni - because there's contextualized admissions nowadays, which take schools/postcodes into account.
As an aside, my siblings and I went to a bog standard comprehensive. We all have at least one degree (mostly from Russell Group Unis), and work in professional jobs. It's about studying and applying oneself - as well as actually having the ability in the first place.

Good luck to your daughter, and you, for the future.

Topseyt123 · 26/07/2022 23:20

Ohthatsexciting · 26/07/2022 13:30

How come she moved?

Because she got the grades needed to get into the grammar school for sixth form and wanted to go there. Why not? Great opportunity for her and she took it.

PandemicAtTheDisco · 26/07/2022 19:45

Thirty years ago I had a mixed group of friends on my course at university. We all had similar A'level grades.

I got the idea that some of the people from Private schools had to do more work to get decent marks and a few (that seemed a bit slower) ended up with Thirds or 2:iis.

The people who came out with First's - all but one came from Private schools. The people from state schools were more 2:is and 2:iis.

That was my general impression from a small group of friends studying my subject thirty odd years ago. Private schools help less able students get better grades by getting them to work harder and longer. They also were more likely to talk to the lecturers afterwards and ask for more help in practicals.

Lancrelady80 · 26/07/2022 19:17

HauntingScream · 24/07/2022 11:56

Yes she can, if SHE wants to.
Don't underestimate the influence of friendship groups too.

Absolutely this. The danger is mixing with peers who aren't particularly motivated or who have downright negative attitudes to school/learning. Pp said consider moving to private at Y9, but if she has already picked up that attitude at a standard high school then that's probably not going to make much difference.

What I would say though, is that she's just as likely to mix with kids with that attitude at either "free" or £££ school.

It's about her attitude and willingness to apply herself. She'll increase odds of better grades at a school with lower class sizes, more resources...but ultimately it's on her.

Nik2015 · 26/07/2022 19:15

Yes, taught plenty of children who have!

redskyatnight · 26/07/2022 19:13

RockandRollsuicide · 26/07/2022 12:13

Red sky the "parent's navigating the hoops" is interesting and probably doesn't just apply to parents getting DC into private.
I think any parents navigating hoops and seeking and searching out the best they can will reflect and says something about those parents doesn't it.

Whether it's private school or state school. It shows an interest?

Yes agree. To give another specific example, this is why faith schools often have better results than non-faith schools. Simply working out sufficiently in advance that you need to attend church at least twice a month for the year before applying, actually organising your life to do this and getting a letter from the vicar (generalised example of faith school criteria) automatically makes you a more involved parent that the average, which means you are more likely to take an interest and support your child's education which are important factors to improve outcomes. The jumping through hoops also means that children from slightly more dysfunctional familes who tend to have worse outcomes are much less likely to get in, which will drive the overall school results up as those children are "missing".

There used to be a poster called seeker who used to explain an example of juggling to explain why the fact that a school is selective (on anything) would drive up results .
IIRC it was something like this:

Imagine you have 2 schools next door to each other:
To get into School 1, you just need to fill in the CAF (common application form).
To get into School 2, you also have to practice for, complete and pass an assessment of juggling 3 balls.

All other things being equal, School 2 would tend to get better results even though no one would claim there was any sort of direct link between parental ability to juggle and child educational outcomes.

Ohhcrap · 26/07/2022 17:34

The study I have found most interesting is the one where they discovered that success at uni is directly inversely proportional to how much was spent on your school fees…in other words, once your bright, comprehensively educated kid gets to uni, then statistically they are likely to do much better than their counterparts educated at great cost. Make of that what you will…

whumpthereitis · 26/07/2022 15:48

thing47 · 26/07/2022 12:18

Obviously some students in comps get top grades, but imo they have to have a level of motivation and determination to do it

I agree with you here @Fairislefandango but this isn't a bad thing. And in fact it may account for why DCs from comps go on to do better at university than DCs from private schools with the same grades (on average), because they are accustomed to having to do it for themselves, which is more the style of learning required at university.

DD2, who went to a shit secondary modern, would tell you she isn't especially clever, but she is focused, motivated and very hard-working. She has a first-class MSc from a top 2 university (for her subject), all her own work, no tutoring, no parental help beyond general support, just sheer determination.

But it is a bad thing, because while some flourish anyway, how many don’t? How many with the potential to do well actually end up sinking because of a poor environment?

Education shouldn’t be trial by fire where the ‘victors’ are considered worthy of success by battling through shit circumstances.

thing47 · 26/07/2022 15:39

I have often looked at my bright pupils in comps and wondered what they could have achieved in the excellent private schools I worked in

In the case of DD2 she probably could have got better A level grades at private school, but she couldn't have got a better grade than she did in her Masters and that's in a hard-core STEM subject from a university ranked above Cambridge – and every other RG university bar Oxford.

The resilience, self-motivation and focus she required to do well at her secondary modern has clearly stood her in good stead.

AppleKatie · 26/07/2022 14:01

How come she moved?

quite.

minipie · 26/07/2022 13:45

Don't underestimate the influence of friendship groups

This. Most teens are hugely influenced by their mates and so will do better in a school where listening in class, doing your work and getting good marks are seen as normal rather than weird.

So the question is whether this is the culture in your local comp, or not.

Ifyoudid · 26/07/2022 13:44

Might have been an 11-16 school.

I completely agree that these super talented children don’t need extra help. They are fine. All power to them. But.

If you’re not amazing - if you’re a bit above average but (if we’re honest) nothing special, how do you think you’ll get on in a poorly achieving secondary school?

Is it just about hard work? What if there is no work set, because the teacher spent all lesson trying to give instructions and couldn’t? What if the work set is assuming all you’re capable of is a 4? What if the work set is never marked because this is the fifth supply teacher you’ve had?

I was talking to DH about this yesterday. I still don’t know what I’ll do for my own children (preschool) but even in my own department this year we’ve had staffing turbulence, meaning year 7s have had supply so that y11 didn’t. Totally understandable except now y7 have spent a year without work marked, in noisy, chaotic, messy classrooms and just have a poor impression of the subject generally.

I was a big reader - probably wouldn’t have massively impacted me. A reasonably bright but unremarkable kid will regress in that environment. How can they not?

Ohthatsexciting · 26/07/2022 13:30

Topseyt123 · 26/07/2022 13:27

It is absolutely possible. My highly academic DD3 went to a very average comp and came away with 9 x grade 9 GCSEs and 1 x grade 8.

She was then accepted to do A Levels at a top girls'grammar school, where she also got top grades (A*) and is now in her third university year at Cambridge (though she is on a year abroad for this).

How come she moved?

Topseyt123 · 26/07/2022 13:27

It is absolutely possible. My highly academic DD3 went to a very average comp and came away with 9 x grade 9 GCSEs and 1 x grade 8.

She was then accepted to do A Levels at a top girls'grammar school, where she also got top grades (A*) and is now in her third university year at Cambridge (though she is on a year abroad for this).