Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD can get top grades in an 'average' comp. secondary?

237 replies

HotCaterpillar · 24/07/2022 11:51

Dd has done well at primary, near top of class academically and is well behaved and conscientious.

I've moved area and she's due to start secondary in an averagely performing comp. in September. Aibu to think she can get top grades in that environment if she continues to apply herself to studying?

She was offered a place in a selective private school but I declined due to the fees, I could probably just about afford them but it felt very expensive when there is a free option. She's done well in state primary. I'm a single parent working FT, we have a good home life.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WombatChocolate · 03/09/2022 13:09

Oxbridge interviewers are on the record as saying that they can look to favour students with less advantages to a point….but beyond a certain point it can be counter-productive. They talk about students who show raw talent, but their knowledge base and sometimes skills are simply too far behind that if some of the advantaged students, to be something that be catch-upable, if you know what I mean. They say they can plug certain gaps and raw talent will allow for some of that…but there’s a limit. Sometimes they regretfully have to turn down a disadvantages student who clearly has a lot of talent, but the gap is just too much for the degree course to make up. They want to level the playing field….but they can’t be the whole solution and often by 18, the gap for some is just too big.

Regarding contextual offers, some people seem to think that attending any state school, gives you these special lower offers. They don’t seem to realise that this can only exist where students attend a school with historically low HE entry or in very deprived areas. Of course lots of state schools are in affluent areas and the bulk of kids couldn’t be considered disadvantaged.

Its absolutely right to try to level the playing field more. The trouble is that certain students just have had such an advantage that they really are so much better placed to succeed on their degrees than many others. Universities and especially highly academic ones rightly want the brightest and most capable students. They are there primarily to deliver academic excellence, not to deliver a social service or a redistribution of income or reduce inequality. They can do those things to a certain level, but it’s not their primary purpose. And if it becomes such, then they will find that the whole nature of what they can deliver and produce changes. The changes society needs must happen sooner. Even today the BBC reports that 50% of kids failing to pass GCSE Eng and Maths with a 4 were flagged as being behind at age 5. Well that’s not a surprise really is it. But advantage and disadvantage have truly taken root well before kids go to school, and university admissions is far down the line for addressing it. But clearly dealing with poverty and disadvantage are massive and hugely complex issues that no government or person has really found the answer to. But we must keep trying.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 03/09/2022 10:21

I think the % at private increases when you consider 6th form only, not the rest of primary and secondary.

No, it's when you consider students studying A-Levels in 6th form, as opposed to vocational qualifications. Then it's about 14%. (I think it's A-Levels; not sure whether it includes other academic qualifications like IB.) But 35% is still 2½ times 14%, so an Oxford college with 35% privately-educated entrants is still hugely skewing its selection towards those students.

SuperCamp · 03/09/2022 10:21

Very little analysis on this thread as to what constitutes an ‘average comp’.

An ‘average comp’ that has a representative number of students at the high performing and needing support ends of the spectrum but has ‘average GCSE results’ is probably delivering a very good education to students of all abilities. The average GCSE point scores being made up of those who score all 8s and 9 s, as well as those who did fantastically well to get 4s.

An average education, average teachers, can deliver a high GCSE score in a grammar because of the cohort.

I think that one of the reasons London state schools do so well against the national average is that the demography is very mixed. High density estates with huge problems border conservation areas and private residential roads. There is a critical mass of students being supported to be high achievers which provides a peer group from intelligent kids from more chaotic backgrounds.

Also on this thread pp talk of the difference between grammar schools and comprehensives in their area. If you live in a grammar area, the ‘comprehensives’ are not comprehensive because 25% of the highest achievers are in segregated grammar schools. Hence fewer options for a choice of MFL, separate sciences etc. Genuine comps cater for all, and have these subjects.

Delatron · 03/09/2022 10:20

@Chilldonaldchill Oh it’s fine - your explanation was much better - I worded it clumsily- and yes that must be very annoying. Didn’t think of it that way!

rnsaslkih · 03/09/2022 10:15

MsTSwift · 03/09/2022 09:59

i think in a family members Oxford college where she works they had 35% private school which sounds ok but only 7% of the population actually go to private school!

I think the % at private increases when you consider 6th form only, not the rest of primary and secondary. So 35% is not as disproportionate as it might sound compare to 7%.

MsTSwift · 03/09/2022 10:03

Oh and my family member tears her hair out at those public school students who have been supported to the hilt and their school has talked the talk and got them in but when they actually get there they fall to pieces. So I wonder if these schools pushing average kids that hard is actually a positive thing for them anyway…

MsTSwift · 03/09/2022 09:59

i think in a family members Oxford college where she works they had 35% private school which sounds ok but only 7% of the population actually go to private school!

Chilldonaldchill · 03/09/2022 09:48

@Delatron
Sorry I wasn't meaning to teach you to suck eggs - I've just had too many conversations with people who tell me that their poor privately-educated children are disadvantaged when it comes to uni admissions. Drives me mad!

Delatron · 03/09/2022 09:44

But that’s what I meant - more levelling of the playing field, lowering grade requirements for certain schools. Basically unis need to think about the balance of where their students are coming from and that may work more favourably for state school pupils.

Delatron · 03/09/2022 09:42

Ok quota was the wrong word! It’s more complicated that that.

Chilldonaldchill · 03/09/2022 09:29

Aren’t top Unis having to fill more of their quota from comps these days?

This isn't correct. What the top universities are doing is creating widening participation where they are putting things in place to try and reduce the inequity and ensure that people don't get unfair benefits from their position of advantage. So for example Oxford will look at GCSEs (traditionally. They haven't so much in the last few years due to covid) and consider someone who got 7s from a school where they were the only person to achieve that very differently from someone who gets 7s from Eton for example. I think they are looking for students from the top 10% of their cohort, whatever their cohort is.
Other universities do it differently (for example making their grade requirements lower by one or two grades) but it's not true to say there is a quota. There is just an attempt (and I think a genuine one) to level the playing field such that, if Student X had had the advantages of wealthy parents (usually meaning a quieter home environment, not necessarily having to get a job to support the family income, being able to spend more time studying, potentially a more selective school with better results) and clearly would have done as well as Student Y who did have those advantages, then X and Y would be treated the same.
A friend of ours has a friend who lives in an area where - if he goes to uni - he would be the first person in his entire village to do so (has just done GCSEs). He is now going to have to get 3 buses and travel for 75 minutes each way to get to the nearest 6th form which offers the A level subjects he wants to do. He wants to do a very competitive subject at uni. If he gets there, he will have overcome a thousand times more than my children's peers, despite the fact that they too will have worked hard to get there and deserve their success.

WombatChocolate · 03/09/2022 09:22

Norma, I’m sure you’re right. That school might mean your DD had a ‘contextual flag’ when applying to uni, which results in a slightly lower offer or more liklihood of an offer. They are given when kids attend schools with a limited record of sending kids to Uni, are in deprived postcodes, or if neither parent has attended HE. I think sometimes you need more than 1 flag for a contextual offer.

It’s great she’s done so well. And of course there will be thousands like her across the country. I guess the thing that worries people is the fact there are also loads like her, who in average Comps DON’T go onto perform at the level they might have and instead finish with a string of 5s and 6s. Nothing wrong with 5s and 6s, but if 8/9 was achievable, then it is a problem. And in certain schools, that underperformance is more likely…it’s what people fear. Schools probably aren’t seriously worried as those kids have still got decent passes, but those kids have been sold short. And sadly, for every child like your DD, there are also kids who could have got 7-9 and could have pursued an academic route suited to them, that instead find some doors starting to close to them, either at 16, or possibly a bit later. I suppose people pay fees because they think the orivate school will keep as many doors open as possible. It’s a bit of an insurance policy. But no-one ever knows for sure how their particular kid would have performed in an alternative school, simply the macro figures for overall general performance, which their kid might have fitted in with…or bucked the trend.

MsTSwift · 03/09/2022 09:20

My Dd got top sats result in English but scraped average in maths she also doesn’t find science easy. We got the best tutors we could find for maths and science she ended up with a7 and two eights (9s in all the others as she finds humanities easier) which blew us away. So am feeling quite pro state atm 😁.

Haahaha · 03/09/2022 09:16

Peer group is very influential to teens. See how it goes. Consider putting her in private the last couple of years. What does she want to do? Grades alone shouldn't be used for self esteem.

AugustaHope · 03/09/2022 09:15

Not rtft but yes.
My dp works in an averagely performing comprehensive. Every year they have around 10 students who get 8 or more 8s and 9s (it the equivalent previously).
A few years ago one of those was a good friend of ours who is now reading medicine.
They got the exact same grades as our child who was at a selective (state) school.
The thing I would say is that I believe they worked harder and had to be more committed than our own child did. At our child's school it was more like 60 children who got 8 or more 8s.
My dp is quite open that the teaching is much better at our children's school because it's much easier to teach children who are all at the same level, who are mostly very keen and enthusiastic and where you can teach the more academic children much faster so get through the course content quicker and spend more time on revision etc.
On results day our child said to us that she recognised that our friend had a significantly greater achievement than she did and I think that is correct.

Norma27 · 03/09/2022 09:13

My daughter has just got all 8s and 9s from a pretty poor comp. I cannot fault most of the teaching and I believe the pastoral care is great. However, because of where it is people just choose to send children to comps out of the area.
The comp most chose has a severe bullying problem and I am so pleased we stuck with the school we did.
In yr 6 SATs my daughter got full marks in both English and a couple of marks off in maths so she was highlighted as a 8/9 grade possibility. She didn’t want to take the grammar test, and I didn’t particularly want her to either.
I believe achieving the grades she got at her school will be looked upon favourably when applying for uni and even jobs. I work for a large professional services firm and it would definitely be viewed favourably as far as I know.

Delatron · 03/09/2022 09:02

Aren’t top Unis having to fill more of their quota from comps these days?

Our local grammar is a very stressful, high pressure environment. They cream off the very bright kids and put them under a lot of pressure. Some thrive, some sink. Results look good on paper but at what cost to their mental health. Many have moved their children out to our very good local secondary. My son gets lots of confidence being in the top set here. He’d be in the bottom at the grammar. I’m not sure that would mean a better outcome for him.

WombatChocolate · 03/09/2022 08:52

One other thing to recognise, is that although many more kids in selective schools or private might achieve a full run of 9 or 8/9 grades, there will be large numbers of bright kids in average Comps who get all grades 7-9 which open doors for them. The grades might not be quite so stellar, but will open the doors to RG unis and certainly into their A Levels of choice. In most cases, it really won’t matter if the grade outcomes are 10x9 grades or 2x9, 4x8 and 4x7.

Although you can generalise and the statistical facts about different outcomes from average Comps vs selective schools are clear on a macro level, you have to play it by ear based on the experience of your individual child in their individual school. Not all private schools deliver fantastic results by any means. Some kids in an average Comp will find a tribe of cover and motivated kids and push ahead and do fantastically, whilst others won’t find that tribe but be influenced by some who are less aspirational. You don’t know until your child is there and can see what’s happening with them. And as others say, you don’t have to remain in the same school all the way through. Independent schools see kids come and go into most year groups and if there’s space, will usually welcome a bright kid paying fees at pretty much any point. You don’t close the door to the option by trying the state option.

Lonecatwithkitten · 03/09/2022 06:35

You are not making a lifetime commitment to this school, you can move her if it's not working out. Many many people do move children at all stages.

thefamilyupstairs · 03/09/2022 06:30

If she's highly motivated and reasonably intelligent then it's possible. I worked in education and the motivated pupils worked backwards - they would access mark schemes and examiners reports for all subjects and make their revision notes accordingly.

ittakes2 · 03/09/2022 06:25

Honestly do the local comp and if you are worried she is underperforming by year 9 can her tutors for year 10/11 much cheaper than private school and she’ll be happier having local friends.

Gonnabegrandma · 03/09/2022 06:18

My son and daughter did and both went on to get first class degrees ! They can do it if motivated . Their younger brother wouldn’t have done that well where ever he went he just wasn’t interested. He did well once he had the motivation on money in an apprenticeship

MsTSwift · 03/09/2022 05:50

The results at the local girls private school are no better than dds all girls state.

That said how can you compare the results of a school that is obliged to take everyone within a catchment area with a selective school? That’s just silly!

Dd and many of her peers just got strings of 8s and 9s from their state school, have nice studious normal friends and play sport regularly so frankly glad I saved the money.

sheepdogdelight · 02/09/2022 22:22

Of course most Comps will have someone or a couple who get all 9s at GCSE. They might have between 10 and 20 getting all 8/9 grades. Will your DD be in the couple who get the top grades….maybe, but probably not statistically. In the selective orivate school, perhaps 25-35 will get all 9s and maybe 75 will get all 8/9 out if a smaller cohort than the Comp.

You seem to be ignoring the student themselves in all this.
A student getting top grades is not purely statistics. Putting a child in a high achieving school does not in itself, mean that they will achieve highly. They actually have to do some work!
As GCSE results have recently come out, I thought I'd look at my DC's comp -which is "bog standard" on many indicators, and teaches mixed ability in every subject except maths.
The school reports that around 15% of Year 11 got 8 or more top grades at GCSE. Our local selective private school takes about the top 15% of the ability range. And a large proportion of these students have also got 8 or more top grades. So actually, if you are just looking at statistics, this seems to show that, if you live round here, the top 15% (ish) of the ability range are going to get top grades, regardless of school. The million dollar question is, of course, whether one's particular child might do better in one particular school as opposed to another.

WombatChocolate · 02/09/2022 21:54

Oh, and all the anecdotes of people who themselves gained fab results from a poor school, or whose kids or friends’ kids got top results from an average Comp are just that…anecdotes. They are true, but do t change the stark cold facts of the difference in grades achieved in different schools. Top grades are absolutely possible in average schools, but are quite simply far more likely in selective or private schools.

Swipe left for the next trending thread