Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be sexually attracted to fiancé?

34 replies

BarefootSand · 24/07/2022 11:38

We’ve been together for 17 years and have 1 DC aged 11.

I feel awful, but it’s getting harder and harder to hype myself up to have sex with him now. DF has put weight on and thinks I’m going off him because of that, but it honestly isn’t anything to do with how he looks. I think he’s a good looking man, but there isn’t a sexual attraction there! If I’m honest I don’t think there ever was, even at the very start of our relationship, but I assumed that if you loved someone and truly cared for them then sexual attraction doesn’t matter.

it’s not gotten to the point where I physically can’t bring myself to have sex with him - I don’t find him repulsive or anything like that, but I just don’t see him in a sexual way.

DF is quite sensitive, and I know that if I try and explain how I’m feeling he’ll see it very black and white, like “well I must be fat and ugly and you find me disgusting”. It’s honestly NOT that, but he wouldn’t understand!

there are a few other factors that come into play that may not be helping; such a poor hygiene on his end, and sex just not feeling that good. I could honestly go the rest of my life without it. I’ve never orgasmed with a man, either or through penetration or other means (sorry, TMI!)

what do I do?? For the past 15 years of our relationship I’ve had sex with him to appease him and get him off my back for a week or so, but lately I just can’t bring myself to do it.

For a bit of context, I’ve posted on here before ages ago mentioning the DF used to try and bribe me for sex - I showed him the thread and he was so ashamed of himself and stopped immediately.

i don’t want to break up as we’ve built a life together, and he’s my best friend. I love him dearly, but I’m not “in” love with him. But also conscious that it’s unfair to him to be stuck in a relationship where he’s not getting the love and intimacy he deserves.

please help?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mummysgogetter · 24/07/2022 19:55

Having been married multiple times myself, I can assure you that what you are feeling is perfectly normal...The only reason I left my previous husbands was because they were very abusive - I am now married to a smart, funny, considerate man for 7 years, and I have had some of those same old feeling again, but realize that the " infatuation" I felt when we first got together never lasts with ANY partner. You should take some time to think about what is important in the long haul (loyalty, honesty, etc) and if your husband gives you these things, then do all you can to stay with him. Good men are hard to find, so hang on to your gold mine! As for the "attraction" issue, talk to him about it and maybe the two of you can do something to spice things up a bit...H. this helps

Sunnytwobridges · 24/07/2022 19:45

I felt the same with my ex. Never was sexually attracted to him. After a while it felt like I was having sex with my brother. It wasn’t fair to him so I had to let him go. He’s much happier now with someone else and I’m happier not dreading sex with him or forcing myself to have sex out of duty.

cookiecreammpie · 24/07/2022 18:30

I was a bit like this with my ex. I never fancied him and was at a bit of a low point when we met. I used to kiss other guys every time I went on a night out with my friends and ended up having sex with 2 men behind his back. I never felt guilty because he was horrible to me. We never lived together even though there were kids involved ans we were so on and off. But he ended up doing something really awful that there was no coming back from and I eventually went on to meet someone better all round who I do fancy and I am more happier and fulfilled.

vaingina · 24/07/2022 18:29

Sorry. This is dead in the water. Release him and yourself and become good friends and Co- parents.

Thistooshallpass01 · 24/07/2022 18:23

Felt this way about my ex, eventually had to call
it quits. He couldn’t make me orgasm during the year we were together and sex became a chore because I really wasn’t sexually attracted to him.Just like you, I thought because I had love for him it would be enough. It wasn’t. This was for
only a year can’t imagine how it would have been it was 17 yrs!!!

EatYourVegetables · 24/07/2022 17:42

Step 1. Start masturbating and figure out what you like. “Never had an orgasm with a man” is not good.

Step 2. Re-evaluate. Is it his bad hygiene? Do you still want a relationship with him? How does it feel when you show him what to do that you like?

If the relationship is dead, end it. But it would be sad if you ended it and then found that you have the same issues in all relationships, because you are asexual, or need therapy, or don’t enjoy penetration, or something else unrelated to DF.

KVick · 24/07/2022 17:32

I understand your predicament (when I was younger, I found myself in a similar one) and can see how your situation has evolved in the way it has, given that your relationship with your partner started when you were both teenagers. You got tied down into this monogamous coupling before you had time to explore your sexuality to figure out the things that actually turn you on.

Hell! Maybe you’re not into males in general, who knows? But what you do know, is that this guy is just not doing it for you sexually.

It’s understandable to me how, as you grew older with this fellow, you came to realize certain things that you were reluctant to admit to yourself at first – namely that you love the father of your DC, but more like a friend or worse: a brother! But because you didn’t want to hurt his feelings, you’ve been avoiding articulating this to him because it will inevitably make him feel bad about himself.

Hetero male egos tend to be fragile and women who choose male lovers/partners often find themselves kind of massaging their egos.

That said, it sounds like you’ve come to an impasse here and out of respect for the both of you, you’re going to have to just “rip the bandage off” and as compassionately as possible, just tell him the truth. Explain it like you’ve explained it on this forum.

Once the truth is out, you can both hopefully remain friends and co-parents to the offspring you have together.

But you do NOT want to marry this guy. Don’t double-down on this incompatible match. Wouldn’t be fair to either of you. And divorces are expensive.

Blossomtoes · 24/07/2022 13:20

even if the sex was fantastic I don’t think you can change your attraction to someone

If the sex was fantastic the probability is that you’d fancy him. I didn’t look at my bloke and go “Phwoar!” when we first met. He was OK but that was all. What a surprise I got when we had sex for the first time. It was the best I’d ever had and I found him very attractive from then on in. But he wasn’t fat and dirty so I can see why you’re struggling.

Onlyrainbows · 24/07/2022 13:19

I wasn't attracted to my ex husband at all. I didn't want any sex either to the point that I thought I was asexual. I did discuss opening the relationship but he didn't want to, we ultimately divorced.

Babdoc · 24/07/2022 13:15

OP, this relationship isn’t just dead, it’s decomposing. Do the decent thing - read the last rites over it and bury the body.
You and your ex can then (hopefully) amicably coparent your child, with him free to seek out soap, water and a woman who can love him.
I think you should avoid dating anyone else until you have perhaps discussed your feelings with a therapist. You may have a very low libido, you may be gay, or you may just never have had the chance to experiment with other men to find one that does float your boat. But it’s worth exploring your options - you only get one life.

WonderingWanda · 24/07/2022 13:12

Having read your last post I think you need to end it for both of you. You sound incompatible and he sounds a bit selfish, he clearly knows you've not been enjoying it and just uses you which is gross.

BarefootSand · 24/07/2022 13:11

The engagement was a discussion. We’ve been engaged for a very long time.

Part of me feels that he doesn’t want to be married either though! You hear of instances where a man won’t propose for years with his partner, but then move on and be married within a year. Not putting blame on him either as I know it’s a 2 way street, it’s just something I’ve noticed.

OP posts:
Calvinlookingforhobbes · 24/07/2022 13:10

I said YABU and you are to stay in this relationship for both of your sakes. P

BarefootSand · 24/07/2022 13:06

I can find people good looking, but it’s very rare that I’d want to rip someone’s clothes off. There was one person about 5 years ago that I had a very strong sexual attraction to, even though he wasn’t conventionally very attractive! There was just something about him. We don’t speak and nothing ever happened between us. But it proves that I can feel that way.

and yes on the sex side. I know how to get myself off, and when DF has asked what I want him to do I’ll guide him as clearly as possible but he just won’t do it! As an example, I’d say yes keep doing that, and then he’d stop? Or change tempo. So it gets to the point where I’m thinking “what is the point? You’re not trying to make this enjoyable for me?”. As long as he finishes it doesn’t matter. When I’ve brought this up in the past he’d say something like “well you don’t like sex anyway, so I thought you’d prefer it to be quick”.

OP posts:
TakeYourFinalPosition · 24/07/2022 13:03

He shouldn’t be your fiancé. It should never have got this far. It has, and there’s no point laying blame for that - but there’s only one fix, and that’s being friends, if anything. There’s no compromise that makes everyone happy here, and in holding on to him and this, you’re being quite selfish while trying to be selfless… it doesn’t help him. It avoids immediate hurt for him now, but it sets him up for a marriage that’ll have him constantly questioning himself. You care for him deeply but you don’t love him and you’re not attracted to him and he deserves both of those things, as do you.

VladmirsPoutine · 24/07/2022 13:02

How did you feel when you got engaged? Did you 'feel' anything? Or was it just a discussion had over dinner and that was that?

BarefootSand · 24/07/2022 12:59

The sad thing is I really really wish I could change how I feel. I’d do anything to feel that attraction to him, but it’s just not there.

I care so deeply for him, I’ve tried so many things to create that spark but it’s not happening and I hate myself for not wanting to have sex with my fiancé.

OP posts:
Goldencarp · 24/07/2022 12:59

It’s a tough one. If you both truly loved each other and are happy not to have sex then that’s fine. Sexless relationships can and do work but it has to be mutual. If one of you is unhappy with no sex then it won’t work.

Elsiebear90 · 24/07/2022 12:53

I think you can’t really continue with this relationship, he won’t be happy being sexless or finding it elsewhere and you won’t be happy having sex with him, you’re incompatible and it will just lead to lots of resentment which will affect the friendship part of your relationship as well.

Are you attracted to other people? Or do you have no attraction to anyone? You might not be interested in sex again because bad sex with someone you’re not attracted to is all you’ve known.

VladmirsPoutine · 24/07/2022 12:48

agree that a sex therapist won’t solve it, even if the sex was fantastic I don’t think you can change your attraction to someone.

I think I missed this bit. I thought it was more that you didn't want to have sex in general as you said you'd be quite happy to never have sex again (i.e. with anyone). In this light then I'd say if the attraction isn't there, that pure chemistry, then it's time to call it a day. I don't think that raw attraction is something that you can create out of thin air. Usually it comes and goes in waves and can be all but invisible when a couple is going through balancing work, life and a kid etc but it invariably comes back. If you don't have it at all then it's not looking good tbh.

If this (relationship) is all you've ever known and for a huge chunk of it you've been 'soldering' through it then it's really time to wind it down.

Scianel · 24/07/2022 12:46

So you've stayed with someone all these years that you were never in love with?
I don't know what to say. I guess sometimes it can be a worthwhile trade off for some people, but you're clearly not happy.
I appreciate it's difficult as you must care very deeply about him and you have children with him.

BarefootSand · 24/07/2022 12:37

Thanks for the replies. To answer some questions:

I don’t think he’d be happy living in a sexless relationship, and quite rightly so.

I think I would be amenable to him finding sex elsewhere as I’m aware he has needs, but I don’t think he’d want to do that.

Not to make excuses at all, however as we got together so young (mid teens) I didn’t know how it was supposed to feel! I didn’t think that I’d be in this position 17 years down the line, it was my first real relationship and I had nothing to compare it against.

I’m aware that I have acted in a cruel way by staying with him and not speaking up, I guess I was being quite the martyr in that way - I’ve been putting his needs first for almost 2 decades and in my mind I’d prefer to just get it over and done with so he’s happy and won’t ask me for another week.

agree that a sex therapist won’t solve it, even if the sex was fantastic I don’t think you can change your attraction to someone.

OP posts:
Spohn · 24/07/2022 12:05

-Stay in a sham relationship with a sexually coercive stinking creep.
-dump him and raise your standards in life.

oooh, so difficult to choose between those options 😄

Palg68 · 24/07/2022 11:59

Oh dear OP. After reading further you had issues from the very very start OP. You should not of continued with this man you've been quite cruel. A sex therapist won't solve 15 years this has been going on.

VladmirsPoutine · 24/07/2022 11:58

If you don't want to leave and all else being equal he treats you well would you consider going to therapy? Because it's not right for you to spend your life having sex when you don't want to just to appease him and it's not right to expect him to completely forgo sex. These positions are irreconcilable. It's either you have some honest discussions and are prepared to work on things together or you part ways. Sorry to say it but it is very black and white.

Swipe left for the next trending thread