Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum on the train

533 replies

MumTrain · 24/07/2022 09:14

Yesterday I was coming home from a day out with DS, aged 3 on the train. We had been out all morning and he was in top form but by the time we got on the train he was understandably tired.

It was a modern train you can walk through with no doors and spacious, wide aisles but still some seats free and no one had to stand.

DS was in the window seat and was standing up so I asked him to sit down and to keep him occupied I gave him my phone to watch a video with on silent so as not to disturb the other passengers. When we were nearly at our stop, I asked for my phone to check the time of our connection and he proceeded to cry as he was watching a cartoon.

A mum who was sat behind me heard all this and came to the aisle, bent down beside us, leaned in. I thought she was going to offer DS a toy or a sweet to cheer him up but instead and said “do you think you could be quiet? My baby is asleep”.

I told her in no uncertain terms that I would not be asking him to stop crying and that we have a baby at home too. She isn’t the first person to have a baby asleep on public transport. She could easily have walked the baby in the buggy further down the train.

AIBU to think that asking a toddler who is crying and having a tantrum to not cry is batshit crazy?

OP posts:
surreygirl1987 · 24/07/2022 19:05

Ok so next time you're upset and crying imagine someone telling you to stop crying. How is that going to make you feel? Reassured? Safe? No, not only will you be upset but also now you won't be able to express the upset as that's not allowed.

Argh. This is a bug bear of mine. I agree that if a child is crying for genuine upset (eg fell and hurt himself, or lost something important to them) it's harsh to tell them to stop crying. My father in law says that to my kids and I can't stand it. BUT if it's whining or tanrumming to try to get what they want (there is a different) then that needs nipping in the bud.

surreygirl1987 · 24/07/2022 19:02

Both a bit unreasonable imo. I used to get irrationally angry about any noise at all when trying to get my son to nap (even at seagulls)... it was unreasonable but I really felt it at the time! Equally, your response was a little OTT - I have a 3 year old as well as I would have tried to get him to be quieter (not necessarily for the mother of the baby, but for the whole carriage). I might have said something like 'wait until your little one is 3' though which I admit isn't a huge amount better!

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 18:50

I've had two, but never ever seen a place screamed down?

It's such an utterly ridiculous and nonsensical saying?

Why do you use it?

Each to their own, lots of people do.

Not dying on this hill @hesttreat

hesttreat · 24/07/2022 18:45

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 18:43

How does it happen?

I'm presuming you've been around small children. Use your imagination.

I've had two, but never ever seen a place screamed down?

It's such an utterly ridiculous and nonsensical saying?

Why do you use it?

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 18:43

How does it happen?

I'm presuming you've been around small children. Use your imagination.

hesttreat · 24/07/2022 18:41

@sunglassesonthetable Ive never actually seen anyone scream the place down?

How does it happen?

Forestgate · 24/07/2022 18:34

You overreacted and quite unnecessarily rude. Hopefully you're feeling embarrassed now and won't behave like that again.

0blio · 24/07/2022 18:32

Ontomatopea · 24/07/2022 09:50

Ok so next time you're upset and crying imagine someone telling you to stop crying. How is that going to make you feel? Reassured? Safe? No, not only will you be upset but also now you won't be able to express the upset as that's not allowed.

And this is why there are so many entitled young people nowadays.
OP needed to tell her son to stop making a noise and think of others. At 3, children are old enough to understand that.

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 18:31

Let's hope the other mum's baby didn't wake up and scream the place down.

🤷‍♀️

Palg68 · 24/07/2022 18:28

Eixample · 24/07/2022 16:44

I currently have my second three year old. People understand that you can’t stop them tantruming, but they want to see you at least trying to stop them. Looking at your phone (bearing in mind they don’t know what you are doing) will have looked like you didn’t care.

You shouldn't assume. It would of been none of your business. What's hilarious about these high horse comments is it could of beeb any of out children crying. Anybody would think it lasted 30 minutes the way posters are being so dramatic. The child could of been unwell or in pain... you can't just jump to conclusions about a stranger.

Chooksnroses · 24/07/2022 18:17

LibraryFairy · 24/07/2022 09:19

I voted YABU. Sometimes a little distraction from a stranger is exactly whar it takes to stop a tantrum in its tracks. I assume that's all she was trying to do and was trying to help you. No need for you to be rude or consider her to be 'batshit crazy. 🙄

I agree!

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 18:09

I don't know what you think sounds hard @sunglassesonthetable. Personally I'd struggle to focus with a child screaming far more than with them chatting. Also,
most people use a maps or train app rather than timetables; it's easier and you get real-time updates on the service.

Err do you think OP wanted them screaming? I have no doubt she was struggling to focus.

I'm honest enough to admit it sometimes is not easy with a toddler. And not just this "oh it's standard parenting"... bollox.

'Train timetables' = train app or whatever 🙄

MRex · 24/07/2022 18:03

I don't know what you think sounds hard @sunglassesonthetable. Personally I'd struggle to focus with a child screaming far more than with them chatting. Also,
most people use a maps or train app rather than timetables; it's easier and you get real-time updates on the service.

Didimum · 24/07/2022 17:57

I think it’s fine you need to vent here, OP. It’s never nice to be confronted in public about an issue surrounding your kid - mums are, after all, mostly always trying to do their best. The comments here criticising your parenting are reaching and then some.

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 17:46

Whilst reading train timetables 👍🏻

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 17:45

Give a warning, distract while doing the task etc. It's standard parenting.

Thinking of the all the parents not reaching the standard. In situations where they have done it wrong. With kids kicking off. Oh dear.

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 17:39

Hindsight? The opposite. It's absolutely predictable that snatching a phone away from a tired child will upset them, so the process needs to be managed. Give a warning, distract while doing the task etc. It's standard parenting.

how lovely to be so adept.

MRex · 24/07/2022 17:29

Hindsight? The opposite. It's absolutely predictable that snatching a phone away from a tired child will upset them, so the process needs to be managed. Give a warning, distract while doing the task etc. It's standard parenting.

vivainsomnia · 24/07/2022 17:28

Totally agree with this … as if you can get a 3 yr old who’s tired and having a tantrum after a day out to just stop crying
So you never bother to try? What do you do? Let them scream until they decide to stop which we know can be a very very long time, or hand up giving them what they want? Either way, how are they to learn that it's not acceptable to disturb others?

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 17:23

as addressing another poster who was clear she definitely saw no point in trying to get a child to stop crying.

@MRex

No you misunderstood

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 17:21

sunglassesonthetable - clearly no, you don't. OP could have done lots of things differently to manage the situation better. She could have warned the boy so he wouldn't cry, could have involved him with "help mummy check the train time, can you spot a number 3...", could have put an arm round to comfort him, etc. Any of those things might have stopped the tears. She and you just shrug that kids cry, but it doesn't have to be the case that he cried in this situation. Just because some 3yo can't moderate their behaviour sometimes doesn't mean giving up on all of them all of the time.

I love the cool calm benefit of hindsight! 😁 " "Can you spot no 3? " Love it! So easy from behind a computer eh?

She and you just shrug that kids cry, but it doesn't have to be the case that he cried in this situation. Just because some 3yo can't moderate their behaviour sometimes doesn't mean giving up on all of them all of the time.

Give me a break. "Giving up on them" 😁A bit dramatic.It's just a tired and cranky 3yr old kicking off at the end of the day. Happens all the time tbh.

MRex · 24/07/2022 17:10

MumTrain · 24/07/2022 16:40

You’ve not read the full thread…. I did try to comfort him

In the OP you didn't, then later maybe you were giving the phone back (unclear), then you did comfort him, then you didn't because there's no point talking to a 3 year old... Sorry, I didn't know which versions to buy into, and I was addressing another poster who was clear she definitely saw no point in trying to get a child to stop crying.

HeArInGhandsgirl11 · 24/07/2022 16:59

Haven't read the whole thread but I think the other women should have just left your DC alone. Unless she was offering a magical solution to stop the tantrum, which she wasn't!

Eixample · 24/07/2022 16:44

I currently have my second three year old. People understand that you can’t stop them tantruming, but they want to see you at least trying to stop them. Looking at your phone (bearing in mind they don’t know what you are doing) will have looked like you didn’t care.

girlmom21 · 24/07/2022 16:42

You’ve not read the full thread…. I did try to comfort him
Your timeline of events is pretty confusing to be fair, as is your version. It's changed a few times so people can be forgiven for not understanding.

This thread prevents users from posting on it until they have been members for at least 1 day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread