Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum on the train

533 replies

MumTrain · 24/07/2022 09:14

Yesterday I was coming home from a day out with DS, aged 3 on the train. We had been out all morning and he was in top form but by the time we got on the train he was understandably tired.

It was a modern train you can walk through with no doors and spacious, wide aisles but still some seats free and no one had to stand.

DS was in the window seat and was standing up so I asked him to sit down and to keep him occupied I gave him my phone to watch a video with on silent so as not to disturb the other passengers. When we were nearly at our stop, I asked for my phone to check the time of our connection and he proceeded to cry as he was watching a cartoon.

A mum who was sat behind me heard all this and came to the aisle, bent down beside us, leaned in. I thought she was going to offer DS a toy or a sweet to cheer him up but instead and said “do you think you could be quiet? My baby is asleep”.

I told her in no uncertain terms that I would not be asking him to stop crying and that we have a baby at home too. She isn’t the first person to have a baby asleep on public transport. She could easily have walked the baby in the buggy further down the train.

AIBU to think that asking a toddler who is crying and having a tantrum to not cry is batshit crazy?

OP posts:
Reddip · 24/07/2022 10:07

I never really understand the responses to these sorts of threads where people think you can just stop a toddler or pre-school aged child crying or having a tantrum. Makes me want to not take my kid out just in case.

Lalliella · 24/07/2022 10:07

I’d have told her to get out of my face. Has she not heard of covid? I had this the other day when DD and I were chatting quietly in the quiet carriage a woman told us to stop talking. Umm you’re allowed to talk, it actually says so on the sign. Get out of my face!

girlmom21 · 24/07/2022 10:07

Asking a child to stop crying never works.

Apart from all the examples people have given where it does.

LampLighter414 · 24/07/2022 10:07

Lol was my Mum on the train book suggestion deleted because I used the word Karen?

C8H10N4O2 · 24/07/2022 10:05

MumTrain · 24/07/2022 09:37

I’m amazed that some posters think I went on a day out without any resources to keep him happy, that I would happily let him cry on a train and not do anything about it. Of course I tried to stop him crying.

I just think it’s bonkers to ask another mothers child to stop crying. I left my own baby at home with DH and I’m a sleep deprived mother myself.

That is probably because in your OP you stated your toddler was having a tantrum, not just crying and youresponded to a polite request, "do you think you could be quiet? My baby is asleep” with:

I told her in no uncertain terms that I would not be asking him to stop crying and that we have a baby at home too. She isn’t the first person to have a baby asleep on public transport. She could easily have walked the baby in the buggy further down the train.

Which was frankly rude.
Now you have modified the story to reflect better on yourself as people have called you out on your own behaviour

MumTrain · 24/07/2022 10:05

Asking a child to stop crying never works. If she was trying to distract him and intervening in a positive way I wouldn’t have minded, but she just directed “do you think you could be quiet” at us. The example of the stranger blowing bubbles in the carriage is lovely, just asking isn’t. I felt judged and she got my back up as I was already trying to calm him down and I managed to. Her intervention didn’t help at all. I thought she was going to show him a toy or something to do so, but just asked us to be quiet which is very different.

This whole thing only lasted a few minutes. She could have pushed the baby further down the train but chose to stay where she was.

No one likes others being noisy in public, but it’s a public place. Would she have asked the group of drunk lads to be quiet who got off the train before we got on? Probably not, but I was fair game.

OP posts:
ComDummings · 24/07/2022 10:04

Georgeskitchen · 24/07/2022 09:27

A train is public transport. Toddlers cry. Anyone wanting perfect silence needs to drive themselves or hire a taxi

Yeah this ^

Cheeseandlobster · 24/07/2022 10:04

Bruce123 · 24/07/2022 09:57

“One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter.” You are both viewing the situation through your own prism. What the world needs is more understanding of the other perspectives, not less. That, my friends, is the way to true enlightenment and harmony.

This. You were both fraught for different reasons and neither of you acted your best. Forget about it now

GretaVanFleet · 24/07/2022 10:02

DS was in the window seat and was standing up

standing on the floor or the seat because the latter would have annoyed me more than the crying. Rather than giving your phone to your child if you know taking it back will get a reaction you could have tried something different from the beginning.

UWhatNow · 24/07/2022 10:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

riserved · 24/07/2022 10:01

She could have asked you to shut your child up, she didn't, she bent down and spoke directly to the child with a perfectly reasonable request. It might have worked if you'd given it a chance. She may have been a nursery teacher, she may understand 3 year olds very well. She wasn't stroppy, you were.

Onthelowdown · 24/07/2022 10:01

I misvoted, I thought she’d asked you to ask him and thought it was ridiculous as if that was a viable solution presumably you’d have done it already but I’ve read the replies and reread op and landed on yabu.

children often listen to other adults better than their parents, and your weird interjection of or objection to a perfectly reasonable request was weird. If she’d have told him off I’d have felt differently but sounds like she just asked

User839516 · 24/07/2022 10:01

I have a newborn baby and the other day there was a mum with a toddler in full screaming tantrum mode. When she saw me with baby she used us as a tool to get her DC to stop screaming. “Oh look! Sssh! A tiny sleeping baby! You don’t want to wake her! Ssshh!!” I joined in, smiling and putting my finger to my lips and bent down to show her the baby. It worked brilliantly and I thought the other mum was very clever. Maybe the lady on the train was trying something similar to help you?

FreyaStorm · 24/07/2022 10:01

You honestly “thought she was going to offer DS a toy or a sweet” to stop him being a brat?

Wow.

Totally with the other mum on this who by the sounds of it won’t be raising an entitled little prince.

CornishGem1975 · 24/07/2022 10:01

@MajorCarolDanvers and she said it to a 3 year old? I wouldn't be very receptive of that at all.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/07/2022 10:01

HumunaHey · 24/07/2022 09:59

Great Ted talk.

One woman's terrorist is another woman's precious first baby throwing a shitfit on a train.

Any better?

HumunaHey · 24/07/2022 09:59

Bruce123 · 24/07/2022 09:57

“One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter.” You are both viewing the situation through your own prism. What the world needs is more understanding of the other perspectives, not less. That, my friends, is the way to true enlightenment and harmony.

Great Ted talk.

Mytortoiseisbetter · 24/07/2022 09:59

“That, my friends, is the way to true enlightenment and harmony.”

guffaw.

MajorCarolDanvers · 24/07/2022 09:59

@CornishGem1975

I know OP has been changing her mind about what was and was not said but

do you think you could be quiet? My baby is asleep

Sounds like a polite request to me.

Maisa45 · 24/07/2022 09:58

This reply has been deleted

This post has been deleted as it breaks our Talk guidelines.

I would soo read this! 😂

Mytortoiseisbetter · 24/07/2022 09:58

Or, “it’s alright we’re getting off”

or “we’re getting off, is you baby safe alone back there?”

fleurneige · 24/07/2022 09:58

agreed

Maisa45 · 24/07/2022 09:57

You were both unreasonable. I think what she did was odd but you should have at least tried to quieten him. Only a minute" is a long time when you're listening to a whiny kid.

Bruce123 · 24/07/2022 09:57

“One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter.” You are both viewing the situation through your own prism. What the world needs is more understanding of the other perspectives, not less. That, my friends, is the way to true enlightenment and harmony.

Mytortoiseisbetter · 24/07/2022 09:57

“do you think you could be quiet? My baby is asleep”
did she address you child directly?
leaving her baby alone further down the aisle as the train came to a halt?

that’s not normal……the best response would have been to ignore her or ask if she was alright or say “where is your baby? They are about to open the doors”

I think she was frazzled.

This thread prevents users from posting on it until they have been members for at least 1 day.