Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum on the train

533 replies

MumTrain · 24/07/2022 09:14

Yesterday I was coming home from a day out with DS, aged 3 on the train. We had been out all morning and he was in top form but by the time we got on the train he was understandably tired.

It was a modern train you can walk through with no doors and spacious, wide aisles but still some seats free and no one had to stand.

DS was in the window seat and was standing up so I asked him to sit down and to keep him occupied I gave him my phone to watch a video with on silent so as not to disturb the other passengers. When we were nearly at our stop, I asked for my phone to check the time of our connection and he proceeded to cry as he was watching a cartoon.

A mum who was sat behind me heard all this and came to the aisle, bent down beside us, leaned in. I thought she was going to offer DS a toy or a sweet to cheer him up but instead and said “do you think you could be quiet? My baby is asleep”.

I told her in no uncertain terms that I would not be asking him to stop crying and that we have a baby at home too. She isn’t the first person to have a baby asleep on public transport. She could easily have walked the baby in the buggy further down the train.

AIBU to think that asking a toddler who is crying and having a tantrum to not cry is batshit crazy?

OP posts:
HumunaHey · 24/07/2022 11:22

Coffeeenema · 24/07/2022 11:05

Is this a serious question...?

No parent "lets" their child cry in a public place! It's just something that happens!!!

🙄Yes, it's a serious question.

The occurrence of a 3 year old crying just happens, yes. But doing nothing to stop it, does not. Whether it's soothing them when they fall over or, in the case of OP, telling DC she understands he wants to much more of the show but she needs the phone and him crying is disturbing other people and is not a way to get the phone back. Both are ways of not just letting a child cry.

The initial OP gave the impression she did nothing to stop him and proudly told the lady who came over that she had no plans to. It's not about the fact the child cried in the first place.

cantcomplainabouttheweather · 24/07/2022 11:21

I wouldn’t usually tolerate this but I made an exception as I didn’t want him to disturb people.

Well you did

And he did

You sound a bit entitled really. Doesn't matter whether it was 1 minute or 10 minutes in an enclosed space like a train I'd be attempting to comfort him / stop him crying

TabithaTittlemouse · 24/07/2022 11:21

Surely you just say, ‘sorry we’re getting off soon’.

Are you always quite so over dramatic?

One of mine used to have major meltdowns. I really felt for those around me. I knew that he is autistic and was often really struggling (other times it was just him being him), strangers just saw a screaming child.
Put yourself in the other mums shoes, don’t argue about who is the most out of order. Neither of you are (or weren’t until you started being dramatic).

MissMaple82 · 24/07/2022 11:19

MumTrain · 24/07/2022 09:37

I’m amazed that some posters think I went on a day out without any resources to keep him happy, that I would happily let him cry on a train and not do anything about it. Of course I tried to stop him crying.

I just think it’s bonkers to ask another mothers child to stop crying. I left my own baby at home with DH and I’m a sleep deprived mother myself.

So why are you asking if you were unreasonable then if you think it's bonkers?

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 11:18

was her child bothering everyone on the train? No.

You have no idea if anyone else cared.

The other mum cared because of her child.

Ladylalaboo1 · 24/07/2022 11:18

@pixie5121 not yet, but I'd bet my house that in future she will be in this position and won't appreciate somebodies tactless input.

pixie5121 · 24/07/2022 11:15

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Ladylalaboo1 · 24/07/2022 11:14

greystarblanchard · 24/07/2022 11:12

I’m actually flabbergasted at the amount of people saying you are being unreasonable! In a couple of years time she will understand that telling a three year old to “stop crying” isn’t as simple as that. My gosh!

Same!!! Sometimes they are just so grumpy and tired no amount of telling them to be quiet will work infact it will probably make it worse Confused and the op probably felt awful the whole time aswell makes me so anxious when my child is crying in public as I worry about things like this happening, children cry just have to deal with it, she wasn't on the train forever!

vivainsomnia · 24/07/2022 11:14

No parent "lets" their child cry in a public place! It's just something that happens!!!
Oh dear, is this the new generation parenting stand? If so, I really despair. So many threads of parents exhausted, depressed, struggling to cope.

It's no surprise if parents believe that they are hopeless at stopping a three year old cry in public and that the only option is to let them do so. I dare to think how long it will be before these kids completely rule the roost!

Rosewaterblossom · 24/07/2022 11:12

I suspect from the other woman's point of view, she saw a woman sat looking on her phone whilst ignoring her crying/tantruming dc hence why she said something.

The woman obliviously didn't know the circumstances that op was checking timings, but to most, if they were sat listening to a child cry whilst mum was on her phone, they wouldn't be happy.

greystarblanchard · 24/07/2022 11:12

I’m actually flabbergasted at the amount of people saying you are being unreasonable! In a couple of years time she will understand that telling a three year old to “stop crying” isn’t as simple as that. My gosh!

Mammajay · 24/07/2022 11:10

Actually it often does work to ask a three year old to stop crying if you explain it would be kind and help the baby to sleep. Children often want to be helpful

chilliesandspices · 24/07/2022 11:09

What part of “do you think you could be quiet? My baby is asleep” is rude? It's a polite request and sometimes kids do get stunned into silence when strangers speak to them. It was worth a shot.

Schmz · 24/07/2022 11:09

LibraryFairy · 24/07/2022 09:19

I voted YABU. Sometimes a little distraction from a stranger is exactly whar it takes to stop a tantrum in its tracks. I assume that's all she was trying to do and was trying to help you. No need for you to be rude or consider her to be 'batshit crazy. 🙄

Totally agree with this -

when my dd was little and kicking off in a shop -
an older lady bent down and spoke to my dd - you should listen to your mum !’
dd made a cat bum face and behaved !!
I was so grateful!!

pictish · 24/07/2022 11:08

Any of my kids would have been so astonished at her quiet, reasonable but unexpected approach, I imagine they would have hushed up immediately.

Kudos.

Ladylalaboo1 · 24/07/2022 11:07

I think she was being unreasonable tbh, I mean, I gather that your response might have been abit snappy but so what? What did she actually envisage happening here? You would say ' oh right wow sorry didn't realise that all I had to do was to keep him quiet and tell him to stop crying! I actually like him wailing in public but I'll ask him to stop and he will straight away just for you!' I get she might be stressed if her baby isn't sleeping and your child's crying might wake the baby, but I mean, she was on public transport, you kind of factor these things in when travelling with a baby?? It wouldn't even enter my mine to ask a person to quiet their crying child so as to not wake my sleeping baby I'd just deal with it?? Different if you were at her house for example but this was public? She could have moved seats. Also what happens when a group of people get on laughing? Or the tannoy is loud? So many variations here that could interrupt a sleeping baby that means expecting them to sleep on a public train is just naive. Incredibly entitled of this woman tbh, I'd have been just like you!

Coffeeenema · 24/07/2022 11:07

Bookworm20 · 24/07/2022 10:57

I cannot imagine for one second that someone got up from their seat and came and talked to you because your ds was 'crying' for just 1 minute.
So I think that perhaps he was crying for a it longer than that, or was he screaming crying? You mentioned tantrum earlier.
And you decided you cannot ask a 3 year old to stop crying?
Sorry, but why not?
A simple, 'if you don;t stop that you won't be getting the phone back' would have done it. Its called parenting your child. At least it would work with a child who has been shown that sort of behaviour doesn't get them what they want.

But then you gave him back the phone, and he stopped crying. So basically rewarded him for having a strop. You do realise that it will only get worse? Every time you do something or ask him to do something he doesn't like he'll just kick off because he knows there are zero consequences and he'll just get what he wants.
You can totally tell a 3 year old to stop crying. It sounds to me like you simply couldn't be bothered because its not worked for you in the past, and its pretty obvious why.

You are so sanctimonious.

PetalLeaves · 24/07/2022 11:06

Can’t believe some of the horrible/strange responses.

OP, i would’ve told her to mind her business and travel by taxi next time. Kids get loud and you see parents trying to calm them, it’s a part of travelling by public transport. Ignore these strange responses somehow trying to blame you.

Coffeeenema · 24/07/2022 11:05

HumunaHey · 24/07/2022 09:21

Not batshit crazy. You just both seemed to think your DC's needs/behaviours trumped the others.

Also, was he JUST crying or having a tantrum? There's astark difference between the two. I feel crying to an extent coulbe tolerated. A tantrum shouldn't have to be by strangers and it's up to the parent to subdue it. Why were you just letting him cry in a public place?

Is this a serious question...?

No parent "lets" their child cry in a public place! It's just something that happens!!!

Crumpleton · 24/07/2022 11:05

Would have thought at 3 he'd understand that you just wanted a quick look to check the connection time, wouldn't have taken more than a minute or two then he could have the phone straight back.

Eggsinthemorning · 24/07/2022 11:03

MumTrain · 24/07/2022 09:14

Yesterday I was coming home from a day out with DS, aged 3 on the train. We had been out all morning and he was in top form but by the time we got on the train he was understandably tired.

It was a modern train you can walk through with no doors and spacious, wide aisles but still some seats free and no one had to stand.

DS was in the window seat and was standing up so I asked him to sit down and to keep him occupied I gave him my phone to watch a video with on silent so as not to disturb the other passengers. When we were nearly at our stop, I asked for my phone to check the time of our connection and he proceeded to cry as he was watching a cartoon.

A mum who was sat behind me heard all this and came to the aisle, bent down beside us, leaned in. I thought she was going to offer DS a toy or a sweet to cheer him up but instead and said “do you think you could be quiet? My baby is asleep”.

I told her in no uncertain terms that I would not be asking him to stop crying and that we have a baby at home too. She isn’t the first person to have a baby asleep on public transport. She could easily have walked the baby in the buggy further down the train.

AIBU to think that asking a toddler who is crying and having a tantrum to not cry is batshit crazy?

I totally agree with you op u did right.

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 11:03

Good grief, it's public transport. If someone is doing something I don't like I either move or hope they'll be getting off soon.

Too right . It would be busy journey walking around telling toddlers to be quiet.

ReadtheReviews · 24/07/2022 11:02

But you can just ask him to stop crying. Surely that's part of what we do to soothe them isn't it? Hopefully you were doing what you could to quiet him down. However,it was odd of her to think you could just turn his switch from on to off because her baby was asleep. She should have understood, having a child herself, that crying happens.

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2022 10:59

A simple, 'if you don;t stop that you won't be getting the phone back' would have done it. Its called parenting your child. At least it would work with a child who has been shown that sort of behaviour doesn't get them what they want.

Snort. 😁🙄

GreenWheat · 24/07/2022 10:59

Good grief, it's public transport. If someone is doing something I don't like I either move or hope they'll be getting off soon.

This thread prevents users from posting on it until they have been members for at least 1 day.