Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister in law driving uninsured my husbands car

108 replies

Hann111 · 23/07/2022 23:54

We had one of his family members weddings - 3 hours away. We left late and on the way back my sister in law took over driving on his vehicle - motorway driving and gone midnight. She's not insured on his car and I'm pregnant. I'm annoyed that my husband left the wedding so late that he then got his uninsured sister in law to drive his car half of the way. AIBU? Thanks

OP posts:
M340 · 24/07/2022 14:28

If he didn't drink why didn't he drive home?

Gottoomuchgoingon · 24/07/2022 14:27

Hann111 · 24/07/2022 13:13

@Quia - yes you are correct - she MAY have been insured to drive it - we still don’t know. The point is that they absolutely thought she wasn’t insured to drive it .

This is the first I have known about the rule of being able to drive other cars and they certainly didn’t mention that possibility ….

I can check with her now to clarify but why would you assume that you were insured?

I just checked and husband and I both have a policy where he cannot drive other cars - it is policy holder only. We are with admiral.

This is exactly my point thank you @saraclara

Admiral policies have this cover if you are over 25 and in certain occupations. If you're in the motor trade etc you won't have it.
It will state the you are covered to drive any other insured vehicle Third Party only. It can't be your spouses vehicle however

99victoria · 24/07/2022 14:26

And Saga - just checked my policy and I'm covered for driving other cars too (as I assumed I was)

Gottoomuchgoingon · 24/07/2022 14:20

Reigateforever · 24/07/2022 00:31

i was worried about my DD BF driving my fully comp car, my insurance company put my mind at rest by saying, if he had a driving license it was covered.

This isn't true at all. It had to be specified by the insurer. Lots of occupations don't get it. It's not automatic

Tryingtokeepgoing · 24/07/2022 14:20

Notbluepeter · 24/07/2022 12:26

It's a out dated myth that being fully insured on your own car gives you third party cover on another. Very very few insurance companies offer this any more. It's called DOC insurance (driving other cars) and the only companies I have found that still do it are direct line, Aviva and Churchill.

You can add LV to that list, or at least my LV policy includes it.

saraclara · 24/07/2022 14:17

Dic · 24/07/2022 14:01

Do you often over worry? This seems a lot of fuss over nothing.

If I discovered that my DH was twat enough to let someone drive his car, who he believed not to be insured to drive it, I wouldn't consider it 'nothing'. Especially if his own driving record wasn't that great (6 points on his licence).

MNers have been furious with their husbands for a lot less.

Dic · 24/07/2022 14:01

Do you often over worry? This seems a lot of fuss over nothing.

Bindayagain · 24/07/2022 13:59

I would assume the OD (original driver) felt too tired to drive. Which is very dangerous of course. His wife was asleep so not the ideal person to ask, and his sister offered. I wouldn't offer if I wasn't insured personally.

SwelegantParty · 24/07/2022 13:39

Notbluepeter · 24/07/2022 12:26

It's a out dated myth that being fully insured on your own car gives you third party cover on another. Very very few insurance companies offer this any more. It's called DOC insurance (driving other cars) and the only companies I have found that still do it are direct line, Aviva and Churchill.

I've just checked my esure policy, I can drive any other car with the owner's permission, I didn't specifically request it, it just seems to be standard.

Quote - Driving other cars: The Policyholder, Xxxxx, may also drive a car that is not owned by them, or hired or leased to them under a hire purchase or leasing arrangement, providing they have the owner's permission to drive the car

Hann111 · 24/07/2022 13:25

@Quia my husband and I are both fully comp with admiral and we both have a ‘policyholder only’ policy - ie we are NOT insured on other cars which is what I thought.

you are right , I didn’t even know you could be insured on other cars in your policy as I don’t recall I have ever had that. This is news to me so thank you all for sharing that with me.

my husband and SIL both said she is uninsured on his car. I can only assume She is insured on her own car, we didn’t even talk about whether that was fully comp or not, and whether she could be insured on his car - maybe they don’t know that rule either… I assume if there was a slight possibility they thought that they would have brought it up there and then when I asked.

OP posts:
Quia · 24/07/2022 13:18

Raul57 · 24/07/2022 09:46

To all - the OP is clear, SiL was not insured, so why debate if she was or not?

If the OP did not say anything at the time, she is to blame as well. If I was in the OP's place, I'd put my foot down as breaking the law is not within my remit.

I don't think she is clear. Her account has changed, since in the first one she specifically says they said the SIL was uninsured for that car. It seems at least possible that they simply meant she was not on that car's insurance, and they were relaxed about it because they were well aware that she was covered by her own insurance. OP seems to know nothing about fully comp car insurance and the fact that it normally automatically covers driving other cars without anyone having to pay extra.

Hann111 · 24/07/2022 13:18

@maddy68 - yes you are right - in Hindsight I should have just been bold and put my foot down from the beginning , but I wasn’t 100% convicted from the beginning for a number of reasons…

The reason i didn’t was because to be honest they were both so relaxed about it, I probably didn’t want to appear to be unreasonable and I thought is this normal to drive uninsured! I have never had experiences with that in my family or me before …

and the reason I brought up the pregnancy in this thread is because I have hormones all over at the mo, with the bleeding I was also anxious and my husband knew about that, I was also very tired having just woken up and I suppose I didn’t have perfect mental clarity - hence me asking the question on here.

the responses have helped clarify that I think I should have been more bold up front - thank you.

OP posts:
Hann111 · 24/07/2022 13:13

@Quia - yes you are correct - she MAY have been insured to drive it - we still don’t know. The point is that they absolutely thought she wasn’t insured to drive it .

This is the first I have known about the rule of being able to drive other cars and they certainly didn’t mention that possibility ….

I can check with her now to clarify but why would you assume that you were insured?

I just checked and husband and I both have a policy where he cannot drive other cars - it is policy holder only. We are with admiral.

This is exactly my point thank you @saraclara

OP posts:
maddy68 · 24/07/2022 13:11

You are as much to blame here. If you weren't happy with her driving your car you should have refused to let her. if she is fully comp on her own she's likely to be insured on yours too

Quia · 24/07/2022 13:08

Hann111 · 24/07/2022 00:27

I guess my point is they stated she was Not insured and they were fine with it, despite me not feeling comfortable being in that car.

I can only go by what they’ve said and cannot scrutinise her policy on her other car.

According to your other posts, they said she was not insured for that car - she was not on that car's insurance. It doesn't necessarily mean she wasn't insured to drive it.

saraclara · 24/07/2022 13:07

A lot of people are missing the point that both the husband and sister did this despite knowing/ thinking that she wasn't insured.
Whether or not she was covered, they thought she wasn't yet were happy to do this, thinking that they were breaking the law and risking all that entailed (and would entail for anyone involved in an accident involving her).

So yes, I'd be really pissed off with them both.

Of course even if she had been covered by her own policy, it wouldn't have covered any damage to OP's car.

Toddlerteaplease · 24/07/2022 12:59

You can buy top up
Insurance by the hour. I've done it for my dads card

gobbynorthernbird · 24/07/2022 12:56

girlmom21 · 24/07/2022 12:48

It's not a myth. It's absolutely still a thing.

It is a myth. Some insurers still provide DOC on a fully comp policy, but those insurers are in the minority.

Hann111 · 24/07/2022 12:55

@M340 @Herejustforthisone i don’t know where the assumption my partner was drunk has come from. my partner had one drink I believe early in the day - he wasn’t drunk to drive and he drove for 1.5 hours before the switch happened. The SIL had the same amount to drink I believe, maybe one drink in the day - drinking didn’t come into it and they both had the same amount anyway.

@Nowisthemonthofmaying @Autumnalblooms thank you - much appreciated

@skippy67 - when the car owner (my Partner) and the driver (SIL) tells you they are uninsured I am going to take their word for it . Assuming she is insured when they’ve told me she’s not and they haven’t looked at the policy is silly in my view.

@Bunty55 - I was asleep when they drove away from the service. I then woke up and realised she was driving - my partner was driving his car prior to that or about 1.5 hours. I immediately asked if she was insured - to which they both said no. I expressed concern at that point in time - and I offered to drive and to which my partner said no. 30 mins later I clarified my concern and stated I was uncomfortable with it.

@MrsClatterbuck thank you and I agree.

@Nc830 - that’s not the point. I’m not judging her driving (even though I had to point out a speed limit as she was unfamiliar with the road) It was the fact it in my view wasn’t legal to drive uninsured and therefore whilst a small risk it is still present and the consequences would have been great.

thank you all for your views. I will certainly let this go, but it’s been interesting to hear the array of views on this and I have learnt something about insurance - that you may be insured on other cars. I checked mine and I am not covered on other cars and I will ask my SIL to check this also.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 24/07/2022 12:48

Notbluepeter · 24/07/2022 12:26

It's a out dated myth that being fully insured on your own car gives you third party cover on another. Very very few insurance companies offer this any more. It's called DOC insurance (driving other cars) and the only companies I have found that still do it are direct line, Aviva and Churchill.

It's not a myth. It's absolutely still a thing.

RealBecca · 24/07/2022 12:41

The main issue here is that you didn't feel able to say "I'm uncomfortable, stop the car so I can make an alternative arrangement for me and the unborn baby".

The big point for me is it sounds like you spend your time worrying about whether he is acting like an adult (knowingly risking his job- as far as he knew) or taking your feelings into account rather than steaming over them.

But you need to start using your voice to put your baby first. Its fine for you to have always put him first and let him in turn put himself first but you have a baby on the way and you both now need to put baby first.

Nowisthemonthofmaying · 24/07/2022 12:36

I don't know why people are being so blasé about insurance, this is quite a serious traffic offence and you would have been buggered if any sort of accident had happened and she wasn't covered! Not much you can do now though. Hope everything is OK with the baby.

Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs · 24/07/2022 12:33

Notbluepeter · 24/07/2022 12:26

It's a out dated myth that being fully insured on your own car gives you third party cover on another. Very very few insurance companies offer this any more. It's called DOC insurance (driving other cars) and the only companies I have found that still do it are direct line, Aviva and Churchill.

I have it with Hastings, as long as the car I'm driving has a valid policy against it at the time.

Notbluepeter · 24/07/2022 12:26

It's a out dated myth that being fully insured on your own car gives you third party cover on another. Very very few insurance companies offer this any more. It's called DOC insurance (driving other cars) and the only companies I have found that still do it are direct line, Aviva and Churchill.

girlmom21 · 24/07/2022 12:09

She shouldn't be driving uninsured but I don't get why you being pregnant makes any difference.

If you felt that strongly about it you could've resolved the situation there and then.