Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister in law driving uninsured my husbands car

108 replies

Hann111 · 23/07/2022 23:54

We had one of his family members weddings - 3 hours away. We left late and on the way back my sister in law took over driving on his vehicle - motorway driving and gone midnight. She's not insured on his car and I'm pregnant. I'm annoyed that my husband left the wedding so late that he then got his uninsured sister in law to drive his car half of the way. AIBU? Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Raul57 · 25/07/2022 11:47

Notcoolmum · 25/07/2022 10:05

My AA brokered insurance has the same wording as swelegant's. Not something I asked for, just a general clause.

What I don't understand is why the OP is so anxious about something that has already happened and passed without incident. She doesn't know her SIL want insured. If her husband was tired and had driven for 1.5 hours then the safest thing was to swap drivers or take a rest.

Sure, take a rest etc and or change driver but it does not mean you should break the law.

saraclara · 25/07/2022 11:46

Notcoolmum · 25/07/2022 10:05

My AA brokered insurance has the same wording as swelegant's. Not something I asked for, just a general clause.

What I don't understand is why the OP is so anxious about something that has already happened and passed without incident. She doesn't know her SIL want insured. If her husband was tired and had driven for 1.5 hours then the safest thing was to swap drivers or take a rest.

Again, her husband and SIL thought she wasn't covered. So as far as they were concerned, they were breaking the law, and taking a big risk.

So it's not really over. OP has discovered that her DH is an idiot who's prepared to break the law and risk his licence. He didn't stop being an idiot as soon as the journey was over.

Sumtimesiamgreen · 25/07/2022 10:15

Yabu
being pregnant doesn’t mean your brain is “scrambled” I personally find this comment unhelpful. It creates an illusion that pregnant women can’t think straight.
Secondly it seems to me that you are more upset that your dp didn’t prioritise your concern about who was driving because now that you are pregnant, you want to be centre stage and not his sister.
If she drives her own car, likelihood is she was insured.

Notcoolmum · 25/07/2022 10:05

My AA brokered insurance has the same wording as swelegant's. Not something I asked for, just a general clause.

What I don't understand is why the OP is so anxious about something that has already happened and passed without incident. She doesn't know her SIL want insured. If her husband was tired and had driven for 1.5 hours then the safest thing was to swap drivers or take a rest.

Raul57 · 25/07/2022 09:52

Hann111 · 24/07/2022 09:59

@Raul57 - also you are right; next time (hopefully not) I will be more assertive about breaking the law and put my foot down from the start.

@Hann111

Thank you. We've all been there IE in hindsight should have done more. What is important that we learn from it.
You are a very decent person, all credit to you.

Bindayagain · 25/07/2022 08:51

@Dontfuckingsaycheese safest thing for you to do is to get added to your mum's insurance for the duration of your trip - my mum used to do this for me and I've done it when going away with a friend - it was not expensive and gave us (comprehensive) peace of mind.

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 25/07/2022 01:32

@Hann111 Thanks for this thread 🙂 Me and mum are going away soon in her car and I said I’d be ok to drive it too. - I know my insurance has in the past covered me for driving other people’s cars but I’ve not checked it lately. Due to this thread I will check before our trip. 🙂 Some of the misunderstandings regarding at insurance on this thread are shocking.
Just to clear up one such misunderstanding. If your insurance covers you for other vehicles that is 3rd party insurance only. Not 3rd party, fire and theft! Basically you are legal and liability for other drivers is covered. And that’s it. So if you have an accident and it’s judged your fault other car is covered but you get nothing for yours. Equally the case if you wrap it round a tree.
Safe motoring folks 🤗

saraclara · 24/07/2022 19:19

RewildingAmbridge · 24/07/2022 19:12

@Blowthemandown third party, fire and theft, if someone else hits you that's on their insurance. So the only thing not covered is of SIL drives the car into a wall/tree

When you hit someone else's car, you generally damage the car you're driving, too. So if SIL had hit someone else, the damage to OP's car wouldn't be paid for.

RewildingAmbridge · 24/07/2022 19:16

I've just renewed my insurance with co-op it covers me to drive any other insured vehicle, in abusive with my licence, with the permission of the owner. I know DB and SIL have the same because of an incident recently where DM ended up in hospital and we were sorting logistics to retrieve her car. DH doesn't as he is only a named driver on my car.
I would've just asked at the time, does your insurance cover you to drive this? If she said no, I would've said well if DH doesn't want to drive, I will.

RewildingAmbridge · 24/07/2022 19:12

@Blowthemandown third party, fire and theft, if someone else hits you that's on their insurance. So the only thing not covered is of SIL drives the car into a wall/tree

Raul57 · 24/07/2022 18:28

@Hann111
Thank you. I'm not sure why some kept on saying that.
You are a very mindful, caring and lawful person I just there were more people like you.

iamjustamumnow · 24/07/2022 17:32

@saraclara the fact that he's got 6 points doesn't help him at all. It sounds like he's just really irresponsible in general...

If the driving was a one off thing but he was otherwise reasonable I would say OK. But taking the 6 points into consideration, I'm with you and OP on this now.

saraclara · 24/07/2022 17:32

Funnily enough, if the mother of the young man from my in-laws village who was killed by an uninsured driver, posted here, of course everyone would be up in arms about someone choosing to drive uninsured.

saraclara · 24/07/2022 17:29

iamjustamumnow · 24/07/2022 17:14

@saraclara I also just want to add that I've never driven an uninsured car or had anyone drive mine. But it's happened to Op and it all worked out.. so I don't see the big deal. Maybe the Op can point out the consequences to her husband and tell him next time not to take such risks. But I wouldn't call into question the brother and SIL entire character over it.

I absolutely would call into question their character. They both agreed to do something that's illegal, and DH demonstrated that he had no concern for the financial and practical risks (any more points for him and he'd lose his license) and for no good reason.

Of course there's no need for OP to fret about danger, because it's over. But she absolutely can fret that she's married to an idiot who would risk his licence (presumably at significant inconvenience to her) for no good reason.

iamjustamumnow · 24/07/2022 17:14

@saraclara I also just want to add that I've never driven an uninsured car or had anyone drive mine. But it's happened to Op and it all worked out.. so I don't see the big deal. Maybe the Op can point out the consequences to her husband and tell him next time not to take such risks. But I wouldn't call into question the brother and SIL entire character over it.

iamjustamumnow · 24/07/2022 17:07

@saraclara I just think so many people over estimate risk on here though! How many times do you have car accidents ?? And how many times does the police randomly stop you?

On the balance of probabilities, it's unlikely either of those two things would happen on a one off trip.

junglejane66 · 24/07/2022 15:32

MrsClatterbuck · 24/07/2022 11:14

Even if she was insured under her own policy it was probably 3rd party. In other words in the event of an accident the other car would be covered but any damage to yours wouldn't be. So a potential financial hit there. Ok if your car is an old banger but not so good if it's the good family car and you can't afford to just go out and replace it. If she really has no insurance then that is totally irresponsible. Doesn't matter how good a driver she is and even if an accident is not her fault her non insurance will come to light and she may be prosecuted plus your insurance company will not be impressed that your DH let an uninsured driver drive his car and may cancel the policy. You don't muck around with car insurance.

'In other words in the event of an accident the other car would be covered but any damage to yours wouldn't be'.

So if you had 3rd party and someone crashed into you, their insurance wouldnt pay out to have your car fixed? Doesnt sound right to me, are you sure?

Blowthemandown · 24/07/2022 15:25

RewildingAmbridge · 23/07/2022 23:55

Is she not fully comp on her own car? If she is its likely she's issued to drive any other insured vehicle in accordance with her licence (ie no hgvs etc)

@RewildingAmbridge full comp cover on your own car would normally only grant third party cover on someone else’s though …

GretaVanFleet · 24/07/2022 15:14

Hann111 · 24/07/2022 09:38

@MandSStoreManager - I had seen a few days before police putting what looked like temporary speed cameras down that road and the speed has fairly recently been reduced from 60 to 50, there are now multiple 50 signs up - I ‘backseat drove’ because I didn’t want 'the car' to get a ticket, i.e. what probably would have been my husband to potentially get points on his license when he is already maxxed out - he would loose his license and also his ability to work.

If you do get a ticket they will check whether her policy allows other vehicles to be driven. If it does, she gets done for speeding and if it doesn’t she still gets done for speeding and driving without insurance. Your DH would be prosecuted for permitting her to drive without insurance.
As far as the event itself unless you get a speeding ticket through the mail I would forget it.

LovinglifeAF · 24/07/2022 15:13

Gingersay · 24/07/2022 00:32

Why did you let her drive if she's not insured then moan about it? You facilitated her breaking the law.

This

Bindayagain · 24/07/2022 15:11

I've just checked my admiral policy and it does insure me (3rd party).

QuestionableMouse · 24/07/2022 15:07

My policy doesn't cover me to drive other cars.

It also doesn't mean that I'm suddenly an unsafe driver if I get behind the wheel of one that I'm not covered to drive. (Not that I would!)

There's a difference between what's legally okay and what's practically okay, if that makes sense.

The op was in no more danger in this situation than she would have been if they'd been in a car the other person was covered to drive. The driver was more at risk of repercussions though.

saraclara · 24/07/2022 14:56

In case that image isn't readable, it says:

If I have fully comprehensive car insurance can I drive any car?
No. There was a time when many fully-comp policies automatically gave you third-party insurance to drive any car, but those days have gone.

saraclara · 24/07/2022 14:53

iamjustamumnow · 24/07/2022 14:30

Oh got. OP, seriously, unclench. Nothing happened. Her insurance probably covered her anyways.

It may well not have. I've just googled and virtually every result has said that this used to be the case but it no longer is in many/most cases.

And had she had an accident, or been stopped, this is from the AA website

A driver who is involved in an accident or caught without DOC insurance, even if the car they are driving is insured by the owner, will be dealt with severely by the law. They will be heavily fined with up to 8 licence penalty points, and could be banned from driving.

What's more, the owner would also face prosecution for allowing an uninsured person to drive their car. The owner's insurer will have to meet any third party damage and injury costs but would almost certainly cancel the policy. They may then take legal action to recover their costs from the owner, who would also be liable for the cost of repairing their own car.

Insurance companies take convictions for driving without insurance very seriously. Both the owner and the driver will find it very difficult to obtain affordable car insurance in the future. This could be a very good way of losing a friend!

Note all the references to the owner also being penalised.

So OP does not need to unclench. She's discovered that her DH and SIL are not morons, and she's entitled to be annoyed.

Sister in law driving uninsured my husbands car
iamjustamumnow · 24/07/2022 14:30

Oh got. OP, seriously, unclench. Nothing happened. Her insurance probably covered her anyways.

Swipe left for the next trending thread