Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Snobbery regarding Doctorate degrees vs PhD

33 replies

Sishirunak · 23/07/2022 23:16

Does anybody have any experience of this first hand? I'm currently applying for Doctor of Education degrees as I work in the field, and I think it will be more suitable for me than a traditional PhD. I'm not looking to pursue a research career.
I've heard on the grapevine that professional Doctorates are looked down upon by academics, and that they aren't considered at the same level as PhDs despite both being exactly the same status and making you a Doctor.
What I've read is that as the Doctorates have taught modules and perhaps a shorter thesis, people just don't believe it should be awarded at PhD level as it isn't 100% research.
This doesn't put me off applying for one and I am still going ahead with it.

OP posts:
SeekingTact · 24/07/2022 00:31

@Sishirunak know academia is often a snob fest, but would agree @Nephthys21 and @dudsville, the PhD is geared towards academic research and the professional doctorate towards expert practice.

StaunchMomma · 24/07/2022 00:25

It's not just snobbery, they are not equal in terms of input.

I considered a PhD but seeing what those students in my department went through in terms of the volume of work/research and then the terrifying interview after submitting their thesis - looks like hell!

As far as I understand it an EdD is more studying, rather than research and they don't have to face the dreaded panel!

Don't blame you for preferring that route, OP!

Nephthys21 · 24/07/2022 00:11

I have a Doctorate in clinical psychology. I would agree that our thesis was less in depth than would be needed for a PhD and I don't feel that I finished it with the same confidence in research skills that someone with a PhD would likely have. On the other hand, people with PhDs wouldn't make very good clinical psychologists so... 🤷‍♀️

dudsville · 23/07/2022 23:33

Snobbery is always a shame, but these are two different qualifications; one is a practitioner's qualification, the other research.

WombOfOnesOwn · 23/07/2022 23:28

But they're not the same degree, or the same status.

An Ed.D. is typically awarded after some kind of clinical project, with little or no original research. A Ph.D. in education (even in the exact topics of the Ed.D.) would require dissertating and defending the dissertation.

One is a clinical degree with significantly reduced selectivity for programs, one is a research degree with high selectivity. They're not the same. I say this as someone who looked into doing either one and decided on neither (very happy with how my career turned out instead, though!).

Sishirunak · 23/07/2022 23:25

I've even read someone say 'A Doctorate degree isn't a PhD, it's a Masters degree.' wow..
It's definitely one of the reasons I don't want to work in academia!
Thank you, I hope it's definitely the right course for me

OP posts:
OwlinaTree · 23/07/2022 23:22

Sounds like snobbery to me. People should do further study because it interests them or it furthers their career, not because they think it makes them better than everyone else. If it's the right course for you then go for it.

SandieCollins · 23/07/2022 23:19

Yes I’ve heard the same, but academia is full of snobbery, there will always be someone wanting to put down your achievement, go for it if it’s right for you.