Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Snobbery regarding Doctorate degrees vs PhD

33 replies

Sishirunak · 23/07/2022 23:16

Does anybody have any experience of this first hand? I'm currently applying for Doctor of Education degrees as I work in the field, and I think it will be more suitable for me than a traditional PhD. I'm not looking to pursue a research career.
I've heard on the grapevine that professional Doctorates are looked down upon by academics, and that they aren't considered at the same level as PhDs despite both being exactly the same status and making you a Doctor.
What I've read is that as the Doctorates have taught modules and perhaps a shorter thesis, people just don't believe it should be awarded at PhD level as it isn't 100% research.
This doesn't put me off applying for one and I am still going ahead with it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
igivein · 24/07/2022 12:57

Sorry, forgot he had to do a viva as well.

igivein · 24/07/2022 12:56

DH did a DProff. He went into academia after a professional career and just got really into doing research. He was already an international ‘name’ in his field when he decided to do a doctorate and was advised to do it ‘by publication’ because he already had a substantial body of quality publications.
It was still flipping hard work and time consuming to do. He had to write a narrative (80k words) explaining the development of his research through publications and how it added to the body of knowledge in the discipline.
He still got loads of snobby comments about how it wasn’t a ‘proper’ doctorate, which was hurtful.
He’s a full Prof now, so what sort of Dr he was is largely irrelevant, and just goes to show that you don’t have to have a phd to be a competent academic researcher.

WitchWithoutChips · 24/07/2022 12:29

If you don’t intend to work in academia then the prejudices of academics are, well, academic Grin

GooglyEyeballs · 24/07/2022 12:28

Academia is very toxic! I have a PhD and first hand experience!

Gooseysgirl · 24/07/2022 12:23

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 24/07/2022 08:30

To be honest, I have a PhD and I would never call it a ‘doctorate’ - the PhD award, ‘doctor of philosophy’ relates to the level of thinking and in particular, independent thinking that goes into a PhD. I wouldn’t necessarily consider a different kind of doctorate to be lesser, but a different beast with a different purpose. I don’t think a taught doctorate could prepare you for an academic career as well, particularly a research based one. But it would be good prep for a professional career in that field.

It’s similar in the masters space tbh - a PGDip vs an MA and an MBA, all three are possible in the field of management/leadership/business, but they are not all equal and have different requirements. Sometimes a PGDip is enough, often the MBA is overkill but is a mark of quality.

Completely agree with this!

Gooseysgirl · 24/07/2022 12:20

GoodThinkingMax · 24/07/2022 01:03

I am doing a taught doctorate, it has a research component - all my own original work, and I will have to defend all 40,000 words of it next year... anyone who says it's like a masters is talking through their arse. It is bloody hard work!!

I agree - a taught or professional doctorate is way above a Masters. But my PhD thesis was 120,000 words, not 40,000 + course work (my Masters was 40,000 + course work). There's a big difference in writing 40k or 100k words in terms of the research and argument necessary.

Yes there is a huge difference! I have to write another 80,000 words in assignments in addition to the 40,000 thesis. And that doesn't include 3 days per week clinical placement work including all the paper work... not remotely like a masters! My doctorate is quite different to PhD or masters. But when I say I'm doing a doctorate people still ask me how's the PhD going 😆 I think there a lot of misunderstanding out there outside of academia about what each entails.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 24/07/2022 08:49

It sounds like immaturity for people to say such silly things. Or insecurity. People who defend the boundaries of who can contribute to ‘their subject’ eg by dismissing others’ contributions tend to be arseholes in other ways and see themselves as better than service users, students etc too. They also tend to be rude and argumentative at conferences without the ability to value others’ research. So glad I did most of my studies at two institutions where such nonsense wasn’t entertained.

I’m not an academic but some of the best-regarded people in my field didn’t have a doctorate/PhD or even occasionally an academic position, and used to put their home address for the correspondence address on academic papers but were welcomed to collaborate/guest lecture.

Other universities didn’t have the same approach. Their loss.

Sadly being a professor or head of department doesn’t make you a mature adult or a decent human being and there doesn’t seem to be enough accountability or transparency to the academic hiring process so if academia is what you want to get into, a PhD might be the necessary route.

Having said that, I don’t get the impression there would be the same prejudice against DFA vs a PhD in creatIve subjects, because the level of original work is so high, but that might be just how it seems from the outside.

It depends what you want to do with your qualification (and where) as to which would be best, though. There isn’t an absolute.

DonnaHadDee · 24/07/2022 08:32

In the software areas, you’ll find that most PhD programs now also incorporate some taught modules in the first year or two to ensure the students have a solid foundation, and these are typically targeted towards topics of value in industry. Of course it’s primarily research, but underpinned by some core taught foundational modules.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 24/07/2022 08:30

To be honest, I have a PhD and I would never call it a ‘doctorate’ - the PhD award, ‘doctor of philosophy’ relates to the level of thinking and in particular, independent thinking that goes into a PhD. I wouldn’t necessarily consider a different kind of doctorate to be lesser, but a different beast with a different purpose. I don’t think a taught doctorate could prepare you for an academic career as well, particularly a research based one. But it would be good prep for a professional career in that field.

It’s similar in the masters space tbh - a PGDip vs an MA and an MBA, all three are possible in the field of management/leadership/business, but they are not all equal and have different requirements. Sometimes a PGDip is enough, often the MBA is overkill but is a mark of quality.

RJnomore1 · 24/07/2022 08:28

There is definitely a difference though - just as there would be a difference between an MRes and a MSc? Doesn’t mean the quality and standards drop but agree they have different purposes.

it was described to me as a PhD helps you become a professional researcher while a ProfDoc helps you become a researching professional. I’d argue unless you are hell bent on academia as a career route a ProfDoc is a better choice.

BTW regarding the 120k words being harder my own supervisors believe it’s much harder to produce work to the depth and quality needed in a smaller word count - it allows very little space for any indulgence. So you will find differing views everywhere on what’s hardest and what constitutes best quality.

Im dude everyone could agree either is bloody hard work mind you.

Sishirunak · 24/07/2022 08:24

Thanks for your answers, I understand your points and can better see the difference between the two now. I think the snobbery was regarding people calling it a 'doctorate' , comparing it to a Masters, even though it's a level 8, saying 'anyone can get on it' and so on. However there will always be snobs everywhere indeed and I am not even surprised that there's snobbery regarding which PhDs are 'better' than others!

OP posts:
RJnomore1 · 24/07/2022 08:21

GoodThinkingMax · 24/07/2022 01:01

They're not the same. A taught Doctorate has taught elements, and a shorter thesis. They're great for people who want to pursue a professional qualification to the highest level, but the emphasis is not on an original contribution to knowledge (subsequently publishable as a scholarly book).

Horses for courses - if you want to become an academic / university lecturer, it might be better to look at aPhD.

Within Scotland an original contribution to knowledge is absolutely one of the SCQF level 12 indicators and the biggest difference between masters and doctoral study. If you’re studying a professional doctorate at a Scottish university it is absolutely a requirement for your thesis.

honkeytonkwoman38 · 24/07/2022 06:08

Yes it's looked down on. A few lecturers in my department were undertaking doctorates and I notice this has now been stopped as a route and lecturers must undertake pHds now in the new policy.

Igmum · 24/07/2022 05:57

It isn't snobbery. I've taught, supervised and examined both and they are different. No, EdDs and DBAs are not Masters level (not sure who told you that), they are docotorates and a lot of work. If you want to be an academic and do research I'd recommend a PhD because of the depth of study required. In your case you are fine with an EdD. Don't let the critics put you off.

Unwavering721 · 24/07/2022 05:19

You will get snobbery everywhere. Even ppl with phds will have a hierarchy of what they consider “important” research within academia, ie a chemist or physics phd is “superior” to a psychology phd etc etc. it’s all bollocks. Just do what your passionate about and to hell with everyone else’s views and opinions!

fUNNYfACE36 · 24/07/2022 04:55

I don't really understand all this
My dc is doing a 4 year PhD in another country and rhe job title is doctoral candidate?

Cameleongirl · 24/07/2022 03:41

@GoodThinkingMax @SarahProblem Thanks for your insights, I know someone who’s doing a Professional Doctorate and I didn’t fully understand the differences between the two qualifications.

So if someone wants to focus on teaching, rather than research, at a business school, for example, is a Professional Doctorate a good qualification to have? Or is the Ph. D. route still the best approach?

SarahProblem · 24/07/2022 02:14

There is snobbery but Professional Doctorates are better in applied subjects like education, psychology, clinical areas.

You'll do a shorter thesis but still have a viva. Your work has to have novelty and be a contribution to new knowledge. If you we're going into research academia I'd probably advise doing a PhD but if this is CPD in a field you're working in a Professional Doctorate would be better.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/07/2022 01:23

Sishirunak · 23/07/2022 23:25

I've even read someone say 'A Doctorate degree isn't a PhD, it's a Masters degree.' wow..
It's definitely one of the reasons I don't want to work in academia!
Thank you, I hope it's definitely the right course for me

Well, they're wrong aren't they? PhDs and professional doctorates are both level 8 qualifications, masters are level 7.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NationalqualificationssframeworksinntheUnitedd_Kingdom

GoodThinkingMax · 24/07/2022 01:05

Sorry my second post is in answer to @Gooseysgirl 's post:

I am doing a taught doctorate, it has a research component - all my own original work, and I will have to defend all 40,000 words of it next year... anyone who says it's like a masters is talking through their arse. It is bloody hard work!!

GoodThinkingMax · 24/07/2022 01:03

I am doing a taught doctorate, it has a research component - all my own original work, and I will have to defend all 40,000 words of it next year... anyone who says it's like a masters is talking through their arse. It is bloody hard work!!

I agree - a taught or professional doctorate is way above a Masters. But my PhD thesis was 120,000 words, not 40,000 + course work (my Masters was 40,000 + course work). There's a big difference in writing 40k or 100k words in terms of the research and argument necessary.

GoodThinkingMax · 24/07/2022 01:01

They're not the same. A taught Doctorate has taught elements, and a shorter thesis. They're great for people who want to pursue a professional qualification to the highest level, but the emphasis is not on an original contribution to knowledge (subsequently publishable as a scholarly book).

Horses for courses - if you want to become an academic / university lecturer, it might be better to look at aPhD.

RJnomore1 · 24/07/2022 00:46

Sorry I could not I plus!

RJnomore1 · 24/07/2022 00:45

I’m at the final stages of a professional doctorate.

Two years of taught modules which must be passed

two years to write a thesis of around 60k words

and yes there’s a viva

I’m finding the opposite, the academics are incredibly supportive (and although I do a bit of teaching I don’t and won’t work in academia full time) - no one out of academia gets a difference at all. I’ll be honest given it’s supposed to be a part time course and I plus write a 70k word phd thesis in 3 years full time it’s a y turned out to be a lot more work than the phd. And my supervisors are absolutely holding me to the same standards as phd students. It’s way above the requirements for a masters.

Gooseysgirl · 24/07/2022 00:40

I am doing a taught doctorate, it has a research component - all my own original work, and I will have to defend all 40,000 words of it next year... anyone who says it's like a masters is talking through their arse. It is bloody hard work!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread