Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To press ahead with this despite DH opposition

81 replies

DancingQueen2018 · 23/07/2022 22:47

We have a 5 bed house 2 doubles 3 singles, we’ve historically always kept the 2nd double as a guest room but it gets used maybe twice a year.

DD1 is now 12 and ideally needs a bigger room, first prize would be to reconfigure the entire upstairs but that isn’t an option right now, so I’m planning to move her into the spare room so she can have a desk for homework and just more room.

DH is vehemently opposed to this and thinks she should just carry on in the small single (despite having a high sleeper she nearly thumps her head on the ceiling in). Mainly it appears As it means getting rid of a perfectly serviceable wardrobe from the current spare room (we’ve had it 15?years, but so huge there’s no way of moving it). I’m going to pay for the whole thing and do all the work myself. Is this massively unreasonable of me???

OP posts:
RJnomore1 · 24/07/2022 08:17

What’s happening with your third single room? Could it not be made into a small study so both girls can benefit and you still keep your guest room?

WinterMusings · 24/07/2022 08:12

TheLadyofShalott1 · 24/07/2022 05:31

With regards to your DD having to give up her bedroom when there are guests, when I was a child and we had Grandparents staying, my parents gave up their double room, I was never asked to. Other visitors had to stay in a B&B or hotel.

Similar here except we had other family from overseas staying too. My parents gave visitors their room I went into a spare bunk in my brothers room and my parents had my room, I vaguely remember we borrowed a second single bed for my room as I only had a single bed.

I remember at one time sleeping on a blow up bed in the little hallway in an off shoot to an unused front door. It would have been for a few weeks too as family had come to us from 12,000 miles away, so at least for a month.

we had camp stretchers in all the bedrooms (and hall) too when cousins came as well as aunt & uncle.

It was a fairly small 3 bed house, it seemed like a tardis looking back!! But then it was just the way it was & we didn't think anything of it!

HTH1 · 24/07/2022 08:04

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 23:21

YANBU. Why are you paying a mortgage for a wardrobe to ‘enjoy’ a big room when your DD could actually enjoy it? It makes no financial sense.

Also, guests are a lot less important that DC.

This.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/07/2022 08:01

OperaStation · 24/07/2022 07:46

What do you mean you are paying for it and you will save for the reconfigured layout in a few years time? Surely this is a shared cost and you are married so it’s shared money anyway?

Yes, I forgot about that. What's going on here?

2reefsin30knots · 24/07/2022 07:59

Could your DD stay in her current bedroom but with a single bed instead of high-sleeper (which could go to DD2) but then be given a second single as a study/ sitting room?

My DS (also 12) has two rooms. His bedroom upstairs which is just for sleeping and his clothes. He then has the downstairs study as a gaming room with his own sofa and space for his nick nacks etc. It works well because gaming is a) downstairs where we can hear what is going on and b) very separate from sleeping.

HikingforScenery · 24/07/2022 07:52

NumberTheory · 23/07/2022 23:02

I don’t think what you want to do is unreasonable, but I think it’s unreasonable to simply go ahead when your partner is opposed. (Unless he’s a complete ass in general and you’re only there because splitting up is too difficult right now).

This is something you need to discuss until you can both agree on a way forward.

I agree with this. Unless there’s some reason why you’ve more of a say than he does.

At face value, sure, your DD needs a bigger room but I don’t understand how a double room can’t fit a wardrobe, a bed and a desk. Could you get a different desk?
what’s in the wardrobe now and where will those things go?

MadeForThis · 24/07/2022 07:50

Who are the important visitors ?

OperaStation · 24/07/2022 07:46

What do you mean you are paying for it and you will save for the reconfigured layout in a few years time? Surely this is a shared cost and you are married so it’s shared money anyway?

TheLoftHatch · 24/07/2022 07:43

It's not unreasonable to want to do it but I think it's unreasonable to do it despite your husband. After all, if a man came on here and said he was going to repurpose a bedroom, his wife was dead against it but he was doing it anyway, he'd get hammered. It's his house too (presumably). Just keep talking to him and if he's reasonable, you'll eventually reach a compromise.

Festoonlights · 24/07/2022 07:37

Your dh is being ridiculous.
Your child soon to be teen needs more space that is readily available in a room you never use.
Is he lazy and can’t be bothered to help make the change happen?

I wouldn’t be moving teen out at Christmas book somewhere nearby well in advance and have your house the way you need it to suit the needs of your family 364 days a year.

3luckystars · 24/07/2022 07:36

Does the wardrobe lead somewhere else?

Maybe you should find out a bit more about it before getting rid of it. All the best.

Thinkingblonde · 24/07/2022 07:34

Do it. If the high sleeper is so high dd hits her head on the ceiling then she’s outgrown it. Use the room for the family who live there.
Theres also a risk with these high sleepers, God forbid, of smoke inhalation f there was ever a fire. Smoke rises These really high sleepers and triple bunks are too close to the ceiling, as told to me by a fireman last year, he was satisfied with ours as the bottom bunk is quite low to the floor hence the gap between ceiling and the top bunk being more than usual. Even so he still fitted a smoke alarm in the gc room.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/07/2022 07:32

Are you sure the wardrobe is the reason? It just seems so ridiculous in the circumstances. Might there be something else going on? Does he not want to reconfigure even in four years when you've had a chance to save?

KangarooKenny · 24/07/2022 07:14

Of course she should have the room, and a double bed too.

Musicalmaestro · 24/07/2022 07:03

Won’t your DD need a wardrobe anyway? You could always paint it if needed.

JennyForeigner · 24/07/2022 06:42

sweeneytoddsrazor · 23/07/2022 23:23

Does the wardrobe lead to Narnia. If so YABU

I'd leave that Narnia to itself. The Turkish delight is dangerous.

YANBU on fictional and real grounds. Some men are just weirdly change averse. Who prioritises Christmas over their kids?

ThinWomansBrain · 24/07/2022 06:38

men are weird.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 24/07/2022 05:31

With regards to your DD having to give up her bedroom when there are guests, when I was a child and we had Grandparents staying, my parents gave up their double room, I was never asked to. Other visitors had to stay in a B&B or hotel.

Divebar2021 · 24/07/2022 04:58

I have this exact issue other than we have a 3 bedroom house and only one DD who is 10. I would like her to move into the spare room from her awkward shaped single but DH is saying no. The main issue appears to be that the king size bed won’t fit in her single room (if we swapped over) and we would need to clear out some of our clothes from a large wardrobe in the spare room. We now only have a guest occasionally as MIL & FIL have both died. My argument is she is a permanent member of our family and her needs trump any occasional guest. I feel weird just going ahead against his wishes though and would be bloody annoyed if he was going ahead with something I was opposed to.

WiddlinDiddlin · 24/07/2022 04:29

Tell him you have a solution, the precious wardrobe can stay..

DD can have YOUR room, and you and DH will move into the spare, as you don't require a desk...

I predict he wont like that plan and may start to see sense.

If its a big solid antique double wardrobe, some of those are actually modular.. I had a super duper ugly one as a child, the top came off, then it split into three sections stood on a base that also came off.
Not that im suggesting the wardrobe goblins steal it when he is out or anything...

Pleasecreateausername · 24/07/2022 04:16

YABVU the wardrobe is older than DD and it needs more space.

Just providing the voice of your husband here for a different perspective...

... Go ahead with the switch.

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 24/07/2022 03:46

Is DD not your husbands child? Because he is treating her like Harry Potter, sounds like a cupboard under the stairs. He is being a dick.

RainbowsMoonbeams · 24/07/2022 03:02

Of course she should have the room.

Isn’t it better it is fully occupied 365 days a year than just when the occasional guest stays?

BoxOfCats · 24/07/2022 02:49

Why on earth do you need a double for guests? That's a luxury, not something to put ahead of your own daughters need for space.

We used to have a spare room with a double bed, then realised it was only actually being used about 3 weeks of every year in total as most guests only stayed 1-2 nights. So we got rid of the bed, and put in a sofa bed, desk and TV. Now in the daytime it's my office, and at night it's a second sitting room if someone wants to watch a different channel on TV. It's already getting a lot more use! You should try to make the most of the space you have instead of prioritising guests.

Pleiades2020 · 24/07/2022 01:56

Dd1 into double, dd2 into the high sleeper, wardrobe into a single with aid of man with van or removal firm, desk in 5th single for study space. Maybe?