Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you take 5 year old out of school?

108 replies

Savador · 23/07/2022 22:37

family are saying I am being unreasonable because I will not take DD out of school for a family holiday, I don’t want a fine and education is important to me. Please tell me I’m not the only one who feels this way?

OP posts:
Sherrystrull · 24/07/2022 09:17

@Silverfinch

Does it make you feel like a better person for correcting the teacher's grammar?

Op, I would absolutely take your daughter out for a holiday.

However, if she is 5 now she is likely to be moving into year 1? If this is the case I would avoid June with the phonic screening. It's a real pain for the teachers if a child is off during the build up weeks and also the week of the screening.

Have a lovely holiday.

Babdoc · 24/07/2022 09:10

I took mine out of the village primary virtually every year. The headmistress used to laugh and say it might give the other kids a chance to catch up!
DD had a reading age of 12 in reception and used to correct her teacher’s spelling. She was teaching herself high school maths at primary, using textbooks sent down by the comprehensive in the nearest town.
Missing a fortnight each year didn’t stop her getting 5 straight As in her Advanced Highers (Scotland) and a maths degree from Durham uni.
And the holidays were educational too - I took her to the neolithic site at Skara Brae, the ruins of Carthage, mediaeval chateaux in the Dordogne, the Minoan palace at Knossos, Hadrian’s wall, etc.
Unless your DC are struggling to keep up at primary, OP, the learning experience of a holiday, trying foreign languages, food, having new experiences, far outweighs anything they miss.

NameChange30 · 24/07/2022 08:57

YANBU. My DS is 5 and has just finished reception. I don't hesitate to keep him off school if he is unwell (I kept him off for several days when he had covid and I didn't want him to infect others). I am also fine with the odd day off for an important occasion. But I would not take him out of school for a holiday. My main reason is that there are enough school holidays as it is, 6 weeks in the summer is plenty of time to fit in a holiday, and DH and I don't have unlimited annual leave to take holiday during term time as well as covering childcare in the holidays (holiday clubs can be tricky for various reasons). Also, it suits DS to have a routine, and he can be really hard work during the school holidays when he's out of routine (this might not be true of all children but I'm sure it is true of some). Lastly, as the teachers on this thread have pointed out, he would miss out on a lot of learning if we took him out for a whole week.

We are lucky in that we can afford a holiday during the school holidays - if we couldn't afford it, I can see how it would be tempting to go in term time, but all the reasons against it would still exist. I think I'd try to find something cheap to do in the school holidays.

SamMil · 24/07/2022 08:57

It depends on the trip. I wouldn't take them out for a general holiday. For a once in a lifetime, time sensitive type thing (e.g. wedding in a far flung place we wouldn't get to go to otherwise), I would consider it.

SpiderVersed · 24/07/2022 08:56

I think it’s wrong that they are in full time education so early anyway, so I had no problem taking them out of school at 5.

Darbs76 · 24/07/2022 08:50

You will get a fine if it 5 days or more. It’s still cheaper than going in school holidays. We tend to go in school holidays but sometimes tag on a day or so. My kids have learnt more from their trips than in the last few days of school

mrsfoof · 24/07/2022 08:42

Hell yes.

Seashor · 24/07/2022 08:35

I’ve taught reception, year 1 and year 2. Contrary to popular belief children of that age miss masses if they are not in school. Phonics is a new sound a day, that’s a big chunk of learning missed and it does impact.

3luckystars · 24/07/2022 08:25

Have you booked something?

Or are you talking about next year?

AverageJoan · 24/07/2022 08:23

When I was young my parents never let me miss a day of school, even if I was ill, and it's fostered an unhealthy mindset in my adult life whereby I feel like I can't miss a day of work even for legitimate reasons. I still hate calling in, even when I'm really struggling.

With my own family, as others have said, I don't see a problem in taking them out a couple of days either side of term to make it cheaper etc. Hopefully my DC will learn there's more to life than 100% attendance.

kitcat15 · 24/07/2022 05:47

Its entirely your choice...I don't think there's a right or a wrong....I did it loads when mine were small..8ncluding 2 long haul 6 weeks to Australia over Christmas.....I got a fine once ( for just 1 of my 3 children) ....50 quid ...and seeing as I had spent thousands on the holiday it was a drop in the ocean...my kids didn't appear to suffer educationally....fast forward to my GDs ...eldest is 6....she's been taken out both in re reception and year1...and plans are to take her out next Christmas for a 6 week l9ng haul trip.... we do it, A to save money.... and B because it works better with parents annual leave.

mathanxiety · 24/07/2022 03:40

If your child is progressing well and you can do some reading together while you're away I wouldn't hesitate.

Just for a little perspective, children in other parts of the English speaking world have been on holiday since the beginning of June. The majority of them will do just fine despite being so deprived of days in school.

Peach27 · 24/07/2022 03:25

PS this was in a school with absence issues and looming OFSTED. Had to argue with head to send home clearly sick kids multiple times.

Peach27 · 24/07/2022 03:24

As a teacher If they’ve got good attendance generally eg less than 5 sick days/year and they know you don’t take the piss they wouldn’t fine you usually. It’s a massive faff. Only time I’ve seen them properly threaten to do so was a family constantly off eg whole days for “dentist” optician etc, constant brazen lying. It’s now escalated to safeguarding. There was 1 week he had covid then chickenpox then the flu. We knew mum was taking the piss bc when we said to the oldest child (Y6) that amount of absences would threaten his place on the football team he came into school more. Y6 child is working 2 years behind, Y2 child came into Y2 working at Christmas reception level alongside another child. That kid had 97% attendance and now is end of Y1 level. The child from this family had 80% T3 (less than 50% before Christmas) and is working Easter Reception level. Can do as many interventions as you like but it won’t benefit child if you don’t come to school. Also SENDCO can’t do anything regarding potential EHCP because LA will just point to low attendance.

user3346315 · 24/07/2022 02:58

I think most people only take them out of school because the cost of everything increases so much in the holidays. Which is completely unfair on parents with school children and it is the real problem here.

Nobody would feel the need to take children during school time if the cost wasn't so ridiculous.

Bluebellsand · 24/07/2022 02:56

Fines are not guaranteed. Dm friend took her kids out of school because her father was very sick and she could only afford to either miss last few days off school or first few days back. Anyway she only got fined for one child out off three.

Her father did end up dieing, the week after returning back home. The school fine appeared more than six months later, and the most horrible thing about it was the woman ex reaction. If your child gets fined, then a fine will go to both parents. Ps, the ex did know and consented to the dc visiting their overseas grandparents, during term time. He was not happy with the fine arriving so late (he had recently ment and was taking out debt to impress a woman).

So be prepared for a possible very late fine.

changzi · 24/07/2022 02:53

I don't like taking them out during school term. Obviously a week here and there won't make any difference to their education but it's about the principle and valuing their time in school.

It also seems slightly entitled. If everyone took their kids out of school whenever they wanted, it really would be chaotic for teachers. So what makes your case more special than everyone else's?

Having said that, I don't actively judge people who are doing it, like previous posters. Just stating my perspective.

fallfallfall · 24/07/2022 02:42

always. school is important but so is seeing different places learning different skill sets and experiencing different situations. no matter how long.

MerryMarigold · 24/07/2022 02:40

You might get a fine (quite likely if it's 5 whole days) but that may/ may not be worth it. Are your family up for dividing the fine out between them all?

I'd do it if it were something special eg. Special birthday, all family get together which is very rare, opportunity to go away that wouldn't normally have etc etc. If it's just a holiday they do every year and how she's school age it's an issue, v then that issue is not going to go away next year or forevermore so I wouldn't.

Middledazedted · 24/07/2022 02:18

Yes OP I was saying I would do it - if you - I mean, as a teacher I can’t. A week at 5 is no biggie. Am less impressed with hols just before, or in the middle of, GCSEs.

DisneyBaby · 24/07/2022 00:42

I remember when I was young, (I'm 32 now), different classmates used to be off school to go on holiday all the time, and then they'd come back from holiday and would bring in sweets for the rest of the class from wherever they'd been, and would also talk about their holiday in 'show and tell'. It never did any harm back then, and I'm no expert but I doubt school results are much different from now to then based on a few missed weeks for holidays.

Personally I would take my kids out a week for a holiday up to year 4, not year 5 or 6 working towards the 11+, and I would be ok taking my kids out in years 7 and 8 too as they don't begin working towards GCSE's until after that.
If it was me and we were planning a 2 week holiday to Florida or somewhere, I'd probably take one week off school and one week in the holidays overlapping the holidays but not fully in it.

Also re secondary school, i bunked a hell of a lot of classes as do a lot of kids, so if that kind of thing is going on, they may as well be on a family holiday!

Bovrilly · 24/07/2022 00:30

Lots of people saying that it won't have any effect on their child's education so that's fine, but it must be disruptive for the class, presumably the teacher has to stay across who's missed what and try and plug the gaps when they could be doing other things. And if everyone did it that would be x 30. Just go somewhere cheaper in the holidays.

Louise0701 · 24/07/2022 00:15

Go in the school holidays. They get something like 13 weeks off school per year. Theres no justification for going in term time.

RoundaboutRacer · 24/07/2022 00:15

Yes. Have and will again.

Eldest is in Y5.

Has been taken out for numerous theatre/holidays/gatherings since the start of primary.

Not been fined yet.

Exceeding in all subjects on last week's school report.

I'm always honest on the absence form and when handing it in let the office know I realise they can't authorise it but I always like to be honest.

Teachers always wish DC a nice time when they're off somewhere.

Once exams etc are involved then we'll need to stop.

Silverfinch · 24/07/2022 00:14

Highfivemum · 23/07/2022 23:54

Teacher here and it is so disruptive and annoying when children are taken out of school. Yes I get why parents are forced to to afford a holiday etc etc but for me it a nightmare. We teach on a yearly plan and when I child is off and they haven’t covered a topic it then has a knock on affect to the nexts weeks topic. I haven’t the time to go over it again. So an emergency odd day is understood but a week is not good.

Effect = noun
Affect = verb

Swipe left for the next trending thread