Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum thinks I should give more to my sister

36 replies

jumpingbean1810 · 23/07/2022 21:33

I recently changed my role and am fortunate to earn a good salary. My sister works in nhs and i now earn c. 3x more than she does. We are both single parents but I have 1 child, she has 4. Whenever our mum asks what I've been doing, where I'm going on holiday, she makes comments about what a shame it is that my sister can't afford to do the same and how I should remember not everyone is so fortunate. I treat my sister and her children, paying for days out, meals etc and flights for her and her eldest to go to Venice. I always feel guilty after speaking to my mum and feel I should give more to my sister (despite her being v proud and would never accept direct money as I've offered before and she's declined, thus treating when I can). Aibu by not trying to do more?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
billy1966 · 05/12/2022 17:32

GroggyLegs · 23/07/2022 22:01

You & your sister seem to have come to your own arrangement which you are both comfortable with.

Your mum needs to recognise you're both adults & leave this subject alone.

This.

Well done.

Stop discussing stuff with your mother, and call less.

Explain why if she asks.

ThinWomansBrain · 05/12/2022 17:04

next time your Mother asks what you've been doing, say you don't wish to discuss it as she'll only go into a rant about you should be sharing your money with your sister.

If she is that manipulative and disrespectful, go non-contact for a bit - doesn't have to be forever, but a year or a few months may bring a change in her attitude towards you.

FabFitFifties · 05/12/2022 16:58

Zombie thread!

knittingaddict · 05/12/2022 06:52

Your mum is being totally unreasonable. I have two adult daughters and would never expect either of them to subsidise the other. By an accident of birth you are siblings, but also separate individuals who need to make their own way in the world.

I think you do too much as it is, but it's up to you if you want to treat your sister sometimes. It shouldn't be an expectation though.

Mamaneedsadrink · 05/12/2022 05:49

No way. If she wanted to have more disposable income, she could've had less children like yourself. What a strange attitude for your mum to have

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 05/12/2022 05:43

If your mum tries to pay for stuff and your sister refuses this is a way for your mum to feel in control by making you do it as your sister accepts it from you.

Hoplesscynic · 05/12/2022 05:22

EL8888 · 23/07/2022 21:53

Your mum needs to butt out and / or give your sister more money if it bothers her. No one made your sister have 4 children. It’s obvious that financially it will be tougher having 4 children, rather than 1. People have choices, even though they like to pretend they don’t

Spot on

FangsForTheMemory · 05/12/2022 04:59

This thread is from JULY.

TwoTimTams · 05/12/2022 04:26

It’s not your job to financially prop up your sister EVER (or your mother either if she tries that one). You are being very generous already and hopefully gratitude from the recipient won’t turn into entitlement or expectation of ongoing or more financial support.

LinesAndDot · 05/12/2022 03:26

“Yes Mum, I do know not everyone can afford these holidays - that was me before I got the new job and started to work incredibly hard, right? Don’t worry, I am putting away savings and not giving money away frivolously to people as I know something could happen and I could be back in that position again someday. And of course, it is a shame DSis can’t afford it now, but my circumstances changed, let’s encourage her to look for more career potential outside the NHS so she can have this too! Now I really need to go, the bag to Capri won’t pack itself.”

Longlostfamilial · 23/07/2022 22:41

I think your mum is very unreasonable. One of my children earns about 5 times that of the other. One (lower paid) works for the NHS as an allied health professional. The other is in a very well paid corporate position currently working abroad. He is very generous with presents etc, and his sibling recognises that, but none of us would ever expect him to subsidise them. And any money we give is equal. So the lower paid child is engaged, the higher one not, but we will give an equal amount to each for their weddings, and all inheritance will be equal.

StClare101 · 23/07/2022 22:32

It’s very easy to spend other peoples money….

Your mum can sod off.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 23/07/2022 22:18

Just saw your last update. I think in that case, your and your sister need to present a united front and tell your Mum to back off! You're both adults and have made your own life decisions.

hoping2021 · 23/07/2022 22:06

Do not get sucked into your mothers fear, obligation guilt tripping cycle.

jumpingbean1810 · 23/07/2022 22:04

DM is always trying to pay for stuff, drives sis up wall as makes her feel like she's not capable (she is). We both have a tense relationship with her as she's opinionated, v negative and treats us like children. although misguided comes from a place of concern. I have told her to stop comparing us but guess old habits die hard and as DM gets older she is becoming more unfiltered and I'm struggling to keep conversation civil.

OP posts:
GroggyLegs · 23/07/2022 22:01

You & your sister seem to have come to your own arrangement which you are both comfortable with.

Your mum needs to recognise you're both adults & leave this subject alone.

11Hawkins · 23/07/2022 21:57

What is your mum doing to support her/you? Nothing by any chance?

She's taking advantage. You don't have to give them anything if you didn't want too.

Craftybodger · 23/07/2022 21:55

You are not responsible for your sister but it’s lovely to treat her if you can. What does your Mum do to support either of you?

lakeswimmer · 23/07/2022 21:55

I have a lowish paid but rewarding job, three DC and can't easily afford holidays and treats. I would never expect my better off siblings to help me. We've made different life choices but I still have a happy life and I'm grateful for what I've got (which is more than many).

This is nothing to do with your DM and there's no reason to think your DS wants your help.

Sally872 · 23/07/2022 21:54

Maybe your mum is just thinking out loud about how she wishes your sister also had more disposable income rather than thinking it is your place to balance it or fix it for her. I am sure your mum is proud of your achievements and your sister pleased to have her 4 kids even if it does mean less opportunity to work/study and more expensive.

Perhaps she is saying to your sister "its a shame jumpingbean can't do xyz because of working so hard."

WhereYouLeftIt · 23/07/2022 21:53

I'll be blunt - has your sister always been your mum's favourite?

LeavesOnTrees · 23/07/2022 21:53

You can't do anymore if you've offered and she's declined.

She'll know that you're there for her if she is ever in desperate need.
It doesn't sound like it though and it's not really any of your mum's business.

If you wanted to do something more then a savings account for her DC, maybe as an 18th / 21st bday present might work.

EL8888 · 23/07/2022 21:53

Your mum needs to butt out and / or give your sister more money if it bothers her. No one made your sister have 4 children. It’s obvious that financially it will be tougher having 4 children, rather than 1. People have choices, even though they like to pretend they don’t

TabithaTittlemouse · 23/07/2022 21:51

Btw I work for the nhs too and am very aware that to earn more I need to leave and rethink my career.

Testina · 23/07/2022 21:50

So does your mum actually tell you to give your sister money / spend money on her?
Because you just said she tells you not everyone is as fortunate as you. Which you can point out without meaning they should give money - though it’s still bloody patronising!