Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Swimming a life skill (following on from driving thread)

213 replies

girlfriend44 · 23/07/2022 20:56

Alot of people here said that driving was a life skill.

If you drive can you also swim?
Do you consider Swimming to be a life skill too that everyone should learn?

OP posts:
DiscoBadgers · 24/07/2022 18:00

Swimming is infinitely more important than driving - if you don’t drive and need to travel you can get a bus. If you don’t swim and need to get out of water, you drown.

bellac11 · 24/07/2022 17:58

gatehouseoffleet · 24/07/2022 17:03

Not at all, everyone should be able to ride a bike unless they have disabilities which prevent it. It opens up leisure pursuits as well as being a method of transport. I bet Dutch and Danish MNers are laughing at the fact that people in the UK could possibly think that learning to ride a bike isn't crucial.

I am not convinced that being able to swim stops people drowning - usually water is too cold and deep. It is however a very useful thing to be able to do and opens up a world of leisure pursuits.

Oh dear Dutch and Danish people laughing at us, whatever shall we do

Perhaps they've got a modicum of sense to realise that different countries have different infrastructures and so cycling for leisure and transport is not as significant in other countries.

I like to ride a bike but I suffer with vertigo so Im very limited about where I can go certainly no where with other people or traffic.

5foot5 · 24/07/2022 17:57

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 24/07/2022 17:18

What do people mean by not being able to swim? As in at all? No floating, no doggy paddle, no treading water? Can't move in the water? Like if your feet aren't in the ground or you're holding on you'll go under??

I'm not being rude or snarky, but I thought everyone could tread water or doggy paddle to some degree even if they never had a lesson to do so?

You thought wrong. I had swimming lessons in school at various time from 7 or 8 all the way to VI Form but have never been able to really master it.

Just don't seem to be very buoyant.

I think the trouble is that I am not relaxed in the water so as soon as my feet leave the bottom I tense up and sink.

A few times on holiday we have rented somewhere with a pool and I enjoy floating around in the shallow end with an inflatable. I once spent the fortnight trying to get the hang of doggy paddle and by the end of the holidays could cover the 8m or so length of the pool. I thought I might build on that when I got home but the reality of spending time in some ghastly leisure centre pool put a stop to that

I did take DD to swimming lessons from an early age. She was quite young when she sussed that mummy's feet never left the floor when I took her in the children's pool.

However I can drive which is much, much more useful.

bellac11 · 24/07/2022 17:54

I used to believe that everyone could swim or at least float.

Its not true. I have a friend who sinks, he literally just sinks, he has no capacity either mentally or physically to float or move in a way which enables him to swim

On holidays he has had the usual lifeguard types who have said 'I'll be able to teach you to swim mate', and they've all given up!!

Changechangychange · 24/07/2022 17:48

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 24/07/2022 17:18

What do people mean by not being able to swim? As in at all? No floating, no doggy paddle, no treading water? Can't move in the water? Like if your feet aren't in the ground or you're holding on you'll go under??

I'm not being rude or snarky, but I thought everyone could tread water or doggy paddle to some degree even if they never had a lesson to do so?

There are definitely people who can do none of that, and even if they can do it in a swimming pool they may not be able to do it in full clothes in a cold river, in a state of either drunkenness or blind panic.

DM is absolutely terrified of putting her head underwater, so no she definitely wouldn’t be able to do doggy paddle or tread water if she fell off a jetty or something. DS can swim 5m in good circumstances but totally wouldn’t manage in a rough sea (he is 5, and will be wearing a life jacket near the sea for the foreseeable future).

AliceMcK · 24/07/2022 17:47

gatehouseoffleet · 24/07/2022 17:05

Just because you can swim doesn't mean you know how to save someone. The two skills are very different, which is why people do a week's course to become a lifeguard.

All well and good if the actual lifeguard had been doing their job. You saying if someone who is a strong swimmer, has good common sense, knows the dangers of the water and the risks involved, shouldn’t save a child from drowning if they can because they havnt done a weeks life guard training? There were plenty of other people around but only my cousin who went after the child, the life guard didn’t even show up until my cousin was on his way back to the beach.

5foot5 · 24/07/2022 17:47

PuppyMonkey · 23/07/2022 22:42

Now that’s a life skill. Grin

@PuppyMonkey Aarg! Wrong thread obviously. It was meant for a thread about life tips.

My mums net has a habit of going "Aw snap" just when I have typed in a long message so I tend to type my message in Notepad then copy and paste to mumsnet. Except this time I pasted to wrong thread. Blame the wine.

AnnaMagnani · 24/07/2022 17:42

It's perfectly possible to live in Denmark or the Netherlands and not cycle as they have excellent public transport.

Plus the number of people who can't learn to ride a bike is surprisingly large - even those of us with Danish parents. Dyspraxia, autism, hypermobility are real things and not necessarily diagnosed.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 24/07/2022 17:18

What do people mean by not being able to swim? As in at all? No floating, no doggy paddle, no treading water? Can't move in the water? Like if your feet aren't in the ground or you're holding on you'll go under??

I'm not being rude or snarky, but I thought everyone could tread water or doggy paddle to some degree even if they never had a lesson to do so?

gatehouseoffleet · 24/07/2022 17:12

Anyway I think if you are prioritising activities for your children based on cost or time or whatever, I'd put swimming and learning to ride a bike at the top.

Everything else is a bonus.

If you fall into a canal Weils disease is probably a bigger danger than drowning (the one near us is actually very shallow - especially at the moment with there having been so little rain).

gatehouseoffleet · 24/07/2022 17:05

AliceMcK · 24/07/2022 15:33

Yes absolutely. My cousin saved a little girl from drowning a couple of weeks ago. The girls dad was stood on the beach not knowing what to do because he couldn’t swim. It is 100% a life saving skill.

Just because you can swim doesn't mean you know how to save someone. The two skills are very different, which is why people do a week's course to become a lifeguard.

gatehouseoffleet · 24/07/2022 17:03

AnnaMagnani · 24/07/2022 11:13

When did cycling get added to the list of life skills?

That's a total stretch.

Not at all, everyone should be able to ride a bike unless they have disabilities which prevent it. It opens up leisure pursuits as well as being a method of transport. I bet Dutch and Danish MNers are laughing at the fact that people in the UK could possibly think that learning to ride a bike isn't crucial.

I am not convinced that being able to swim stops people drowning - usually water is too cold and deep. It is however a very useful thing to be able to do and opens up a world of leisure pursuits.

SpilltheTea · 24/07/2022 16:57

It's far more important than driving. I don't think you can compare them.

oobeedoobee · 24/07/2022 16:56

To me, BASIC parenting means your child learns

  1. Manners
  2. Social skills
  3. Reading/writing
  4. Swimming
  5. Riding a bike
  6. Driving
  7. Budgeting/ money management
  8. Cleaning/laundry etc
  9. Cooking
  10. Taking responsibility for your own actions/omissions.
Of course, you'll be teaching more in depth with things like problem solving, friendship issues, family issues, bullying/school conflicts etc etc, but, for me, these are the bare essential 'responsibilities' of being a parent.
CarlCarlson · 24/07/2022 16:25

Both driving and swimming are life skills

It was always strange people who couldn’t do one or both of those things in my experience

brighterthanaluckypenny · 24/07/2022 16:22

glamourousindierockandroll · 24/07/2022 15:03

Both are definitely life skills as you never know when you might need them.

There are always people saying that they live in a major city and therefore don't need to drive, but I always think it's a bit short sighted; and some of them must end up living elsewhere. There are only a handful if cities in the UK where public transport is excellent. I live in a small city myself and we only have a pretty basic bus service.

No one is ever going to push me into a car and shout 'drive.'

Someone might push me into the Thames though, so I know how to swim whilst weighed down by wet clothes.

lucifur · 24/07/2022 16:22

Swimming is a life skill. Every year a teen who isn't a competent swimmer ends up drowning trying to cool off with mates. It absolutely is a risk to not be able to swim. Also what a huge joy to miss out on? Not everyone will enjoy it but most certainly do. You would miss out on so many opportunities. I'd also be terrified to be near water with my kids if I felt like I couldn't get them out if they fell in. Yes, there will be many people who manage to live without swimming but it seems like such a shame to miss out on so much. My mother couldn't swim and it really limited what we could do in the summer.

The same goes for driving. It just narrows your life choices. Why narrow those the choices of where you can live and work?

Plenty of people will be along to say how they've lived to a ripe old age without being able to do either but there's no disputing that it's life limiting.

Kite22 · 24/07/2022 16:02

I don't think it needs to be a competition.
Neither is more or less of a "life skill".

Both are great things to learn and will enhance the opportunities you have, if you acquire them as skills. Obviously there will always be people who can't do one, or the other, or who can't do either, who - in their circumstances - will tell you they are fine.

liveforsummer · 24/07/2022 16:01

Sorry, but taking your child sailing when she can't swim is foolhardy, risky, and irresponsible. Why would you do that? Also, why can she not swim?! Are you going to claim she has tried, but can't? Because I will find that very hard to believe.

Tbf I had an ex boyfriend who was (and still is 25 years later) in the Navy. Has spent most of his adult life at sea and cannot swim so it's definitely not a complete necessity for sailing!

AliceMcK · 24/07/2022 15:33

Yes absolutely. My cousin saved a little girl from drowning a couple of weeks ago. The girls dad was stood on the beach not knowing what to do because he couldn’t swim. It is 100% a life saving skill.

LoveAfternoonTea · 24/07/2022 15:28

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 23/07/2022 23:09

Sorry, but taking your child sailing when she can't swim is foolhardy, risky, and irresponsible. Why would you do that? Shock Also, why can she not swim?! Are you going to claim she has tried, but can't? Because I will find that very hard to believe.

Do you really have such a lack of imagination? My daughter has a muscle wasting condition. She will never be strong enough to swim, no matter how hard she tries. You do know that disabled people enjoy outdoor pursuits though? And many have precious few options where they can participate fully and even compete with their able bodied friends. Sailing is a wonderful sport for inclusivity and can be safely enjoyed by non- swimmers.

3luckystars · 24/07/2022 15:26

‘Both are definitely life skills as you never know when you might need them.’

well that might be true for some but not for me. I never ever ‘need’ to swim. I don’t go near water.

I drive every day though.

so I think it depends on your life, what is a life skill and what is not. Swimming is not a life skill for me.

Mommabear20 · 24/07/2022 15:23

I do both and absolutely think both are a life skill. If pushed, I'd give swimming the number 1 spot though as that could genuinely save your life and others more often than driving.

glamourousindierockandroll · 24/07/2022 15:03

Both are definitely life skills as you never know when you might need them.

There are always people saying that they live in a major city and therefore don't need to drive, but I always think it's a bit short sighted; and some of them must end up living elsewhere. There are only a handful if cities in the UK where public transport is excellent. I live in a small city myself and we only have a pretty basic bus service.

stayathomer · 24/07/2022 15:00

We couldn’t afford to give the kids swimming lessons and the guilt really gets to me especially when I see people who live on the coast whose children are like fish. Our kids only get lessons in school and everyone says it doesn’t do much of you don’t swim regularly. We live in the midlands and there’s only the public swimming pool that is too far away and anyway always booked up and some lakes. The guilt really gets to me