Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can i have a rant about my Ukrainian guest

658 replies

fakenamefornow · 23/07/2022 19:50

Context, normal family home with teenage school children. Taken in mum and six year old, they're living in our spare bedroom (with ensuite) and living as part of the family. We didn't know them previously and they came directly from Ukraine to us. They're both lovely and generally easy to live with, been with us one month, no regrets. Just need a little anonymous rant to let off steam though.

Ukraine seems better than the UK in every way.

The food. She's a very good cook and makes lovely Ukrainian dinners for us. But British food is terrible, Ukrainian people would never eat so much processed food (she might have a point). They have processed food in Ukraine but only foreigners eat it. Ukrainians always cook fresh.

The health care. She's had three medical emergencies with her child since being here. First one, child had temperature of 38, (bouncing around playing looking in perfect health to me.) She was astonished that a doctor wouldn't immediately come to house to see child. Arranged GP appointment that afternoon (she doesn't drive, I had to take her) . Upset, angry and confused that antibiotics weren't given. She really just couldn't understand it at all. I Ukraine a doctor would have come to the house, day or night, and given medication, you treat small things immediately so they don't get big. Child had three days off school and spent the whole time running around playing.

Child had tiny abscess on gum, no pain or any other symptoms. This necessitated an immediate trip to the out of hours minor injuries unit (still appalled doctor wouldn't come to house). No treatment, told to ring 111 in the morning. I live in an NHS dentistry desert but because they've come from Ukraine a local dentist has taken them on as NHS patients. Had emergency dental appointment next day. Dentist said leave it alone, come back in two months time or if problem develops with it. Mum wanted minor surgery to remove/empty it and antibiotics. More anger and confusion. She can't believe how bad medical care is here (again, she might have a point). Anyway, more time off school for this.

Her appointment for biometrics was messed up (their fault not her's) and she missed the card delivery. So bureaucracy and postal service doesn't work here. She's applied for universal credit, no money yet though, and it seems ridiculous that she should go to the office every week. Nothing works well in this country. Even the streets are difficult to walk on because the pavement is uneven.

I know many Ukrainian have lost good lives to take children to safety and life probably was much better in Ukraine than it will ever be in UK. Hopefully this is temporary and they will be able to return. Her life in Ukraine, was living in a nice flat that was her mother's (mother dead, now hers) with her brother and her kid. She's divorced, kids dad not around, no contact for years. Worked as office manager (small company, not high flying) with good salary.

Really, she's lovely and very grateful.
I just need a little rant about a few things.

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 25/07/2022 15:50

my dad is French and he detests British food despite living here most of his life. It’s beige and bland, they call us roast beef

Yes some French people can be bigoted idiots, you get them everywhere unfortunately.
I certainly don’t eat beige bland food, and I wasn’t brought up on it either.

Sartre · 25/07/2022 15:34

It’s easier to become a doctor in lots of Eastern European countries than it is here. DH went to school with someone who didn’t get straight A’s in her A levels so wasn’t allowed to join medical school here as a result, she went to Prague and became a doctor there instead. So that’s part of the reason we have a shortage, they should perhaps consider lowering the criteria slightly…

Our pavements are uneven and our roads are potholed, she isn’t wrong. Our ‘cuisine’ is mocked worldwide, my Dad is French and he detests British food despite living here most of his life. It’s beige and bland, they call us roast beef.

SpaceGoatFarm · 25/07/2022 15:21

It means they are extremely soviet, to put it diplomatically.

Can i have a rant about my Ukrainian guest
Can i have a rant about my Ukrainian guest
User952539 · 25/07/2022 14:24

Just repeating what I’ve been told.

forinborin · 25/07/2022 14:20

As an aside, I think the antibiotic prescribing is terrible and also a doctor doing a home visit to a child running around playing with a temperature of 38c is ridiculous.
Honestly, it is not that bad with the antibiotic prescription. There's indeed a school of medical thought (not specific to Ukraine) that recommends antibiotics at the early stages of bacterial sore throats. And yes, you absolutely test to confirm it is bacterial, not viral. And yes, many of those cases will be self resolving through "natural immunity", but many, if not treated early on, will result in longer term rheumatic conditions. Considered to be an acceptable human cost in some medical cultures, and unacceptable in others.

These practices do not contribute to the antibiotic resistance to a major extent, as the pathogen is exterminated and that's the end of the story. Look at agriculture and healthcare facilities first.

forinborin · 25/07/2022 14:03

User952539 · 25/07/2022 12:35

The BMA thing was both a “safety” thing but also a protectionist move by doctors. Medical training in Ukraine is very different. As posted upthread, many who say they have studied medicine at university are actually not what we would call doctors in the UK, they’ve just studied some healthcare related subject and could be the equivalent of a HCA. If you look on the boards of people searching for hosts in the UK you will see an enormous number of “doctors” and “lawyers” but they’re not all qualified doctors or lawyers as we would regard it here. But of those who are actually doctors it isn’t regarded as an elite academic profession like it is here. It isn’t difficult to get into medical university and it’s state funded and controlled and allocated (and low paid). This is all according to my guest. She said the choices when you finish school at 16 are medical, economic (which seems to mean accounts), legal (which seems to mean general business) or one other which I forget (probably science/engineering based). You then go to an appropriate college/university to study on that pathway.

This is nonsense. Nursing / HCA in Ukraine pretty much an equivalent of a high school leaving qualification, only instead of going to an academic school one goes to a vocational college. No degree is required for nursing.

Universities are mostly of the classical type and offer your typical range of everything - humanities, history, linguistics and modern languages, jurisprudence and STEM included, so not sure where your guest gets her "pathways" split from. Medical schools are standalone universities, specialising only in medicine, and they do make real doctors. It is true though that even human medicine is not an elite profession, and, say, vet medicine is considered a very redneck / low intelligence occupation, in contrast with the UK.

User952539 · 25/07/2022 12:35

The BMA thing was both a “safety” thing but also a protectionist move by doctors. Medical training in Ukraine is very different. As posted upthread, many who say they have studied medicine at university are actually not what we would call doctors in the UK, they’ve just studied some healthcare related subject and could be the equivalent of a HCA. If you look on the boards of people searching for hosts in the UK you will see an enormous number of “doctors” and “lawyers” but they’re not all qualified doctors or lawyers as we would regard it here. But of those who are actually doctors it isn’t regarded as an elite academic profession like it is here. It isn’t difficult to get into medical university and it’s state funded and controlled and allocated (and low paid). This is all according to my guest. She said the choices when you finish school at 16 are medical, economic (which seems to mean accounts), legal (which seems to mean general business) or one other which I forget (probably science/engineering based). You then go to an appropriate college/university to study on that pathway.

fakenamefornow · 25/07/2022 12:32

My experience of their hospitals- they are like something from dr zhivago

Never read it, what does it mean?

OP posts:
fakenamefornow · 25/07/2022 12:17

The Ukrainian child we have is very well behaved. They are up very late at night though and do things like eat food around the house that I would never have let my children do.

The BMA voted to restrict the number of medical training places.

Anyone know why this was and also why they get a veto?

OP posts:
Flittingaboutagain · 25/07/2022 11:37

The biggest issue for me is the difference in parenting - they generally ignore the kids and let them roam all 3 floors of the house and the garden whenever, which means we end up doing a lot of extra parenting (sorting out squabbles, getting drinks, cuddles for bumped knees etc.). They also don't have a proper bedtime routine, the kids (3 and 6) are awake and running about till past 10pm every night.

^ yes we are struggling with this. We had a conversation this weekend and they said in their family/culture (not sure if they meant most Ukrainian families) whomever is present does the parenting. So if someone's child is annoying you or misbehaving you can tell them yourself. I explained this isn't what we do here and that it's the parent's responsibility to stop the snatching, pushing over, writing on the walls etc. Although I have started stepping in now when I see something unacceptable.

gnilliwdog · 25/07/2022 11:12

SpaceGoatFarm · 25/07/2022 11:03

Cant remember if I mentioned it before but un a lot of places in eastern europe, including ukraine you can just buy anti biotics without prescription. My experience of their hospitals- they are like something from dr zhivago. I'm helping ukrainian refugees myself, but if you are utterly obnoxious and rude about a place which is shelling out millions and helping you, the you are just obnoxious and rude. I've never heard stuff like this about afghan and Syrian refugees, more of whom we should be helping. They also rarely have the option to pop home for a bit without being tortured, executed, forced in to the army or prison.

We had a Syrian family at our school. Children so appreciative of teachers, the parents desperate to work and contribute, though not allowed to. The parents cooking and hosting a friendship group with locals so we could experience their food and culture. Their town had been destroyed, family still in danger in the country. They were the bravest, kindest people I have met.

SpaceGoatFarm · 25/07/2022 11:07

It's also cheeky as fuck to be demanding we put in a no fly zone, send our NATO armies or other things which will trigger nuclear war when in the months leading up to the invasion the Ukrainian government was warned and warned by the west but basically met that with mockery.

Dont be rude to those sheltering you or helping you is a pretty universal idea, I dont care how blunt a culture is.

This wint stop me sending mkney to ukraine, matching people with sponsors etc. But there needs to be a big attitude change.

SpaceGoatFarm · 25/07/2022 11:03

Cant remember if I mentioned it before but un a lot of places in eastern europe, including ukraine you can just buy anti biotics without prescription. My experience of their hospitals- they are like something from dr zhivago. I'm helping ukrainian refugees myself, but if you are utterly obnoxious and rude about a place which is shelling out millions and helping you, the you are just obnoxious and rude. I've never heard stuff like this about afghan and Syrian refugees, more of whom we should be helping. They also rarely have the option to pop home for a bit without being tortured, executed, forced in to the army or prison.

DenholmElliot1 · 25/07/2022 10:56

Doctors train doctors, not “teachers”. If the doctors are training the baby doctors they can’t do as much doctoring. I

How come Ukraine manages then?

KvotheTheBloodless · 25/07/2022 10:51

I know how frustrating it is, I have a family of 4 Ukrainians living with me, I'm really happy they're here but of course there are culture clashes/niggles from sharing space with another family. The biggest issue for me is the difference in parenting - they generally ignore the kids and let them roam all 3 floors of the house and the garden whenever, which means we end up doing a lot of extra parenting (sorting out squabbles, getting drinks, cuddles for bumped knees etc.). They also don't have a proper bedtime routine, the kids (3 and 6) are awake and running about till past 10pm every night. They don't see a problem leaving kids home alone or smacking/beating them when they're naughty. We've put a stop to the latter two, in our home at least.

They in turn are horrified by how coddled English children are, and how dependent on their parents, and probably a whole host of things they're too polite to say.

It's swings and roundabouts.

They've been through some awful things, and they'd much rather be home in Mariupol (if it weren't for the bastard Russians). They're lovely folk, and niggles aside we like them very much.

User952539 · 25/07/2022 10:49

Doctors train doctors, not “teachers”. If the doctors are training the baby doctors they can’t do as much doctoring. It becomes a resource and a safety thing. The BMA voted to restrict the number of medical training places.

fakenamefornow · 25/07/2022 10:43

I'm guessing that medical training is a money making thing in Ukraine?

The fact we don't have the teachers to train doctors doesn't answer the question, it's just another 'why not?'

OP posts:
DenholmElliot1 · 25/07/2022 10:33

Presumably because we don't have the amount of back-up support/teaching staff to carry out the training.

Which begs the question, how come OUR trainee medical students don't go to Ukraine like the Africans and Asians do (not in wartime obviously).

fakenamefornow · 25/07/2022 10:26

I believe they train a lot of doctors in Ukraine (using English) I think that what all the students from Africa and Asia were doing. If they can train so many doctors I don't see why it's so impossible for us to do so. Perhaps somebody in the know can explain? I heard on the radio this morning we are short of 12,000 doctors and 50,000 nurses, wtf! Tory PM candidates are calling it a crisis while taking absolutely zero responsibility for creating the crisis in the first place.

As an aside, I think the antibiotic prescribing is terrible and also a doctor doing a home visit to a child running around playing with a temperature of 38c is ridiculous.

I do feel very embarrassed by my country sometimes, we have absolutely run our public services into the ground. We are a democracy though and this is entirely our own choice, I just don't understand why we would make that choice? There's often the cry of 'WE CAN'T AFFORD IT!' But Ukraine, a much poorer country (although I'm sure she's painting a rose coloured picture) can afford it. IMO, public services are things we can't afford not to fund. What's the point of organising ourselves into a society if not to pool resources or everyone's benefit?

With regard home heating in the UK, I'm dreading the winter. She says she has her house at 27c in the winter. Lovely for the people inside, but very expensive and most importantly not great for the environment. I do try to be environmentally conscious but this seems to have completely passed her by.

Anyway, anyone know why we can't train the number of doctors Ukraine can?

OP posts:
forinborin · 24/07/2022 20:37

Forgot to mention free or nearly-free universal childcare. Many women new to the UK just cannot believe how much it costs here.

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/07/2022 20:37

Antigonads · 24/07/2022 19:46

Interested to know what daily comforts Ukraine had over the UK?

A doctor who does house visits to a sick child rather than the non functional NHS out of hours service?

Possibly also things like more affordable housing, better quality housing, better quality food, subsidised public transport? A society less geared towards car driving?

forinborin · 24/07/2022 20:35

Antigonads · 24/07/2022 19:46

Interested to know what daily comforts Ukraine had over the UK?

Most were mentioned elsewhere on the thread. Warm and dry housing (despite not always aesthetically pleasing), great food (even supermarkets have tiny field-to-fork distances, and will sell fully ripe produce in season), very affordable or free extracurricular education for children (and quite affordable private schooling too), there are indeed free home visits by GPs for minor ailments which is quite convenient (prescriptions are not free though), great dentistry, again, with cosmetic treatment being affordable on "average" salaries. Beauty industry is very high quality and low price, I am on the mn- famous six-digits in the UK and cannot afford self care routines that my peers in Ukraine can on very mid-range salaries - I don't mean just purely superficial stuff, but things like regular spas, massages, detox and fitness.

I planned returning back in 2021, now that my job (and income) is mostly remote. Won't now due to the war, obviously.

blubberball · 24/07/2022 20:32

She is right though. Services are poor here, and the pavements are uneven. We need to sort it out really

RockandRollsuicide · 24/07/2022 20:23

@Pooet

I also agree

It is and we need reform.

C0mfyChairP0se · 24/07/2022 19:54

In my work I have been meeting a lot of Ukrainians and to my surprise, at least three of them that I've been dealing with have chosen to return home in the last few weeks. Although, sensibly, seeking confirmation that their temporary protected status is still valid if they leave and return. It will be. I am not in the uK, I'm in irleland. When one woman told me she was going back, I asked if there was any level of normality there, buses running?, supermarkets stocked? and she said yes. I think that the amount of Russian soldiers sent in to fight is dwindling and some are deciding it's ''safe'' to go back. I really hope they don't regret it.