Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving to Basingstoke vs Newbury

145 replies

lunepremiere79 · 23/07/2022 14:16

Not a AIBU, posting here for traffic.. I've seen a number of now older threads but wondering if anyone can give an honest opinion on moving to/living in Basingstoke. We are looking to move out from a London suburb and looking for a nice area with things to do (pubs, shops, some buzzy atmosphere) and also for our dd3 to grow up in a family friendly place with good schools and plenty of activities. We have visited and loved Newbury - it's going to be a bit of a trek to commute to London though (we both currently have to do it about 1-2 times a week), so Basingstoke came up as an option, as commuting to Canary Wharf would be the same as our current commute from North London. I keep reading that it's a mixed bag of areas and it seems to be a bit of a marmite place but that things are changing for the better and it's a much nicer place to live now? Is this true?

OP posts:
Sapphirejane · 23/07/2022 19:35

I consider Basingstoke to be one big suburb, just lots of roundabouts and housing developments doesn’t feel like it has much of a soul. I can’t believe it has high crime? That PP poster must have been unlucky. With your budget I would look at Caversham, depending where, you can walk/bus to Reading Station which is 25 mins into Paddington. Train prices are very expensive though. Have you considered going into Kent? Will be easier for Canary Wharf.

sixtiesbaby88 · 23/07/2022 19:29

Caversham? We walk to the station and it's 22 minutes to Paddington

lunepremiere79 · 23/07/2022 19:27

Tiani4 · 23/07/2022 18:54

I mean you can get large detached 4 beds with garages for £450k easily upwards in Andover and fairly central ones for £600-700k!

Look at this gorgeous house with character inside too - £695k and pretty central 0.9 miles from train station 1 hour 9 mins to London Waterloo

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/125023877#/?channel=RES_BUY

This looks lovely, but if you do directions to Canary Wharf it's 1h 46mins one way, compared with Newbury at 1h 10mins..

OP posts:
lunepremiere79 · 23/07/2022 19:19

Lonecatwithkitten · 23/07/2022 17:21

My DH I met me a Newbury dweller and him Basingstoke.
Basingstoke no longer has ab ice rink - closed, no longer has the aquadome - closed. There is a shopping centre opened in the noughties that is reasonable and lots of supermarkets.
We choose Newbury and once the Elizabeth Line runs from Reading Canary Wharf will be very easy,
We live in what feels like the middle of nowhere 5 mins from a Sainsburys and 11 mins from Newbury Station.
The other day I did Newbury Station to Tottenham Court Road in 51 mins via Elizabeth Line.
Newbury has good schools, market town feel with lots of culture and artisan stuff going on.
Newbury every time for me.

That's interesting - I am trying to estimate the timings for commuting from Newbury and there seems to be a direct train to Paddington and then it's 30 mins to Canary wharf on the Elizabeth line. This is the best I can find, but it seems maybe there is a faster route?

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 23/07/2022 18:59

I would go to Guildford or Godalming or the guildford side of Woking (horsell) for that money . You will get a nice 4 bedder and a lovely town with tons to do , great leisure centre etc. newbury is nice enough and I don't deny you will get a cheaper house but I think for older children Guildford is better . My other suggestion would be oxford. We lived there for a bit .

Tiani4 · 23/07/2022 18:56

This one for £575k 0.4 miles from train station and is very central in Andover

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/96545551#/?channel=RES_BUY

Tiani4 · 23/07/2022 18:54

I mean you can get large detached 4 beds with garages for £450k easily upwards in Andover and fairly central ones for £600-700k!

Look at this gorgeous house with character inside too - £695k and pretty central 0.9 miles from train station 1 hour 9 mins to London Waterloo

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/125023877#/?channel=RES_BUY

Tiani4 · 23/07/2022 18:47

Yo be honest for £800k you can live far closer to London in a lovely 4 bed house and have a shorter train commute than Basingstoke or Newbury!!

Tiani4 · 23/07/2022 18:46

What about Andover? Lovely large town just a couple stops from Basingstoke on railway line to Waterloo. Great services and family friendly too.

You'll easily buy a nice 4 bed in Winchester for that and also a huge one for that in Andover .

Just a thought.

UnicornMadeOfPinkGlitter · 23/07/2022 18:45

For £800k look at Wokingham or Woodley. Both have good train routes and are commuter towns. Direct access to the m4 as well.
my husband commutes into London every day but his location varies as he’s network engineering.
from Woodley you can get a train that takes 4 minutes into reading for the fast train to Paddington or earley winnersh Wokingham are on the Waterloo line. That’s a longer train journey at about an hour and 20 ish to Waterloo.
schools in the Wokingham Borough are generally very good. We moved out of Reading Borough to Wokingham for schools and have been very happy with the decision.

lunepremiere79 · 23/07/2022 18:42

1Wanda1 · 23/07/2022 14:39

Have you ever been to Basingstoke? If not, go there. It has good fast train link to London (much better than Winchester as it's further up the line and several trains go direct to London). But the town centre is grim. Soulless shopping centre. There is a big leisure centre on the ring road. Not much else to distinguish the place. Some of the villages outside Basingstoke are nice, but then you've got a longer drive to the station.

I grew up near Basingstoke and wouldn't choose to live there.

We would love a good fast link into Central London, but trying to avoid moving from one soulless place (where we currently live in the suburbs of London) to another. We want to live somewhere 'nice' for better quality of life and where our DD can have a happy childhood

OP posts:
lunepremiere79 · 23/07/2022 18:39

AnnaMagnani · 23/07/2022 17:44

I'd pick Newbury any day - travel is going to be transformed by the Elizabeth Line as well, it's part way there already.

I'm biased as I grew up there but it's even better now with the influx of the Vodafone money. Basingstoke - just no.

I am not certain how much time the Reading-Canary Wharf connection would save on the Elizabeth line. It says that it would take 75 mins from Reading to Liverpool st, but there is already a fast train that goes between Newbury and Paddington, which takes 45 mins and then it's 30 mins to Paddington across London to CW, so actually it seems that the Elizabeth line is not actually going to change much, since I'd still have to change at Reading? www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2022-uk-elizabeth-tube-line-opening/

OP posts:
lunepremiere79 · 23/07/2022 18:35

Entwifery · 23/07/2022 18:31

You could look at Thatcham as well which is right next to Newbury.

We did look at Thatcham, but weren't really sure about the area tbh We want to be closer to the center of Newbury, so we don't have to drive all the time

OP posts:
lunepremiere79 · 23/07/2022 18:33

BrioNotBiro · 23/07/2022 14:35

I personally think it's a bit of a 'none' place and a lot of shops etc have shut down and not reopened after Covid which has made it worse. Newbury is more interesting/historic.

Have you considered Winchester? Lovely place, good schools and entertainment etc and good connections to London trains/motorway. Expensive though.

We loved everything about Newbury when we went - so much history and character. Loved all the cute shops and the farmer's market and the canal. Just a great all-rounder of a town, plus the great schools etc.

Winchester is a bit too far south, as we need to be close to M4 for visiting family who all live in the west

OP posts:
Entwifery · 23/07/2022 18:31

You could look at Thatcham as well which is right next to Newbury.

Entwifery · 23/07/2022 18:30

I lived in Newbury for a few years before moving up north and it's a nice little town, but of course it's expensive but that's to be expected. It has everything you'd need, nice high street, and there's easy access to Reading and London. Can't speak to Basingstoke though.

lunepremiere79 · 23/07/2022 18:26

Thanks for all the comments and suggestions - we'll take a look! Personally I don't mind a smaller villagey place, but DH is set on a bigger town (hence Newbury). In terms of budget we can probably stretch to 800k, but for that it would be good to have a detached house with at least 4 bedrooms, a couple of baths and a nice big garden. Not keen on new builds. We've seen this around Newbury but not around Basingstoke. We are also looking for easy access to M4 so we can be close to the family in the west, so Kent/Essex is the wrong direction.

OP posts:
Davros · 23/07/2022 17:48

I like Newbury but I've never lived there, just visited a lot

AnnaMagnani · 23/07/2022 17:44

I'd pick Newbury any day - travel is going to be transformed by the Elizabeth Line as well, it's part way there already.

I'm biased as I grew up there but it's even better now with the influx of the Vodafone money. Basingstoke - just no.

megletthesecond · 23/07/2022 17:31

The ice rink isn't closed. It's on dodgy ground and needs a massive refurbishment, but it's not shut. The flumes are shut at the aquadrome but the pools are open.
Basingstoke is a bit rubbish tbh. No decent shops and nothing "nice". It's well located though.
Secondary schools seem to finally be improving.

ANewNameANewDay · 23/07/2022 17:29

Basingstoke is really, really shit IMO. Newbury a bit better but if you're looking for a commuter option this way I'd go for Alton.

Bigger budgets you could look at Salisbury or Winchester, beautiful cities with heaps of buzz and history albeit you pay a premium for the privilege.

Andover is near both B'Stoke and N'Bury, on a commuter line and probably your cheapest option but it's the absolute worst place I've lived in.

Lonecatwithkitten · 23/07/2022 17:21

My DH I met me a Newbury dweller and him Basingstoke.
Basingstoke no longer has ab ice rink - closed, no longer has the aquadome - closed. There is a shopping centre opened in the noughties that is reasonable and lots of supermarkets.
We choose Newbury and once the Elizabeth Line runs from Reading Canary Wharf will be very easy,
We live in what feels like the middle of nowhere 5 mins from a Sainsburys and 11 mins from Newbury Station.
The other day I did Newbury Station to Tottenham Court Road in 51 mins via Elizabeth Line.
Newbury has good schools, market town feel with lots of culture and artisan stuff going on.
Newbury every time for me.

Quarique · 23/07/2022 17:02

Basingstoke has an excellent teen Athletics Club at Down Grange.

Bluevelvetsofa · 23/07/2022 17:02

Fleet is mega expensive now.

Ionacat · 23/07/2022 16:48

I’d go Newbury over Basingstoke. Basingstoke schools are a bit patchy. I also agree with looking at Alton or Fleet or perhaps Thatcham if you like idea of Newbury - it’s that bit closer to Reading.