Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be realy put out by this from a friend?

207 replies

50mg · 23/07/2022 12:50

We've had a trip planned for months. It's to go to a specific event, I.e. there won't be another opportunity.

Friend has just messaged to say adult son is planning a birthday party for his wife that evening, so friend can't come. Apparently friend has only just been told. Event is in 2 weeks.

I know family is important, upsetting DIL can be a bit of a minefield (although they don't seem to have that issue here) but AIBU to think that if someone invites you to a party with 2 weeks notice, they'll have to accept you might have plans. Or are parents, even of adult children, not allowed to have plans?

Would you have cancelled for DIL's birthday? Should I be all understanding or is it reasonable to let them know I'm not entirely happy with the decision?

FWIW it's quite a niche activity, there's not someone else who would want to come with me.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 23/07/2022 15:46

KosherDill · 23/07/2022 14:53

Exactly. A death in the family, not a young adult birthday.

Absolutely this.

It's not entitlement to have the basic manners not to back out of an arrangement because something else comes up.🙄

Good gracious I taught this to my 5 year old children when things they preferred came up after committing to something else, and they were able to grasp it.

A DIL's party makes no difference.

I would be unimpressed, even more so if I had declined other invitations.

OP, perfectly reasonable for you to not make firm arrangements ahead of time with her again.

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:46

Really not sure what the OP has to gain by doing anything other than replying ‘oh no, you’ll be missed! But have an absolutely lovely time at DIL’s 30th. See you soon x’

Just because it is disappointing does not mean it is a good idea to pass on bad vibes. It will weaken the OP’s friendship and upset the friend and will not make it less not more likely that they have a nice evening out together.

MargotChateau · 23/07/2022 15:44

I’m quite surprised at the other posters responses.

You don’t just can out on friends for a better offer or for a late invitation. It’s doubly rude and thoughtless of your friend given that you have recently had a personal tragedy and are trying to keep occupied with friends.

If she felt pressured into going from obligation the polite thing to do would have been to ask if you minded and offered to make it up to at a later date. I hope you are able to go solo to your planned event. Even if it’s a niche thing, I’d ask some one to come, I’d accompany a friend to that if I felt they needed the company if I was free, I just generally enjoy my friends company and don’t mind what we get up to while I spend time with them.

Sorry your friend is so thoughtless.

autienotnaughty · 23/07/2022 15:44

Yes I'd be annoyed and would probably say "I'm disappointed especially given we have had this booked for ages and it's only two week away."

Hobele · 23/07/2022 15:43

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:17

I am sorry to hear you have had a personal tragedy. Your friend hasn’t cost you a ticket.

If you had two other things to do that weekend, why not pick up those offers?

Because OP has already committed to other things. Which then her 'friend' cancelled. I'd be furious and would be the end of a friendship for me.

Hiddenvoice · 23/07/2022 15:43

I’d be disappointed to in your position but maybe her son has arranged a proper party for that night and is going on the night that suits him and his wife. I arranged my 30th birthday for a night that suited me, I sadly couldn’t please everyone else’s social arrangements. If they couldn’t make it then that’s fair enough but she sounds like she doesn’t want to create any friction with her son and dil which is fair enough!
is there anyone else you can go with to still enjoy your night?
Im sorry it’s happened but unless you want to throw away your friendship, I’d just reply with sorry to hear that, rotten you’ll miss out and then I’d leave it like that.

ConfusedElephant · 23/07/2022 15:40

OP my ex friend begged me to go to Glastonbury - I got the tickets, sorted train fare so we're travelling from her city and not mine, train tickets were to be collected from the train station.

1 hour before I was to leave my city for her city via coach - she messaged to say she couldn't go!!!

She left me no time at all to get someone else.
I couldn't go on my own as I missed the coach reading her message and in shock and couldn't catch the train - I would've gone on my own and waited for someone to meet me down there, whatever
But this b*tch friend didn't give me any options.
I don't know why she did it - she got a better offer but what was better than Glastonbury last minute? Must've been a man! (That's not worth missing anything for)

ddl1 · 23/07/2022 15:40

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:35

I’d be annoyed. I wouldn’t fall out with her about it, but I wouldn’t pretend that it was fine either.

Why not? Why not just let it go and let her feel good about the party (or at least not bad)? What is it going to achieve?

Because this was arranged MONTHS in advance, and it's not really on to suddenly cancel it for a party. I wouldn't make a fuss -what's the point of doing so?- but it isn't great behaviour.

JustJeans · 23/07/2022 15:38

My mum would do this.
I preface every invite with "do you have any plans on X date" and she always answers 'no'.
I'll arrange the activity, checking a few times whether she's sure she's free, only to find out later that she did have plans and has let someone down.
It's so frustrating because I could usually have rearranged in some way. When I pull her up on it, she will only say that 'family comes first' or some other rubbish.
I don't know what she tells the people she lets down.

Arenanewbie · 23/07/2022 15:38

I think @JustLyra got it right : either her DS forgot to tell her or to organise it and now she sees as her priority to rescue him. She might be a bit of martyr or maybe things are not good between her and DIL or DS and DIL. I think the fact that it’s a free event makes it more difficult to accept it as an important one for her family. She didn't apologised because she saw the commitments and priorities differently then you. She probably even thought that you would understand being her friend.

It’s not right to cancel plans with you but I wouldn’t hold it against her much.

Easilystartled · 23/07/2022 15:36

I’m dying to know what the free niche event is!! Maybe someone on here would want to go too op if you share…..

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:35

I’d be annoyed. I wouldn’t fall out with her about it, but I wouldn’t pretend that it was fine either.

Why not? Why not just let it go and let her feel good about the party (or at least not bad)? What is it going to achieve?

HyggeandTea · 23/07/2022 15:31

Your friend does not want to go to the event with you.
That's a shame, and she will be aware she has let you down and may, or may not, want to make it up to you.
Of course you feel annoyed; what happens next is in your hands. Personally I would go on my own or take up one of the other offers. Life is for living and often takes a bit of an unexpected curve.

SalviaOfficinalis · 23/07/2022 15:28

I’d be annoyed. I wouldn’t fall out with her about it, but I wouldn’t pretend that it was fine either.

If it’s just the two of you going it’s really unfair - yes you can still technically go, but not many people enjoy going to events alone.

diddl · 23/07/2022 15:21

I have to say that it's not obvious to me that she would rather go to her DIL's 30th that what she has planned with Op.

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:20

Urgh. This is not ‘being a doormat’ FGS. It’s called understanding. And yes it gets you lots of good friends.

Most of the advice on this thread either wants to 1) make the friend go to an event when we know she would rather be somewhere else or 2) make the friend feel bad about going to the party, just to make her feel bad. Or 3) some combination.

What is the point? This is how old women end up lonely!

50mg · 23/07/2022 15:19

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:17

I am sorry to hear you have had a personal tragedy. Your friend hasn’t cost you a ticket.

If you had two other things to do that weekend, why not pick up those offers?

Because frankly I don't want to say "remember that friend I couldn't cancel to come out with you, well they've cancelled...."

Plus they'll have made other plans now.

There are far more important "costs" in life than monetary ones imo.

OP posts:
50mg · 23/07/2022 15:18

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:15

And FGS do not send any of these pass-agg ‘I’m so hurt’ prissy emails or texts that other posters have suggested!

Take your disappointment with good grace. These things happen. Be cheerful and understanding and you may find you have more people who want to do things with you.

I have plenty of people who want to do things with me, thank you and I've been saying no to them because I was already committed to this event with this friend. It was their plan, it's not like they were doing me a favour!

OP posts:
ddl1 · 23/07/2022 15:17

I'd be annoyed too. But no point in sending snarky messages; just be cautious in the future about making long-term plans with her. An existing long-term commitment comes first. If someone was ill, or there was some emergency, that would be different; but not just to attend a spur-of-the-moment party. She could have paid a special visit to her DIL with gifts on another day.

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:17

I am sorry to hear you have had a personal tragedy. Your friend hasn’t cost you a ticket.

If you had two other things to do that weekend, why not pick up those offers?

Perple · 23/07/2022 15:17

@PersonaNonGarter - being a doormat doesn’t get you good friends…

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:15

And FGS do not send any of these pass-agg ‘I’m so hurt’ prissy emails or texts that other posters have suggested!

Take your disappointment with good grace. These things happen. Be cheerful and understanding and you may find you have more people who want to do things with you.

50mg · 23/07/2022 15:14

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:12

I don’t agree - YABU and possibly about to lose a friend who hasn’t done anything wrong. She has given you two weeks notice for a free event. You have lost nothing.

I feel sorry for your friend that two things she would like to do came up in the same day. It’s obvious to me that she would want to go to the 30th birthday (that IS a big birthday). Unless you are travelling across the continents to see her, she is going to that.

OP, do you work/have a full diary? Because two weeks notice for a free evening event is actually pretty good going for people balancing children friends work and so on.

As it happens I haven't lost "nothing". I've had a personal tragedy, which friend knows about and have been "keeping busy" to cope, which friend also knows. I turned down two other invitations for that weekend because I was already committed....

OP posts:
TedMullins · 23/07/2022 15:13

Of course she’s out of order, you honour the first thing you’ve committed to unless someone dies! The concept of inviting parents/in-laws to a 30th is bizarre to me tbh. I’d much rather have fun with my friends on my birthday. Will her son or DIL actually care if she doesn’t go?

PersonaNonGarter · 23/07/2022 15:12

I don’t agree - YABU and possibly about to lose a friend who hasn’t done anything wrong. She has given you two weeks notice for a free event. You have lost nothing.

I feel sorry for your friend that two things she would like to do came up in the same day. It’s obvious to me that she would want to go to the 30th birthday (that IS a big birthday). Unless you are travelling across the continents to see her, she is going to that.

OP, do you work/have a full diary? Because two weeks notice for a free evening event is actually pretty good going for people balancing children friends work and so on.