Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the cost of living crisis isn't really a "crisis" for most people?

648 replies

buzzheath · 23/07/2022 12:15

Not meant to be inflammatory at all. I'm well aware of the hardships that some people and families will face. But for the majority of people in the UK, will it really be a "crisis"? Isn't around half of the population middle class?

OP posts:
MrsJBaptiste · 23/07/2022 17:01

I agree OP, we are very lucky in that we haven't had to cut back on anything as yet. We aren't very extravagant and don't have a mortgage or car loans so appreciate we are in a very fortunate position to start with.

Looking at friends/family and the amount of people in our local bars and restaurants, you wouldn't think there was any crisis imminent at all.

RoonilWazlib21 · 23/07/2022 16:54

I'm absolutely terrified. I don't know how I'm going to manage.

I'm an unpaid carer living with my disabled adult child. We have no luxuries at all including haircuts, takeaways etc. The gas and electricity has risen from £78 before April to £175 now and will be around £300 from October.

The food shopping is rising rapidly. A pizza that my daughter likes was £1.75 earlier this year, it's now £3. I can't eat gluten and a small loaf of bread has just risen again to £2 when it was £1.75 four weeks ago.

I can only afford to put £20 petrol in my car per month and its obviously not going very far on that. The car spring broke 3 weeks ago and I needed to find £470 to repair it.

Saying all that we are not in as bad a position as some for now for which I am extremely grateful.

Tiani4 · 23/07/2022 16:34

buzzheath · 23/07/2022 12:22

@BalloonsAndWhistles Yeah, same, and I'm not a high earner at all. I don't have a car so don't need to buy petrol, don't need to buy expensive train tickets and I suppose it's summer too so not using much gas. Plus, I live in a small flat so even when it's cold I usually just use an electric heater in one of the rooms.

It's the summer for me too. Hasn't stopped British Gas's from doubling my gas and electric DDs to £330!!! And I was in credit before - a £190 DD last month for gas which I haven't used! No heating - using the gas oven a once a day for about 30- 45 mins at a time !!

I don't have £330 a month to pay gas and electric bill- I am a lone parent of 3DCs. Both older ones work part time jobs.

So yes- it is biting this increase in cost of living . I'm saying no to using my car where my teenage DCs can catch a bus or a train, as it costs me £85 instead of £60 to fill my car. So that seems 35% more expensive than usual and my mortgage has rocketed as I can't fix the rate. An extra £180 a month and still going up I expect .

Food bills are higher and we are living on cheap food that I am stretching out. I'm losing weight rapidly as I'd rather DCs eat before me.

So I'm not sure where that extra £300-400 a month will come from.

It's great if you have two wages coming in and you're not supporting everyone on one wage or has carefully budgeted with only a little left over spare to set aside each month, and now in minus at end of each month. I'm picking up overtime where I can from work. My son (at Uni) is struggling with extra costs too. I've exhausted all my savings over past 6 months.

Miajk · 23/07/2022 16:22

It's still a crisis because just being alive shouldn't be this hard.

People working full time should be able to afford food, shelter, to start a family. Or to afford being single. And to save, considering were always told we should have living expenses saved up.

It's ridiculous how hard it is to have a nice quality of life unless you have a good job, no kids and are coupled up.

FunDragon · 23/07/2022 16:18

MintJulia · 23/07/2022 15:00

For the majority of people, it means a reduced standard of living. It isn't a crisis in terms of starving or freezing, or having to turn to risky behaviours to survive.
It will mean a reduced spend on holidays, clothes, cosmetic stuff and activities/hobbies.
For the next level down, it will mean buying less food, cheaper food, but not necessarily less nutritious food.

For the bottom 10% though, it is a crisis, requiring very real & extreme measures. I hope the new PM acts to further support that group.

I think this sums the situation up pretty accurately.

FunDragon · 23/07/2022 16:13

The rising energy and food bills will be painful for our household, but we won’t be in crisis as such. I think I will have to go back to work from maternity leave full time though, rather than part time as I originally hoped, but I wouldn’t call that a crisis.

But we will only be ok as long as we both hold onto our jobs. The thought of losing our jobs in the face of rising interest rates and energy bills makes me feel queasy.

Blossomtoes · 23/07/2022 16:10

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/07/2022 15:55

Perhaps my memory is better than yours.

Clearly it is not, if your memories of past economic fluctuations are not strong enough to help you keep current events in perspective.

It’s good enough to recognise just how bad things were and I’m realistic enough to recognise this will be at least just as bad and very possibly far worse. Minimising is just sticking your head in the sand.

Themsthebreak · 23/07/2022 16:04

I come from a family that lost every penny in a 90s recession. We lost the roof over our head and I will never forget that feeling. But as an adult, I am very lucky as DH earns six figures and I earn a v good day rate. However - first world problem alert - both jobs are vulnerable to a recession. We have parked our plans for a ‘final forever’ house as it would mean taking on a mortgage that would cost three times as much to service as it would have a year ago. Basically, if high income people like us are adjusting our plans and spending, it’s really going to hurt those on the breadline. It’s giving me shivers as I remember what that felt like. I do think there may be civil unrest unless something is done.

HelenHywater · 23/07/2022 16:03

It is a crisis for many people. I work with families who are already skipping meals and unable to pay all their bills.

And to a pp who says that the media is blowing this up - they really aren't.

Mumsnetters are lucky, they have a buffer in their income, they can cut out things, even if they aren't living in luxury. This isn't the case for many people in this country.

UnnecessaryFennel · 23/07/2022 15:59

We will manage, as we have stable jobs, a small mortgage and savings, but most discretionary spending and 'treats' will stop. This will impact on the local businesses we currently use - eg: independent coffee shops, restaurants, yoga classes, etc. We've already cut down on lots (well, I have, DH is slower to tighten his belt Hmm) so I've not bought any new clothes at all this year, no cosmetics, no haircuts, etc. Instead of employing local contractors to do work to the house or garden, we will either do it ourselves or, more likely, not do it at all. So we will not be contributing to the local economy and more businesses will close.

DS is off to university in Sept so some of our bills will fall a bit when he goes, but equally we will be supporting him financially as well.

Petrol and energy prices are my biggest worries. I WFH most of the time but DH has to drive to work (literally no public transport available) and despite our best efforts to increase the insulation, the house is COLD in the winter. I am investing in heated throws for all of us (ds included as he will be in a rented house) and an airfryer to try and keep a lid on the worst of the price hikes.

We live in a deprived area of the country and there is already a huge amount of poverty. I'm going to up my donation to the local foodbank, but if I'm really really honest I worry about increases in crime etc as people get desperate. I feel awful for saying that but there we go.

So to answer your question OP, no I don't forsee us being in crisis, but I am not looking forward to winter at all. It will be constrained for us, and unremittingly awful for many others.

LemonSwan · 23/07/2022 15:56

I think it will affect everyone.

I had a bill come in yesterday for electric and gas. It’s looking at about 4/5k for the year.

We are actually renovating our house so haven’t had electric on.

We are living in a studio which is one room for everything. It’s super efficient energy wise and we barely had the heating on - which is wet underfloor and very efficient. We are running lights in one room, one computer, one tv and charging devices (2 tablets and 2 mobiles) for two people. We have no kitchen and are using a fridge freezer, a microwave, stove top travel hob and an air fryer.

People won’t be able to afford to work in supermarkets or as carers - anything minimum wage really. I am on maternity but have done the maths and would be better off not going back to work and going on UC.

It’s going to get tough out there and MC will get hit.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/07/2022 15:55

Perhaps my memory is better than yours.

Clearly it is not, if your memories of past economic fluctuations are not strong enough to help you keep current events in perspective.

Heatstrokeunsteady · 23/07/2022 15:54

I am working ridiculous hours and still skint. But then I have kids who never stop eating and need data/money for spirts/pocket money etc. bad timing doesn’t quite cover it

Blossomtoes · 23/07/2022 15:52

in another 10 years we will barely remember this.

I’d like to think you’re right. Unfortunately I think in another ten years we’ll still only just be emerging from what’s to come. Perhaps my memory is better than yours.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 23/07/2022 15:51

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/07/2022 15:44

I agree OP, and I think it bears saying. There is a very strong narrative on Mumsnet that "everyone is struggling" and it simply isn't true. I've lived long enough to know things have been worse and things have been better. The 1970s were tough, the 1980s were very polarised, interest rates were out of control in the 1990s, we were told to expect global financial collapse in 2007, and in another 10 years we will barely remember this.

That’s because we haven’t reached that point yet. This is just the start.

CeeJay81 · 23/07/2022 15:46

We are def feeling the pinch. On low income and will rely on the government help. £400 energy payment, plus another £650 as we are on tax credits and also the Welsh government are extending the winter fuel allowance(£200) to those on tax credits.

So we will be OK because of that. Without that we'd have to cut out the kids after school activities. We would be able to heat and eat but with only a little left over for kids clothes etc and everything else.

Lomex · 23/07/2022 15:45

(That doesn't mean I don't think the cost of living crisis isn't a genuine crisis, just that I'm not surprised that lots of people are fine.)

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 23/07/2022 15:44

Wait until October when your energy bill goes up by 64% and again in January and then again in April. Wait until the interest rates hit 15% like they did in the 80s and families start losing their homes and social services start taking children into care because their parents can’t afford to feed them and have the heating on because that’s the reality we are facing.

Food inflation in this country has hit 30%. This isn’t going to end until the energy companies are renationalised. Big business and the energy companies are seeing this as a free for all and increasing their prices way about what they need to out of pure greed. It’s called profiteering.

This will be the end of home ownership for most people. We will end up renting from investment companies such as vanguard and black rock. How many members of the government stand to benefit from this situation? I’m willing to guess quite a few.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/07/2022 15:44

I agree OP, and I think it bears saying. There is a very strong narrative on Mumsnet that "everyone is struggling" and it simply isn't true. I've lived long enough to know things have been worse and things have been better. The 1970s were tough, the 1980s were very polarised, interest rates were out of control in the 1990s, we were told to expect global financial collapse in 2007, and in another 10 years we will barely remember this.

Lomex · 23/07/2022 15:44

Isn't this always the case though? If there was a crisis which genuinely caused hardship for the majority of the population, then the poorest 10 million would be destitute and probably starving, so in any crisis lots of people will basically be okay (you need something on the scale of war to affect everyone). So much of how we perceive a crisis is, for most of us, due to the media, as often we don't experience it directly (for example, I don't know anyone who has died of covid or even been seriously ill, if it wasn't for the media I wouldn't have a clue it was serious). Most people (including me) really struggle with stats once the numbers get big - it's hard to differentiate between a million people being affected, or five million or 10 million. It's all just big numbers! Same with the economy- once we get to talking billions most people haven't got a clue what that actually means in real terms. If the media decide to pick something up (like "immigration") people can get a massively skewed and unrealistic idea of the scale of the problem.

Calledakaren · 23/07/2022 15:38

Personally I don't think my family will be in crisis, but i am worried for the increase in electricity/ gas and the general state of the economy.

I'd be surprised if we didn't see riots on the streets by the end of the year. What have people got to loose - life is shit for many atm

BrokenToy · 23/07/2022 15:36

Our gas and electric has doubled to £200.

Our mortgage deal ends early next year and currently the cheapest deal I can find is £200pm more than we’re paying now.

Our council tax went up to £290 a month last year, from £260. So god knows what that will jump to in April.

We both have good jobs but bills going up by HUNDREDS of pounds a month means yes, this is a crisis.

ilovesooty · 23/07/2022 15:33

Pooet · 23/07/2022 14:54

No. Poor people are poor for a variety of reasons. People who want to live like people who work and do fuck all should have to fund it themselves. And ypu full know well there is a difference between your average 25 year old on benefits with their tech and a 45 year old teacher who has just lost their job. Mumsnet needs a crisis, remember the amageddon of Brexit on here 🤣

Nice to see you find Brexit and poverty amusing.

MyneighbourisTotoro · 23/07/2022 15:33

Well we are struggling to keep the bank balance above 0 and we don’t have any luxuries other a subscription that is split between us and my parents.

feellikeanalien · 23/07/2022 15:31

OP I got a quote for heating oil this week. Over £500 for 500 litres. A couple of years ago I was paying under £200. I can't afford that and the price will no doubt go up over the winter. If I don't have oil I don't have hot water. Luckily we also have an open fire but the price of coal is going up all the time, from approximately £12 for a 50 k bag to £17.50.

That's just coal and oil. God knows what petrol will be like. We live rurally so I need to drive. We're not in crisis at the moment but come winter I just don't know what's going to happen.

The only certainty is that prices are not likely to go down.