Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About strange myths that permeate MN about other countries and cultures

181 replies

Wetsummers · 23/07/2022 07:43

Does anyone else know what I mean - in particular about ‘Africa.’ I’m not claiming to be an expert on African culture or social norms but I’m pretty sure the ‘African tribes’ often referred to on here are a myth.

See also the insistence that we start children at school too early. Pretty sure most 4/5 year olds are in some form of education / kindergarten or whatever.

And you can’t open a thread on sleep without someone confidently stating the Japanese all co sleep.

OP posts:
Chemenger · 23/07/2022 17:12

RadicalFern · 23/07/2022 12:01

Rainbowshit yes indeed. In the run up to the last indyref my (English) mother was told by her (Scottish) colleague that when independence came they’d finally be able to get rid of “people like you.” It does happen, and not just (as implied by other posters) on drunken nights out with neds.

I lived in England for a few years and can confirm that anti-Scottish remarks are commonplace, also resolute refusal to understand anything said in a Scottish accent and ignorant questions about the weather and availability of electricity, tv and other modern conveniences. Not defending my fellow Scots if they are rude to other nationalities, but it very much goes both ways.

ancientgran · 23/07/2022 17:10

Kendodd · 23/07/2022 12:52

Yes I do.
I used to work for a newspaper and we were always told to check spelling on every name.
Also, if you are entering a name onto a data base it has to be correct, never assume how someone spells their name.

I've got a fairly simple British name, I never get asked how to spell it, hospitals, GP, government stuff. I'd actually find it really weird to be asked to spell my three letter first name that follows all phonetic rules. I can't even think of another way you could spell it. Very occasionally someone will say "Smith, S M I T H?" (my name isn't Smith but another straightforward 5 letter name.)

As for journalists my children were featured on local TV and several national newspapers, they both have a first name with alternative spellings and they did check the first names but not the surname, again it would be hard to imagine an alternative spelling.

QueenWatevraWaNabi · 23/07/2022 16:54

Genuine question if you are English in Scotland how would anyone know you're English unless you announce it given many Scots have names like 'James Smith' and speak with an English accent?

I announce it by speaking in an English accent when Scottish people are, for the vast vast overwhelming majority, speaking with Scottish accents. I'm not walking around condoning the poll tax, wearing a Conservative rosette, or wearing an England football shirt whilst banging on about '66 if that's what the implication here is!

Fluffycloudland77 · 23/07/2022 16:50

I know someone who is 100% convinced that the father your child they is LEGALLY OBLIGATED to house you until the child is 18. They are so convinced that now other people are also convinced the father of your child is LEGALLY OBLIGATED to house you until the child is 18.

This is despite it not happening for them when they split with the father of their child and no one made the dad house them until the child turned 18.

The birth rate would drop right down if men thought they’d have to pay for a house for 18 years, vasectomy rates would increase.

calmlakes · 23/07/2022 16:45

Gun violence is absolutely a big deal in the very liberal USA city I live in. Despite guns being harder to buy here. Other states locally have laxer laws but fewer gun issues. Overall I do think it is an American issue.

But my abortion rights are actually much stronger than they were in the UK. Although currently in reality it is straightforward to access an abortion in the UK, other than in NI. The actual laws are stronger in my State.

I understand that in all the States I'm bordered by abortion is much harder or impossible to access.
But it is a State by State issue not a country issue.

Boxowine · 23/07/2022 16:34

I'm an American living in the US and what I see on MN is a number of Brits who either live here or have lived here downplaying the abortion and healthcare and abortion issues. The impression I have is that most of them have experience living in or near to prosperous cities in the US. Boston, Chicago, LA, NY or nearby suburbs. Those areas tend to be more liberal about those issues. Massachusetts is one of the smallest and most liberal states in the country, their gun laws are an outlier compared to the rest of the US and may be subject to change due to the SCOTUS Bruen ruling. There are more states seeking to criminalize abortion than there are states which have codified it and those that have codified it are subject to having such laws repealed because overturning Roe means that there is no longer federal protection for a woman's right to privacy regarding her own body.

Not everyone who votes republican is a backwoods hick, but everyone who is a backwoods hick votes republican. That's how they stay in power. And all republican politicians toe the party line re: gun laws, abortion, and usually healthcare.

It's not my intent to hijack this thread to talk about US politics but I do find it strange how many mumsnetters seem to work it into threads that women can just go to another state or that the gun violence is not a big deal.

MistyFuckingQuigley · 23/07/2022 16:20

EV117 · 23/07/2022 10:24

French women happily crack on guzzling wine and scoffing Brie through pregnancy.

I sat in a bar in Paris at 7 and a half months pregnant drinking red wine (2 large glasses) no one batted an eye, it was great 😁 no soft cheese though 🤔

calmlakes · 23/07/2022 16:18

@VladmirsPoutine my DH is English when we visit my home area in Scotland he sometimes gets groups of neds walking behind him mimicking the way he talks.
Or he can get abuse thrown at him as we walk past people in the street.
Or people on public transport talking about English people very loudly and rudely for us to hear.
Obviously most people don't behave like that but it is there.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/07/2022 16:13

in Massachusetts, those who wish to purchase a firearm must obtain a permit to purchase from their local police department

Out of interest, is that also necessary to buy online or at gun shows?
There was a recent thread where much was made of permits, but this detail was conveniently (?) left out

There are people in the US with equally ridiculous views about the NHS

Very much agree with this, WomanStanleyWoman

VladmirsPoutine · 23/07/2022 16:03

@NotDavidTennant I asked because I don't know. One of my parents is from an African country yet speaks English with an RP accent. I just wondered what xenophobia looks like from a white perspective because I've only ever experienced it based on skin colour so I genuinely didn't know.

Pemba · 23/07/2022 16:02

Rose Leslie the actress (Game of Thrones etc) is Scottish with an English accent, I believe she comes from a very grand family, like aristocracy?

calmlakes · 23/07/2022 15:58

The local aristocrats had English accents, I went to University with two Scots whose public school education really had given them English accents.
But I'd agree usually there is a Scots burr that is recognizable.
But the overwhelming majority of Scots sound clearly Scottish it is odd to suggest otherwise.

NotDavidTennant · 23/07/2022 15:53

Who are the Scots that speak with an English accent? Even posh Scots tend to still have a recognisable lilt to their accent.

NelStevHan · 23/07/2022 15:51

'Genuine question if you are English in Scotland how would anyone know you're English unless you announce it given many Scots have names like 'James Smith' and speak with an English accent?'

When's the last time you went to Scotland?? The only people with English accents living there that I've ever meet were actually English... go to somewhere like St Andrews and the town is over-run with posh English twats...

Getoff · 23/07/2022 15:51

I've googled, and I wasn't too far off with my made-up statistic. 97% of UK population do not speak using RP.

NelStevHan · 23/07/2022 15:49

'The anti USA sentiment on here is massive. Like everyone has a gun & is a crazed anti-abortionist'

Married to a yank, lots of US family so always been tuned into anti-USA sentiment and to be fair to MN there's a lot of anti- American sentiment everywhere at the moment as the US does seem to be on the verge of an actual civil war, the government seems unable and unwilling to do anything about the endless mass shootings, and the Roe vs Wade overturn makes the country look like it's heading for a real-life Handmaid's Tale.

Getoff · 23/07/2022 15:48

VladmirsPoutine · 23/07/2022 15:40

And I'm Scottish and have observed anti English xenophobia many many times.

Genuine question if you are English in Scotland how would anyone know you're English unless you announce it given many Scots have names like 'James Smith' and speak with an English accent?

I assume an "english accent" that is also spoken by some Scots is RP, which 99% of English people don't speak. So that's how's the Scots know.

(99% is a made-up statistic, replace with your own number if you know better.)

calmlakes · 23/07/2022 15:47

VladmirsPoutine · 23/07/2022 15:40

And I'm Scottish and have observed anti English xenophobia many many times.

Genuine question if you are English in Scotland how would anyone know you're English unless you announce it given many Scots have names like 'James Smith' and speak with an English accent?

Scots usually speak with a Scottish accent not an English one.
There is a very small percentage of the the Scots population who have English accents due to their educational background but they are the exception not the rule.

NelStevHan · 23/07/2022 15:44

'That anyone with a non English name will be utterly tormented by having to spell it for the rest of their lives'

I have a non English surname, I wouldn't say I'm tormented exactly but I do have to spell it EVERY single time I pronounce it for someone. In fact I say it then just immediately spell it.

Changechangychange · 23/07/2022 15:42

WillMcAvoy · 23/07/2022 12:28

The anti USA sentiment on here is massive. Like everyone has a gun & is a crazed anti-abortionist

I think you've misunderstood, I don't think anyone thinks that or says that.

I know that not everyone has a gun or is anti-abortion. That's completely obvious. But the laws are pro gun and anti abortion. The society as a whole is far too pro gun and anti abortion. And the healthcare is expensive and workers rights are limited and the work culture is much harsher, and so many other things.
I would never want to live in America. IT doesn't mean I hate all americans though. I imagine my thoughts are similar to most others posting the same

There’s a difference between that and some of the venom you see on threads about the US though. There was one poster recently who just would not drop it, telling @mathanxiety that she was wrong about where she lived, and generally came across as completely unhinged over multiple pages of posts.

I agree with you that there are aspects of life in the US that mean that I, personally, wouldn’t choose to live there (I work in healthcare, I don’t want to work in the US system for multiple reasons not all of which are related to insurance). DH would live there if we were in California and had a high income. We’d both prefer Canada (having lived there before, we know we like it there). That is a world away from the “all Americans are fat” posts.

VladmirsPoutine · 23/07/2022 15:40

And I'm Scottish and have observed anti English xenophobia many many times.

Genuine question if you are English in Scotland how would anyone know you're English unless you announce it given many Scots have names like 'James Smith' and speak with an English accent?

Wetsummers · 23/07/2022 15:36

That’s exactly what it is @Changechangychange

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 23/07/2022 15:27

dreamingbohemian · 23/07/2022 10:14

Yes it's usually on breastfeeding and attachment parenting threads that you see people going on about how 'African tribes' do X, Y or Z, but clearly with no actual knowledge of anything. It's just something they read on a mummy blog somewhere.

'In Africa they do X' as if Africa is just one monolithic country and culture

Often contradictory as well - either “African tribes” leave their kids with granny/Aunty/whoever is at home that day while the mothers work in the fields/get on with housework. Or they have their child strapped to their back 24/7 until the child is 7, doing full-on attachment parenting and the child is potty trained by six weeks.

There’s also the implication that whatever “African tribes” do, represents the original untouched state of humanity, which we have lost with our modern western ways. Like societies in Africa haven’t changed in any way since homo erectus, and represent some kind of noble savage. One quick trip to any country in Africa would disabuse you of that.

calmlakes · 23/07/2022 15:26

And I'm Scottish and have observed anti English xenophobia many many times.

I have too.

SeaToSki · 23/07/2022 15:19

WillMcAvoy · 23/07/2022 12:28

The anti USA sentiment on here is massive. Like everyone has a gun & is a crazed anti-abortionist

I think you've misunderstood, I don't think anyone thinks that or says that.

I know that not everyone has a gun or is anti-abortion. That's completely obvious. But the laws are pro gun and anti abortion. The society as a whole is far too pro gun and anti abortion. And the healthcare is expensive and workers rights are limited and the work culture is much harsher, and so many other things.
I would never want to live in America. IT doesn't mean I hate all americans though. I imagine my thoughts are similar to most others posting the same

Yes but here you are saying that the laws are pro gun and anti abortion. That is lumping all 330 million people into one bucket.

63 million women live in States that have protected their abortion rights with State law. I wish it were more, but please dont overlook this fact as it weakens your very valid argument that more States should be doing this.

As for guns, again I believe that gun ownership should be properly regulated and, for example, in Massachusetts, those who wish to purchase a firearm must obtain a permit to purchase from their local police department. This process alone can take weeks and requires paperwork, an interview, and a background check. After all of that, the police chief still has the discretion to deny the license. After obtaining a license, the purchaser must present the license at the gun store and pass additional background checks. An argument that Arizona (7.1 million people) which has very few gun regulation should copy Massachusetts (population 6.8 million) regulation is far more sensible than just saying that ‘America has pro gun laws’

We dont talk about Europe and throw Germans into the same bucket as Ukrainians when discussing laws. We shouldnt talk about Africa and assume all Africans live in (or identify with) a tribe; or Asia and group Pakistanis and Indians when talking about wedding traditions etc etc.