Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being made out to be the bad guy over a dog

294 replies

User18283 · 22/07/2022 22:26

Can someone help, this situation is driving me mad.

Long story short my husbands ex wife has a dog, a young German shepherd cross. It's very friendly and a lovely dog but that's beside the point.

She has recently changed jobs and is struggling to give it the time and attention it needs and so has spoken with my husband and said she will need to re-home her. She hinted that maybe me and DH would like her.

The trouble is DSD is absolutely in love with this dog and is absolutely distraught at the prospect of her being rehomed and the pressure is being put on for us to take her.

My husband said no at first but has now come round to the idea and I feel like I'm the last "barrier" and am being made out a villain for continuing to say no.

I feel like this whole situation is so unfair. I'm a SAHM currently to our very young child so it would be down to me to do the majority with her and I just really do not want a dog. I love dogs, but after our own very much loved and adored DDog passed a couple of years ago I have found no longer being tied to one quite freeing especially whilst my own DC is young and a handful themselves. My house feels cleaner, there's less stress and worry, less responsibility, more freedom and I'm just not ready to take it on again especially such a young basically still pup!

I don't know what to do, I don't want to agree to this but DSD is so upset and I feel like I'm being cast as the bad guy when it's her mum who got a dog and then not long after found she couldn't keep it, how has this ended up my fault?!

My husband has said he and DSD will do everything for it when he's home from work (yeah right) but that still leaves me all day having to deal with a dog I do not want.

AIBU to stick to my guns with this?

OP posts:
Indoctro · 23/07/2022 18:53

I'd be more concerned about your young child and the dog

Young kids and dogs don't mix. A GSD is a large dog, and a guarding breed.

These dogs need a lot of stimulation and well trained. I wouldn't have it near a under 5 it's a accident waiting to happen.

Bonheurdupasse · 23/07/2022 18:49

OP

whenever the guilt trip is put on you by DSD say something along the lines of “yes it’s a pity that your mum doesn’t want to get a job to fit with the dog”. If she says “but she can’t” reply “she could if she really wanted to”

cuprunnethover · 23/07/2022 18:46

So if you marry someone with a child (or children) you have to be willing at some unspecified date in the future to take on a dog or dogs if the child's other parent decides that they will not longer look after a dog they took responsibility for?

Nope, never said that.

CPL593H · 23/07/2022 18:37

PrivateHall · 23/07/2022 17:48

This is Mumsnet gold, actual suggestions that OP maintain her husbands exes dog financially so her DSD doesn’t suffer hurt feelings

Well now that's a bit silly, especially given that op doesn't actually work. So it would hardly be her funding the dog. That being said, is it really so unreasonable to have DH pay towards his own daughter's pet? I wouldn't have thought so. OP says she would be raging even about DH paying.

So is OP an equal partner when it comes to finances as she is (presumably) not working because she is caring for her/husbands " very young child" or is she in fact Dobby the House Elf?

Anyway OP, re: that very young child, there is also the consideration of introducing a large breed "not puppy" dog into your household.

Skodacool · 23/07/2022 18:36

User18283 · 23/07/2022 08:28

It’s not just the walks anyway - the dog will just be there every minute of the OP’s day and she doesn’t want it!

Yes this really. It doesn't matter to me if DH did do every "job" involved with it. Not that I believe that would actually be the case for very long!

I still don't want a dog in my house. It still makes the house smell, have hairs everywhere, it still affects our finances and freedom, especially mine during the day. It's unrealistic to think I'd never have to consider it if I was the one home all day.

As for paying for her to send it to doggy daycare or us offering to walk it when she's walking. No I wouldn't be happy to do that either. I don't see why we should be forking out a lot of money (dog daycare is extortionate!) because of a mistake she made and quite frankly no I'm not willing to give up my time to walk her dog.

SHE should pay for doggie daycare; it’s her dog and her responsibility.

5foot5 · 23/07/2022 18:32

PrivateHall · 23/07/2022 17:48

This is Mumsnet gold, actual suggestions that OP maintain her husbands exes dog financially so her DSD doesn’t suffer hurt feelings

Well now that's a bit silly, especially given that op doesn't actually work. So it would hardly be her funding the dog. That being said, is it really so unreasonable to have DH pay towards his own daughter's pet? I wouldn't have thought so. OP says she would be raging even about DH paying.

So if the feckless ex had decided to buy her DD a pony, say, and then "Oh dear me ponies are so expensive I can't afford it but she will be so upset if I sell it" do you think the DH should then put his hand on his pocket to fund his ex's whim?

And can you really not see what is so wrong about suggesting that because the OP doesn't currently go out to work she doesn't get a say in where the households money is spent?

nothingfound · 23/07/2022 18:25

Op - I suggested day care for the dog in the expectation that there is no way your DH will pay for it. I also suggested that he has full responsibility for everything dog-related including dropping it off and picking it up on his way to and from work. Slightly tongue in cheek but - he'd never sign up for that would he? He's being a total prat about this - don't budge.

BrettIsHot · 23/07/2022 18:24

What hours was she working? What hours is she working now?

User18283 · 23/07/2022 18:22

What happens if she decides to buy a horse next and then wants DH to pay for the stables in case we risk DSD being upset. It's silly. It wasn't our decision to buy the dog, our family shouldn't be ££ out of pocket for it.

OP posts:
User18283 · 23/07/2022 18:20

I don't think the fact I don't work is relevant. I can still have an opinion on what DH spends money on considering it is family money and the decision for me to leave work and save us a fortune in childcare every month was a joint one.

Committing to paying for daycare is huge. We're talking about a dog that could potentially (no, likely!) live for over a decade. Daycare for our last dog which we only needed to use very occasionally was £25 per day! That's a ridiculous amount, along with everything else, to commit to paying to another household for a dog we don't even own. And once you've committed it will then be spun as our fault if we can no longer afford or no longer want to pay it at some point in the next 10+ years.

OP posts:
PrivateHall · 23/07/2022 18:17

It is actually none of my business whether or not op works haha! However DH gets to spend what he wants on his DD. He clearly wants to find a solution that keeps his DD happy so if that is helping funding doggy daycare; that is his perogative really. But suggesting it would be the OP funding it is silly, whether posters like it or not.

ImJustNotMeAnymore · 23/07/2022 18:14

If you and your family had come to me to buy a dog I'd not sell you one, just to put your situation in perspective. You, as the main caregiver for the dog, have to be the one who wants to keep the dog otherwise the situation will breed nothing but discontent, resentment,and an unhappy home.
stand your ground and do not be backed into a corner over this.

rookiemere · 23/07/2022 17:58

@PrivateHall I don't think OP said she'd be raging about her DH paying for the dog but she did point out that they don't have unlimited income and the money could be used more appropriately.

Perhaps you think she should go back to work before she is allowed an opinion Hmm ( I guess at least everyone would stop expecting her to be de facto dog care if she did).

HotDogKetchup · 23/07/2022 17:58

PrivateHall · 23/07/2022 17:48

This is Mumsnet gold, actual suggestions that OP maintain her husbands exes dog financially so her DSD doesn’t suffer hurt feelings

Well now that's a bit silly, especially given that op doesn't actually work. So it would hardly be her funding the dog. That being said, is it really so unreasonable to have DH pay towards his own daughter's pet? I wouldn't have thought so. OP says she would be raging even about DH paying.

OP and her husband are a married couple and their finances therefore entwined, so yes, she would be contributing. Unless you consider there is no value in being a SAHM.

The pet is a household pet. Not his daughters, it was a dog purchased independently of OP and her DH so yes, it is unreasonable to expect someone else to fund it retrospectively when they weren’t consulted in the first place.

PrivateHall · 23/07/2022 17:48

This is Mumsnet gold, actual suggestions that OP maintain her husbands exes dog financially so her DSD doesn’t suffer hurt feelings

Well now that's a bit silly, especially given that op doesn't actually work. So it would hardly be her funding the dog. That being said, is it really so unreasonable to have DH pay towards his own daughter's pet? I wouldn't have thought so. OP says she would be raging even about DH paying.

luckylavender · 23/07/2022 17:18

@User18283 - this is a fine opportunity for the old Mumsnet classic 'No is a complete sentence!'

PurpleWisteria · 23/07/2022 17:07

OP, be sure to let DSD know whose fault this is. Don't let the feckless mother try to put any blame on you. Bat it back where it belongs.

Tiani4 · 23/07/2022 17:03

I completely agree with OP
@User18283

It is not for OP to be dragged into this. She has a toddler at home and does not want a dog at home to care for , walk and clean up after , right now. If she did, she would get a dog. She doesn't and as the expectation and 10 hours per day care or dog would be down to her, keeping it away from toddler, then that's OPs decision.

She may choose to return to work too later on

Regardless the fecklessness of DSDs mum in letting dSD down and upsetting her, is not OPs problem to solve by causing strife in her and her DS's life.

Both the dad and mum here of DSD are selfish and are trying to use OP and turn it into her responsibility when it clearly IS NOT.

No way would that dog set paw into my house. And if DH brought it home, the moment he went to work , I would take it the moment he and return it to ex wife's house.

Mellowyellow222 · 23/07/2022 16:44

I am sure someone has already suggested it - but the ex could hire a dog walker. She just doesn’t want to.

riesenrad · 23/07/2022 16:30

noirchatsdeux · 23/07/2022 16:07

I hate dogs so the devil would be going to work in a snowplough before anyone who knows me would be stupid enough to even suggest that I take one on.

Personally I'd be saying if the dog comes in, I'd be going. And mean it.

Well, same here, but the OP actually likes them. That doesn't mean she has to take on the responsibility she doesn't want though. I like guinea pigs and rabbits but don't want the responsibility of looking after them or worrying foxes will get them etc. And dogs are far more work and demand much more effort.

riesenrad · 23/07/2022 16:29

and she chose to marry a man who already had a daughter, and therefore prior responsibilities to create a stable environment for another person. Perhaps he thinks not getting rid of her dog is part of that

So if you marry someone with a child (or children) you have to be willing at some unspecified date in the future to take on a dog or dogs if the child's other parent decides that they will not longer look after a dog they took responsibility for? Sod that for a game of soldiers.

Really people do have ridiculously skewed priorities when it comes to dogs. They are not the most important thing in life! But if you have one it is YOUR responsibility. Nobody else's It is for the OP's DH's ex to come up with a solution that does not inconvenience others and is right for HER daughter.

Agree daughter will blame OP but so what. She will probably hate the OP anyway at some point and maybe eventually she'll mature and think "why didn't my mum just arrange a dog walker/doggy daycare and/or why did she get a dog like that in the first place if she couldn't cope" etc.

MagneticRubberDucks · 23/07/2022 16:24

“It's very sad for DSD I accept that but it's not our problem to solve, it's her mother's. If we wanted the financial responsibility of a dog we'd have one.”

This is the crux of the matter.
in your position I would be repeating this to DH every time the matter is brought up.

forrestgreen · 23/07/2022 16:23

'No I don't want a dog just because your ex wife made a stupid decision to get one, she does not run my life or my house'

If dsd still wants to see it, get her to ask her friends who will have it....

musicforthesoul · 23/07/2022 16:18

You aren't wrong but just be aware that your dsd will likely blame you rather than her mom, not sure how old she is but that could impact your relationship for a long time.

That isn't fair and it definitely doesn't mean you should take on a dog you don't want but you might want to consider how you're going to deal with the upset (and your DH needs to get onside, at least in front of dsd, it will be a losing battle if he just blames you for saying no).

I do feel very sorry for dsd, its a horrible position she's in and even if she's old enough to accept it's the right thing for the dog to be rehomed that won't stop it hurting.

Fenella123 · 23/07/2022 16:10

You are absolutely in the right here OP.

It is NOT fair to a young dog to be somewhere without committed, responsible adult "parents".

Let me hand you a few reality points to help you stick to your guns.
I have owned dogs for 26 years and also grew up with them. I love dogs. But you have to go in with your eyes open!

Decent dog insurance shoots up as they get older. For a puppy (even breeds with known issues - how is this dog's hips?) it may not be much, but the last 3 years of their life you might be looking at £100+ a month.

Food - maybe getting on for the same again (depending on what they eat) right now.

Kenneling when you go abroad on holiday - where we are in the south of England, £20+/day all-in. So £2-3 THOUSAND a year.
And if you think DSD is upset now, try when she's doing important exams, the dog has cancer and needs £5K+ treatment, and is not insured!

That's just money. I understand - and I'll defer to people with direct experience here - GSDs should have two hours of walking a day. TWO. HOURS.

And that's not even getting into your ENTIRELY REALISTIC appreciation about how much extra hoovering and cleaning they generate!

It is not fair to the dog, it is not fair to your family, stick to your guns OP!

Explain to DSD that being a good pet owner means putting their needs ahead of your own wants. The right thing for her to do is to accept she will miss the dog, but let her go to a good home. Poor DSD has done nothing wrong; her Mum, I guess, meant no ill, but wasn't aware how much she didn't know about GSDs; and her Mum has actually done the right thing in recognizing that her home is no longer suitable, rather than sticking her head in the sand.