Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the child benefit arrangements are unfair?

279 replies

MobLife · 22/07/2022 21:41

Only just clocked this and I'm still not 100% sure I've got it right because it seems wrong...
So if 2 parents are both earning £49,999 and hence taking in almost £100k household income they can continue to claim full CB

But

2 parents where the household income is way under that (lets say for arguments sake £70k) and one parent is earning the greater proportion (between £50-60k) will either get a much reduced CB amount or potentially nothing at all?

How is that fair??!

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 23/07/2022 10:59

SheeplessAndCounting · 23/07/2022 10:46

And why is Mumsnet not launching a campaign for that? It's on very tangible issue affecting women and children's quality of life that could be fixed fairly simply as it's a matter of law and maths, not as complex as stamping out general discrimination, sexist attitudes etc. I wish someone would take this up and push for it. Sadly single mums are probably stretched too thin and too overwhelmed already to do so, so you'd hope organisations would do so on their behalf.

It is because ten million cb claimants would have to move into the UC system in order to begin assessing household income.

The government claim it would cost more than it would save.

Let's face it, no one would end up with more, it would just make people feel better to see it removed from households they felt didn't deserve it.

I'd like to see a campaign to increase the amount you can earn before beginning to lose cb as that's been the same since 2013.

SheeplessAndCounting · 23/07/2022 10:46

And why is Mumsnet not launching a campaign for that? It's on very tangible issue affecting women and children's quality of life that could be fixed fairly simply as it's a matter of law and maths, not as complex as stamping out general discrimination, sexist attitudes etc. I wish someone would take this up and push for it. Sadly single mums are probably stretched too thin and too overwhelmed already to do so, so you'd hope organisations would do so on their behalf.

SheeplessAndCounting · 23/07/2022 10:44

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 23/07/2022 10:33

Absolutely agree. I wholeheartedly agree that a household income of £x amount should stop receiving CB but it's not fair if it's based on one earner.
And while we're on a CB bashing thread it also infuriates me that my second born twin gets less than his other first born twin! Born one min apart but he's my second child so gets the lower amount. As far as im concerned they're my first babies. Not my fault two came out at once!

I wonder what they would do if you had a section and somehow lifted both out at the same time. 🤣🤣 Kidding, I know it wouldn't work like that. It all does seem arbitrary but I think when you dig deeper and look at the whole system it is deeply misogynistic and set up to penalise women. Especially single mothers who stick around to raise their kids and try to do the job of two parents. Whereas as we all know the CMS system is as lax as possible, because that mainly impacts men.

It doesn't seem like an accident that it's all set up this way and it makes me really angry. Especially when a large proportion of children in poverty live in single parent households. If tax and CB and childcare etc were all assessed on household income, that would be one simple measure to massively improve that situation. So you have ask yourself, why is nobody campaigning for it, why are no politicians even discussing it?

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 23/07/2022 10:33

Absolutely agree. I wholeheartedly agree that a household income of £x amount should stop receiving CB but it's not fair if it's based on one earner.
And while we're on a CB bashing thread it also infuriates me that my second born twin gets less than his other first born twin! Born one min apart but he's my second child so gets the lower amount. As far as im concerned they're my first babies. Not my fault two came out at once!

SheeplessAndCounting · 23/07/2022 10:31

Having two parents working full time in jobs that earn them almost 50 grand each is going to be incredibly stressful and come with work and childcare expenses that a family with a SAHP simply won’t have.

But again, how do you think it is for the single parent in this situation? They are taxed more, have CB etc taken away at half the household income level, have to pay all childcare costs from the single salary and do everything at home with nobody to help. Almost all such parents are women. Why are all women not angry at this blantant discrimination?

Onionbhajisandwich · 23/07/2022 10:31

My DH doesn’t earn anywhere near 50k but we can’t claim as he has a company car (that we pay tax on already) and they take that into account too. I earn much less than DH, I’m also full time so we also have to pay for childcare as well. If I had a company car and DH didn’t, we’d still be able to claim in full.

Minimalme · 23/07/2022 10:30

Looneytune253 · 23/07/2022 10:17

Come on, you're talking about massive salaries here though!! If you're earning that much (50k even on your own) you don't need child benefit. We earn less than £50k combined and we manage fine. Live according to your means.

This is oversimplifying it though.

A single parent on £50k, living in the SE with one child under 4 could easily be spending 2/3 of their take home pay on rent and childcare.

Another example could be someone like my best friend - her parents have helped her and her husband out financially for the last 20 years. They both earn a combined wage of under 50k but live very comfortably.

Floralnomad · 23/07/2022 10:29

TheWayoftheLeaf · 23/07/2022 09:44

Free school meals are also there to help children who are neglected and not fed by parents at home. If those parents got CB they would still not feed them.

And fourth children also eat. In poverty stricken homes... do you think kids after the third shouldn't be helped?

My point was that FSM for all infants isn’t means tested or based on salary , you can have millionaires kids eating free at school , that money could have been better used to provide FSM throughout the holidays to those that genuinely need them . Also if you can’t afford to care for 4 children without the extra x amount of CB maybe you should consider not having anymore .

ClocksGoingBackwards · 23/07/2022 10:27

I can see why people think this is unfair, but I don’t think the outrage is proportionate to the actual problem.

Its a luxury for a family to be able to have a SAHP and it’s one that comes with many benefits. Having two parents working full time in jobs that earn them almost 50 grand each is going to be incredibly stressful and come with work and childcare expenses that a family with a SAHP simply won’t have.

I prefer universal benefits that everyone is entitled to even if they don’t really need it because I don’t think it’s fair that those who pay the most tax receive the least support from their own government when they need it. This system is rewarding families that choose to both go out to work and who support the economy by paying for childcare and leaving the families that have decided to have a SAHP to get on with it because they can clearly afford it. I don’t think it’s that terrible.

SherbertLemonDrop · 23/07/2022 10:22

It's because they have the potential to earn more than the first scenario if both parents work.

Looneytune253 · 23/07/2022 10:17

Come on, you're talking about massive salaries here though!! If you're earning that much (50k even on your own) you don't need child benefit. We earn less than £50k combined and we manage fine. Live according to your means.

FeedMeSantiago · 23/07/2022 10:14

Everyone can claim Child Benefit. If you are affected by the tax charge you can claim Child Benefit and opt not to receive the payments.

That way you get the NI credits and your child gets their NI number but you avoid paying the tax. (Obviously if you're not liable to the tax, opt in to the payments).

The NI credits are worth having as they count towards your pension and if you don't need them, you can transfer them to someone else like your parents or PILs, if they help care for your child.

Ontomatopea · 23/07/2022 10:12

Maybe to encourage both parents to work?

justfiveminutes · 23/07/2022 10:10

this is the latest research briefing to parliament if anyone is interested in the design flaws

Notcoolmum · 23/07/2022 10:07

I agree it's not fair. Particularly to single parent families. I've had to work full time to support my children as my ex has never worked since we split up therefore doesn't have to pay any maintenance. I'm now just above the threshold for repaying part of my child benefit and higher tax.

In a couple we could earn almost twice as much as I do, be on a lower tax bracket and claim full child benefit.

justfiveminutes · 23/07/2022 10:05

"But there are already ways to calculate total family income. When my children were small (just before the Child Benefit was changed) we used to be eligible for Working Family Tax Credit. We had to complete a form with our total family income. Why couldn't this same form be used?"

Yes, for those in the tax credit/UC system they already assess household income. For those who are not, they only have access to individual income via HMRC.

If they were to decide that anyone claiming CB needed to now be subject to a household income assessment, then all ten million of claimants would have to be moved to the UC system. It would cost more to administer than they would save in removing CB from some households (apparently). There have certainly been reviews over the years that have concluded this.

So you could do it, because people are cross that other families are getting money that they don't need, but it would cost the country more.

It depends how much people want to punish those claiming 'unfairly' because it would - allegedly - not save us any money at all, quite the opposite.

cheninblanc · 23/07/2022 09:58

Agree. I don't get cb for my two because my dh earns too much. But they are not his children and we don't share finances I have in paper just under the UK average in salary. His dd gets free school meals, mum gets cb and everything else yet the child's father, is the high earner.

ApplesandBunions · 23/07/2022 09:58

InChocolateWeTrust · 23/07/2022 07:01

It is a funny quirk but it reflects that if you have one earner on 80k and another non earner, you have a choice to increase your income by going out and working. The benefits system as a whole is intended to discourage reliance, the whole point is to ensure that choosing to work always makes you better off.

Two earners on 49k each have probably already done everything they can to maximise their income.

The 30 hours childcare is another one - if you have one high earner and one SAHP here's little evidence that the extra 15 hours has educational benefit, and it doesnt need to be given for childcare as there's a SAHP.

The fact that it's applied in exactly the same way to single parent households kind of does a shit on that though.

Especially as a household who haven't done everything to maximise their income may still be eligible. I'm in one such household actually. We get full child benefit, with me working part time, but we wouldn't get any and would also only have the benefit of one personal allowance if the same wages were coming into a single parent household.

justfiveminutes · 23/07/2022 09:51

HMSSophia · 23/07/2022 09:34

Another fab Tory policy by the way.

Tbf it used to be universal. You could be earning millions and still get CB. Gradually removing it when earnings went over a certain amount was supposed to make it fairer.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 23/07/2022 09:44

Floralnomad · 22/07/2022 22:47

Nobody is saying that 50k is poverty stricken it’s a matter of unfairness which is why it should be on household total income . I actually think it would have been better to have left it at everyone gets it and cut other things like the FSM for all infants or perhaps capped it at 3 children per family . It is amazing to me that they can take CB away from people they perceive don’t need it but can’t do the same with the heating allowance for pensioners who don’t need it .

Free school meals are also there to help children who are neglected and not fed by parents at home. If those parents got CB they would still not feed them.

And fourth children also eat. In poverty stricken homes... do you think kids after the third shouldn't be helped?

Lb482 · 23/07/2022 09:41

BarbaraofSeville · 23/07/2022 09:33

It's also worth bearing in mind that if you're not sure how much you'll earn due to bonuses etc, you can claim the CB and pay back what you're not entitled to via a tax return, which if it's just for this purpose, it's a 10 minute job.

It's only if you know you're well above the threshold does it become not worth claiming at all.

We do this, one of us earns over £50k and the other less than half this. So we put all CB into a separate account, then if we haven’t managed to get taxable income down to £50k via pension then we pay it back from the account when we do the self assessment. What is then left is my budget for the year for clothes, classes etc. or put into account to pay towards childcare.

HMSSophia · 23/07/2022 09:34

Another fab Tory policy by the way.

BarbaraofSeville · 23/07/2022 09:33

It's also worth bearing in mind that if you're not sure how much you'll earn due to bonuses etc, you can claim the CB and pay back what you're not entitled to via a tax return, which if it's just for this purpose, it's a 10 minute job.

It's only if you know you're well above the threshold does it become not worth claiming at all.

Lb482 · 23/07/2022 09:29

mamatravels · 23/07/2022 06:54

This affected me - was on £51k as a single parent when this came in. When my children where 1 & 3 i lost CB, had to pay nursery fees and overnight cover when i travelled for work (often). My new tax rates were also.kicking in.

I had also sold my house due to marriage/divorce problems and was now paying 3 times as much in rent. It was tough to get to the end of the month then. Single parents with similar earnings/aged kids will be in an even tougher spot today.

As others have said this, plus tax regime are extremely unfair on single parents.

If you were paying to a pension you weren’t losing any CB

Lb482 · 23/07/2022 09:28

despicable · 23/07/2022 06:47

I cancelled it as hit 60k (with bonus, although pension would take it under) and received this letter.

Is this suggesting I reapply for it?

Yes if your salary sacrifice pension takes you under £60k then you still get some benefit. It’s worth sacrificing more salary down to £50k as your pension is your future income, and taking anything over £50k now you lose 43.25% in tax and NI and your child benefit so effectively over 50% if one child and 60% if 2+