Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the child benefit arrangements are unfair?

279 replies

MobLife · 22/07/2022 21:41

Only just clocked this and I'm still not 100% sure I've got it right because it seems wrong...
So if 2 parents are both earning £49,999 and hence taking in almost £100k household income they can continue to claim full CB

But

2 parents where the household income is way under that (lets say for arguments sake £70k) and one parent is earning the greater proportion (between £50-60k) will either get a much reduced CB amount or potentially nothing at all?

How is that fair??!

OP posts:
AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 24/07/2022 18:28

@SwanBuster thanks for that will double check as he definitely pays into a pension. If it is over And self assessment needs to be done do you have to pay it back in a lump sum or is taken back some other way?

SwanBuster · 24/07/2022 15:42

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 24/07/2022 15:34

sorry I know this thread isn’t about this but my DH made £50,000 before tax this tax year probably around £44,000 take home after taxes, pension etc what figure does it go off before we have to pay the tax charge?

50k before tax and NI and after deductions for pensions etc

www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-charge

Calculator here:

www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-calculator

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 24/07/2022 15:34

sorry I know this thread isn’t about this but my DH made £50,000 before tax this tax year probably around £44,000 take home after taxes, pension etc what figure does it go off before we have to pay the tax charge?

user1471447863 · 24/07/2022 15:05

There seems to be a bit of the usual mantra that anyone earning £50k is obviously a millionaire (actually in many threads that threshold is much much lower) and how dare they expect a penny more.
There seems to be an effort to level down than level up.

As for the idea that household income would be to difficult to work out - they seem pretty capable when it comes to catching up with those higher earners whose partners haven't stopped claiming CB.
A few colleagues have been caught out, and fined/paid back the over payment +daily interest. In one case his wife wears the financial trousers in their household and didn't stop claiming when the rules came in and it was him a couple of years later got the please explain letter and the several years of self assessment to fill in and pay for.
Another had mentioned it in passing with his wife when the change happened. His kids being late teens he had no idea if she was still recieving CB or not and having never had any dealing in it had no clue or control. Yet he too got the letter and request for payment.
So they are more than capable of figuring out household units and who earns how much when it suits.

Personally I feel it should be either universal - if it's aim was to put money in mother's hands for the upkeep of their children if they couldn't guarantee support from their husband (which is a separate issue in its own right and shouldn't be a thing) - or it should be scrapped and fed into some other means tested benefit stream.

As a single parent, in that part repayment earnings band (and paying the Scottish tax rates so automatically £1500 worse off) I do find the cut off pretty unfair as there is no 2nd household wage or a stay at home parent to offset things child care related.

SheeplessAndCounting · 24/07/2022 13:59

SwanBuster · 24/07/2022 00:08

The only thing that might bring about real change is the age related demographics. But give it a generation or three, and the same old issues will arise. It’s human nature. Most people are both ridiculously short termist, and myopically selfish.

I think you are right. I just don't want to believe it as it's so depressing. I like to think that just out of self-interest, if enough constiuents flood MPs inboxes complaining about an issue it will have an effect. But maybe it won't. Or maybe just not enough people care about it to do so. Sad

CaptainMerica · 24/07/2022 11:22

Child benefit should be a universal benefit, available to everyone, IMO. It is a clear statement that the well being of children is a priority. While not everyone needs it, the high earners are paying high taxes, and this, along with a basic state pension, should be considered the cost of having everyone's buy-in for a system where we pay taxes, often for the benefit of other people.

Palg68 · 24/07/2022 11:05

BadPhotographer · 24/07/2022 09:07

Good for you? I remember my dad used to work 60 hours a week. It was basically work, sleep and repeat. What sort of life is that?

Says the person complaining about poverty. The point completely went over your head quite clearly.

I often work extra to buy things I need not 60 hours as I can't... being a single parent. Because a life of poverty is no life either.

mewkins · 24/07/2022 10:39

alwayslearning789 · 24/07/2022 08:49

I remember when this policy was introduced, was in the deep midst of single parenting on a single income.

Thought it was really unfair at the time, as I was penalised for striving to earn more and then just when getting there...being beaten down.

I recall the 'Big Society' theme was being pushed around quite a bit at the time, and maybe I was being cynical but I thought it was subtlety 'discouraging' single parenthood and deliberately 'showing' that the family unit is ultimately better.

As if single parenting is what someone would consciously want to do if they could help it? No recognition of the factors driving it nor the impact.

I agree - this policy needs to be revisited. It is grossly unfair on those who are single for whatever reason.

You're right. Remember lockdown too? All the rules of lockdown one assumed a nuclear family. It was hellish for single parents with kids as well as lone elderly etc.

ApplesandBunions · 24/07/2022 10:04

We were a dual income household earning below 50k total not that long ago, and I still knew it was grossly unfair to single parents then.

GretaVanFleet · 24/07/2022 09:47

As a two income family whose gross income is under £50k I don’t think about the households where the sole parent or one of a couple earn over the threshold nor the family where both earn just under. We spend what we can afford and save what we can where we can. I have more concern for a sole parent earning well under £50k

BadPhotographer · 24/07/2022 09:07

Palg68 · 23/07/2022 21:23

Why is a single person in poverty? Before having ny Son I worked 60 hours a week.. I had 2 jobs. I had plenty of money not even that I had OPTIONS and FLEXIBILITY these things dramatically change if you are a parent, let alone a SINGLE PARENT.

Good for you? I remember my dad used to work 60 hours a week. It was basically work, sleep and repeat. What sort of life is that?

JustLyra · 24/07/2022 09:05

It’s never going to change.

By pissing off people who can afford it (and by that I mean people who feel the loss of CB, but it isn’t the very very very last straw of heat or eat) it gave the government free reign to attack other benefits with public support under the guise of “everyone is suffering”.

Universal credit and its farce, the nightmare of PIP, and the absolute decimation of widowed parents benefits all had a veneer of acceptability because “everyone” was taking a hit.

FriedasCarLoad · 24/07/2022 08:59

It's very unfair.

Married couples should also be allowed to file joint tax returns - as they can in vast majority of countries.

alwayslearning789 · 24/07/2022 08:57

It was said at the time it was due to 'HMRC Systems'...Well....look what has happened in the recent past with Covid Loans, Furlough, etc at very short notice.

I know they will say global pandemic but the issue of the Single Parents CB being unfairly taxed would surely be on a much smaller scale?

I agree with PP's who have suggested that we should look to rekindle this debate via MP's

alwayslearning789 · 24/07/2022 08:49

I remember when this policy was introduced, was in the deep midst of single parenting on a single income.

Thought it was really unfair at the time, as I was penalised for striving to earn more and then just when getting there...being beaten down.

I recall the 'Big Society' theme was being pushed around quite a bit at the time, and maybe I was being cynical but I thought it was subtlety 'discouraging' single parenthood and deliberately 'showing' that the family unit is ultimately better.

As if single parenting is what someone would consciously want to do if they could help it? No recognition of the factors driving it nor the impact.

I agree - this policy needs to be revisited. It is grossly unfair on those who are single for whatever reason.

SwanBuster · 24/07/2022 08:24

BarbaraofSeville · 24/07/2022 07:33

But that's hardly a typical situation. Very few families will be entitled to such a large amount of tax credits on that income plus they have more children than average anyway.

The loss for a 2 child household with no additional needs will be far lower.

Does it not being typical make it fine?

Should we really have interactions in our tax and benefit system where people lose money from their household working more?

I thought ‘making work pay’ was a thing.

In the case above - the person is better off cutting their hours, unless they can salary sacrifice the money.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/07/2022 07:33

SwanBuster · 23/07/2022 19:00

This is exasperating. If you don’t know about it, or seek to understand the issue then why comment! This is the same as earlier with that person who just kept saying ‘can’t be right’ and then messing up their own figures .

if people aren’t capable of understanding it, fine. but this family ends up with less net income on 50k than 60k. If you’re interested - read it again, if not don’t bother.

yes, you’re right - their income from the one job is as you say - but their household income - which is what counts is reduced for every £1 above 50k.

one more time I’ll spell it out

£1 earned

40p taken in income tax
3.25p take in Ni
33p Of child benefit taken away
41p of tax credits taken away

adds up to £1.1725 loss, on £1 earned.

But that's hardly a typical situation. Very few families will be entitled to such a large amount of tax credits on that income plus they have more children than average anyway.

The loss for a 2 child household with no additional needs will be far lower.

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/07/2022 07:19

As a single parent earning between 50 & 60k, I pay 40% paye, 12% NI and for every £ I earn, I lose 10p in child benefit, making my marginal tax return 62.5%

Fyi this is incorrect. Over the upper earnings limit (about 50k) your NI rate is only 3.25%. Your marginal tax rate is 53.25%.

I do think there should be some means of adjustment for single parents, especially those receiving little/no maintenance.

SwanBuster · 24/07/2022 00:10

But absolutely do keep writing. If nothing else, it’s a sense of doing something, and keeping your own perspective in check and shows deep integrity. That’s a good thing. 👍👍👍

SwanBuster · 24/07/2022 00:08

The only thing that might bring about real change is the age related demographics. But give it a generation or three, and the same old issues will arise. It’s human nature. Most people are both ridiculously short termist, and myopically selfish.

SwanBuster · 24/07/2022 00:05

SheeplessAndCounting · 23/07/2022 23:51

I agree with your suggestions 100% but it’ll never happen because the government does not care about single people (with or without children)

You're right. But that is because nobody is campaigning for this change. If MPs start getting lots of emails about this from constituents, it WILL change.

The question is how many will stand up and do this: write a simple email?

This is the only thing you’ve written that I disagree upon - but I do admire it 👍 I have close to zero faith sadly in our ‘democracy’ in this regard. I’ve written numerous letters over the years to both sitting MPs, candidates and journalists.

vanishingly few of them understand basic arithmetic, the unintended consequences of their systems - no matter how well intended etc. I genuinely believe the lobbyists and corporations that fund the political parties have become far, far too powerful for us to see any real change now. And it doesn’t matter which party is in power.

look at who we are about to get as PM. Both inept, just differently so and with an opposition who’s only current strength is the other side are even more stupid.

SheeplessAndCounting · 23/07/2022 23:51

I agree with your suggestions 100% but it’ll never happen because the government does not care about single people (with or without children)

You're right. But that is because nobody is campaigning for this change. If MPs start getting lots of emails about this from constituents, it WILL change.

The question is how many will stand up and do this: write a simple email?

SheeplessAndCounting · 23/07/2022 23:49

Lanesdown · 23/07/2022 22:09

Typical comments here like 50k income "you don't need it" How do you know they don't need it? With a single parent earning 50k likely comes with a big mortgage they are struggling with alone plus HUGE childcare costs because, yes they are a single WORKING parent to earn that 50k. So they doesn't deserve that benefit to help them out a bit as well? So many of these comments automatically assume there are two parents involved, it's shocking.

Yep. Always zero understanding of housing costs and childcare costs in different parts of the country. Do people think women choose to be poor?

rainbowmilk · 23/07/2022 22:49

SheeplessAndCounting · 23/07/2022 21:36

And @rainbowmilk I was actually homeless for a while when single and childless and got no help at all. I get your perspective. I think changing the system so that single people living alone also have double the tax free allowance etc would make a HUGE difference.

I agree with your suggestions 100% but it’ll never happen because the government does not care about single people (with or without children), sadly.

rainbowmilk · 23/07/2022 22:48

Palg68 · 23/07/2022 21:23

Why is a single person in poverty? Before having ny Son I worked 60 hours a week.. I had 2 jobs. I had plenty of money not even that I had OPTIONS and FLEXIBILITY these things dramatically change if you are a parent, let alone a SINGLE PARENT.

The simple answer to this is: not everyone is you. If you genuinely think the only reason anyone can be impoverished is by having children then I’ve no idea what to say to you except educate yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread