Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do you think of people who use SM if you don’t?

89 replies

JuniorTiger · 22/07/2022 21:34

I was chatting to my friend earlier and we were talking about social media. She cannot understand why anyone would post personal information of any nature / pictures of either themselves or their children on a social media platform claiming that people only do this to reach a much wider audience and need attention. She said pics and personal information should just be for WhatsApp group chats.

She said it makes her cringe that people are so self important they actually believe their SM ‘friends’ are interested in the details of their life. She was then laughing at all the people who go to restaurants and take a picture of their food to post online.

She went on to say how fake it all is and sad that so many people must need attention and self validation, also naive that because people ‘like’ their posts they must be their ‘friend’.

she was then scoffing at the people who air their dirty laundry on FB and saying how pathetic it was and that it was like the guests on ‘Jeremy Kyle’.

I was a little taken aback but then thought maybe she does have a fair point? So I wondered if people who don’t use social media share this view?

OP posts:
PiaPressure · 22/07/2022 22:15

DH has never had SM (he doesn't even have a phone). I have Facebook. He thinks people who use SM are incredibly stupid for sharing photos etc and he wishes I didn't use it, but I have no 'real life' friends and no family so it's my only contact with the outside world via groups related to my interests, so I can't really give it up. I don't share photos or statuses anymore though.

Bookshadow · 22/07/2022 22:15

But who has a public Facebook account? Almost nobody. Everyone on my Facebook has a private account. Only their family and friends can see it. In my case I have about 30 family members and fewer friends. I could put up details of when I was going on holidays if I wanted as they all know when I'm going anyway. I could put up pictures of my DC as they all know what they look like anyway.

Grooming gangs can only see pictures if they are public or if you accept friend requests from all and sundry. All of these issues are only issues of you sharing information with the internet. If you have a small private account and you want to show your aunties and close friends a few pictures of your DC taking their first steps I don't really see what the problem is.

QuandaleDingle · 22/07/2022 22:14

JazzyBBG · 22/07/2022 21:48

She's entitled to her view fair enough. But what I find weirder are the people who go on but pretend they don't! I know people on Facebook who never post anything or comment and will claim they don't go on. But if you put a story up BOOM they are always the first to look. What's that all about?

Haha yeah! Weirdos

Dalaidramailama · 22/07/2022 22:10

Oh one of those “I don’t use social media because I’m far too superior to engage in anything that any other mere mortal does”.

Alternatively there are people who aren’t interested in it but then don’t really have opinions about those who do use it because they just don’t care. The latter type being more my type of person.

The former being a self obsessed twat when without SM.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 22/07/2022 22:10

My mum is the same as your friend - she is 78 just can't get her head around it
I must admit l see their point about it being superficial.
But it can be a conversation starter if you have put something on and bump into someone you are friends with.
Like everything- if you have a healthy balance it can be a good thing - l helped a lady who had fallen over last week and am friends with her daughter on fb so was able to contact her- would never have her phone number so it was handy.

onepieceoflollipop · 22/07/2022 22:10

I don’t use any personal SM such as instagram or Facebook

some of my reasons:

  • personally I am quite sensitive and was spending too much time worrying about things on there, such as seeing close friends tagging each other, wondering why I hadn’t been invited etc. I switched it off 6 years ago after spotting someone (not very subtly) being nasty about me and a friend. My only emotion was mild relief that I had chosen to opt out.
  • I have teenage girls and like pp I have concerns about the pressure they are under to post so much on sm. I think it is unhelpful for many of our dcs especially in terms of emotional and mental well being.
  • I find it sad that some people seem to prioritise sm over ‘real life’ - if your honeymoon/holiday/anniversary dinner is so special, why not focus on the event instead of updates and photos?!
  • I find some people’s constant sharing rather self absorbed. Makes me cringe sometimes.
  • I find it sad that at events (such as parties, concerts etc) a significant number of people won’t be in the moment enjoying it but will be filming, updating etc. this may include the tagging people who would rather not be tagged, or at times posting unflattering photos that friends would rather they didn’t.
  • yes also agree with pp point about children - not so much paedophiles but more so the dcs lack of consent to agree to parents posting so much.
  • I find it undignified and inappropriate at times when some people seem in a rush to post about events, even when it might be insensitive or not really their place to do so.e.g. Posting about a death or birth. Oh and sometimes this is the only announcement so you may not find out till later (or ever!) …if you are not on sm you quickly find out that some friends cba to update you personally. Up to them entirely of course.
CuriousCatfish · 22/07/2022 22:08

Your friend sounds like one of those annoying superior know it alls.

Sartre · 22/07/2022 22:06

Your friend sounds a bit insecure tbh. I don’t use SM, I quit it all together almost 2 years ago after I got totally out of hand using Instagram. Never really been into Facebook, I was a fan of MySpace in my teens and Facebook never really did it for me. I honestly have zilch opinion on it, most people use it and I really don’t care. There’s certainly annoying attention seeking behaviours on there but I don’t have to see it anymore so it doesn’t affect me at all 🤷🏻‍♀️.

Your friend is like a vegan who just can’t quite understand why anyone else wouldn’t want to be a vegan. In other words, she’s annoying as fuck.

PlanetNormal · 22/07/2022 22:05

I have no social media accounts, and I never have. (MN is an anonymous forum, and my profile is not linked to my real identity). I’m not on FB, Instagram, tick tock etc at all. I have a Twitter account under a false name which I use to follow news outlets & senior journalists but I don’t tweet myself and have no followers.

I don’t profess to be an expert on SM, obviously, but from what I have seen of it, the biggest problem with it is that idiots were allowed access to it. I did once look through my local area’s FB pages and they were a moronic semi-literate cesspit of ignorance, racism and personal abuse. I don’t feel I am missing out on much.

FunDragon · 22/07/2022 22:02

I think it’s possible to have a healthy relationship with social media.

However, generally speaking, I’ve noticed that the more people post on SM, the more unhappy and insecure they seem to be in real life.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 22/07/2022 22:02

Its her opinion. I find that like most things it takes a bit of practice to get the most out of it, but a lot of people dont invest any time in honing.

madasawethen · 22/07/2022 22:01

Posting pictures of children isn't a good idea.
I'm sort of stuck with fb as my relatives use it to communicate.
I have to laugh at some holiday photos. They aren't just holiday photos, they involve flowing gowns and a bunch of posed things.

SomethingOnce · 22/07/2022 22:01

Nobody will look back on their life and think hours performing semi-fiction on social media was a good use of their time on Earth.

Bubblebubblebah · 22/07/2022 21:58

*. She said pics and personal information should just be for WhatsApp group chats.

She said it makes her cringe that people are so self important they actually believe their SM ‘friends’ are interested in the details of their life*

Yeah, she is just moving it off sites to the whatsapp group. It's actually very much the same if people use SM just with friends and family, except that on SM they can at least ignore some posts😂 not on forced what's app group😂

girlfriend44 · 22/07/2022 21:58

Yes never understand the holiday photos as well while your away. Open advert to a burglar. Like I said they are addicted and can't stop.

3luckystars · 22/07/2022 21:57

I feel sorry for them, because for a lot of people it is part of their job and I would HATE that. I don’t really care or see what people post so I couldn’t care any less but I’m just glad it has nothing to do with my job and I can avoid it completely !!

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 22/07/2022 21:56

I don't mind seeing people's meals, especially if it's from a restaurant because it might make me go there or discover new places.
Homemade stuff I'm happy to see and 'like' if it's something new for them. I share things I'm proud of.

Those who post every thought in their head or everything thats happened to them, or worse, if they straight up lie are muted/unfollowed/unfriended.

Not my place to complain about what they do on their page, but my choice to remove them from my feed.

Also, I love seeing my friends kids and families. I have friends all over the world and love seeing what they're up to, commenting on each others photos etc. It's nice to see.

WarnerSisters · 22/07/2022 21:55

Agree with your friend. SM generally is a sinkhole of vanity and self-indulgence, no matter how people want to justify it.

Naimee87 · 22/07/2022 21:54

Totally agree with your friend! In my opinion SM adds no value whatsoever to anyone’s life, it’s self-indulgent and superficial. Surely if your are living a life you can’t have time to post every minute of it. I have no SM apart from MN. I do have a 13yr old and it’s unbelievably scary how online his world is. The competitiveness that goes on. It could also be a generational thing for me i’m 35, gave up my IG and FB accounts years ago and don’t miss them at all looking back i can’t even believe i actually had SM accounts at all.

WTF475878237NC · 22/07/2022 21:53

I use information and support sites to get answers to specific questions I have. So not social media in the sense of forming or maintaining social connections such as Facebook. I agree with your friend. I'm not on things like Facebook because I don't care about anyone's life even to see what they think or do everyday and certainly wouldn't expect anyone to care about mine. The people I do care about update me personally on their lives when we catch up, speak or email, and vice versa, but it's a conversation between us, not a generic statement for their "fans" too.

Catlover77 · 22/07/2022 21:53

I feel exactly the same as your friend

BettyOBarley · 22/07/2022 21:51

DH says exactly the same as your friend (pretty much word for word). He just can't fathom it (and he's only 38 so grown up with it being a big thing).
Not me obviously! I use SM but I've stopped posting anything personal in the last couple of years, I just use FB for groups and events.

Boxowine · 22/07/2022 21:51

Facebook was actually great when it first came out. Just remember when we used it to catch up with old friends, picking your favorite cartoon character as a profile pic, planking, the ice bucket challenge? That one actually left to medical breakthroughs. It was a force for good.

Then came Cambridge Analytica.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 22/07/2022 21:51

Are you looking to write an article?

FlorettaB · 22/07/2022 21:51

I don’t use social media. Your friend was being an ass. I don’t have any particular feelings about adults who use social media. I feel sorry for teenagers now because I know how difficult it was to be a teenager without social media. The added pressure of social media must be awful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread