Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do you think of people who use SM if you don’t?

89 replies

JuniorTiger · 22/07/2022 21:34

I was chatting to my friend earlier and we were talking about social media. She cannot understand why anyone would post personal information of any nature / pictures of either themselves or their children on a social media platform claiming that people only do this to reach a much wider audience and need attention. She said pics and personal information should just be for WhatsApp group chats.

She said it makes her cringe that people are so self important they actually believe their SM ‘friends’ are interested in the details of their life. She was then laughing at all the people who go to restaurants and take a picture of their food to post online.

She went on to say how fake it all is and sad that so many people must need attention and self validation, also naive that because people ‘like’ their posts they must be their ‘friend’.

she was then scoffing at the people who air their dirty laundry on FB and saying how pathetic it was and that it was like the guests on ‘Jeremy Kyle’.

I was a little taken aback but then thought maybe she does have a fair point? So I wondered if people who don’t use social media share this view?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
50mg · 23/07/2022 18:57

FB has beenn lifechanging for me. I've been to so many things that I wouldn't that I wouldn't have know anything about without it and received a lot of invitations too a casual "does anyone fancy" that I wouldn't have otherwise seen. Also direct invitations via FB messenger from people I wouldn't have necessarily swapped numbers with I.e an aquaintance through a hobby.

All my FB friends are people I genuinely know, but not necessarily close friends. TBH I don't see many of the gloating posts or people posting their food. I don't share those things myself either. Most of my feed is sports, politics, events and occasionally photos from social things.

MMBaranova · 23/07/2022 18:30

I cut down to a core four or five years ago. Facebook went, which was something of a relief. I post little on what I have now and often get timely information from what remains.

Many of my friends have done much the same (I was born in 1990). One however still says ‘On Facebook…’ to me as if I am deprived and another will say ‘…on Mumsnet’ a lot, while failing to register I am recognisable on here.

littlepeas · 23/07/2022 18:17

Whoops! Social media, not social Jesus!

littlepeas · 23/07/2022 18:16

I agree with your friend. I also strongly dislike how people who work in my industry use social Jesus - it’s almost entirely pointless showing off.

BadPhotographer · 23/07/2022 18:12

maranella · 23/07/2022 09:32

I feel exactly the same as your friend. I also think it's sad that people aren't just enjoying their lives, spending times with their friends and families, enjoying eating out or being on holiday, and that they spend (sometimes a large part of their time) posing for and taking photos specifically to upload them onto social media. It strikes me as utterly narcissistic. But narcissism seems to be the norm these days.

I do find it odd that when some people are on holiday, they're constantly posting on SM about it. You're clearly not enjoying your holiday that much if you're constantly posting. I actually came off it for a week when I had my last holiday.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 23/07/2022 17:34

My social media is part of my career ñ. I need to reach an audience to reach my targets.

So I think it's useful. I also get to see pics of my nephew and cousins children who I see maybe once a year otherwise.

lljkk · 23/07/2022 11:28

As if "forums" like MN aren't full of BS, too.

Not least because we can post anonymously.
<eye rolling>

SafeMove · 23/07/2022 10:31

Is obsession with social media any worse/better than being obsessed with how other people live their lives? Why are you bothered how other people use SM? If it's not for you, fine, crack on but why project that onto others?

Trying to police others behaviours and say what people should or should not be doing on SM is seeking validation for your own choice for goodness sake, it is easy to see that.

Feedback from other humans is how we have organised ourselves for thousands of years and has created excellent systems to encourage human development (for example justice systems, health systems, social systems) the fact that in the last 20 years this has come from SM is just a new method of delivery for validation. We have been seeking and giving validation for thousands of years and there is nothing wrong with it. It is essential. Clapping and smiling at a child when they roll over, take their first step, say their first word is the start and we carry on wanting and giving that throughout life. SM is just another tool fir human interaction isn't it?

Chakraleaf · 23/07/2022 09:46

Holiday photos and excessive posting every time you go somewhere is ott

JuniorTiger · 23/07/2022 09:45

daisychain01 · 23/07/2022 09:30

Knows my address
Is a criminal who is on the lookout for empty houses to burgle

perhaps not you, but in general, people who overshare on social media tend to be scarily ignorant about how cybercrime works and therefore underestimates what it takes for their account security to be compromised, their data to be triangulated across multiple SM platforms and the repercussions of that.

just like people who happily post with alacrity on MN thread "what is your Grandfather's name" "What is your salary and your job title" etc etc. Harvesting data is a multi-faceted activity and people think meh this is an anonymous forum. Until Bang! The site gets hacked.

This is interesting- this is the sort of thing my friend says about how ignorant people are about cyber crime, but when she says this others roll their eyes and call her ‘dramatic’ and say she watches too much tv.
I am not sure whether this is a complete embellishment of reality or whether I’m a bit blissfully ignorant as well. Unless you work in the area of cyber crime I guess you wouldn’t really know if this was an accurate description or not?

Also something which makes me think twice is the use of meta data and how this information is used. Again something I’m not knowledgeable about but a lot of people do not seemed phased or concerned about this.

OP posts:
Raul57 · 23/07/2022 09:44

Not meaning to offend anyone and probably just my luck. Those I've seen via work/clients and relatives that post almost everything on SM are often of a type I avoid as much as possible. They are often loud-ish, live beyond their means, are artificial to an extent and not aware of the dangers that surround them when they offer too much info via sM and their gob.

I guess the above would say that I was boring, too strict, backwards, an introvert and cared too much what others say.

SM and mobile phones the smart one have resulted in may break-up that otherwise would never have occurred is my belief.

ChiTorpedo · 23/07/2022 09:42

Personally I find it sad when I look at my friends' Instagrams (not a model, just regular people posting pictures of family stuff etc) and they've done so much editing they (and sometimes even worse, their family) become barely recognisable. It's not just mild filters either, but full on wrinkle-erasing, body-contouring, skin colour-changing photoshop work.

Think the whole obsession with Instagram has also contributed to people having an unrealistic outlook on life and people.

It's only going to get worse now that people are becoming increasingly isolated (it's almost cool even, in some circles, to be socially isolated and not leave the house) and have no contact with people outside of social media!

x2boys · 23/07/2022 09:38

maranella · 23/07/2022 09:32

I feel exactly the same as your friend. I also think it's sad that people aren't just enjoying their lives, spending times with their friends and families, enjoying eating out or being on holiday, and that they spend (sometimes a large part of their time) posing for and taking photos specifically to upload them onto social media. It strikes me as utterly narcissistic. But narcissism seems to be the norm these days.

Well it isn't, people often use the term narcissism as a throwaway comment usually about something/ someone they don't like but most people are not narcissistic.

Howabsolutelyfanfuckingtastic · 23/07/2022 09:36

ouch321 · 22/07/2022 23:38

I don't touch it and never have but I'm in a small minority, I'd guess 90% of people have one or more of the main ones eg Facebook, Twitter, Tiktok and Instagram.

I don't think it's been a good thing in general for society, one of the significant downsides of the introduction of the internet.

(And to poster up above, Mumsnet is not social media, it's a forum. They're not the same thing.)

This pretty much sums up what i was going to say.

x2boys · 23/07/2022 09:35

Does it matter how people use social media?I have had a facebook account for over 12 years ,I never post anything personal on it ,I use it mainly for support groups ,but if someone wants to post every detail of their life on social media who cares,just scroll down.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 23/07/2022 09:33

There are different ways to use social media. Accounts can be set to private so that only friends can see them. I have under 100 friends, all people I know and like, on both Instagram and Facebook. I have friends all over the UK plus abroad and I like that it’s a way to share photos or updates. I don’t post often but when I’ve been abroad sometimes stated the odd picture or might share big news like graduating uni etc rather than tell everyone individually. The majority of friends I have who share photos of their kids also have private accounts with only friends added and only post photos occasionally.

I do have a few friends with public Instagram pages, they’re also the ones who are posting daily or close to. I have one who only posts selfies of himself and another who posts at least daily updates of her kids and is always showcasing her kids using products/ toys and tagging in the brands in the hope of free stuff. I do find those kinds of pages a bit cringey and have those friends muted so I don’t have to see the endless updates but each to their own really.

maranella · 23/07/2022 09:32

I feel exactly the same as your friend. I also think it's sad that people aren't just enjoying their lives, spending times with their friends and families, enjoying eating out or being on holiday, and that they spend (sometimes a large part of their time) posing for and taking photos specifically to upload them onto social media. It strikes me as utterly narcissistic. But narcissism seems to be the norm these days.

daisychain01 · 23/07/2022 09:30

Knows my address
Is a criminal who is on the lookout for empty houses to burgle

perhaps not you, but in general, people who overshare on social media tend to be scarily ignorant about how cybercrime works and therefore underestimates what it takes for their account security to be compromised, their data to be triangulated across multiple SM platforms and the repercussions of that.

just like people who happily post with alacrity on MN thread "what is your Grandfather's name" "What is your salary and your job title" etc etc. Harvesting data is a multi-faceted activity and people think meh this is an anonymous forum. Until Bang! The site gets hacked.

Raul57 · 23/07/2022 09:22

I use forums but I don't post my life on SM and TBH don't use it other than once added my name to it to access others info and soon deleted the account as it was just as the OP's friend stated

SM causes so many fallouts and over things, you would not fallout over if you spoke to the other

When people live their lives on SM, steer clear of them as they are IMO ticking time bombs, EG, why did you not say my pics were nice, ignore me, posted your similar pics, left me out of pics, put in pic someone I don't like, buy the same dog as me, showing off, etc etc. Avoid at all costs IMO.

daisychain01 · 23/07/2022 09:21

I like your friend's style.

Im not on Fb Twitter Insta or any of that cannon fodder.

my life is immeasurably the richer, the happier and the more meaningful for that absence. And I have a lot more time to live a real life, rather than a fake one.

Stellaroses · 23/07/2022 09:21

Some pp are on a very high horse! I am busy living real life too, but every few days I have a sit down a flick through the “magazine” that is SM.

Stellaroses · 23/07/2022 09:19

I don’t really recognise the descriptions some of you give of SM.
It depends who you follow. On insta I don’t follow any posing influencer types and my feed is full of craft, talented artists, gardening tips - the house decor ones are the only ones showing-off, but I like to see nice houses.
My own profile is private so only actual friends and family see it. It is what you make of it. I mostly post my cats or my vegetable patch?
My teen son also has insta because he likes to follow football players and clubs, but isn’t allowed to post. His feed is just full of fball speculation/opinions.
I’ve never seen bullying, self indulgence or ignorance that I can recall. If I did, I’d unfollow. Simple really.

BlueWhat · 23/07/2022 09:15

Who gives a shit what your friend or anyone on mnet thinks.

  • I don't understand people who don't want to travel.
  • I don't understand people who don't want to educate themselves.
  • I don't understand why people don't read books every day.
  • I really don't understand the popularity of Snapchat.

But you know what? I don't need to understand, everyone is different!

So what if someone wants to take a picture of their dinner?

Fuck sake your friend sounds judgemental and and nasty. Is she generally a negative person?

EllieQ · 23/07/2022 09:12

girlfriend44 · 23/07/2022 00:22

You don't know who they could tell though. Best to put your pics up if you need to when your home.

😂I’m going to assume you’re joking with that ridiculous comment about ‘you don’t know who your FB friends could tell about your holiday’ because if you’re not, it makes you look stupid, quite frankly.

While it’s plausible that one of my FB friends could mention to someone else ‘EllieQ is on holiday this week, they’ve gone to Spain, lucky them, I can’t wait for our holiday’ - that kind of thing, it is really fucking unlikely that the person they speak to:


  • Knows my address

  • Is a criminal who is on the lookout for empty houses to burgle


What kind of people do you and your friends hang around with??

LIareggub · 23/07/2022 08:53

It's terrible for bullying, humiliation and mocking people

Sounds a bit like some corners of MN tbh 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread