Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You're in administration are you?"

343 replies

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 22/07/2022 19:28

Waiting for a train and a guy started chatting to me to pass the time. Told me he had a 51 year old son so he must be in his 70s. When he discovered I work at a university he asked me the question in the subject line.

I asked him what made him say that and he just shrugged. I didn't say so, but I suspect it's because I'm a woman and also his generation.

Unreasonable to be wryly amused/slightly miffed? Not the first time it's happened and always men that say it.

Not that I'm saying there's anything wrong with working in administration either btw.

OP posts:
Walkaround · 23/07/2022 15:12

Also, @brookstar, what’s with the assumption that someone thinks you couldn’t possibly be an academic if they assume something else first off? When it comes to use of language and assumptions, if you are a person who finds assumptions problematic, then you have no business making so many assumptions of your own. If someone thinks you are an administrator and you are not, you could be flattered they appear to think you have excellent organisational and managerial abilities if you made different assumptions about administrators, rather than apparently assuming yourself, or assuming that everyone else assumes, that an academic could be an administrator if they so wished, but an administrator would never be capable of being an academic.

brookstar · 23/07/2022 15:11

I’m not assuming you are referring to female staff, I’m saying you think the admin roles are worth less, as assumptions about roles have no particular bite otherwise.
Wrong. I'm not saying these roles are worth less. I don't believe that at all - I used to do one of those roles. It's about assuming women aren't capable of doing an academic role.

When people make these assumptions, you also make assumptions about what they mean by it, and your assumptions always diminish the role they refer to to the lowest possible level. You assume they are thinking the “lowest of the low,” you don’t assume administration in the person’s head could mean head of the civil service, for example. Well, in my head, administration does not mean typing up letters for people and I really don’t think that’s what it would mean in the head of someone in their 70s either. Secretaries were not referred to as administrators when that man was in the world of work and administrators were not predominantly women.

You're making some huge assumptions here. I don't think administration means typing letters. My area of study is career development and specifically womens career development. It's my job to know about jobs. It's also my job to research unconscious bias around job roles specifically in relation to sec based stereotypes.

You're really missing the point I'm making, it's not about the administration job, they could have said any non-academic job (some of which pay significantly more than an academic role) it's the assumption that women aren't academics. It's about looking at a woman who works at a university and assuming she does any job other than being an academic.

As I've mentioned im an academic and my husband works in professional services. He is more senior than me and earns significantly more. People always assume he is the academic and that I do his job. It pisses me off, not because people assume I work in professional services but because people assume I'm not an academic.

So, it really depends on your own bias as to the assumptions you make, and yours appears to be very negatively inclined towards any reference to administration.

I think you could do with checking your own biases as you've made a number of incorrect assumptions about me.
At no point have I suggested I'm negative about administrative roles. I'm just sick of people assuming women aren't academics!

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 23/07/2022 15:02

AdelaideRo · 22/07/2022 19:54

Being picked up from work in an uber at 3am (work = hospital).

Uber driver "oh are you a nurse?".

My male colleagues never get asked that.

Is it not because there are probably more nurses in a hospital than any other profession so that was most likely?

EerieSilence · 23/07/2022 14:51

Talking about a new car I'm buying, getting asked: so, what car did your DH pick for you?
The colleague who asked the question didn't forget the answer yet and it's been few years.

Elphame · 23/07/2022 14:49

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/07/2022 19:55

Me too!

and me!

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 14:48

brookstar · 23/07/2022 14:24

When I'm praising my course management team I'm referring to my male school manager, the male senior course administrator, the female student records manger, the female course administrator and the male course assistant.

Why are you assuming we're referring to female staff?

Again, it's not about being referred to as administrative staff. It's the assumption that we couldn't possibly be academics. There's a difference.

@brookstar - I’m not assuming you are referring to female staff, I’m saying you think the admin roles are worth less, as assumptions about roles have no particular bite otherwise. You are bitten by them though, aren’t you? When people make these assumptions, you also make assumptions about what they mean by it, and your assumptions always diminish the role they refer to to the lowest possible level. You assume they are thinking the “lowest of the low,” you don’t assume administration in the person’s head could mean head of the civil service, for example. Well, in my head, administration does not mean typing up letters for people and I really don’t think that’s what it would mean in the head of someone in their 70s either. Secretaries were not referred to as administrators when that man was in the world of work and administrators were not predominantly women. So, it really depends on your own bias as to the assumptions you make, and yours appears to be very negatively inclined towards any reference to administration.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 23/07/2022 14:46

Unwavering721 · 23/07/2022 14:33

I think you are missing the point - why would you be offended if you are admin? Are you too good for that sort of job? He took a pot luck chance at guessing your job role within the uni, maybe because you were friendly and chatty he thought it was unlikely you were a snooty academic who looks down on others. Ironic really 😂

I can't believe you've said this after 8 or 9 pages as it's clear you're the one missing the point. You've probably only read the first post and maybe a couple of others.

OP posts:
brookstar · 23/07/2022 14:37

maybe because you were friendly and chatty he thought it was unlikely you were a snooty academic who looks down on others.

I wonder if the man who laughed in my face and said 'fuck off, that's not your job' just thought I was friendly and chatty 🤷🏼‍♀️ maybe I should have been flattered 🤔

Unwavering721 · 23/07/2022 14:33

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 22/07/2022 19:53

My point is that the first thing that apparently popped into his head is that I'm an administrator because I'm female. I told him I'm an academic and he didn't have much to say to that!

I think you are missing the point - why would you be offended if you are admin? Are you too good for that sort of job? He took a pot luck chance at guessing your job role within the uni, maybe because you were friendly and chatty he thought it was unlikely you were a snooty academic who looks down on others. Ironic really 😂

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 23/07/2022 14:32

Spot on.

OP posts:
brookstar · 23/07/2022 14:24

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 14:13

So yes, you are all 100% buying into an unconscious bias, however much you spout the platitudes that you couldn’t cope with all your wonderfully underpaid, sexist-stereotype underlings. It sounds exactly like men who used to say they couldn’t cope without their secretary/PA.

When I'm praising my course management team I'm referring to my male school manager, the male senior course administrator, the female student records manger, the female course administrator and the male course assistant.

Why are you assuming we're referring to female staff?

Again, it's not about being referred to as administrative staff. It's the assumption that we couldn't possibly be academics. There's a difference.

brookstar · 23/07/2022 14:20

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 14:09

The fact remains, it is always women being offended by these assumptions. Nobody ever suggests a man should be offended if it is assumed he is a medical doctor or university professor. The fact remains, women are offended by “sexist assumptions” because female dominated roles are underpaid and looked down upon for no good reason - there would be no reason whatsoever otherwise to take offence at any assumptions made.

Why do you think it's women who are offended by this? I mean, it seems obvious to me but you seem to think we've missed something.

Do you think sex based stereotypes aren't a problem? Do you not think they're worth challenging?
Do you think i should just find it amusing that people assume my husband is an academic instead of me? And when I use the title Dr Brook that people assume that's my husband?

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 14:13

So yes, you are all 100% buying into an unconscious bias, however much you spout the platitudes that you couldn’t cope with all your wonderfully underpaid, sexist-stereotype underlings. It sounds exactly like men who used to say they couldn’t cope without their secretary/PA.

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 14:09

The fact remains, it is always women being offended by these assumptions. Nobody ever suggests a man should be offended if it is assumed he is a medical doctor or university professor. The fact remains, women are offended by “sexist assumptions” because female dominated roles are underpaid and looked down upon for no good reason - there would be no reason whatsoever otherwise to take offence at any assumptions made.

brookstar · 23/07/2022 12:42

I tend to agree. I could not do my job without professional service staff.

Me neither. They're that backbone of my university- my course management team are fabulous.

RhubarbCheekbones · 23/07/2022 12:40

Oh, posted too soon. I actually became an academic, and a significant number of students assumed that two women in an office must mean we were the secretaries, despite the fact that our titles were clearly marked on the door. Never happened to the two male junior lecturers next door…

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 23/07/2022 12:39

DangerouslyBored · 23/07/2022 12:23

I couldn’t agree more and would like to see some of the posters who have taken offence at the notion that they might be a lowly administrator do my role for the day. They wouldn’t last 5 minutes 😂 oh and I’m educated, paid v well and respected.

Some people really do need to get over themselves 🙄

I tend to agree. I could not do my job without professional service staff.

OP posts:
RhubarbCheekbones · 23/07/2022 12:38

Thus is reminding me of the time when an older man at a dinner party given by my friends’ parents just couldn’t get his head around the fact I was at Oxford (which is how I knew the friend -/ we’d gone to visit in the vac). ‘At the secretarial college, I assume?’ is what he actually said, then he haw-hawed and tried to make me admit I was at Oxford Brookes. He looked very out out.

brookstar · 23/07/2022 12:37

couldn’t agree more and would like to see some of the posters who have taken offence at the notion that they might be a lowly administrator do my role for the day. They wouldn’t last 5 minutes 😂 oh and I’m educated, paid v well and respected.

Some people really do need to get over themselves 🙄

Who is taking offence at being called an administrator? If you think that's what people have issue with then you've misunderstood.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 23/07/2022 12:33

Its just the Patriarchy talking.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 23/07/2022 12:32

Whitehorsegirl · 23/07/2022 07:41

Somebody got it right in a previous message. You said you ''worked'' at a university which suggest you have an office/support job there.

A lecturer would have worded it differently. Just like a teacher would not say ''I work in a school'' but ''I am a teacher'' or ''I teach art'' instead.

Yes, it could be due to sexism and the expectation that women are in support roles (although we also should not look down on admin staff...) but it also could just be basic common sense.

Question: Where is it you work
Answer: University X, Y building

If I'd told him exactly what I did in answer to that and given title I bet I'd have been accused of being smug and condescending to an old guy.

As it happens he asked me if I was in admin, I asked him why he thought that, he shrugged and then I said I teach (STEM subject). I didn't mention anything about the research side which would have no doubt been doubly smug.

He then asked me if I knew a guy called Graham who taught the same subject. In a school. I didn't!

OP posts:
DangerouslyBored · 23/07/2022 12:23

justhereforthisthread · 23/07/2022 10:41

There's also the assumption that admin is an easy job that anyone can do. Most admin jobs these days aren't yet so many people seem to look down on the role. I suspect a lot of people in the roles above would have the shock of their life if they had to do that type of work for any length of time. Either that or they would do it very badly.

I couldn’t agree more and would like to see some of the posters who have taken offence at the notion that they might be a lowly administrator do my role for the day. They wouldn’t last 5 minutes 😂 oh and I’m educated, paid v well and respected.

Some people really do need to get over themselves 🙄

brookstar · 23/07/2022 12:21

I'm amazed that so many people - especially women - don't get why this is sexist and infuriating.

Me too!

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 23/07/2022 12:21

@brookstar I don't read this as someone taking offence at being called an administrator. Surely the issue is with sex based stereotypes?

And you'd be perfectly correct. I can't believe people didn't understand that.

OP posts:
bloodyunicorns · 23/07/2022 12:19

I'm amazed that so many people - especially women - don't get why this is sexist and infuriating.

Why didn't he just ask 'what do you do?' Instead of assuming?!