Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You're in administration are you?"

343 replies

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 22/07/2022 19:28

Waiting for a train and a guy started chatting to me to pass the time. Told me he had a 51 year old son so he must be in his 70s. When he discovered I work at a university he asked me the question in the subject line.

I asked him what made him say that and he just shrugged. I didn't say so, but I suspect it's because I'm a woman and also his generation.

Unreasonable to be wryly amused/slightly miffed? Not the first time it's happened and always men that say it.

Not that I'm saying there's anything wrong with working in administration either btw.

OP posts:
brookstar · 23/07/2022 19:46

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 19:36

@brookstar - well, you know the older man and I don’t, so it may well be sexist, but I wouldn’t find it odd for my dh to be asked if I was babysitting, or vice versa, if one of us was out for a drink without the other one evening, when our children were small enough to need babysitting. I have no experience of mutual friends and acquaintances suggesting my dh can be described as a babysitter of his own children and I cannot, or that it is somehow offensive to describe staying in to look after the kids while your other half is out having fun, as babysitting. It’s what someone would be doing if we were both out without our children, so just a lazy way of finding out whether we have a babysitter, or one of us is being the “babysitter” that night.

I'm sorry but I find it hard to believe that your DH has ever been asked if you are babysitting your children.
I think you're being deliberately facetious now.....

It's a well known phenomenon that when men look after their own children it's considered 'babysitting'. Nobody ever uses this language towards women.

DarkShade · 23/07/2022 19:43

I can see how your case is different because you were specifically talking about the location of your workplace. But also to be fair, most people who say they work in a university are admin because if you're an academic you say "I'm an academic".

Julie89uk · 23/07/2022 19:40

I'd have said the same tbh.. Normally when people teach they say

"i lecture/teach at xxxx university"...

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 19:36

@brookstar - well, you know the older man and I don’t, so it may well be sexist, but I wouldn’t find it odd for my dh to be asked if I was babysitting, or vice versa, if one of us was out for a drink without the other one evening, when our children were small enough to need babysitting. I have no experience of mutual friends and acquaintances suggesting my dh can be described as a babysitter of his own children and I cannot, or that it is somehow offensive to describe staying in to look after the kids while your other half is out having fun, as babysitting. It’s what someone would be doing if we were both out without our children, so just a lazy way of finding out whether we have a babysitter, or one of us is being the “babysitter” that night.

MsBombastic555 · 23/07/2022 19:24

Normally I wouldn't. But I don't know some men make such stupid comments sometimes they are begging for it. There are tens/hundreds of jobs she could be doing at a university, it's stupid to assume.

MsBombastic555 · 23/07/2022 19:20

😂😂 this.

brookstar · 23/07/2022 18:53

There are so many kinder interpretations of his faux pas that do not immediately boil down to sexism and it is frankly a shame if simple interactions are so easily poisoned.

Unfortunately when you experience sexism time and time again it becomes quite difficult to ignore and easier to recognise. In most cases it's not intentional and is the result of deeply ingrained unconscious biases and stereotypes but it's still frustrating.

For example, I've come out for a drink with my friends. An older man I know just asked me if DH is babysitting. It's a sexist comment that DH would never get asked.
There was no malice behind it but it's still sexist and I rolled my eyes.

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 18:48

And this thread is a case in point - two people apparently being friendly and chatting to pass the time of day and the atmosphere is suddenly poisoned by a simple question that was clearly never intended to cause offence, but merely trying to extend the conversation. He may have known someone who worked in administration at the university, but felt more out of his depth trying to establish connections with an academic, if that wasn’t his own background. There are so many kinder interpretations of his faux pas that do not immediately boil down to sexism and it is frankly a shame if simple interactions are so easily poisoned.

justhereforthisthread · 23/07/2022 18:44

Once again, another thread on Mumsnet where it makes me realise that whatever you say someone will be offended.

I have come to the conclusion that I have probably spent my whole life offending people!

brookstar · 23/07/2022 18:36

SpeakingMyThoughts · 23/07/2022 18:31

Strange what can cause irritation in some folk.
Some are fortunate to have work.

Their pound buys the same.
Strange.

It's not a race to the bottom!!
It's still important to challenge unconscious bias!

brookstar · 23/07/2022 18:35

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 18:28

@brookstar - it does sound more like the stereotype of an academic in general is the main problem you face, rather than your sex Grin. I should imagine they would be equally incredulous if a young man who dressed and looked like a bodybuilder said he was an academic and his older wife who looked like Mary Beard said she was a hairdresser or director.

As for assumptions and pronouns, tbh, whatever pronoun is used these days, it seems to cause a problem of one sort or another - if one says “one,” one is made to feel archaic and unnatural; use “you,” and people take comments personally rather than understanding them to be generalisations; “they,” and some people find this confusing and think it is intended to be a plural; “he” and it is offensive because it cannot be used to as a shorthand for either sex; he/she and it is unwieldy, tiresome to keep using and doesn’t account for gender neutrality. It is quite hard to communicate these days in a way that is universally understood and tolerated, because everyone has a different reason to take offence and very few oeople are willing to be tolerant and give someone the benefit of the doubt.

But sex does play a part. I'm not making that up! There's plenty of research to support that.
Im not just basing it on my experience- although it does illustrate the point!

That doesn't mean everyone assumes that all academics are male or that it happens to all academics, but it is a thing!

I chair my university's Athena Swan committee- it's a particular passion of mine.

SpeakingMyThoughts · 23/07/2022 18:31

Strange what can cause irritation in some folk.
Some are fortunate to have work.

Their pound buys the same.
Strange.

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 18:28

@brookstar - it does sound more like the stereotype of an academic in general is the main problem you face, rather than your sex Grin. I should imagine they would be equally incredulous if a young man who dressed and looked like a bodybuilder said he was an academic and his older wife who looked like Mary Beard said she was a hairdresser or director.

As for assumptions and pronouns, tbh, whatever pronoun is used these days, it seems to cause a problem of one sort or another - if one says “one,” one is made to feel archaic and unnatural; use “you,” and people take comments personally rather than understanding them to be generalisations; “they,” and some people find this confusing and think it is intended to be a plural; “he” and it is offensive because it cannot be used to as a shorthand for either sex; he/she and it is unwieldy, tiresome to keep using and doesn’t account for gender neutrality. It is quite hard to communicate these days in a way that is universally understood and tolerated, because everyone has a different reason to take offence and very few oeople are willing to be tolerant and give someone the benefit of the doubt.

purplebunny2012 · 23/07/2022 18:27

He definitely shouldn't be assuming.
I get the opposite. I work in Finance, but when I say I work in a uni, I get asked if I'm a lecturer!

brookstar · 23/07/2022 18:08

do you mean people assume you do your dh’s role and, because they are assuming it is you doing that, think that it is less well paid and prestigious than it actually is; or do you think it has anything to do with the way you and he come across to them as people?
It's nothing to do with how prestigious the job is and everything to do with the fact he's male, older than me and the fact that people find it difficult to believe that someone who looks like me is an academic. I've had a number of people say that to me - apparently academics don't have platinum blonde hair, wear heels and make up. I've genuinely had people say I look more like a hairdresser, whatever that means 🙄
I know I'm not the only one. There was a Twitter campaign a couple of years ago which was aimed at challenging what academics look like.

Because, tbh, I find it odd that so many people would assume you are not an academic but that your dh is, as I know plenty of people have stereotypical ideas of what “academics” are like (male and female), but don’t personally have experience of people who think only men are academics.

People do make assumptions about the sex of an academic. There was a thread last night where people automatically used 'he' and 'him' when the OP hadn't mentioned the sex of the academic they were talking about. That's not uncommon.
I've turned up to do talks in schools and had people say they were expecting a man.

Does your dh get annoyed that people think he is an academic?

He gets annoyed that people find it incredulous that I'm an academic. He's seen first hand the challenges female academics face.

rumporolypolyofthebailey · 23/07/2022 18:02

when in court I am frequently mistaken for the defendant.....once when in QC´s silks

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 17:52

@brookstar - do you mean people assume you do your dh’s role and, because they are assuming it is you doing that, think that it is less well paid and prestigious than it actually is; or do you think it has anything to do with the way you and he come across to them as people? Because, tbh, I find it odd that so many people would assume you are not an academic but that your dh is, as I know plenty of people have stereotypical ideas of what “academics” are like (male and female), but don’t personally have experience of people who think only men are academics.

Does your dh get annoyed that people think he is an academic?

LexCake · 23/07/2022 17:51

luxxlisbon · 22/07/2022 19:45

I don’t get your point? Do you think it’s a criticism that he assumed administration rather than a lecturer?

To be honest if someone phrased something in that way I would think the same. If they said “I work in a school” I would assume something like admin, reception, management, lunch room etc otherwise they would usually say “I’m a teacher”.

I think you are looking to be offended here.

I was thinking something similar, on the phrasing point. A new friend once asked me where I work, I told her I work in a law firm. Years later she was surprised when I told her I was a solicitor. She’d assumed I was a secretary.

brookstar · 23/07/2022 16:09

Playing devil's advocate - as you accept that there are lots of 'administration' roles that are actually more senior and better paid than academic ones, how do you know he wasn't complimenting you by assuming perhaps you were a Senior Project Manager or Director of IT at the university and on £90K per year rather than a lowly academic? Isn't there a possibility that you yourself are a) assuming he thinks admin=unimportant or derogatory and b) assuming that because he is old he is sexist?

This actually happens to me. As I've said, it's not about the job role it's the assumptions being made about the role of an academic.
My DH is a director at a uni and is paid significantly more than me but people assume that I do that job and that he is the academic.
It still pisses me off!

brookstar · 23/07/2022 16:07

yes, I understand unconscious bias can and does perpetuate inequalities, but not acknowledging that the value of traditionally female dominated roles is not accurately perceived by society and not fighting against this, doesn’t help society change for the better in the long term, it just condemns some roles to being viewed by a great many people as roles you take, male or female, if you couldn’t find something more important and prestigious to do. It is not an improvement if both men and women are always encouraged to favour being a doctor over a nurse; or to be an academic over an administrator.

I agree with you. However, you have been accusing me of not valuing these roles. That couldn't be further from the truth.

A lot of work rightly goes into encouraging women to think of careers in STEM subjects, to think of becoming doctors, to keep going with their careers and get into more positions of power. There is absolutely no equivalent effort to encourage men to become nurses or carers, or effective administrators.
Actually, you're wrong. I've worked on projects to encourage boys into considering female dominated professions. They don't get as much attention and there aren't as many but they do exist.

The effort is simply funnelling everyone in the same direction, thus continuing to discredit the roles that women used to do but are now told they may well only be choosing to do as a result of unconscious bias.

This becomes quite complicated. We know that girls and women make career and education choices differently to boys and men and we know that much of this is due to unconscious bias and societal expectations- for example, women will choice jobs which are flexible and family friendly even before they have children in preparation for taking on more childcare responsibilities.
Raising aspirations can be quite contentious and we need to be careful not devalue career choices because they aren't traditionally aspirational while ensuring young people can reach their potential and become a doctor if they want to.

latetothefisting · 23/07/2022 16:06

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 22/07/2022 20:00

I'm surprised you didn't get the point. I don't think it's a criticism because I don't think this guy thought that far, rather he assumed woman = secretary.

There are plenty of people in administration paid much more than I am and who make decisions about us lecturers! The conversation centred around travel to work rather than actual jobs.

Playing devil's advocate - as you accept that there are lots of 'administration' roles that are actually more senior and better paid than academic ones, how do you know he wasn't complimenting you by assuming perhaps you were a Senior Project Manager or Director of IT at the university and on £90K per year rather than a lowly academic? Isn't there a possibility that you yourself are a) assuming he thinks admin=unimportant or derogatory and b) assuming that because he is old he is sexist?
He could even have just been operating on the balance of probabilities - there are a lot more people involved in the large umbrella of 'administrative' than academics.

Perhaps he was being sexist -but you don't know, you are basing that solely on assumptions about him!

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 15:50

@brookstar - yes, I understand unconscious bias can and does perpetuate inequalities, but not acknowledging that the value of traditionally female dominated roles is not accurately perceived by society and not fighting against this, doesn’t help society change for the better in the long term, it just condemns some roles to being viewed by a great many people as roles you take, male or female, if you couldn’t find something more important and prestigious to do. It is not an improvement if both men and women are always encouraged to favour being a doctor over a nurse; or to be an academic over an administrator.

A lot of work rightly goes into encouraging women to think of careers in STEM subjects, to think of becoming doctors, to keep going with their careers and get into more positions of power. There is absolutely no equivalent effort to encourage men to become nurses or carers, or effective administrators. The effort is simply funnelling everyone in the same direction, thus continuing to discredit the roles that women used to do but are now told they may well only be choosing to do as a result of unconscious bias.

brookstar · 23/07/2022 15:20

what’s with the assumption that someone thinks you couldn’t possibly be an academic if they assume something else first off?

What wrong with it do you mean?
Lots. The same goes for any job that is dominated by one particular sex.
If I'm a societal level we associate a particular job with one sex then this has wide reaching implications. It impacts children's views on particular careers which impacts education and career choices ( we know that children start to see jobs as suitable for male/females from around age 6/7). It influences decisions made by recruitment and selection panels (if their unconscious bias tells them men are more suitable - again lots of research around this particularly in relation to academia). It means we perpetuate inequalities.
It's important.

When it comes to use of language and assumptions, if you are a person who finds assumptions problematic, then you have no business making so many assumptions of your own.
What assumptions have I made?

If someone thinks you are an administrator and you are not, you could be flattered they appear to think you have excellent organisational and managerial abilities if you made different assumptions about administrators, rather than apparently assuming yourself, or assuming that everyone else assumes, that an academic could be an administrator if they so wished, but an administrator would never be capable of being an academic.

Again, please tell me where I've made these assumptions?

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 23/07/2022 15:18

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 15:12

Also, @brookstar, what’s with the assumption that someone thinks you couldn’t possibly be an academic if they assume something else first off? When it comes to use of language and assumptions, if you are a person who finds assumptions problematic, then you have no business making so many assumptions of your own. If someone thinks you are an administrator and you are not, you could be flattered they appear to think you have excellent organisational and managerial abilities if you made different assumptions about administrators, rather than apparently assuming yourself, or assuming that everyone else assumes, that an academic could be an administrator if they so wished, but an administrator would never be capable of being an academic.

I don't think a guy at a party or a train station, met fleetingly, is going to think that deeply about it.

OP posts:
Walkaround · 23/07/2022 15:16

And it was the OP who assumed the elderly man she was talking to was thinking she had a role that would involve typing up letters for people - so definitely her assumption, thus increasing the offence she took.