Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You're in administration are you?"

343 replies

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 22/07/2022 19:28

Waiting for a train and a guy started chatting to me to pass the time. Told me he had a 51 year old son so he must be in his 70s. When he discovered I work at a university he asked me the question in the subject line.

I asked him what made him say that and he just shrugged. I didn't say so, but I suspect it's because I'm a woman and also his generation.

Unreasonable to be wryly amused/slightly miffed? Not the first time it's happened and always men that say it.

Not that I'm saying there's anything wrong with working in administration either btw.

OP posts:
OutsideLookingOut · 24/07/2022 11:20

Walkaround · 24/07/2022 11:10

Well, obviously I could ensure I refer to racism and other inherent biases and examples of stereotyping in every thread, but this was a thread about inherent sexism, so I focused on the specific topic. Also, it is not a particularly good comparison to make, as administrator encompasses such a colossally wide field of work that to find it sexist or racist requires a few more steps than it takes if you are assumed to be a janitor or cleaner. Ideally, nobody would ever ask whether someone works in a particular field, in case they say the wrong thing, but nobody is perfect and people tend to look for things they might have in common and slant their questions accordingly. Sometimes their questions are inherently sexist or racist and sometimes they aren’t.

I was using an example to point out that men in this case a black man could be offended at being thought to do a stereotypical job. It isn’t just something women are over sensitive about. Womens concerns and feelings are often dismissed as such. It is fine for folks to point out when they have been on the receiving end of these biases though. If you just put up and shut up nothing changes. Challenging, even just discussing it can be good.

And actually i don’t think it is all that different as a black woman. I’ve been impacted by both sexism and racism. I know many would not agree. It does impact you as a child and teenager imagining what your life could be like and ultimately what you do.

Missisipihallelujah · 24/07/2022 11:16

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 24/07/2022 11:07

Oh yes, "support" staff. Really patronising title and glad it has gone. At my workplace, apparently they were once referred to as "non-academic" which is almost worse.

@Missisipihallelujah You've not grasped the point I was making. I was discussing the assumption that because I am female and employed by a university the default position was that I was not an academic. It's not that I look down on professional services staff, think I am too good to be one, or that I am smug because I'm an academic. It's about assumptions.

Someone suggested that I may not "look like an academic". I probably don't but then we are getting back to stereotypes and assumptions. Of course it doesn't matter what a complete stranger thinks I do or don't do at work. But it does matter in the general scheme of things if incorrect assumptions aren't challenged.

I have worked in education, first as support staff and later as teaching staff. Two lecturers laughed at me, when I was an Admin Mgr in a university, for doing my job, as I held an MA. Snobbery is rife in education, and sorry this is more about that than equality. The latter is hardly going to be impacted by harmless, albeit ignorant presumptions.

brookstar · 24/07/2022 11:10

But it does matter in the general scheme of things if incorrect assumptions aren't challenged.

Exactly! Sex based stereotypes still exist and need to be challenged.

Or do people really think it's acceptable for children to think there are appropriate jobs for girls and appropriate jobs for boys? The impact this has on aspirations, education and career choices is huge. Once these ideas are ingrained they're very difficult to challenge.

People might think this is a non issue but there are lots of people who disagree. The government policy around careers education and guidance specifically talks about addressing stereotypes.

Walkaround · 24/07/2022 11:10

OutsideLookingOut · 24/07/2022 10:52

But being a janitor isn’t female dominated. Sorry perhaps I should have used the example of a drug dealer and footballer too? Because all have been assumed. Not all negative but it is the stereotyping due to race that offends.

Even for positive things like being assumed to be athletic.

Well, obviously I could ensure I refer to racism and other inherent biases and examples of stereotyping in every thread, but this was a thread about inherent sexism, so I focused on the specific topic. Also, it is not a particularly good comparison to make, as administrator encompasses such a colossally wide field of work that to find it sexist or racist requires a few more steps than it takes if you are assumed to be a janitor or cleaner. Ideally, nobody would ever ask whether someone works in a particular field, in case they say the wrong thing, but nobody is perfect and people tend to look for things they might have in common and slant their questions accordingly. Sometimes their questions are inherently sexist or racist and sometimes they aren’t.

MeenzAmRhoi · 24/07/2022 11:09

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 24/07/2022 09:50

Physical sciences and I know of someone who graduated in a first degree (integrated masters) and then did a PhD at 35 and went on to have a career as a professor. She was my dissertation supervisor for my first degree. So go for it!

Thank you for replying! It's nice to hear positive stories. I would start at 35 as well and feel like I'd regret not going for it.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 24/07/2022 11:07

brookstar · 24/07/2022 10:49

I think I'm tense about this issue because there's a whole training and research programme based on the sexism of being mistaken for admin! And it seems very offensive to me.

I can understand why you'd feel this way but that programme isn't about saying administration jobs are worth less (it used to really infuriate me when we were referred to as support staff!!) but it's about acknowledging the challenges of being a female academic, of which there are many!!

I can see why it could appear to be offensive though.

Oh yes, "support" staff. Really patronising title and glad it has gone. At my workplace, apparently they were once referred to as "non-academic" which is almost worse.

@Missisipihallelujah You've not grasped the point I was making. I was discussing the assumption that because I am female and employed by a university the default position was that I was not an academic. It's not that I look down on professional services staff, think I am too good to be one, or that I am smug because I'm an academic. It's about assumptions.

Someone suggested that I may not "look like an academic". I probably don't but then we are getting back to stereotypes and assumptions. Of course it doesn't matter what a complete stranger thinks I do or don't do at work. But it does matter in the general scheme of things if incorrect assumptions aren't challenged.

OP posts:
brookstar · 24/07/2022 11:06

Your first sentence is stretching credibility.

I'm what way?

brookstar · 24/07/2022 11:05

LiveLoveLifeForever · 24/07/2022 11:01

You're not being unreasonable to be amused / miffed but it simply is what it is, an older generation man assuming because you’re a woman you were in a secretarial type role. I’m sure he didn’t mean to offend you and his shrug was because he didn’t really have any reason to assume that other than back in his day it is probably what most woman would have done. This is only my thoughts as I have no idea about universities and the inner workings, who’s more important or higher paid, which actually has nothing to do with your post anyway!! (Double exclamation mark just in case I’m not making my point clear 😂😂)

I'm an academic and my DH works in professional services- he earns almost double my salary and is far more important in relation to the actual running of the university!!

Missisipihallelujah · 24/07/2022 11:04

brookstar · 24/07/2022 11:02

Because if, on a societal level, people believe there are male or female jobs then this can have wide reaching consequences.

There's a significant amount of research on this subject.

Your first sentence is stretching credibility.

brookstar · 24/07/2022 11:02

Missisipihallelujah · 24/07/2022 10:53

Why does it matter what job strangers presume you do?

Because if, on a societal level, people believe there are male or female jobs then this can have wide reaching consequences.

There's a significant amount of research on this subject.

LiveLoveLifeForever · 24/07/2022 11:01

You're not being unreasonable to be amused / miffed but it simply is what it is, an older generation man assuming because you’re a woman you were in a secretarial type role. I’m sure he didn’t mean to offend you and his shrug was because he didn’t really have any reason to assume that other than back in his day it is probably what most woman would have done. This is only my thoughts as I have no idea about universities and the inner workings, who’s more important or higher paid, which actually has nothing to do with your post anyway!! (Double exclamation mark just in case I’m not making my point clear 😂😂)

brookstar · 24/07/2022 11:00

you appear to be telling me how to think and feel about sexism. Pot. Kettle.

I'm really not. I've been explaining why it's an issue. You can choose to agree or not.

You're the one telling people not to bother getting upset about it! Telling me to 'pick my battles' how bloody patronising.

I suspect you're just spoiling for an argument though 🤷🏼‍♀️

Missisipihallelujah · 24/07/2022 10:59

missushbbb · 24/07/2022 02:27

This is one of the most non event threads I've ever read on here. And also quite insulting to administrators!

Hear hear. It is full of snobbery, in the guise of feminism.

Walkaround · 24/07/2022 10:55

brookstar · 24/07/2022 09:51

I am a woman. I was referred to as babysitting. You are conveniently ignoring this, or even worse, denying it is humanly possible, because it doesn’t suit your argument.

I'm not ignoring it. It's just incredibly rare for women to be referred to as babysitters for their own children. If it's how you talk about caring for your children then fine.
However, it is well known for men to be referred to as babysitters and for people to talk about men babysitting their children. I've not made that up.
It's in the same category as men helping their wives with childcare and housework rather than sharing the responsibility.

Every thread on Mumsnet is full of ridiculous arguments due to misinterpretation of other people’s intended meaning and thought processes. You can’t claim always to know better than the person who said something why they said what they did and what they meant by it. You are every bit as affected as anyone else by your own prejudices and obsessions. So I say, pick your battles, there is no need to poison every interaction you ever have by seeking out unintended sexism.

Are you telling me how to think and feel about sexism and sexist remarks? I have picked my battle - this is my battle!!

I don't poison every interaction but I will challenge when appropriate. As I've said numerous times, sexism ( just like racism ) doesn't always have to be intentional. Just because someone didn't mean to be sexist or racist doesn't mean it's any less sexist or racist.
Challenging these comments or behaviours doesn't have to be aggressive. Sometimes you don't challenge them immediately.... people are capable of reading a situation.

The theme for international womens day this year was 'break the bias' and was about challenging these 'micro aggressions' (not my choice of language) it was about challenging the little things because they do make a difference. most people are intentionally sexist but that doesn't mean they should continue being sexist!
Through my job and my research I see the consequences of deeply ingrained sexist views.

Social interactions work better and people are less likely to be teetering on the edge of taking offence if they give each other the benefit of the doubt when it does them no harm to do so. An elderly man on a train station platform is not going to benefit from being told he is sexist for asking a question, he’s just going to talk less to strangers for fear of unintentionally causing offence. Many people feel isolated enough as it is.

Again, with the telling people how to manage their social interactions!!
I don't think people are 'teetering on the edge of taking offence' it's more that were just more aware and heightened to sexist remarks. That doesn't mean we're aggressive to everyone..... in this situation I would have just explained that I was an academic and left it at that. There would be no benefit to telling an elderly man that I considered his remark sexist. I would probably have a little rant about it later though!

You might not think this is important but what gives you the right to tell other people it shouldn't matter to them either? That's just arrogant.

I'm sure there are things you're passionate about that other people don't understand.

@brookstar - you appear to be telling me how to think and feel about sexism. Pot. Kettle. Or maybe we are both simply expressing our opinions.

Missisipihallelujah · 24/07/2022 10:53

Why does it matter what job strangers presume you do?

OutsideLookingOut · 24/07/2022 10:52

Walkaround · 23/07/2022 20:10

You haven’t read my post properly, have you? I said men never appear to be offended by assumptions they are university professors or medical doctors, I didn’t say men would not be offended to be assumed to be a caretaker.

But being a janitor isn’t female dominated. Sorry perhaps I should have used the example of a drug dealer and footballer too? Because all have been assumed. Not all negative but it is the stereotyping due to race that offends.

Even for positive things like being assumed to be athletic.

brookstar · 24/07/2022 10:49

I think I'm tense about this issue because there's a whole training and research programme based on the sexism of being mistaken for admin! And it seems very offensive to me.

I can understand why you'd feel this way but that programme isn't about saying administration jobs are worth less (it used to really infuriate me when we were referred to as support staff!!) but it's about acknowledging the challenges of being a female academic, of which there are many!!

I can see why it could appear to be offensive though.

Jalisco · 24/07/2022 10:39

ihavenocats · 22/07/2022 20:00

Yes, in his generation a woman stayed at home to raise a family and any job would be menial for pin money allowing quick exist when necessary to tend to the children, and he assumed you did the same forgetting that in the modern day we also pursue careers and no parent focuses solely on the family home and children.

He didn't watch himself and ensure he didn't utter such an assumption, he just spoke freely assuming you were just up for a friendly conversation and not a chance to get offended.

Utter rubbish. I'm 65. I am working class. Women have always worked, women have always had careers, and the universities were chock full of women students and academics in the 60s and 70s. Just because someone is older doesn't mean they spent their youth in some concocted reality where women stayed at home or worked in menial jobs. There are plenty of people today who stay at home or have "menial jobs". It wasn't the stone age you know?

Reallyreallyborednow · 24/07/2022 10:39

ILs when gossiping/bragging/competing re friends’ children etc, will say things like ‘he works at Freshfields’, without telling me about his profession/role. I feel like saying, yes but what does he do? Cleaner, security, IT manager?

to be fair my mum doesn’t actually have a clue what I do.

years ago I had many colleagues that would not say more than “work at the university”- in reality they did mouse and rat studies. But back then telling people that was an actual physical risk.

lots of people have reasons for not specifying what they do. I am not allowed to go into detail, so I often let people assume. Some of my colleague fabricate jobs, some just don’t say.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 24/07/2022 10:34

eastegg · 24/07/2022 10:23

Yes! This is a little peeve of mine, but I wouldn’t criticise the OP for it on this occasion, it annoys me more when people do it as a easy brag/status claim.

ILs when gossiping/bragging/competing re friends’ children etc, will say things like ‘he works at Freshfields’, without telling me about his profession/role. I feel like saying, yes but what does he do? Cleaner, security, IT manager?

I'm delighted you wouldn't criticise me for answering the guy by telling him where I worked, because that was exactly what he asked me, not what I did. We were discussing length of time to walk to the station, rather than professions.

OP posts:
DarkShade · 24/07/2022 10:33

DuesToTheDirt · 23/07/2022 21:27

Do they? I never did, I just said I worked at X University. (I was a research associate.)

I don't know then, it probably varies. I usually say "I work at the university" when I deliberately don't want to say. But yeah maybe it just depends. I think I'm tense about this issue because there's a whole training and research programme based on the sexism of being mistaken for admin! And it seems very offensive to me. But also I have admin and project manager friends who work at the uni and get offended by being mistaken for academics.

Walkaround · 24/07/2022 10:32

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 24/07/2022 09:41

It's not about the "event" itself but rather a debate on what the event represented. Do we still have a patriarchal approach over 100 years after women were allowed to vote and almost 50 years since the equal pay act?

@ImJustMadAboutSaffron - yes, but then what do you expect if you accept the structures and hierarchies that held women down for so long and just try to shoehorn women into the male-created structures and hierarchies? Infinitely more effort goes into encouraging women to consider careers that are currently dominated by men than goes into encouraging men to consider careers currently dominated by women. In fact, women are often those most resistant to men entering the female sphere. Society does not benefit from simply converting what used to be seen as “women’s work” into, “you aren’t good enough for anything else work,” but that is the message given out by drives to get women into higher positions in the patriarchy as these drives implicitly indicate that traditionally female roles are inferior and confer lower status and power.

eastegg · 24/07/2022 10:23

ihavenocats · 22/07/2022 20:05

It's also very annoying when you ask someone 'what do you do?' and they answer with where they work.

Yes! This is a little peeve of mine, but I wouldn’t criticise the OP for it on this occasion, it annoys me more when people do it as a easy brag/status claim.

ILs when gossiping/bragging/competing re friends’ children etc, will say things like ‘he works at Freshfields’, without telling me about his profession/role. I feel like saying, yes but what does he do? Cleaner, security, IT manager?

brookstar · 24/07/2022 10:01

Their report 'sharing the caring' looked specifically at professional services staff and the impact of having caring responsibilities during lockdown.

brookstar · 24/07/2022 09:58

We should be finding ways to support each other

I absolutely agree.
For those who work in higher education I'd really recommend joining the Women's Higher Education Network (WHEN). It's free!
They represent all university staff.

Their reports on the impact of covid on womens careers are very insightful.... and depressing!