Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would men just put their kids into care?

361 replies

MustdrinkmoreH2O · 22/07/2022 12:32

Would be interested to know peoples thoughts on this.

since having my baby and going to a lot of baby groups and mixing with other mothers and reading these forums In can safely say a high proportion of men (not all of course), see child rearing as women primary responsibility.

Women tend to be the default parent in the events of splits and men having EOW or even just walking away completely.

So I was thinking, if women suddenly acted like men in this regard and literally left men holding the baby, what would honestly happen to a lot of children?

If women suddenly stopped carrying the mental load so didn’t book in any kind of medical appointment or arrange play dates or buy new clothes, what would honestly happen?

One of my friends is dating a single dad (mum walked out), but his parents practically raised the kids as he worked away. So still pretty much saw them only at weekends. However if a man leaves a woman with a baby, in normal circumstances she’d just find a new job where she didn’t work away, reduce hours of needed and use paid childcare. They wouldn’t normally hand their kids over to others to raise 80% of the time because they had to work.

So I’m really interested to see what a lot of men would do if the roles were reversed. If women literally just walked out or stopped carrying any mental load type stuff relating to the kids. Would men leave their jobs if required or go part time and claim universal credit?

Would the majority step up as women do and stop their hobbies, arrange childcare and extracurricular activities and basically fully give themselves to parenthood? Would they realise their kids need new vests, socks and tshirts or need a dental check up?

Or

Would they hand over their kids to grandparents/family members to be primarily raised or if failing that, put them into care? Would they do the bare minimum so kids are literally fed, watered and taken to school but other than that left to their own devices with no activities or medical appointments arranged or assemblies attended or well fitted clothes worn and basically be kind of neglected?

Be interested to know others thoughts on what would actually happen.

YABU - as many men as women would step up and look after their kids the same way single mothers do.

YANBU - unfortunately most men would try and shirk as much responsibility of child rearing sometimes even resulting in the care system if their were no willing people to become primary cater.

OP posts:
minticelime · 22/07/2022 19:48

Obviously it doesn't literally mean women know the details of everything!

It means that women have an instinct men do not have. Because men are not women. They are not the childbearing sex and are not designed to feed babies. They don't have the hormones women have after birth, nor same intuition.

That's not to say they would put the kids in care! But, on average, men are less attuned. Men have different hormones and physicality that predispose them to focusing on slightly different things.

CharlesIsQueensHorcrux · 22/07/2022 19:43

I agree with @nesbo that men would think their job is to provide more financially. I get the point you are making @MustdrinkmoreH2O but don’t think I agree with lauding single mums for going part time and claiming Universal Credit, isn’t that avoiding your responsibility in a different way?

luxxlisbon · 22/07/2022 19:35

RedWingBoots · 22/07/2022 19:26

Sorry that's BS.

I agree this is all BS.

From a very recent experience of being in an antenatal group I can say that vast majority of women don’t “just know” at all. Actually that natural instinct/ mother’s intuition rubbish is a large contributing factor to post natal mental health issues and PPD because women are shocked when they realise they don’t just know everything about their newborn and they then question themselves as a mother and a person.

In fact the majority of this site is mother’s asking various questions throughout ttc, pregnancy, postpartum and childhood. That alone should totally disprove “men learn, women know”.

RedWingBoots · 22/07/2022 19:26

ChinBristles · 22/07/2022 19:02

I agree with "men learn, women know".
And I think children sense when that is the case. When you are hurt, it's your mum you generally want.

Sorry that's BS.

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/07/2022 19:21

Change your social circle.

The men in my family and social circle are great dads, partners and human beings.

Sorry the ones you know are not.

ChinBristles · 22/07/2022 19:02

I agree with "men learn, women know".
And I think children sense when that is the case. When you are hurt, it's your mum you generally want.

ladydimitrescu · 22/07/2022 18:25

My Dh is the most hands on dad, if I wasn't around he'd die before he gave them up.

My uncle in law, spent thousands and fought tooth and nail to gain full custody of his DC, when their mother was a malicious, evil witch who made up lies, refused him access - to the point they were removed from her care, she was only allowed supervised access, and now she has written a letter stating she never wants to see her sons ever again. The only interest she ever had In the kids, was to use them to control and abuse him.

Your generalisation is really shitty. Women are more than capable of being horrendous parents.

minticelime · 22/07/2022 18:21

There us a saying where I come from regarding babies - "Men learn, women know." I think this is true, broadly speaking. It starts from the first minutes. As a mother, you can physically feel when your child needs feeding. A man can't do this. As a new mum, you never really sleep as you did before. You are so attuned too the baby, they don't need to be crying much to wake you. I can only speak for my husband, but he was just not attuned in the same way.

That's not to say men are incapable of learning - but men are not women. Also, there are some women who aren't maternal either. These women struggle to see the difference between themselves and men from day one because they didn't feel it. But, I would say, for the vast majority of couples, women are instinctively attuned from the first minutes in a way men are not.

As children get older, biological differences between men and women become less relevant. But still, in the whole, I think women have just got into the habit of putting the kids first and anticipating their needs, in a way that men don't. It's partly that they haven't had to (because they will have felt a need to prioritise other things, such as their work); or it's something that they have to learn.

For our primitive ancestors, it was all about survival and it would not have been efficient to have both parents focusing on the same thing. One would have needed to go off hunting; one keep the children safe. This is how we've evolved as a species and there's nothing like children coming along to cause couples to revert to certain roles. That's my experience anyway.

lljkk · 22/07/2022 18:18

Natural caregivers or control freaks?

Honestly the amount of whinging on here that DHs are doing stuff wrong.

No wonder they leave their female partners to do things female partners are control freaks about.

My only personal experience worth contributing is observing that MN is full of control freaks.

2bazookas · 22/07/2022 18:12

My husband was an equal-share parent from day one (he'd never actually touched a baby in his life, so learned fast, on the job) and so are our sons.

One of my aunts developed a fast terminal illness and died three weeks later. They had six very young children. Her husband raised all of them on his own and did a great job.

Topgub · 22/07/2022 18:08

@OddSockQueen

Both are true

Both are a result of each other and of the patriarchy

OddSockQueen · 22/07/2022 18:06

Topgub · 22/07/2022 17:32

@OddSockQueen

No, I don't think you're arguing with me in particular.

I just dont get the point you're making in relation to the context of the thread

Patriarchy/mysoginy is to blame. But both men and women seem happy enough to enforce it most of the time

I’m arguing with the ideas on this thread that:

a) women are gate-keeping childcare
b) there’s no general trend for men to dodge childcare

both of which very much have been argued on this thread.

Topgub · 22/07/2022 18:06

@NorthCountryBlues

I'm not being argumentative.

You responded to me first. Disagreeing with what I has said. And have replied twice, still disagreeing.

Why are you being so argumentative?

I disagree bf has anything to do with bond, especially as most women only ebf for a relatively short time

LetsGoRound · 22/07/2022 18:00

My son brought his daughter up when her mother left when she was a 9 week old baby.
He would rather have thrown himself under a bus than give his child up.
He never bothered with another woman until after she began university last year.
We managed to juggle childcare so he could continue working.
I have an uncle who brought all four of his children up as a single parent, his youngest was only four months old when his ex went off with another man.
He didn't bother with another woman until his kids were adults, he was too busy raising his kids and working.
I think most men would raise their kids as single parents if it came to it.

RedWingBoots · 22/07/2022 17:45

It looks like you need to choose the people you associate with a bit better.

@Simonjt stop being so middle class liberal elite. 😂

I new plenty of dads when I was growing up who would who looked after their children on their own at specific time due to the jobs they did as well as some single fathers. I didn't live in a middle class area then.

Now I do, and realise I know and have met plenty of fathers who look after their children more than the mother.

NorthCountryBlues · 22/07/2022 17:42

Well that’s not exactly what I said topgub. What I said was that I had a better bond because as well as being the sole feeder I could very easily soothe our babies, so I always wanted them when they were crying. He would gladly bounce them or sway them or whatever but it was much easier and quicker to just comfort feed them. For my ebf babies. I wasn’t talking about anyone else’s babies.
None of the ff babies I know were comfort fed in the same way, most of them had dummies. Unfortunately none of mine would take a dummy or that would’ve been a good way of comforting them too.

No idea why you feel the need to be so argumentative.

Topgub · 22/07/2022 17:35

@NorthCountryBlues

You said you had a better bond than your oh because he had a different way of comforting

So it follows that bf mums must have a better bond than ff mums too

Either that or bf doesn't make a difference to strength of bond

Topgub · 22/07/2022 17:32

@OddSockQueen

No, I don't think you're arguing with me in particular.

I just dont get the point you're making in relation to the context of the thread

Patriarchy/mysoginy is to blame. But both men and women seem happy enough to enforce it most of the time

Simonjt · 22/07/2022 17:32

There are lots of dads (and grandads) at the various baby groups our daughter goes to, there were also lots of dads at the toddler groups my son attended.

At rugby tots I would say around 90% of the parents are dads, at my sons rugby club again I would say around 90% of the parents attending are dads, at my sons ballet its about 50/50 mums and dads. At school drop off/pick up its about 50/50 mums and dads for the children collected by parents. Same for swimming lessons, generally 50/50.

I was a lone Dad for quite a while, I know three other single dads who are the RPs, I know two who have 50/50 and I know one who does nesting on a 50/50 basis with his children.

It looks like you need to choose the people you associate with a bit better.

NorthCountryBlues · 22/07/2022 17:32

Do mums who ff have a worse bond because they can't feed/comfort/soothe in ways bf mums do?

No, they just have a different way of feeding/comforting/soothing. Obviously when a baby is ebf (assuming no bottles) then no one can feed them but the mother.

OddSockQueen · 22/07/2022 17:23

It was you who decided I was arguing against you in particular 🤷‍♀️

Topgub · 22/07/2022 17:20

@OddSockQueen

I havent said they do.

But you're still arguing against a point no one is making.

Topgub · 22/07/2022 17:19

@NorthCountryBlues

I bf mine too.

It didn't make my bond better.

Do mums who ff have a worse bond because they can't feed/comfort/soothe in ways bf mums do?

OddSockQueen · 22/07/2022 17:19

If women choose to have kids with mysoginist men who have patriarchal values, thats on them

You don’t get it then. Society itself is deeply misogynistic. The whole operation is massively skewed. Individual men don’t come up with misogyny independently.

NorthCountryBlues · 22/07/2022 17:16

I think my dh would be pretty gutted to be told he didn't have as good a bond with his children as I do.

My DH would say himself when our kids were babies that he didn’t have as good a bond with them as I did. I breastfed them and I could therefore feed them, comfort them, soothe them in a way that he simply couldn’t. He did everything he could - nappies, taking them
out so I could rest, play, stories, etc etc.

Now they’re older, of course he has just as good a bond with them as I do.