Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would men just put their kids into care?

361 replies

MustdrinkmoreH2O · 22/07/2022 12:32

Would be interested to know peoples thoughts on this.

since having my baby and going to a lot of baby groups and mixing with other mothers and reading these forums In can safely say a high proportion of men (not all of course), see child rearing as women primary responsibility.

Women tend to be the default parent in the events of splits and men having EOW or even just walking away completely.

So I was thinking, if women suddenly acted like men in this regard and literally left men holding the baby, what would honestly happen to a lot of children?

If women suddenly stopped carrying the mental load so didn’t book in any kind of medical appointment or arrange play dates or buy new clothes, what would honestly happen?

One of my friends is dating a single dad (mum walked out), but his parents practically raised the kids as he worked away. So still pretty much saw them only at weekends. However if a man leaves a woman with a baby, in normal circumstances she’d just find a new job where she didn’t work away, reduce hours of needed and use paid childcare. They wouldn’t normally hand their kids over to others to raise 80% of the time because they had to work.

So I’m really interested to see what a lot of men would do if the roles were reversed. If women literally just walked out or stopped carrying any mental load type stuff relating to the kids. Would men leave their jobs if required or go part time and claim universal credit?

Would the majority step up as women do and stop their hobbies, arrange childcare and extracurricular activities and basically fully give themselves to parenthood? Would they realise their kids need new vests, socks and tshirts or need a dental check up?

Or

Would they hand over their kids to grandparents/family members to be primarily raised or if failing that, put them into care? Would they do the bare minimum so kids are literally fed, watered and taken to school but other than that left to their own devices with no activities or medical appointments arranged or assemblies attended or well fitted clothes worn and basically be kind of neglected?

Be interested to know others thoughts on what would actually happen.

YABU - as many men as women would step up and look after their kids the same way single mothers do.

YANBU - unfortunately most men would try and shirk as much responsibility of child rearing sometimes even resulting in the care system if their were no willing people to become primary cater.

OP posts:
OddSockQueen · 22/07/2022 20:50

@Topgub
Are you saying that, because women don’t want to share mat leave, they’ve no right to expect decent division of labour later down the line? Why is maternity leave the battle ground? Most men can’t breastfeed so they wouldn’t get on brilliantly in many cases. Women can have full maternity leave AND expect decent division of labour throughout child rearing.

I don’t know what you mean about the ‘science’ saying otherwise? There’s no science behind arguments around maternity leave, as far as I know?

Nothappyatwork · 22/07/2022 20:49

Why aren’t men up in arms then, why aren’t they demanding their rights to look after their own children and take paternity leave ?

have we seen any online positions, have we seen any lobbying ?

I personally think that men think that women are better, maybe that’s lack of confidence on their part. The point of my earlier rambling post which I didn’t make and I meant to, was that I think men would by default when landed with the entire responsibility of youngish children would be to find another woman to step in.

Heatstrokeunsteady · 22/07/2022 20:46

No they love bomb a woman and get her to do the work 😁

Topgub · 22/07/2022 20:45

@OddSockQueen

I'm not trying to let men off the hook. But I dont think women should be either.

I see loads and loads and loads of women arguing in favour of not sharing mat leave or childcare.

Men for the most part dont even get a say.

You'd argue that's because they dont want it. I'd argue its because they've no idea they can

@minticelime

You can disagree all you like, the science says otherwise.

The arguments throughout the thread haven't been that men are just different but that women are better

minticelime · 22/07/2022 20:41

Topgub - I tend to disagree, though I'm not arguing this makes men bad fathers. Just different. And it's absolutely ok to be different.

OddSockQueen · 22/07/2022 20:41

@Topgub
The massive imbalance of childcare between men and women is not due in any major part on women gatekeeping childcare. There may be a tiny grain of truth in the notion, but it’s as nothing compared with the fecklessness of men.

Yes, the patriarchy is a societal force perpetuated by men and women too (hence your desire to split the blame I assume) but the patriarchal norms always serve men better than they serve women, and men (as a group) have had a lot more to do with keeping them going. Unsurprisingly.

So I’m not going to let men off the hook here.

Nothappyatwork · 22/07/2022 20:36

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/07/2022 20:19

@Nothappyatwork

Oh dear. My comment still stands. The men I know are decent.

Until their circumstances have been tested I honestly don’t think you can answer that question and I would say that about men and women. @MajorCarolDanvers

Jeds55 · 22/07/2022 20:35

Depends entirely on the man I should imagine. (Just like the level of involvement a woman has depevds entirely on the woman in question).
My brother was a single father for many years when his wife walked out on him and 1.5 year old daughter. He has been an absolutely amazing father. Continued to work full time but had his daughter every single second around that. Sweeping generalisations aren't helpful at all.

Topgub · 22/07/2022 20:31

@minticelime

Its similar.

Topgub · 22/07/2022 20:31

@OddSockQueen

No.

I don't agree with you.

Women do 'gatekeep childcare

I'm not making it womens fault.

Its everyone's fault.

Men and women's

minticelime · 22/07/2022 20:29

I'm sure men can and do have some hormonal fluctuations TopGub, but it's just not the same thing at all.

OddSockQueen · 22/07/2022 20:25

Topgub · 22/07/2022 18:08

@OddSockQueen

Both are true

Both are a result of each other and of the patriarchy

Ok… so it would seem you do agree with me?

Which begs the question- why did you start arguing with me a few pages back? I was saying women are not gatekeeping childcare, and men as a group do dodge childcare. And I was saying those things precisely because some people had said the opposite on this very thread. Indeed, it sounds a lot like you are saying those things in this quote:

I've seen loads of women moaning their ohs don't look after their kids.

But if asked why they don't just leave them to it, there's loads of (rubbish excuses)

Sounds a lot like you’re making it women’s fault 🤷‍♀️

Topgub · 22/07/2022 20:24

@minticelime

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/02/170217095925.htm

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/07/2022 20:19

@Nothappyatwork

Oh dear. My comment still stands. The men I know are decent.

minticelime · 22/07/2022 20:14

"Men do have the same hormones"

How do men have the same hormones? They're not producing milk. Their bodies haven't grown a baby over nine months. They don't have whatever hormone causes the uterus to contract back - they don't even have a uterus! Tudy have no physical changes whatsoever. Also, women have a raised adrenaline in the first few weeks after birth that puts them in a kind of high alert and means they are less likely to sleep through the baby crying. It's how humans survived as a species.

luxxlisbon · 22/07/2022 20:06

ChinBristles · 22/07/2022 19:55

@RedWingBoots @luxxlisbon it was a pp just above me who explained the whole "men learn, women know" thing in detail.

And obviously women at an antenatal class don't know yet! The baby hasn't been born yet . But guaranteed when it is, they will have a better instinct than the man re what to do with it.

No, the antenatal experience was the first 12 months of having a baby and being on mat leave.
I can’t think of a single time one of the women just knew what to do because “instinct”. They were learning just as much as the dads.

GoldenSpiral · 22/07/2022 20:05

There's no way my DH would hand our son over to GPs if I ran off or died. I don't think he had the maternal instincts that I have for DS but he would be an excellent single parent if needed. I don't think my DH is the only one.

Teder · 22/07/2022 20:03

lljkk · 22/07/2022 18:18

Natural caregivers or control freaks?

Honestly the amount of whinging on here that DHs are doing stuff wrong.

No wonder they leave their female partners to do things female partners are control freaks about.

My only personal experience worth contributing is observing that MN is full of control freaks.

You probably would have said the same about my mum. She thought my dad often did wrong.
After the divorce, she would send us (young children under the age of 9) with my dad and he indeed would send us to school without our bags or lunch. He didn’t realise we needed to wash our hair until I told him. 🤷🏻‍♀️He didn’t cook and fed us only chips and chicken nuggets and pasta. It wasn’t neglect as such. You can see where my mum was coming from.

Simonjt · 22/07/2022 20:02

But guaranteed when it is, they will have a better instinct than the man re what to do with it.

Really? No missing instincts for these two Dads, the same certainly cannot be said for the birth mother.

Nothappyatwork · 22/07/2022 20:00

Topgub · 22/07/2022 19:58

@Nothappyatwork

How did you manage to have more than 1 kid with such a great guy?

Because I alluded to be low they aren’t like that or at least less ridiculous when they have to keep the mother of the children happy. Although actually to be fair he did get his mother around to babysit the baby whilst he went off to fuck somebody else while I was at work.

What a delight.

Topgub · 22/07/2022 19:58

@Nothappyatwork

How did you manage to have more than 1 kid with such a great guy?

ChinBristles · 22/07/2022 19:55

@RedWingBoots @luxxlisbon it was a pp just above me who explained the whole "men learn, women know" thing in detail.

And obviously women at an antenatal class don't know yet! The baby hasn't been born yet . But guaranteed when it is, they will have a better instinct than the man re what to do with it.

Topgub · 22/07/2022 19:54

@minticelime

Men do have the same hormones

The more direct childcare they do for their own babies and children, the more they produce

Nothappyatwork · 22/07/2022 19:51

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/07/2022 19:21

Change your social circle.

The men in my family and social circle are great dads, partners and human beings.

Sorry the ones you know are not.

And I would completely agree with that, whilst they are in relationships with the children’s mother, a very different kettle of fish afterwards. When they aren’t fucking the mother of the children and she isn’t there to advocate for them the children very often become second-best we see it on threads on here, day and day out.

Nothappyatwork · 22/07/2022 19:48

I once decided to give my ex-husband a taste of his own medicine when he kidnapped my children overnight, simply to upset me he took them to a hotel room and then brought them into school the next day they had had no dinner no breakfast they were in Yesterdays clothes including knickers hadn’t brush their teeth and had no lunch with them . The school absolutely bent over backwards to help and assist him to sort the children out. I know it was for the children’s benefit of course it was. BUT
Can you imagine if a woman a done similar thing?
later on that day when he arrived back at the house to further verbally assault me I told him if he was taking the children don’t forget to take the baby with you was well, given that that’s the most difficult one to manage. I walked off halfway down the street turned around to see him on the phone to his mother I shit you not crying. Obviously I went back and took the baby.