Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would men just put their kids into care?

361 replies

MustdrinkmoreH2O · 22/07/2022 12:32

Would be interested to know peoples thoughts on this.

since having my baby and going to a lot of baby groups and mixing with other mothers and reading these forums In can safely say a high proportion of men (not all of course), see child rearing as women primary responsibility.

Women tend to be the default parent in the events of splits and men having EOW or even just walking away completely.

So I was thinking, if women suddenly acted like men in this regard and literally left men holding the baby, what would honestly happen to a lot of children?

If women suddenly stopped carrying the mental load so didn’t book in any kind of medical appointment or arrange play dates or buy new clothes, what would honestly happen?

One of my friends is dating a single dad (mum walked out), but his parents practically raised the kids as he worked away. So still pretty much saw them only at weekends. However if a man leaves a woman with a baby, in normal circumstances she’d just find a new job where she didn’t work away, reduce hours of needed and use paid childcare. They wouldn’t normally hand their kids over to others to raise 80% of the time because they had to work.

So I’m really interested to see what a lot of men would do if the roles were reversed. If women literally just walked out or stopped carrying any mental load type stuff relating to the kids. Would men leave their jobs if required or go part time and claim universal credit?

Would the majority step up as women do and stop their hobbies, arrange childcare and extracurricular activities and basically fully give themselves to parenthood? Would they realise their kids need new vests, socks and tshirts or need a dental check up?

Or

Would they hand over their kids to grandparents/family members to be primarily raised or if failing that, put them into care? Would they do the bare minimum so kids are literally fed, watered and taken to school but other than that left to their own devices with no activities or medical appointments arranged or assemblies attended or well fitted clothes worn and basically be kind of neglected?

Be interested to know others thoughts on what would actually happen.

YABU - as many men as women would step up and look after their kids the same way single mothers do.

YANBU - unfortunately most men would try and shirk as much responsibility of child rearing sometimes even resulting in the care system if their were no willing people to become primary cater.

OP posts:
Topgub · 23/07/2022 17:14

@Trytoavoidthebastardbus

Because currently that's the status quo.

Women entitled to mat leave. And men only now being entitled to slightly better pat leave.

I dont think a year is really necessary so I don't see an issue with splitting the leave equally between both parents.

There's no logical reason for the woman to take all of it.

Trytoavoidthebastardbus · 23/07/2022 17:10

I didn’t say it shouldn’t, I said why should it be women that give up maternity leave for men to have more paternity leave.

NDandMe · 23/07/2022 16:27

Effing phone! Gah.

My children's father got married again almost immediately, and she does all the arranging, organising, planning, cooking, and childcare. So I assume that's what he would have done if I wasn't resident parent, as well.

Topgub · 23/07/2022 16:26

@Trytoavoidthebastardbus

That doesn't really explain why it should be that way?

Why not share it equally?

NDandMe · 23/07/2022 16:25

My children's father got ma

Trytoavoidthebastardbus · 23/07/2022 16:21

I know one couple who split the parental leave 50/50 for the 1st baby and she did 9 months him 3 for the 2nd, I wonder if they have a 3rd she’ll take the 12 months.

antelopevalley · 23/07/2022 16:10

I think more mothers would be happy to split maternity leave if the father were going to pick up all the housework she would do at home.
Most fathers do not want paternity leave alone with the baby. I have seen too many new fathers deliberately stay late at the office so they get home after the baby or toddler is in bed, to believe most fathers want this.

Trytoavoidthebastardbus · 23/07/2022 16:03

Topgub · 23/07/2022 15:39

@Trytoavoidthebastardbus

But why should you get the whole first year?

Personally because that’s what I did with my 1st born.

Topgub · 23/07/2022 15:39

@Trytoavoidthebastardbus

But why should you get the whole first year?

Comedycook · 23/07/2022 15:37

I don't know why the op has had a few mean responses. It's a fascinating question and one I've often wondered. My own mum died and I was raised by my dad...some aspects of parenthood he was good at but in a lot of others ways, I wasn't looked after properly.

Trytoavoidthebastardbus · 23/07/2022 15:33

That’s the thing why is it the women giving up time for the men to have longer paternity? If the time was increased to 18 months then I would have 100% had the first year as I did with my eldest and then be happy for my partner to have 6 months with our child.

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 23/07/2022 12:55

Re the parental leave comments upthread

My (entirely anecdotal) experience of shared parental leave was that I found DHs bit much harder than he did (he took 3 months, I took 9). We decided on the split before DD was born and I was adamant that I wasnt going to be the 'default' parent. However when she arrived I was surprised by how strong my urge was to take care of her and when it was my turn to go back to work I was gutted. DH did an amazing job, she ate healthy meals cooked from scratch, went to baby groups, was always dressed appropriately and loved and well taken care of buy my god did I wish it was still me doing it all. If we had another I'd do everything the same though as the time meant the world to my DH and I'm glad he had the chance to bond with her and prove what a cracking parent he is. But I can see why so many women are resistant to the idea. And my experience was that most women don't want to share their mat leave even if it is an option, I got told on many occasions that I was crazy for 'letting' him have some of 'my' leave and they'd never entertain the idea.

Obviously I know there are plenty of useless twatty men out there who cant get far enough away from their kids but I also think there are loads who would bite your hand off to get the chance to take more paternity leave/go part time.

vivainsomnia · 23/07/2022 12:54

The sexism on this thread!
Nothing new!

My dad was as much a carer figure to me as my mum. My ex was raised by his dad after his mum left. Dad was only 24. He did am amazing job.

My boss who is an executive level took 6 months off to look after his son after his wife went back to work. He didn't look overly excited to be back.

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 23/07/2022 12:42

Honestly I can't think of a single family in my entire circle where the Dad would even contemplate care as an option if they lost their partner or they ran off. I think most would find it tough but I think that very much applies for BOTH partners.

Goldbar · 23/07/2022 12:21

I don't buy that women in general still think that men should be the sole financial providers. Maybe some do, but something like 72% of women work compared to around 78% of men. More women than men work part-time though (around 38% compared to 13%).

So if women do view men as the sole financial providers, then men on the whole aren't that great at it, given their overall employment rates aren't that much higher than the rates for women. What is true is that many women take pay cuts or reduce their hours to fit in their caring responsibilities.

MsPincher · 23/07/2022 11:55

I think the other side of the coin is that we socialize women generally to think of men as the financial providers (although this is changing).

How many women post on mn expecting their dh to bear the entire responsibility of the finances and this is often supported by many posters. Also all the threads about marrying someone financially secure or indeed marrying at all for “financial protection” (obviously you would have to marry a higher earner or more wealthy man for that to be any use.

traditional gender roles hold women back imo but also they do benefit some women in some circumstances. However they are damaging to women as a class. Time to drop them imo and challenge them. But some women are definitely resistant to that as they do like the idea of having a man provide for them.

RustyShackleford3 · 23/07/2022 11:53

I think it is really tricky to generalise in this way. My DH would absolutely step up and do it all by himself. Our children are his first priority.

Some other men I know would be cowardly twats and walk away.

These are all just anecdotes, anyway. I'd like to think that most men actually care enough about their children to look after them properly. I'll continue to believe this until I see some proper, data based evidence to the contrary

Goldbar · 23/07/2022 11:48

No matter how many hours a man works, it is never OK to sit back and say "I contribute to the family financially and so I don't need to do anything else".

I don't know a single woman who works full-time and thinks that this exonerates her from doing any chores and childcare during evenings and weekends. To be fair, I don't know all that many men who will admit to thinking this either (although this rarely seems to translate into sharing the burden equally). I know quite a few women who work full-time and seem to do most stuff at home as well.

Loving the idea that financially contributing to your children and doing nothing else makes you a responsible parent. As pp say, how does that work in single parent families or families with 2 working parents? Do these children just take care of themselves or something?

lljkk · 23/07/2022 11:48

I don't know any young widows, I only know a young widower of a popular mutual friend. Yes (my social group) rallied round him. It was a tragic early death not a relationship breakdown, though. And I was very happy when he found love again.

We also rallied round friend who kicked out her cheating husband, friend had an amazing social life as "single mum", lots of support. Not sure how her dating has gone, but no lack of opportunities pursued.

MsPincher · 23/07/2022 11:46

I think some men would step up but a lot wouldn’t. If they were socialised differently though and we didn’t see children as womens’ primary responsibility though, it would be different I think

Sneezesthrice · 23/07/2022 11:37

wallpoppy · 23/07/2022 10:32

When my sister-in-law went into hospice and after she died, lots of women came out of the woodwork to help my poor dear brother in law with offers of free childcare and cooking. None of these women (supposedly good friends of SIL when she was alive) were this generous when she was struggling to keep it together for the family while on chemotherapy and radiation. BIL was remarried within a year, new wife is a SAHM to my nieces and to the two boys of her own she's had since then. She seems alright but she's a lot more short-tempered and less affectionate than my husband's sister was and she doesn't allow any photos of her predecessor to be displayed in the main part of the house, only in photo books in a drawer or in the girls' rooms.

I said something that echoes this to my husband a few weeks ago, if I died there would be women folk falling over themselves to help support you with our child and running the home, enabling you to work and probably encouraging you to date a find a replacement wifey. If you died, I’d be fucked because men evoke a level of hands on sympathetic help when their wives abandon them or die, women are seen as capable of running everything even in the absence of a partner/husband because a lot of women do so much of caring/cooking/organising in most families they aren’t seen as being thrown in at the deep end and needing others to pick up the slack.

Passedmybedtime · 23/07/2022 10:36

Not all men, my bil was a single dad, also worked so we helped with childcare. my father tho without a doubt after he beat the shit out of us of course though wouldn't put my brother into care as he was only 1 he never beat the shit out of, he just hates us for being girls

wallpoppy · 23/07/2022 10:32

When my sister-in-law went into hospice and after she died, lots of women came out of the woodwork to help my poor dear brother in law with offers of free childcare and cooking. None of these women (supposedly good friends of SIL when she was alive) were this generous when she was struggling to keep it together for the family while on chemotherapy and radiation. BIL was remarried within a year, new wife is a SAHM to my nieces and to the two boys of her own she's had since then. She seems alright but she's a lot more short-tempered and less affectionate than my husband's sister was and she doesn't allow any photos of her predecessor to be displayed in the main part of the house, only in photo books in a drawer or in the girls' rooms.

Q2C4 · 23/07/2022 05:08

Nesbo · 22/07/2022 12:44

I think your binary options are wrong. A proportion of men would believe (be socially conditioned to believe) that the main thing they have to offer their children is the income they can make from working outside of the home. I suspect they would try to find support from family etc as they would believe that this frees them up to make the contribution they are best suited to make.

now it is completely valid to criticise that view, to say that it is misguided and argue that their presence would be more valuable to the kids than their money, but I think the point remains that this is an approach a lot of them would take, and they would see it as being driven by love and concern and a desire to do what is best for the children.

It's not either or though, is it. Many mothers work and undertake the lion's share of their children's needs. Fathers could "contribute" by adopting this balance of working and child rearing.

Ciela · 22/07/2022 23:57

My mum was born in 1958 and her brother in 1962. Their dad raised them as a single parent without help when their mum walked out. My mum was 7.

Life wasn’t perfect but my grandad did his best. My mum sent him a mother and Father’s Day card until he died in 2010.