Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would men just put their kids into care?

361 replies

MustdrinkmoreH2O · 22/07/2022 12:32

Would be interested to know peoples thoughts on this.

since having my baby and going to a lot of baby groups and mixing with other mothers and reading these forums In can safely say a high proportion of men (not all of course), see child rearing as women primary responsibility.

Women tend to be the default parent in the events of splits and men having EOW or even just walking away completely.

So I was thinking, if women suddenly acted like men in this regard and literally left men holding the baby, what would honestly happen to a lot of children?

If women suddenly stopped carrying the mental load so didn’t book in any kind of medical appointment or arrange play dates or buy new clothes, what would honestly happen?

One of my friends is dating a single dad (mum walked out), but his parents practically raised the kids as he worked away. So still pretty much saw them only at weekends. However if a man leaves a woman with a baby, in normal circumstances she’d just find a new job where she didn’t work away, reduce hours of needed and use paid childcare. They wouldn’t normally hand their kids over to others to raise 80% of the time because they had to work.

So I’m really interested to see what a lot of men would do if the roles were reversed. If women literally just walked out or stopped carrying any mental load type stuff relating to the kids. Would men leave their jobs if required or go part time and claim universal credit?

Would the majority step up as women do and stop their hobbies, arrange childcare and extracurricular activities and basically fully give themselves to parenthood? Would they realise their kids need new vests, socks and tshirts or need a dental check up?

Or

Would they hand over their kids to grandparents/family members to be primarily raised or if failing that, put them into care? Would they do the bare minimum so kids are literally fed, watered and taken to school but other than that left to their own devices with no activities or medical appointments arranged or assemblies attended or well fitted clothes worn and basically be kind of neglected?

Be interested to know others thoughts on what would actually happen.

YABU - as many men as women would step up and look after their kids the same way single mothers do.

YANBU - unfortunately most men would try and shirk as much responsibility of child rearing sometimes even resulting in the care system if their were no willing people to become primary cater.

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 22/07/2022 14:00

StClare101 · 22/07/2022 13:54

Generally speaking, women take time off first. They have after all birthed a baby. I think that sets up unequal parenting arrangements that seem hard to break. It wasn’t until DH took a 12 month career break to look after the kids that he really got it! He was pretty involved before then but I carried the thought load. When I handed the thought load over he almost buckled. Now we are both working again and it’s much more equal… but it took the career break to do it.

This is why I think properly paid shared parental leave would help a lot. Starting with 90% of earnings for 6 weeks.

All the dads I know who took some form of leave, even if it was only with their first child, put a lot more effort into parenting.

OddSockQueen · 22/07/2022 14:00

It’s heart-warming to hear all the instances of dads stepping up. But, with respect, people must know that each anecdote, even when all added together, doesn’t negate the actual, endemic reality that women are overwhelmingly left holding the baby and that men are praised to the skies for doing basic stuff women do every day.

In extremis, most men would step up. Until that point, most, to varying degrees, do less than their partners. So, if OP’s question was about the issue of how unbalanced childcare is, I think people are wasting their time trying to deny this.

mam0918 · 22/07/2022 14:00

I will also say before my parents devorced my father was a SAHF and he did it purely to avoid going to work, he would lock me in a room and forget to feed me or change me (couldnt go to the toilet) so he could drink and do drugs with his friends.

It all came to a head when he left me home alone to go to the pub and a horrible accident happened that was life changing and nearly fatal, my mam devorced him immediately and quit work to become a full time cutodian.

I have no doubt there are some good STAF out there (just as theres some shit SAHM out there) but sometimes some men (and women) would happily keep the kids not to parent them but just for the free ride (while the kids are neglected).

HappilyHadesBound · 22/07/2022 13:59

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 22/07/2022 13:29

As a social worker I can tell you that these things happen a lot;


  • mum has difficulties, social workers get involved and dad barely attends meetings etc as 'working' seeing the social work plan as all about mum

  • agencies like schools and nurseries ask social services to pay for childcare to help mum out because 'dad is working' and seem surprised when we say dad needs to work less to care for the children

  • Many dads are surprised that social workers tell them they are expected to change work patterns and hours to be able to care for their children when mum can't do it because 'working'

  • many separated dads will let things get so bad with mum that child protection or even care proceedings are started before it occurs to them to take steps to have the DC in their care

  • even when this does happen they still expect social workers to pay for childcare etc

Bear in mind we work with families where there is risk of significant harm so the idea that men are stepping up automatically when it's just a case of separated parenting is unlikely IME

I'm pleased to say that my experience- both personal and within social work- is entirely in contrast to that!

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 22/07/2022 13:58

Seeing as gay men are actively becoming parents and bringing up children it would seem men as a group are capable, competent fathers

I do see a proportion of posts on here around men who are completely useless fathers. But its one sided, people post complaints more than compliments.

So some fathers would dump their children on other people etc, as some mothers do, and I think potentially a slightly higher proportion of fathers would.

But realistically speaking most men would not.

Besides which - in terms of the 'dumping' children on grandparents and paid care, what is the difference between a mother returning to paid employment using grandparents, nannies or nurseries for childcare, and a single father doing the same?

bloodywhitecat · 22/07/2022 13:58

My dad "stepped up" back in the 60s, everyone's advice to him was to divorce his wife (she was mentally unwell and nowhere near stable enough to be around us kids), put the kids in care and start again. He ignored the advice. There were times when he had to use the care system for us but he held things together, continued to work full time, visited mother daily and remained married to her until his death 5 years ago.

luxxlisbon · 22/07/2022 13:58

DH would do an absolutely cracking job of parenting if for whatever reason I wasn’t around.
He currently gets DD up, gives her breakfast, reads to her.c gets her ready for the day including hair, takes her to nursery then does bath time after work and alternates bedtime depends on workloads.
He makes medical appointments where necessary, brings DD to appointments.
I don’t run his life/book his dentist appointments/ make his lunch/ iron his clothes etc.

This isn’t a fluke, I picked an equal and capable partner to have children with.

CthulhuInDisguise · 22/07/2022 13:54

My late DH was left holding the baby (and a primary aged child) when his ex walked out. He arranged his shifts around childcare and was a solo parent until he met me - so 10 years of raising them alone. He had some help from his parents but no more than we had as a couple with DS. It's less common but it happens.

StClare101 · 22/07/2022 13:54

Generally speaking, women take time off first. They have after all birthed a baby. I think that sets up unequal parenting arrangements that seem hard to break. It wasn’t until DH took a 12 month career break to look after the kids that he really got it! He was pretty involved before then but I carried the thought load. When I handed the thought load over he almost buckled. Now we are both working again and it’s much more equal… but it took the career break to do it.

Lomex · 22/07/2022 13:54

I dunno. I think lots of men don't walk out on their families (including those who go through a divorce but continue to take the role of active dad). They're not as obvious as they're generally just getting on with things, but I think those dads would parent fully if they had to be the lone parent. I know that if I died my husband would take full responsibility for the kids, although I don't think he'd manage the juggle as well as I do, but that's more due to a disability he has than lack of willingness.

RedWingBoots · 22/07/2022 13:54

NancyJoan · 22/07/2022 13:19

My DH, and most men of our age (late 40s/early 50s) that I know, would expect a female relative to help out. When DH’s friend split from his wife when their son was 6, DH was astonished by my suggestion that if he changed his working hours he could have his son more that EOW. The wife took a lower salary, part time job to fit around school hours, of course.

Honestly, that told me a lot, and surprised me.

That's just your social circle.

Mine includes lots of older fathers who are in their late 40s/early 50s who took shared parental leave or did their holidays flexibly. They learnt a lot about parenting in those months and as they have good relationships with their children this has continued into the school years.

I also went to school with children's whose primary carer was their dad for a variety of reasons. Or whose parents both did shift work and the way the shifts fell both parents had to step up.

MercurialMonday · 22/07/2022 13:53

Depends - many step up.

Other's rely on other women to step into role - new GF or GM or other female family member.

However there's a shocking number that once done with the relationship with the mother even if apparently great father's before just seem to detach from the kids - they often great Step fathers to new women kids.

I think if I'd gone when the kids were very young DH would have stepped up but IL would have been there to help - in fact I suspect DH would have been pushed out by IL. Now they're teens of course DH would cope - they might have to be bit more independent but they'd adapt.

I do agree with PP though there's great expectations on mother's to just cope.

mam0918 · 22/07/2022 13:53

My DH isnt terrible, compared to most he is a very involved dad but if I died tomorrow everything would carry on as is with his mother replacing me, He would not quit work and raise them fully himself... Im certain of it.

He could handle morning school runs, taking them to the park at weekends, feeding/bathing them (after work), homework, putting them to bed but when it comes to Xmas/Birthdays/Holidays I would love to see how they would suddenly work.

DH dispise holidays (going away) with kids and birthday/Xmas would be 1 or 2 gifts bought the day before/day of or possibly even late, he never 'thinks' to do anything like easter egg hunts and 'marvels' at how I come up with basic normal ideas so the kids would miss out a lot.

There would be no birthday paries, whimsy, child like pomp etc... and all the 'fun' school projects (easter egg painting, dress up day etc... would never get done) unless his mother did them for him.

Londontown12 · 22/07/2022 13:53

In the 1980s my mother ran off
And my father brought us up !
Working full time as well it would have never crossed his mind to do anything but look after us x

ChagSameachDoreen · 22/07/2022 13:53

woolwinder · 22/07/2022 12:34

I am a male single parent, I know plenty of others. Don't generalise.

She isn't generalising. She's asking a question.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/07/2022 13:51

ihavenocats · 22/07/2022 13:36

Maybe maternal instinct is real.
Maybe we are natural caregivers.
Maybe men are natural providers.
Maybe children want and need their mothers when sick, upset, needing nurturing.

Maybe we don't need to progress or evolve, maybe traditional values are traditional because they work well.

So what are women who don't want kids or who leave their kids? What are men who want to be the SAHP?

SisyphusDad · 22/07/2022 13:51

Another single male parent here. Ten long, hard years and counting.

blebbleb · 22/07/2022 13:50

Not all men are useless turds. It seems to be the norm on Mumsnet but most dads I know are great.

SpencersCroftCat · 22/07/2022 13:49

I've been the secondary parent to one of my children for a while. Ex is lovely but he needed MASH to get through a lot. Our child is autistic and inattentive adhd and was non verbal til nearly five, doubly incontinent... Did my best from a distance and kid is pretty much thriving now, he's amazing. But when it came to life admin and doctors and so on, nothing was ever really pushed for and he never applied for DLA which he needed because he was also being pushed into work but he had no family on his doorstep.

Father of my other child openly said having his son living with him full time would be a serious problem because of his 'hobby' (not specifying the kind because it's not cycling but would make other details of this comment identifiable).

Lived with an ex long term partner who was the primary parent to a couple of kids. He was only just about coping but only because when he didn't get life admin sorted on time, eventually one of his friends or his dad would get involved.

I knew of two cases in my life where the mums walked away and the fathers situations really came to mind when my ex had our child for a few years - looked bedraggled and unkempt, looked like they needed some help with how to clean the children properly, their presentation on the whole looked somehow awkward. But they were doing the job.

I've know two men who were the primary or sole carer who got on and managed just as well as most mums.

And then back in the day, some men put their kids into homes or sold them or other family reared them - even in well to do families, kids were often sent to be reared by another family member for a period of time.

I notice more men being visibly the default primary parent/ carer. There's probably loads we just never knew about. And I know some same sex male families who are doing a stellar job at regular parenting. It's just a case of when it's happening, why it's happening, what society at that point says about it and what support there is or isn't for those who are dealing with the situation.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/07/2022 13:48

Hes the only bloke that goes and is treated like some kind of golden treasure because of it hahaha this is so true. Either adored or ostracised.. My friend is a good dad. He'll primary parent during working day - works around the kids where possible, is the one who stays home if a kid is sick etc. Lots of the women fawn over how good a Daddy is, esp as he helps me with mine and
people assume.

Hed be fine as a single parent. He does have family support but he'd cope.
DH would run a tidier house but the kids would def DO less. Both our families would help but I think that's fair enough, and it would be in childcare not child raising.
But I can imagine a few where the kids would basically be cared for by female relatives whilst they remained fairly hands off.

MayDaze · 22/07/2022 13:47

My partner, before I met him, was a fully functioning working single dad to 2 children.

My brother is a fully functioning single dad to his daughter

In both cases, neither mother is on the scene - very different reasons.

Both made use of family help and after school clubs etc. Same as I did when I was a fully functioning single parent to my 2 children.

Feckless parents are feckless parents, regardless of sex. I believe the majority of men would step up to the plate when faced with single parenting. It is ridiculous to think otherwise.

ChinBristles · 22/07/2022 13:47

Hmm. I think if my mum had died when we were kids, we would have eaten a LOT of (burned) fish fingers and oven chips.

I'd imagine my dad would have carried on with his job to pay the bills and my grandparents would have moved closer to do childcare.

Mind you, parenting in the 1980s was pretty much benign neglect anyway so I'm sure I would have been ok.

AnneElliott · 22/07/2022 13:46

I think most would find another female to take up the work. A PP references the thread the other day about the dad wanting 50/50 with the grandma as the mum wasn't keen on parenting.

No way does that happen with single mums!

Different maybe if all female help disappeared? I guess some would sink and others would swim.

TimeSlipMushroom · 22/07/2022 13:45

ihavenocats · 22/07/2022 13:36

Maybe maternal instinct is real.
Maybe we are natural caregivers.
Maybe men are natural providers.
Maybe children want and need their mothers when sick, upset, needing nurturing.

Maybe we don't need to progress or evolve, maybe traditional values are traditional because they work well.

Are you my local Conservative mp?

BiscoffSundae · 22/07/2022 13:44

My ex wouldn’t have our children if something happened to me, he openly said he wouldn’t. I think a lot would be put into care despite what people say on here

Swipe left for the next trending thread