Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if most people openly share salaries with friends (and families?) in the UK?

218 replies

polka6 · 21/07/2022 23:15

I know it often comes up on MN how much people earn etc, are people in the UK anywhere near as open in real life? what about with close friends - do you share when you have a promotion etc? Is it more standard to do that with family?

Personally, I more or less share the details with parents and friends in the same line of work (who earn similar or previous have done or will do in the future) but not so much with friends not in the same career circles and probably downplay it whereas the general consensus on MN seems to be people inflate the figures?

OP posts:
Pyewhacket · 22/07/2022 12:37

I don't but I work for the NHS so you can go online and see the salary bands there.

RedWingBoots · 22/07/2022 12:37

Cyclebabble · 22/07/2022 11:48

There will often be good reasons why someone receives a higher bonus or is on higher pay as productivity varies significantly in most roles. IME where one person receives a higher bonus for performing well, the rest of the team will sometimes not say well done they will rant and bitch very significantly. I would strongly advise not discussing pay or bonus. If you need to benchmark you can ask HR some very specific questions around pay which you are absolutely entitled to.

That isn't true.

Some of these "good" reasons are:


  1. Not having children

  2. Sexism

  3. Ableism

  4. Racism

  5. Religious discrimination


Management then pretend that it is because you don't have as much experience as someone else, when in fact you have more experience as you have discussed with your peers.

RedToothBrush · 22/07/2022 12:35

Disagree. People shouldn’t be on wildly different salaries for the same job so colleagues absolutely should discuss it.

See I disagree with this to an extent. Whilst you can be the same grade or have the same job title as a college, this doesn't make all things equal.

Its still possible that one will be given projects which have greater responsibility and profitability to a company and one employee may have significantly more valuable skill sets and experience that makes them worth paying more.

For example, someone who has worked at a company for a number of years and has been a solid and reliable employee may be paid more and this is reasonable. An employee might go above and beyond regularly by choice, whereas another has to leave at 5pm on the dot or doesnt want extra responsibility.

Its much more complex than just saying you should all get the exact same wage on the same grade. There should be a range within grade to reward those who do take on more. Otherwise what is the incentive to do so apart from a perhaps limited opportunity for promotion?

saraclara · 22/07/2022 12:35

I think colleagues knowing each other's salaries can be very positive. Transparency in that regard is valuable.

But friends and family? I can't see anything particularly positive about sharing it (in most cases) and there's definitely a possible downside if it changes the way people see you, or if they feel resentful.

RedWingBoots · 22/07/2022 12:34

WendellGeez · 22/07/2022 11:55

I forgot my main point — I think this whole culture of "salary secrecy" is a tactic invented by employers so they can pay everyone as little as possible.

It is which is why I enjoyed working with international teams in the UK.

Some of them had no problems talking about salary and perks. 😀

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 22/07/2022 12:24

Cognacsoft · 22/07/2022 08:25

It doesn't matter who you tell or don't.
Mortgages are mostly linked to salaries.
It takes a minute to chk what you paid for your home on zoopla sold prices.

We got our mortgage 12 years ago and it was small because we bought a very cheap house. My annual salary is now twice the total amount remaining on my mortgage and we have no plans to move so not indicative at all of salary.

WendellGeez · 22/07/2022 11:55

I forgot my main point — I think this whole culture of "salary secrecy" is a tactic invented by employers so they can pay everyone as little as possible.

WendellGeez · 22/07/2022 11:54

I used to work in the public sector and everyone knew exactly what everyone else earned—the jobs were all graded and on a scale. It seemed fair.

When I moved to the private sector I was initially surprised at how cagey everyone was about disclosing their salary. I soon learned that that it was was "every man for himself" and someone doing the same job as me might be earning twice as much!

In hindsight I prefer the first system. although it doesn't exactly encourage people to excel, but I was never pushy enough to wrangle a good salary for myself in private sector.

Cyclebabble · 22/07/2022 11:48

TedMullins · 22/07/2022 09:25

Disagree. People shouldn’t be on wildly different salaries for the same job so colleagues absolutely should discuss it.

also for all the people saying “it’s considered rude/I was brought up being told not to talk about it” do you never question anything you’re told? Positive change only happens because people challenge the status quo and resist doing things in the name of tradition or expectation. Just because someone told you not to talk about salaries doesn’t mean you have to abide by that.

There will often be good reasons why someone receives a higher bonus or is on higher pay as productivity varies significantly in most roles. IME where one person receives a higher bonus for performing well, the rest of the team will sometimes not say well done they will rant and bitch very significantly. I would strongly advise not discussing pay or bonus. If you need to benchmark you can ask HR some very specific questions around pay which you are absolutely entitled to.

daisypond · 22/07/2022 11:47

I profoundly disagree with the idea that it is vulgar to talk about salaries. It isn’t. The concept of vulgarity comes from the concept of work, and goes back to the idea that those who work and get paid for that work and need that salary to live are very non U. Talking about salaries is important. Unless you’re landed gentry with inherited money and no need to work, everyone should talk about salaries.

latetothefisting · 22/07/2022 11:37

SheeplessAndCounting · 22/07/2022 11:20

But you have no idea how much of the sale price was a deposit and how much was mortgage?

Exactly! Plus my mortgage was arranged based on my salary at the time, by the time I'd actually moved into the house 5 months later I'd changed jobs and salary had honestly up fifty percent, and has now 3 years later nearly doubled to what it was when mortgage was agreed.

House price is no reflection at all of salary - what about where one partner buys the home then the other moves in? Or vice versa after a separation? Or just people who've lived in the same house for years and will have often increased salary fairly significantly over that time?

Thatswhyimacat · 22/07/2022 11:27

I will tell if asked. I probably wouldn't ask anyone else but mostly just because I don't really care. My friend is OBSESSED with other people's salaries so I know an awful lot through her gossiping, it's actually really annoying.

SheeplessAndCounting · 22/07/2022 11:20

Cognacsoft · 22/07/2022 08:25

It doesn't matter who you tell or don't.
Mortgages are mostly linked to salaries.
It takes a minute to chk what you paid for your home on zoopla sold prices.

But you have no idea how much of the sale price was a deposit and how much was mortgage?

Jolinar · 22/07/2022 10:46

My family don't. But lots of my friends do. We often discuss stuff like pensions and investments which naturally leads to income discussion. But we all have broadly similar household incomes. I don't discuss it with people I don't know well.

I have friend who constantly boasts about her husband's income and it drives me nuts. So I don't discuss finances with her.

RedWingBoots · 22/07/2022 10:41

Oddly I know what acquaintances e.g. friends spouses, friends of friends, earn because they are work in the same way I do but we work in different industries. The main things we discuss is ensuring we don't come a cropper with the taxman and stop people from doing anything stupid.

One of my siblings knows what I earn and I know what he earns. Plus we know what some of our young adult nieces and nephews earn in similar fields. We are always trying to work out ways for them to earn more.

OooErr · 22/07/2022 10:35

Butteryflakycrust83 · 22/07/2022 10:26

Also I earn more than the majority of my friends and there is one in particular who seems to have a mild gripe at my salary when her own 'key worker' role is paid minimum wage and its just uncomfortable. I deflect from mine and point out that yes, she should be paid more for her valued work.

Same here.
People think my job is easy, just sitting in front a computer all day.
I agree that a lot of more important professions should be paid more but it’s not my fault. Why resent me?

bingoitsadingo · 22/07/2022 10:30

I'm fairly open with my friends - for some I know exact amounts, others I have a reasonable ballpark. I've given exact amounts to some at times - I don't go around shouting "I earn XX" but it comes up in conversation now and then.
Close family (i.e. my siblings and parents) I'm very open with, they are great with financial advice and not judgemental so it would feel really weird to be secretive about.

Butteryflakycrust83 · 22/07/2022 10:26

Also I earn more than the majority of my friends and there is one in particular who seems to have a mild gripe at my salary when her own 'key worker' role is paid minimum wage and its just uncomfortable. I deflect from mine and point out that yes, she should be paid more for her valued work.

RincewindsHat · 22/07/2022 10:26

Yes, I share what I pay myself very openly if people ask. It's above average and more than my family members earn, but below what several of my friends earn. I don't care if people know how much money I make, and I think it's a very odd and outdated attitude to consider it crass to talk about money openly. If as a society we were more open about money, I think people would be encouraged to be more fiscally responsible and more inclined to become increasingly financially literate, particularly if budgeting info, investing and saving choices etc were also shared. I love seeing what other people do with their money because it was never talked about when I grew up and I came to financial literacy later than I would have otherwise chosen, simply because I didn't know what I didn't know.

smileandsing · 22/07/2022 10:25

No I don't share salary info. My DH knows of course, and work colleagues know because we are all on a salary scale. No one else does though as I earn well and tend to find people judge jealously, which is ridiculous!
Many of the most judgy are unfortunately women who work PT by choice with on tap grandparent childcare and a DH/P who earns well. I find they see it as different for me to earn well than for their DPs because I'm a woman. But what they don't see is I don't have the options they do. I have no choice but to work because I have to support my family, DH can't work due to ill health, so although he's around I also have to fund childcare. We have no family to assist with this. So while I earn a lot and seemingly have a comfortable lifestyle, I don't have the choices and support that many take for granted.

Some things are best kept private.

Butteryflakycrust83 · 22/07/2022 10:25

I cant think of an example of when I would volunteer the information, but if someone asked I dont mind telling them!

Lomex · 22/07/2022 10:21

I don't because I earn more than most people I hang out with and it would definitely come across as boasting. But on the other hand I think it's sad we're not more open about salaries, as now I earn more, I realise that the trick to a higher salary is knowing what is possible and demanding what you're worth.

MsPincher · 22/07/2022 10:19

I discuss salary with close friends irl. On mn I accurately post how much I earn because it’s an anonymous message board. I don’t see the excitement of some posters claiming posters are lying if they have large salaries. I know lots of people irl who earn that sort of money.

Butchyrestingface · 22/07/2022 10:17

Scottish, self-employed for over 20 years. I don't discuss salary specifics with anyone. My parents never discussed theirs with me, although I have a vague idea what one earned because they worked for the local authority.

I think the fact I'm self employed makes it less likely that I'd discuss this with colleagues? We are all ultimately competitors and it's just done something that happens. Some people in my industry are registered as limited companies though, so if I had a burning urge to find out, I could out check their returns on Companies House.

latetothefisting · 22/07/2022 10:17

No haven't discussed with family or friends. I don't have an absolute aversion to it, but can't think of any situations where needing to know my actual salary would be relevant in any conversations I might have. That said a lot of my friends and family work in the public sector so I could probably make a fairly close guess at what they make if I wanted to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread