Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Get married !! If you are the poorer half

117 replies

Lindasllama · 21/07/2022 21:56

Have read so many different threads on here this evening and still women are putting themselves in such a precarious position..

if your earning power will diminish once pregnant.. if you are /will be reliant on your 'D' P for financial stability when child arrives . Why haven't you both signed that legal contract called marriage ?

I honestly believe this stuff should be taught in schools to empower women to make their own well informed choice before they screw their later lives looking after kids - ending up far poorer than their children's fathers .

If you are the higher earner. Own your own home , have independent income .. then this question does not apply. Only interested in the thoughts of those who will be screwed if DP fucks off and will leave you screwed .

OP posts:
EtnaVesuvius · 22/07/2022 08:16

Also

if you split having given up your career for a man

is a bit offensive, isn’t it? No one gives up their career for ‘a man’ - they give up their career for their children.

EtnaVesuvius · 22/07/2022 08:15

Coffeaddict · 21/07/2022 22:09

I always find it funny on mumsnet that there is an image that marriage gives you this amazing financial security.
It will give you a higher proportion of the equity in the shared home and access to spouses pension. However if you split having given up your career for a man then you are still in a precarious position even with a marriage certificate. There are so many threads here telling women who have been at home for 10 years that now the husband has left they need a job.
Spousal support is not a thing in this country except in some very high earning situations.

Not much of this is true. Spousal maintenance is more common than you think, for a start.

oviraptor21 · 22/07/2022 08:13

Nothappyatwork · 21/07/2022 22:07

Marriage does not offer the protection that people think it makes it more difficult to navigate the escape.

Less difficult now with no fault divorce.

BadNomad · 22/07/2022 08:12

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/07/2022 07:24

Right but if that happens you go it alone. At least that way what’s your is yours.

Shackling yourself to someone who can’t be arsed to marry you and “hoping for the best because you want a family” is a pretty desperate way to plan a life.

This is exactly the mindset which gets women into so much trouble and we would eliminate a lot of this is we taught them to aspire for some financial independence rather than desperately scratching around for a man to cling to.

What financial independence do you think a woman on minimum wage will have when she has children? Because not everyone is able to study or train their way into 6-figure jobs with good maternity perks and flexible hours. Your carers, waitresses, shop workers are going to struggle to do it alone if they want children. Unless you think only well-off women should have children, then? It's very ignorant to say women just need to be taught to do better for themselves.

SpilltheTea · 22/07/2022 08:11

Don't rely on a man financially in the first place. Marriage isn't the magic solution.

mug2018 · 22/07/2022 07:55

I would have been so better off if I hadn't married my ExH before having my daughter
We married, bought the house, had a child & he quit his job, became a lazy abusive b*d, ran up debts & the divorce cost me more than he deserved
Marriage does not provide financial security in all case.

OooErr · 22/07/2022 07:54

I thought it was all about the house - as it used to be common for people with kids to own a house.
If there’s no house then no bother…

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/07/2022 07:53

Numbat2022 · 22/07/2022 07:45

It would be far more sensible to tell women to keep their jobs and make sure their names are on the house deeds/rental agreement. Better to have financial security for yourself than rely on anyone else.

This. In giant neon letters.
This should form part of the primary school curriculum tbh. It's so important.

Discovereads · 22/07/2022 07:53

There are now civil partnerships as well as marriage which give the same legal benefits and protections.

It’s all well and good saying women should be financially independent, have a career and so on but even the best laid plans can go tits up. The same with saying only enter into marriage/civil partnership if you’re the lower earner but avoid it if you are the higher earner- your comparative earnings could fluctuate over the long term.

I married young. I was degree educated, with a career and the higher earner by a factor of 3. I married a poor working class man who didn’t get his GCSEs until he was in his 20s and worked in a factory. By MN, I should never have married.

But then I was completely disabled in a hit and run accident. I lost my job, my career, my ability to work, and my income went from six figures to the pittance of state disability benefits and a workplace ill health pension. In the meantime, my DH had gone to University and was now a degreed professional earning a good salary and owned a business on the side. Now the tables were fully turned. He was the cash cow in the relationship. He was also now caring for a disabled wife.

If he’d decided my condition was too much for him, he could have fucked off. And people do in these sorts of situations all the time. A colleague of mine left her partner when he went blind. And if we weren’t married, I’d have no claim on anything he built up during our marriage with my support- after all I paid his tuition costs at University. I supported us and the DC while he went to Uni full time and only worked PT. He didn’t get to where he is without my support.

Too, if I had not been married and not survived the accident, my DH and by extension DC would have lost quite a bit to inheritance tax. Married/civil partner couples can inherit everything from their other half tax free.

So, I don’t think there are any rules of thumb to marry/civil partner or not. I agree though that boys and girls need to be educated on marriage/civil partnership vs cohabitation and what that means for legal rights and then make their own decisions. Because it doesn’t just matter what your circumstances are now, it matters what kind of person your partner is and what your future might be.

Goesbothways · 22/07/2022 07:47

I have informed my son what a failed marriage could cost him and I think he’s put off for life

Me too

Numbat2022 · 22/07/2022 07:45

It would be far more sensible to tell women to keep their jobs and make sure their names are on the house deeds/rental agreement. Better to have financial security for yourself than rely on anyone else.

Onlyrainbows · 22/07/2022 07:45

Well I mean for me it means that staying married is always the most financially safe thing to do.

Anothernamechangeplease · 22/07/2022 07:43

Well, I will certainly be encouraging dd not to put herself in a financially vulnerable position where she is dependent on a partner without any legal protection.

However, I will also be warning her about potentially putting her assets at risk by legally attaching herself to someone who can't or won't pull their weight financially and may later lay claim to what she has earned.

Best case scenario in my view is that she will work towards being financially independent, get together with someone who shares that goal and then both maintain their careers so that they will always be able to support themselves. Of course, life gets in the way sometimes, and sickness/disability etc can make it impossible for one partner to work, and that's where the other has to step in to support, but being in a relationship where partners are contributing about the same financially is the ideal as far as I'm concerned, and I hope that that's the kind of relationship that dd will end up in.

Mally100 · 22/07/2022 07:41

cantcomplainabouttheweather · 21/07/2022 22:27

My advice to my girls will be not to need to rely on a partner for financial security. There is no need in todays society. Giving up a career or having a year on ML is a choice and a luxury. Go out and study and earn your own money then you won't need to rely on marriage 🤔

This ! Take responsibility and accountability for your own choices. It's 2022, there are no excuses to hide behind this mentality that women are some precious, vulnerable, feeble species that have no capacity. It is your responsibility.

Mally100 · 22/07/2022 07:38

Boxowine · 21/07/2022 22:14

Strongly disagree! Teach your daughters to be financially independent and support social services so that women have access to family planning and reproductive healthcare. Fund anti poverty measures so that women who are or may become single mothers aren't forced to choose between staying with a man or abject poverty and teach financial literacy so that women with assets know how to protect them if they choose not to get married.

Exactly! It's disgusting that you think a woman needs to do this to a man, instead of taking responsibility for her own independence. I was the lower earner compared to dh but I can see that is because of the choices that I made. Girls don't need to be taught this in school ffs. They need to be taught that they are responsible for their own financial situation, not go marry a man.

Cosmos123 · 22/07/2022 07:36

Badgirlgonegood · 21/07/2022 22:30

There are plenty of married women on here with a tight as fuck husband who still doesn’t share his wealth.

Marriage is not a fool proof plan for financial protection.

The answer is earn your own money and remain financially independent.

InChocolateWeTrust · 22/07/2022 07:33

Getting married isnt the answer to women's financial insecurity!
It doesnt solve:

  • situations where the couple are asset poor (don't own any property) - child maintenance doesn't make up for a lack of a proper income to get a mortgage with.
  • having kids with a bloke who doesn't earn much

The best ways for women to guarantee their own financial security are:

  • get your own good full time job - actually plan your career considering how much a job pays and what the long term prospects are
  • save up before a pregnancy and return to work after maternity leave, splitting child care costs with your childs father.
  • save in your own name
  • make sure property is in your name & that you are contributing towards the mortgage.
Thepeopleversuswork · 22/07/2022 07:24

BadNomad · 22/07/2022 04:37

Ageing happens. Not everyone has the time to find someone to marry first before having children. And accidental pregnancies happen. You can't force a man to marry you. Sometimes women will take what they can get, and hope for the best, if it means they can have a family.

Right but if that happens you go it alone. At least that way what’s your is yours.

Shackling yourself to someone who can’t be arsed to marry you and “hoping for the best because you want a family” is a pretty desperate way to plan a life.

This is exactly the mindset which gets women into so much trouble and we would eliminate a lot of this is we taught them to aspire for some financial independence rather than desperately scratching around for a man to cling to.

sorrynotathome · 22/07/2022 07:23

If all the things people insist “they should teach in schools” were taught in schools, children would be attending 12 hours a day and learning no traditional subjects at all.

Hannakl · 22/07/2022 07:21

This is a common theme on MN and I don’t really get it. My two divorced friends were totally screwed over by their ex husbands and would have been far better off if they weren’t married. Surely financial independence is what people should aim for. I am the much lower earner but could support myself and DH would have to /want to pay a lot towards the children because they are his children, nothing to do with marital status. My advice wouldn’t be to get married but would be to go back to work after maternity leave.

BadNomad · 22/07/2022 04:37

Ageing happens. Not everyone has the time to find someone to marry first before having children. And accidental pregnancies happen. You can't force a man to marry you. Sometimes women will take what they can get, and hope for the best, if it means they can have a family.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/07/2022 00:34

OP's proposition is far too simplistic.

I don't disagree that being married can confer necessary security for some.

However, this idea that being married offers a cast-iron security in the case of relationship breakdown is nonsense. I'm 9 years on from managing to get my abusive ex to leave & I am still not divorced & it has been financial hell. (Partly complicated by being in Ireland and at the time of separation, you had to be married 4 years before getting divorced. It's been reduced since).

As a PP said, what is vitally important is that women in particular prioritise their financial & employment security, in particular their ability to eg return to full time financially sustainable employment if their marriage ends (his many times on MN do we read of a women who either became a SAHM early in the marriage or chose a low paid flexible job to fit in with kids - doing either is not wrong but please ensure you keep your options open, in terms of training or re-skilling).

I have always worked in a professional role. I earned approx the same as my exH. However he was financially abusive, and burnt through every penny we earned + all savings, as he became increasingly profligate, I bailed him out at my own cost, no life for me, putting my own needs last as he spent & lived recklessly. What I needed was a huge dose of reality & a lot more self-esteem to realise he was an abusive shit much earlier & not stand for it.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/07/2022 00:22

Nothappyatwork · 21/07/2022 22:07

Marriage does not offer the protection that people think it makes it more difficult to navigate the escape.

Great point 👏

Reallyreallyborednow · 22/07/2022 00:01

If you are the higher earner. Own your own home , have independent income .. then this question does not apply. Only interested in the thoughts of those who will be screwed if DP fucks off and will leave you screwed

it does apply.

a) why wouldn’t you also teach your daughters that if they are the higher earners, independently wealthy etc that marriage doesn’t benefit

b) if dh fucks off you will still be screwed as he will fuck off with half your house, half your pensions and savings, and possibly even may claim maintenance.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/07/2022 23:56

Boxowine · 21/07/2022 22:14

Strongly disagree! Teach your daughters to be financially independent and support social services so that women have access to family planning and reproductive healthcare. Fund anti poverty measures so that women who are or may become single mothers aren't forced to choose between staying with a man or abject poverty and teach financial literacy so that women with assets know how to protect them if they choose not to get married.

Totally agree.

Marriage is a reasonable insurance policy for a woman who is already the financially weaker partner and tactically to be recommended in this case. But it's no substitute for being financially independent and standing on your own two feet in the first place.

What worries me a bit about posts like this is that you're encouraging women to continue to see marriage as an end in itself and a panacea for all financial problems.

When in fact, yes it does give you a degree of protection. But marriage won't compensate for years of lost earnings when you give up work. It won't protect you from an acrimonious split and even in the best case scenario, where you get 50% of all earnings in a divorce, its going to take years and be messy and unpleasant to get there.

Marriage should never be a woman's primary financial goal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread