Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Get married !! If you are the poorer half

117 replies

Lindasllama · 21/07/2022 21:56

Have read so many different threads on here this evening and still women are putting themselves in such a precarious position..

if your earning power will diminish once pregnant.. if you are /will be reliant on your 'D' P for financial stability when child arrives . Why haven't you both signed that legal contract called marriage ?

I honestly believe this stuff should be taught in schools to empower women to make their own well informed choice before they screw their later lives looking after kids - ending up far poorer than their children's fathers .

If you are the higher earner. Own your own home , have independent income .. then this question does not apply. Only interested in the thoughts of those who will be screwed if DP fucks off and will leave you screwed .

OP posts:
Mennex · 22/07/2022 14:42

The people that I know who are in a precarious financial position in middle age are ALL people that have been through a divorce. I really don't get this argument. It's really expensive to go through a divorce.

TimBoothseyes · 22/07/2022 14:42

I'd never marry anyone who earned less than me anyway. Made that mistake before, won't happen again.

deedledeedledum · 22/07/2022 14:39

hattie43 · 21/07/2022 22:10

Strange post but I agree women should have financial independence.
I can't ever imagine leaving my financial security to a man .

It's not about leaving your financial security to a man. It's that if you get pregnant and have dc, most of the time, there will be a hit to your career due to time taken out. Once your pay falls beneath his, it often becomes default that the woman is the one to sort out staying home if dc are unwell etc to protect his higher earnings. This causes a further curb on her career. It is doable but very hard to have zero negative impact on a career if you have dc. So this needs to be accounted for in divorce

Vikinga · 22/07/2022 14:34

LondonQueen · 22/07/2022 14:18

So it's okay for men to end up poorer but not women? How about pick your partner well before you have DC.

No. The point is that when you get married and have children, sacrifices have to be made by everyone.

I didnt work for 10 years as I birthed and looked after 4 kids. My ex wouldn't have been able to do his job had he had to look after the kids 50% .

If we had both carried on working and not had kids we would both have been better off.

However, my career pause set me back whilst his grew. I had to restart.

So if there are equal childcare and career breaks and stuff then it's fine to each keep what they earn

Lindasllama · 22/07/2022 14:33

Coffeaddict · 21/07/2022 22:09

I always find it funny on mumsnet that there is an image that marriage gives you this amazing financial security.
It will give you a higher proportion of the equity in the shared home and access to spouses pension. However if you split having given up your career for a man then you are still in a precarious position even with a marriage certificate. There are so many threads here telling women who have been at home for 10 years that now the husband has left they need a job.
Spousal support is not a thing in this country except in some very high earning situations.

Yes I absolutely agree that marriage does not mean some sort of magical ring of security. However it does provide for a huge amount more than cohabitation. Which provided bugger all.. unless you get v lucky and able to make a claim for housing under the childrens act.

If you are the generalised sahm alluded to here who is left by a husband it is unlikely she would get spousal maintenance. However she would have a financial interest in a property if they own. Of which she would usually be able to secure more than a 50% interest in. Not great - but something .

Parents living in their cohabiting partners property are entitled to nothing save CM.

OP posts:
D0lphine · 22/07/2022 14:21

vivainsomnia · 22/07/2022 14:08

Oh the irony of this thread! For every poorer person in a couple, the other will be better off. If none of the better off decide to marry, how will the worse off end up married?

Or should people only dates those of the same income? But then what happens after children, after promotions etc.... Total rubbish.

I've taught my daughter to be financially independent and advised to it have children with an prepared and wanting to be 50% involved in childcare. I taught my son to be financially independent and to be prepared to do 50% of childcare.

I advised to never marry to provide security for their partner or unless they are prepared to potentially lose more than half their assets.

Exactly what I was trying to say up thread. All I got was "clue is in the title". Peak Mumsnet

LondonQueen · 22/07/2022 14:18

So it's okay for men to end up poorer but not women? How about pick your partner well before you have DC.

vivainsomnia · 22/07/2022 14:08

Oh the irony of this thread! For every poorer person in a couple, the other will be better off. If none of the better off decide to marry, how will the worse off end up married?

Or should people only dates those of the same income? But then what happens after children, after promotions etc.... Total rubbish.

I've taught my daughter to be financially independent and advised to it have children with an prepared and wanting to be 50% involved in childcare. I taught my son to be financially independent and to be prepared to do 50% of childcare.

I advised to never marry to provide security for their partner or unless they are prepared to potentially lose more than half their assets.

TedMullins · 22/07/2022 13:58

Fleur405 · 22/07/2022 12:51

Well I realise you don’t want my opinion because I earn enough to be financially independent (even though I’m currently subsided by my other half (to whom I’m not married) because I’m on maternity leave) … but I’m going to give it to you anyway. I can’t disagree more with the idea we should be teaching girls they need to get married to be secure! I certainly won’t be teaching my daughter that. What we need to do is challenge the societal issues that leave women in this position (I.e the gender pay gap, the idea that caring is primarily women’s responsibility and the high cost of childcare).

Agree wholeheartedly with this.

Fleur405 · 22/07/2022 12:51

Well I realise you don’t want my opinion because I earn enough to be financially independent (even though I’m currently subsided by my other half (to whom I’m not married) because I’m on maternity leave) … but I’m going to give it to you anyway. I can’t disagree more with the idea we should be teaching girls they need to get married to be secure! I certainly won’t be teaching my daughter that. What we need to do is challenge the societal issues that leave women in this position (I.e the gender pay gap, the idea that caring is primarily women’s responsibility and the high cost of childcare).

notamilf · 22/07/2022 12:45

Wtf have I just read? Maybe go out to work and earn your own bloody money

Goesbothways · 22/07/2022 12:19

Sons have to be educated too for their future marriages

My son is adamant he doesn't want kids, and knows that if he partners up with a woman who does and is eventually persuaded to have them (how many times do we see that on here), he can't say "well it's you who wanted them" and leave her to bear the burden in so many ways.

He's got his eyes wide open and is determined to only settle (if at all) with a like minded woman who shares his aspirations.

ihavenocats · 22/07/2022 11:19

chopc · 21/07/2022 22:13

Haven't read the full thread. I am the lower earner of the two but with the support of my family, hired help and a hands on DH, managed to keep my career going and earn a comfortable salary. If he buggers off I won't be able to support my current lifestyle alone. However if he pays all the school fees and other costs related to the kids, I can comfortably support myself.

DH however said if that were to happen, everything will be split 50:50. I don't think this is right as most of our assets are due to his earnings. I also know the person you are divorcing will not be the person you are married to

Sounds like you have a proper man there who will ensure his children's mother is taken care of no matter what. I know mine is the same. They do exist, you just have to be clear about wanting them when dating. And have something to offer them in return.

ihavenocats · 22/07/2022 11:17

Well I would never be screwed because I am employable and have earning potential. I am married, but if you are a SAHM you have time in your day to work on your future. Yes, you're busy, but there's no travel, it's a whole day, oftentimes little one is at school leaving 5 hours at least to improve yourself; a course, learn about investments, do a little job for cash to use, crafty stuff to sell etc. etc.

Take advantage of the situation don't sit there eating bon bons.

HesterShaw1 · 22/07/2022 10:38

Gsds · 21/07/2022 21:59

Totally the advice I would to my daughter, which is all well and good, except I have informed my son what a failed marriage could cost him and I think he’s put off for life.

Yes this is a good message to teach girls. However the boys will learn it too.

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 22/07/2022 10:36

@Blossomtoes yes we both get each other's.
We are financially water tight.

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/07/2022 09:26

BadNomad · 22/07/2022 08:12

What financial independence do you think a woman on minimum wage will have when she has children? Because not everyone is able to study or train their way into 6-figure jobs with good maternity perks and flexible hours. Your carers, waitresses, shop workers are going to struggle to do it alone if they want children. Unless you think only well-off women should have children, then? It's very ignorant to say women just need to be taught to do better for themselves.

Of course having children shouldn’t only be for well off women.

But the point is that as a woman in minimum wage or whatever you are not going to enhance your financial prospects by hooking up with a man just for the sake of it. Particularly one who won’t marry you.

Better poor but free and independent than poor and having all the shots called by a bloke who is also poor and doesn’t really give a shit.

neverbeenskiing · 22/07/2022 09:16

I agree with PP that marriage doesn't necessarily give the financial protection many on MN think.
I know a woman who's DH left her suddenly for another woman, emptied their joint bank account, stopped making mortgage payments, cancelled all his direct debits for household bills and just refused to communicate with her at all. She was later told by a solicitor this is more common than people think. He was by far the higher earner but suddenly she was responsible for paying everything. They had a DC at university and he also withdrew all financial support from them. She increased her hours at work but still ended up going into debt. After very lengthy and stressful court proceedings she was eventually granted permission to sell the marital home. She got half the proceeds from the sale but got nothing else in the divorce as he claimed to have no other assets/savings. She suspects these were transferred into OW's name. She is now living in a small flat, still working FT in her 60's and can't see how she will ever be able to retire.

Shortjanet · 22/07/2022 09:09

As a couple of other posters have said the advice to remain financially independent does not consider the potential for illness or disability. I was the higher earner for the first decade of our marriage and continued to work ft with the first two children. We didn't expect DC3 to be born disabled but the impact on my ability to work when they were was enormous. DH's earnings had caught up with mine by then. Totally fair enough to encourage everyone to be independent but the unexpected does happen to some!

I'm opposed to treating cohabiting couples as if married from a financial perspective. It removes the ability for those who do not wish to have any financial link to live together when there may be good reason, eg wanting to pass inheritance to their own children. Couples should weigh up what marriage means for their circumstances and make an informed choice.

Blossomtoes · 22/07/2022 08:54

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 22/07/2022 08:35

Been with dp for 3 years and never married.
I legally own half of everything and I won't be screwed if we split up.
Don't give up your financial independence and earn your own money

If his assets are more than £325k you’ll pay unnecessary tax if he dies though. And would you get his death in service payment if he has one? I know someone who’s missed out on over £1 million because she wasn’t married to her partner.

Mally100 · 22/07/2022 08:53

cantcomplainabouttheweather · 22/07/2022 08:47

No one gives up their career for ‘a man’ - they give up their career for their children.

No but they sure are quick to blame a man.

Exactly!! So many women who would love not to work and be sahp but won't admit that, easier to blame a man.

cantcomplainabouttheweather · 22/07/2022 08:47

No one gives up their career for ‘a man’ - they give up their career for their children.

No but they sure are quick to blame a man.

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 22/07/2022 08:35

Been with dp for 3 years and never married.
I legally own half of everything and I won't be screwed if we split up.
Don't give up your financial independence and earn your own money

loislovesstewie · 22/07/2022 08:29

I think it is important that everyone understands the legal differences between being married and being in a long term relationship and not being married. Not just in the sense of division of assets upon divorce but also such things as next of kin at death, whether survivor's pension will be paid etc. There are still people who think that common law marriage exist sand confers the same status as actual marriage, and it must be very distressing to find that one party is not able to be next of kin legally as no marriage has taken place.

Mememene · 22/07/2022 08:24

Goesbothways · 22/07/2022 07:47

I have informed my son what a failed marriage could cost him and I think he’s put off for life

Me too

Goesbothways ·
I have informed my son what a failed marriage could cost him and I think he’s put off for life

Ive tried to educate my son too, his dad and myself are divorced and each own a house which he will eventually inherit when we've popped off. These houses will eventually become a part of the marital assets when we are no longer here.

Sons have to be educated too for their future marriages. He still wants to meet the right lady, marry and have children, bless his non cynical little soul. 😀

Swipe left for the next trending thread