Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Catholic school admissions

85 replies

ivfbabymomma1 · 21/07/2022 21:41

Hi all

Does anyones children go to a catholic school when they aren't catholic?

My son is christened CofE but there is a really good catholic primary school 2 minutes walk from my house...

So I have a chance?

Thank you!!!!

OP posts:
theruffles · 22/07/2022 09:35

I think there is always a chance OP. We live on the same road as a Catholic primary school which is rated very highly and my DC got a place. We're not religious in any sense of the word and in the end we turned the place down mainly because of this aspect and DC already attending a nursery attached to a good primary school up the road.

Ragwort · 22/07/2022 09:32

Yes, my DS went to a Catholic school - we are practicing Christians but not Catholic. We had moved into the area and there was just one space in his year group - we had a chat with the Head and he did discuss faith. It was a wonderful school, we attended all the church services etc and fully respected the ethos of the school.

ivfbabymomma1 · 22/07/2022 09:20

@Kite22 I wasn't asking what my exact chances were at all! I was asking for other peoples personal experiences.

OP posts:
MrsMariaReynolds · 22/07/2022 08:33

It ready depends on a number of things, the area (like if there's another equally good non-faith school nearby that draws local families in) recent Ofsted, birth year and demographic stats--the lovely Catholic school that my son attended had a wait list a mile long when he was given a place in reception. Roll on several years later, they now have banners outside the gate advertising "places available" with lots of non Catholic families attending.

The fact of the matter is, nobody on MN can tell you if you have a hope of getting your child in, Catholic school or any school for that matter. Attend an open day in the autumn, call the local authority, figure it out.

Noodlicious · 22/07/2022 08:15

Plus at primary we all did First Holy Communion together and then later Confirmation. Both big things. If you don’t do these will your DC be ‘left out’ and how do you feel about them becoming that faith?

really don’t think you’ve considered this at all.

Mememene · 22/07/2022 08:14

Porcupineintherough · 22/07/2022 08:04

@SavoirFlair and if the Catholic school is your local school, what then?

I think if schools want to select by religion then they should be 100% funded by the religion in question.

The parents of those children are also taxpayers, so are already contributing towards the school. I know the church partially funds these schools, but don't know by how much currently.

If you allow all children over every faith and no faith to attend a Catholic school equally, and I can see the argument, then they cease to become Catholic schools because the parents would not have any interest in faith.religious activities/events/teachings etc.

I'll be honest, I'm a very lapsed Catholic, and on my divorce wanted my son to go to the same Catholic school that I did which had an excellent reputation and brilliant results. He was already baptised or both sets of devout Catholic parents would have murdered us ironically.

I moved back into the area, and having a then 2 year old, (25 now) his choice of school was a major factor in where I moved to.

But I was brought up in that faith, and could support my son in that faith until he was old enough to make his own mind up. Then he lapsed too.

But overall I think what I am saying is despite my own behaviour faith schools should be available for people who want to bring those children up in that faith as a priority. Their parents are taxpayers too.

Noodlicious · 22/07/2022 08:08

Have you actually thought about what it means for your DC to go to a Catholic school?

I was raised Catholic and went to a Catholic school in England until age 18, although this was a few years ago. We had to do things like open confession (do you know what that is?); one friend was asked to leave the school when she repeatedly refused and didn’t continue to agree with school ethos. Priests very involved with school. Church was next door to school so loads of mass like assemblies. Most socialising among the parents was with people who attended church (regular attendance). We’d sometimes be asked about the sermon on Sunday and it would be discussed in class. RE didn’t cover other religions at all as I remember. Are you happy with broader curriculum about sex ed and what will be taught etc.

i’d describe myself as agnostic now and not saying I had a bad experience at school as I enjoyed it, but it’s not what my DC are doing.

Each school is different but I think you really need to do some research.

Porcupineintherough · 22/07/2022 08:04

@SavoirFlair and if the Catholic school is your local school, what then?

I think if schools want to select by religion then they should be 100% funded by the religion in question.

Mememene · 22/07/2022 07:58

SavoirFlair · 22/07/2022 05:32

Being Catholic will always trump every other criteria

Exactly. And personally I don’t see anything wrong with a Catholic school prioritising Catholic children.

people could always send their children to the local school?

No nor me, plus the church partially funds these schools which releases local authority/government money to go on non Catholic schools.

I sent my son to a Catholic primary, godamn awful teacher started who didn't understand OCD or autism, nearly destroyed him after 5 extremely successful years there. Eight children were pulled from that previously oversubscribed school in that class in that year which spoke volumes towards the behaviour of that bullying teacher.

I moved him to an agnostic school, still in the catchment who were totally and utterly amazing with him. He thrived there again.

In secondary, he started at the agnostic feeder school, but was bullied there by other children, the head was amazing I have to say, moved him to a Catholic Secondary who again were fabulous.

So have had good and bad in both unfortunately.

Desert76 · 22/07/2022 07:47

This depends on so many things.

I would say things that are hopeful signs are:

Living in a more rural area so the school has a very wide catchment - lack of free school transport for faith schools might lead to catholic parents choosing a closer, non RC school.

Availability of other good schools locally, which might mean some catholic parents choosing a different school.

It being a relatively low birth rate year in your local area.

Some faith schools put baptised children of other Christian denominations who wish for a catholic education slightly higher up the admissions criteria, so check this.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/07/2022 07:31

sashh · 22/07/2022 06:02

Again you need to look at the admissions criteria. Then you need to talk to the school.

The (secondary) school I attended merged with the one my brother attended but their current admissions criteria gives priority to children from another town's RC primary above distance.

OP I would NEVER send a child to an RC school, look carefully at the school before you do. Ofsted inspect schools but the RC curriculum is inspected by someone appointed by the governors.

Exactly. And personally I don’t see anything wrong with a Catholic school prioritising Catholic children.

I do. I pay taxes, that money should not go to fund a faith school. In the days when the schools were 50% funded by the faith they belonged to there was an argument for saying the children would need to attend school anyway, but now 90% comes from the government that no longer stands.

You seem a little confused by the concept of Section 48 inspections. It doesn't matter what faith it is, Section 48 of the Education Act 2005 places a duty on the board of governors of a school that is deemed religious in character to inspect any denominational education and the content of the collective worship. If it's a maintained school, it's the responsibility of the board of governors to arrange for inspection - the actual faith/denomination is immaterial, the Statutory requirement is for all schools of religious character.

In Church of England and Methodist schools, this is called a SIAMS inspection carried out with the input of the Diocese.

In RC schools, it's called a Section 48 (no need for a fancy name) and is carried out with the input of the Diocese.

It's exactly the same in Hindu, Muslim or any other faith school - the inspectors are appointed by the board of governors and usually in conjunction with the religious organisation/faith body that is consistent with the religious character of the school.

As it is, the GAG is largely taken up with staffing costs/ever increasing utility bills/catering and the faith body, where they own or hold the land/buildings, pays for things such as major repairs, legally required fire safety works, temporary classrooms, etc. Schools can also hold private (audited) accounts as result of things such as premises hire, fundraising, donations and legacies; that's the sort of thing that pays for libraries, new play equipment, activities, minibuses, etc.

It's easy to say that government pays for everything in maintained faith schools. The reality is that they really don't.

As a side note, the RC church recognises baptisms made in the trinitarian tradition (father, son, holy ghost), as does the CofE and any other member church/group in Churches Together in England, an ecumenical association. As such, Canon Law means that if a child baptised in that way goes on to take their First Holy Communion, they are Catholic. They are not CofE going through the motions to get a place at an RC secondary, they are Catholic from that moment onwards. Perhaps this might make a difference to some people?

Louise0701 · 22/07/2022 07:25

@ldontWanna so if you lived near a Muslim school that had good results, small class sizes and good behaviour; you’d try to get your child in there and be happy for them to be an active part of all religious holidays and practises and join all the prayers?
You’d be happy; as parents, to attend religious services held within school and happy to confirm on entry that you will raise your school believing in and conforming to in the Muslim ethos of the school?

balalake · 22/07/2022 07:17

Check the admissions criteria as stated. Many Catholic schools indeed all I have ever come across (teachers in the family all now retired though) have had non-Catholics.

There are those who 'rediscover' their faith upon having children and then becoming non-practicing once their children leave school, a separate issue.

MissGlitterSparkles · 22/07/2022 07:13

Very much depends on the catchment. There is a catholic school in our village, Ofsted outstanding with a very good reputation. Admission criteria has 8 criteria on it. I won’t go through the list, but in effect if you are a non catholic and live next door to the school - a catholic child who lives 5 miles away will get in as priority over your child. And this often happens. They don’t even accept practising CoE families - they would be in priority 8. It is very very unusual for a non catholic child to get a space in this school. The local catholic church is also always very busy with young families drumming up the necessary ‘points’ to qualify for the school!

sashh · 22/07/2022 06:02

ivfbabymomma1 · 21/07/2022 22:14

And if location comes in to it as in 2 minutes away. I know no one can tell me as it depends of the area, I know this. I was looking for some hope that some children out there got accepted without being baptised.

Again you need to look at the admissions criteria. Then you need to talk to the school.

The (secondary) school I attended merged with the one my brother attended but their current admissions criteria gives priority to children from another town's RC primary above distance.

OP I would NEVER send a child to an RC school, look carefully at the school before you do. Ofsted inspect schools but the RC curriculum is inspected by someone appointed by the governors.

Exactly. And personally I don’t see anything wrong with a Catholic school prioritising Catholic children.

I do. I pay taxes, that money should not go to fund a faith school. In the days when the schools were 50% funded by the faith they belonged to there was an argument for saying the children would need to attend school anyway, but now 90% comes from the government that no longer stands.

SavoirFlair · 22/07/2022 05:32

RelativePitch · 22/07/2022 00:56

My DS2 is at an outstanding Catholic school and for 12 years it's been just over half Catholic, so if you were non Catholic and lived fairly close by, your child stood a good chance. However next year it's all Catholic. Fairly gutting for non Catholic familea who wanted younger siblings to join their older siblings already there. Being Catholic will always trump every other criteria.

Being Catholic will always trump every other criteria

Exactly. And personally I don’t see anything wrong with a Catholic school prioritising Catholic children.

people could always send their children to the local school?

RelativePitch · 22/07/2022 00:56

My DS2 is at an outstanding Catholic school and for 12 years it's been just over half Catholic, so if you were non Catholic and lived fairly close by, your child stood a good chance. However next year it's all Catholic. Fairly gutting for non Catholic familea who wanted younger siblings to join their older siblings already there. Being Catholic will always trump every other criteria.

Bbqchicken · 22/07/2022 00:41

Also if somone is prepared to move house to get their child into a certain school, that child is likely going to achieve well just because they would have the influence and support from home. Ie you aren't going to move house if you really didn't care if your child failed.

Bbqchicken · 22/07/2022 00:32

Mememene · 21/07/2022 23:52

So are you saying they DO have better results but it's because the parents situations are the reason?

I'm going back a couple of decades but the high standards of the local schools, both Catholic and non Religious had parents moving into the catchment area to get their kids into them.

Not necessarily, although it is possibly a factor, but their upbringing and the values of religion taught since birth, yes. Lots of information out there on it.

Kite22 · 21/07/2022 23:54

Yes, YABU to think that all of us strangers on the internet, can tell you how likely it is your child will get into a school which could be any area of the Country, when we don't know the admissions criteria.

Mememene · 21/07/2022 23:52

Bbqchicken · 21/07/2022 23:46

Academic research has consistently made clear that religious schools don't in fact perform any better than other schools, when the background of the pupils is considered.

So are you saying they DO have better results but it's because the parents situations are the reason?

I'm going back a couple of decades but the high standards of the local schools, both Catholic and non Religious had parents moving into the catchment area to get their kids into them.

jayho · 21/07/2022 23:52

older DS had an in-year transfer so the faith thing was not much of an issue (raised Catholic but not practicing) I was asked to make a commitment to the Catholic ethos of the school - which wasn't difficult to be honest, be kind, be honest, share love - I feel fortunate he's at this school regardless of denomination. younger got in on the sibling rule

demokitty · 21/07/2022 23:49

Take a look on your county council website and you should be able to find out how places for each school were allocated. Where I live you would have very little chance of getting your child into the local catholic school. Even if you lived next door to it, they would give the place to child who has been baptised catholic and has a signed certificate by the church to say the attend regularly who lives 5 miles away!

If you're in Surrey here is the link for how school places are allocated.

www.surreycc.gov.uk/schools-and-learning/schools/admissions/arrangements-and-outcomes/previous-years

Bbqchicken · 21/07/2022 23:46

Academic research has consistently made clear that religious schools don't in fact perform any better than other schools, when the background of the pupils is considered.

Mememene · 21/07/2022 23:32

Louise0701 · 21/07/2022 23:18

@Bbqchicken agree!! I genuinely do not understand people like @Icouldabeenalawyer who go to great lengths to get their children into a Catholic school when they aren’t Catholic / have no intention of practising. I wouldn’t send my children to a Jewish/Muslim school because we aren’t Jewish or Muslim. It makes no sense whatsoever.

If the schoo! Is

A. On the doorstep
B. A higher standard of school\education\results

Then I get it, but I'd be annoyed if those parents objected to their non Catholic children going to mass on Holy Days of Obligation or other religious events during the school day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread