Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Catholic school admissions

85 replies

ivfbabymomma1 · 21/07/2022 21:41

Hi all

Does anyones children go to a catholic school when they aren't catholic?

My son is christened CofE but there is a really good catholic primary school 2 minutes walk from my house...

So I have a chance?

Thank you!!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VerifiedBot2351 · 23/07/2022 12:46

I used to work in a Catholic school. It was about 20% Catholic.

ivfbabymomma1 · 23/07/2022 12:39

@Noodlicious thank you!!!! Honestly I'm
Totally aware that no one's experience will be like mine! I was just interested! I will definitely research further into the religious side of it!

Thanks all

OP posts:
sashh · 23/07/2022 06:21

I'm a couple of years older than you and also In a Catholic school in the 80,s my point was that Catholic school ,s have changed a lot since we were at school ,my son gets taught about all religions ,his RE teacher was Muslim!,you were telling the Op to do her research whilst recounting your own very outdated experience of a Catholic school.

But it varies so much.

I went tot he RC girls' school, my brother went to the RC boys' school in the same town.

My brother said a prayer at the start and end of the day. He was taught 'scripture' to O Level.

I had prayer or assembly first thing and mass on Fridays. Before lunch there was 'the angelus bell' so we all said the angelus before the lunch break.
We had 'hymns' as a lesson where we learned new hymns or new tunes.
We had prayer before we went home.
My O Level RE was a specific to RC doctrine.

Yes that was the 1980s, but there is still a variety in what different schools teach. And things that should be secular are still often taught through the lens of the faith eg there were machines to buy sanitary towels but not tampons. Sex education was none existent other than doing a project on marriage and where was a good place to find a husband.

NSS has reported something like 70% of faith schools teach SRE according tot he faith of the school.

www.secularism.org.uk/news/2018/05/most-faith-schools-distorting-sex-education-nss-study-finds

Nat6999 · 22/07/2022 20:53

Ds did, it was the best supposedly good school near where we lived. It was the biggest mistake I ever made, the school wasn't a good fit, too much time was spent on religion & not enough on the curriculum. All the Catholic parents & children knew each other from church & many of the parents were former pupils, we were treated as outsiders

LadyApplejack · 22/07/2022 20:22

For non-Catholic I think it'll just boil down to whether it's oversubscribed. If it isn't you'll probably get straight in, especially being local and C of E. If it is busy, who knows?

We were recommended a site called Locrating which has various school stats including over-subscription numbers and heat maps of children who attend etc.

BlackAndPinkNose · 22/07/2022 20:12

OP I would urge you and anyone who is thinking about a Catholic school to really understand what a Catholic education entails.

The school I work in has the Catholic ethos running throughout EVERYTHING.

The day starts with a prayer and there are prayers before and after lunch; Tutor time includes gospel readings; there is termly mass; they make their confirmation together and the preparation for this is included in the school lessons; there are crucifixes in every room and a chapel on site.

x2boys · 22/07/2022 20:10

Noodlicious · 22/07/2022 19:49

Open confession is not in a confessional box and there is no anonymity. Priest(s) seated at the front of the altar, kids brought out of the pews and lined up. You go up individually, 2 metres from the person behind you.

No idea why people are so snarky on MN, or very Christian is it. I could equally write, ‘well your son’s experience is nothing like mine!‘ with the requisite passive aggressive exclamation mark. I don’t presume everyone’s experience is the same but given OP is not even Catholic posed the questions as kinda useful to know what you’re potentially signing up for when you have no idea. I’m mid 40’s so talking about school in the 80’s and 90’s. My experience is not unique to several other Catholic schools in the area at that time.

I'm a couple of years older than you and also In a Catholic school in the 80,s my point was that Catholic school ,s have changed a lot since we were at school ,my son gets taught about all religions ,his RE teacher was Muslim!,you were telling the Op to do her research whilst recounting your own very outdated experience of a Catholic school.

ChuckBerrysBoots · 22/07/2022 19:55

Our local Catholic school is only about 30% baptised Catholic. Great school, very undersubscribed. So non-catholics get in pretty easily. But in other areas unless you meet the church attendance criteria (so not just baptised but baptised and having attended regular mass for an extended period of time, to be signed off by the parish) you haven’t a hope of getting in.

Councils usually publish a breakdown of how many children got in under each criteria in previous years, so you can make an informed decision about how likely you are to get a place.

Noodlicious · 22/07/2022 19:49

Open confession is not in a confessional box and there is no anonymity. Priest(s) seated at the front of the altar, kids brought out of the pews and lined up. You go up individually, 2 metres from the person behind you.

No idea why people are so snarky on MN, or very Christian is it. I could equally write, ‘well your son’s experience is nothing like mine!‘ with the requisite passive aggressive exclamation mark. I don’t presume everyone’s experience is the same but given OP is not even Catholic posed the questions as kinda useful to know what you’re potentially signing up for when you have no idea. I’m mid 40’s so talking about school in the 80’s and 90’s. My experience is not unique to several other Catholic schools in the area at that time.

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 22/07/2022 19:49

I remember reading a thread on here from someone who sent their child to a Cof E infant/junior school. She wasn't a Christian but it was the best school around.

She then had the brass neck to come on here complaining that her child was 'forced' to sing hymns etc and asking for advice on how she could force the school to keep him out of assembly or anything else that had a religious flavour about, "The Sky Fairy"-as she called God in her post.

I sincerely hope the school opened the door, told her-and her child- to step through it and fuck off.

What will you do OP when the Catholic faith is taught?

liverpoolnana · 22/07/2022 19:29

I, too, am puzzled by a PP's reference to 'open confession'. I am wondering if they are referring to confession aka the 'Sacrament of Reconciliation' being celebrated in various corners of the Assembly Hall (for instance ) rather than in the box in church. Surely the reason for this practice growing in recent years is obvious?

Yodaisawally · 22/07/2022 18:59

Dts are at catholic primary and it is over subscribed.

Criteria are

LAC and previously LAC (any or no religion)
Baptised siblings
Baptised children on distance
Other christened children on distance
Other religions on distance

In our school they never get past baptised children on distance

x2boys · 22/07/2022 15:58

Noodlicious · 22/07/2022 08:15

Plus at primary we all did First Holy Communion together and then later Confirmation. Both big things. If you don’t do these will your DC be ‘left out’ and how do you feel about them becoming that faith?

really don’t think you’ve considered this at all.

Only around half my sons class too their first communion and the teachings were all after school so there was no leaving out
I think some people have a very outdated view of Catholic schools.

x2boys · 22/07/2022 15:54

Noodlicious · 22/07/2022 08:08

Have you actually thought about what it means for your DC to go to a Catholic school?

I was raised Catholic and went to a Catholic school in England until age 18, although this was a few years ago. We had to do things like open confession (do you know what that is?); one friend was asked to leave the school when she repeatedly refused and didn’t continue to agree with school ethos. Priests very involved with school. Church was next door to school so loads of mass like assemblies. Most socialising among the parents was with people who attended church (regular attendance). We’d sometimes be asked about the sermon on Sunday and it would be discussed in class. RE didn’t cover other religions at all as I remember. Are you happy with broader curriculum about sex ed and what will be taught etc.

i’d describe myself as agnostic now and not saying I had a bad experience at school as I enjoyed it, but it’s not what my DC are doing.

Each school is different but I think you really need to do some research.

I wentbto a Catholic convnt primary school in thec70,s and 80,s ww never did open confession ,either in primary or secondary school ,there was a Chapel attached to the convent so we did attend Mass fairly often ,but my Catholic secondary school was just like any secondary school ,apart from a prayer and hymn in assembly ,
My sin goes to a Catholic school and its nothing like you describe either!

fiftiesmum · 22/07/2022 15:48

As most Catholic schools will prioritize practising Catholics then baptized Catholics over others for admission then spare places could mean falling numbers of Catholics in the catchment area, withdrawal of transport in the outer catchment parishes or as in the case of my DC's primary school a fall in standards

Halfpint737 · 22/07/2022 15:08

The only thing that trumps being catholic is having a. EHCP then you have to get a place.
I went to a catholic primary and secondary school . Primary school was amazing. We all made out first holy communion together at a special service in the church, then went for a tea at the school afterwards. It was a d still is a very small school, one class a year.
Secondary school very strict on criteria, I was interviewed separately from my parents to check our stories matched and that was in spite of my sister already attending the school. I got in

tiggergoesbounce · 22/07/2022 14:38

Our DS's Catholic School is really popular and has no problems filling the spaces for the Catholic Children, with lots on a waiting list. But they have to or opt to take in 5% non religious apparently.
Our DS's friend is non religious and got a place.

Electriq · 22/07/2022 14:34

Oh and to add I'm in London.

Electriq · 22/07/2022 14:32

And whilst he does have to sit in through mass etc
The school make it clear that if you have no religion or practice another religion, that you sit quietly through it.

Electriq · 22/07/2022 14:31

My dc attends a Catholic school and is of no religion, they were very clear that Catholic Children would be given places over children of no religion, but they welcome other religions and those of no religion.

warmeduppizza · 22/07/2022 14:27

If the school’s criterion is baptism, you are meeting that criterion. There is no such thing as being baptised a Roman Catholic, just being baptised by a Roman Catholic priest. Baptism is baptism.
Just make sure you are comfortable with the ethos and atmosphere of the school.

Smurftastic · 22/07/2022 14:13

It really depends on the school in question. My DC is starting reception this September, although we did consider a Catholic school, DC is starting in our local non-denominational school instead. We liked one Catholic school a lot, it is undersubscribed and lovely, but out of our area and I don't want to commit to driving for what would end up as an hour a day. They have 50% Catholic children.

There is a local Catholic school as well, but it backs onto the Church, most children are Catholic, they spend an hour every Thursday attending mass etc. I decided I am not 'Catholic enough' to want my DC spending that much time in Church! They both have better results than our local school though.

PassMeThePineapple · 22/07/2022 14:03

ivfbabymomma1 · 21/07/2022 22:12

I do know their admissions criteria! It says catholic children will be given the first spots and if there's spaces left they will go to non baptised children but I was just asking what the chances are of getting a spot on this basis. Just looking for other peoples experiences really, any positive stories etc

Even in the same town it can vary. In a town near me there's a highly regarded girls' Catholic secondary school which has strict criteria. Priority is given to those baptised the youngest. There's another Catholic mixed secondary which is not popular and anyone could get in

ivfbabymomma1 · 22/07/2022 13:42

Thank you to everyone who gave me a reply - really appreciate it.

OP posts:
ldontWanna · 22/07/2022 12:29

Louise0701 · 22/07/2022 07:25

@ldontWanna so if you lived near a Muslim school that had good results, small class sizes and good behaviour; you’d try to get your child in there and be happy for them to be an active part of all religious holidays and practises and join all the prayers?
You’d be happy; as parents, to attend religious services held within school and happy to confirm on entry that you will raise your school believing in and conforming to in the Muslim ethos of the school?

I was giving you a reason why some people might want a Catholic school. DD does attend one, but she is baptised Catholic,goes to church and is being raised in the faith.

I wouldn't pick a Muslim school no matter how great it was because it is quite far removed from our lifestyles and beliefs. I was raised Christian Orthodox, since there aren't any churches of that faith in my area and the Catholic church is 2 minutes away from house and very closely related to what I know(including the prayers) it was the obvious choice and the transition was very smooth.