Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what else to do with DM racist comment?

209 replies

FluffingMarvellous · 21/07/2022 21:29

I'm utterly shocked.

Sat watching the news with DM and she randomly comes out with "I hope Rishi Sunak doesn't get PM as it would be awful to have a Muslim PM".

I was so shocked I just stared at her and said "That's completely racist, you can't say that!"

She then said "No its not really. It's political. If he got it, the Muslims would take over the country".

I was completely appalled, told her never to say anything like that to me and certainly not to the children but she just didn't get it.

DM has MH issues so it's v hard to challenge her on anything or it can turn quite nasty. But I still feel like I should have done more, I just don't know what as she's still my DM but I'm so shocked. She's never said anything like that in front of me before although I know she does have some very strongly pro Brexit ideas which almost verge on being anti non British people, but never explicit and only in line with other strongly pro Brexit people (which I'm not here to start a debate about).

Haven't told DH as would literally ban her from ever coming in the house again.

OP posts:
5zeds · 22/07/2022 08:31

Tony Blair waited to convert to Catholicism till after he left office. Catholics cannot be PM because their of their allegiance to Rome and because the prime minister helps (?) choose the high ups in the Church of England by chatting to the monarch about them.
Boris was born a Catholic but converted to C of E (I think). Camilla is also Catholic I think but too old to have any pesky Catholic princes.

Discovereads · 22/07/2022 08:09

Ggu · 22/07/2022 05:12

Rishi Sunak isn't Muslim

Yes I know that. Your point?

Berlinlover · 22/07/2022 07:15

Qwertysfine · 22/07/2022 03:00

Tony Blair was always open about being Catholic. His children went to a Catholic Secondary School.

He spoke to Pope Benedict about converting to Catholicism within days of leaving Number 10, so clearly felt it wasn’t possible as Prime Minister.

Notateacheranymore · 22/07/2022 06:27

As an aside, it was my understanding that it was not legal for this country to have a Catholic PM. But then, we appear to have had one by stealth!!

I am atheist so don’t want a PM of any religion, but then I know several people plus some on here that don’t relish a PM of any religion either, including their own, because of the risk of exploitation, either personally or through coercion by religious leaders. The secretive nature of the below is BJ all over.

Link won’t paste! From yahoo! 18 June 2021.

“Great Britain has its 1st Catholic prime minister, to the great surprise of most Britons

British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, in the office since 2019, "recently came out as Catholic, to the concern of British Catholics, some parish priests, and parliamentarians," and to the surprise of even some of his closest political allies, Catherine Pepinster reports at Religion News Service. Johnson was baptized Roman Catholic, his mother's religion, but was confirmed in the Church of England at Eton and is not generally known to be a churchgoing man.

On May 29, though, Johnson married his longtime girlfriend Carrie Symonds at Westminster Cathedral, the seat of English Catholicism, and the Catholic Diocese of Westminster then declared that husband and wife were both baptized Catholics and Westminster Cathedral parishioners. (Symonds is Johnson's third wife, but they were allowed to wed in the divorce-hostile Catholic Church because Johnson's first two weddings were civil and thus not recognized as valid under canon law, Pepinster explains.) The couple gave their baby son Wilfred a Catholic baptism in September.

Fairyliz · 22/07/2022 05:48

The hilarious thing about this is that most of MN would call Rishi ‘scum’ for being a Tory. Apparently that’s perfectly fine but being racist is appalling.
Perhaps everyone needs to be more tolerant and actually listen to other people and find out why they hold different views. Try and change their views by reasoned argument rather than immediately cut them off.

JudithandHolofernesHead · 22/07/2022 05:28

My step-mum-in-law is racist and homophobic. She calls people "coloured" and believes she can "catch the gay". She was horrified when a gay couple of diverse heritage moved in next door. My father-in-law is a live and let live liberal so we were surprised when he decided to marry her. He, my DH, me and my DD are always telling her she can't say this or that but she won't change.

She is entitled to her opinion of course but there's free speech and then there's having respect for others. She gets on with her neighbours and even cat-sits for them now but she still calls one of them a disgusting name behind his back because he's not white.

Ggu · 22/07/2022 05:12

Discovereads · 21/07/2022 23:22

I don’t think it was racist but religious intolerance as she is objecting to a Muslim PM. Still wrong, but not racism. But if you ask her, what if Liz Truss were Muslim? And she says “well that’s alright then” then you’d be able to say she was being both religiously intolerant and racist.

Rishi Sunak isn't Muslim

fallfallfall · 22/07/2022 04:54

genuine question many people share their inner thoughts with family.
i agree some thoughts are not politically correct but if a person can't speak freely with said family and then have a conversation to discuss where that person is coming from who can they talk to? the priest?
many people fear the unknown and people who they see as different.
can you not just say a little something and help her along with her cultural education?

Tandora · 22/07/2022 04:53

picklemewalnuts · 21/07/2022 21:53

If you make a blanket ban on say8ng things like that, you don't actually educate or change people's minds. They still think like that, just quietly.

You could answer:
He's not Muslim, anyway.
Don't you worry the Christian politicians will try and convert everyone?
Why do you think a Muslim prime minister would make the country Muslim?
Do you think everyone that's dark skinned must be Muslim?
Why does that scare you?

Etc.

If you actually talk about it, she'll get to explain what she's really worried about and expose her irrational ideas to disinfecting sunshine.

'Shut up, that's bigoted!' Is such an unhelpful trap we've fallen into these days.

This. It would be much more helpful to talk to her about her ideas, and help her see her see and understand her own prejudice, than shut her down for being a racist. Unfortunately a lot of people think this way, it doesn’t help to be outraged and shocked.

Krabapple · 22/07/2022 04:42

It’s not sexist to ask for female care workers, especially when there is an element of personal care involved. I have requested it for dim in the past. As a manager it would be easier to just change it up this

Krabapple · 22/07/2022 04:37

hesttreat · 21/07/2022 21:45

Having MH issues doesn't make you a racist!

I think op means it makes it harder to challenge her.

Plopplopboogey · 22/07/2022 03:28

Sorry have just seen the posts saying he’s actually Hindu (or was raised as such). I thought what the OP’s mum said was based on knowledge that she had of him being Muslim. If she was actually just assuming his religion based on what he looks like, then yeah, racist.

ImustLearn2Cook · 22/07/2022 03:28

@FluffingMarvellous I have read all your posts but not the full thread.

How does your mum feel about other religions that have elements of being the only true religion, a history of converting people and a history of influencing society to fit in with the core beliefs of that religion such as Christianity?

Some people strongly believe that religion and politics should be kept separate and that is completely different from racism.

Some people have a strong belief that religious and spiritual beliefs are a personal decision and should be kept to yourself and not forced onto other people who have their own beliefs.

And some people have had negative experiences of other people trying to convert them to such and such religion. So they develop a distrust of all fundamentalist religions whether they be Muslim or Christian etc.

Maybe get to the bottom of what she really believes before labelling her a racist. It is a very serious accusation to make. You could be right and she might be racist. But just make sure that that really is the case before you label her.

Qwertysfine · 22/07/2022 03:26

I don't think he shouted about it but I certainly remember it being mentioned at the time and he sent his children to Catholic school

Plopplopboogey · 22/07/2022 03:20

If I remember correctly, Tony Blair didn’t officially become a Catholic until after his term ended.

Plopplopboogey · 22/07/2022 03:19

To all the people saying it’s racist, Muslim isn’t a race. She’s actually being Islamophobic.

Personally I wouldn’t want anybody with strong religious views of any sort to be the PM as I think it might cloud their judgement. But I don’t know anything about Rishi’s beliefs or lack thereof. I just don’t like him because of his policies.

Qwertysfine · 22/07/2022 03:00

Tony Blair was always open about being Catholic. His children went to a Catholic Secondary School.

fUNNYfACE36 · 22/07/2022 02:22

I think op, that people are allowed their own opinions however odious you may find them.You are not the thought police

fUNNYfACE36 · 22/07/2022 02:20

Tania64 · 21/07/2022 21:55

When I worked in social care I had a client that had been raped by a black man. As a result she didn't want any black male support workers to support her. Do you think that this was 'blatant racism' & I should have told her she must accept whoever I send to support her??

I think , yes. The care company would have been behaving in a racist, sexist and probably unlawful manner in acceding to this request

powershowerforanhour · 22/07/2022 00:38

"I'm afraid all four of my children's grandparent hold views similar to this. We are not about to cut off the whole family, but we made it clear that things were not to be said in front of the children."

That's the most important thing I think. Your mother is racist. You aren't. So in your family, the racism will die out, as long as you do your best to stop your children getting infected by avoiding exposure to it at a young age and "vaccinating" them by teaching them to think critically when they're old enough, so that they can successfully fend off any toxic attitudes from peers and orhers who had the misfortune to be raised racist. If this situation is replicated on a population level then the "R number" will be <1 and, in the end, racism will be extinct or at least struggle along at a much lower level.

It's great to hurry up the racism extinction process by helping turn those who can be helped, or at least trying to turn the racism down a little notch or two from whatever "level" they started at (ie maybe still a carrier but at least shedding fewer racism particles??) but I think the most important thing is protecting/arming children against it, to keep the population shifting towards racism-free.

Govesdancingpartner · 22/07/2022 00:32

I have an Asian friend who said she was afraid Rishi would not be elected because of his race.
I hope that is not the case. I am voting for him because I think he is the best candidate. I thought racism was long gone but obviously not in all walks of life.
Sorry your mum thinks like that maybe you could educate her that we are all equal in race.

SammyScrounge · 22/07/2022 00:20

picklemewalnuts · 21/07/2022 21:53

If you make a blanket ban on say8ng things like that, you don't actually educate or change people's minds. They still think like that, just quietly.

You could answer:
He's not Muslim, anyway.
Don't you worry the Christian politicians will try and convert everyone?
Why do you think a Muslim prime minister would make the country Muslim?
Do you think everyone that's dark skinned must be Muslim?
Why does that scare you?

Etc.

If you actually talk about it, she'll get to explain what she's really worried about and expose her irrational ideas to disinfecting sunshine.

'Shut up, that's bigoted!' Is such an unhelpful trap we've fallen into these days.

Good post. Reasonable. Constructive.
No mother being thrown into the street.

Discovereads · 22/07/2022 00:09

wellhelloitsme · 21/07/2022 23:56

@Discovereads

We don’t actually know why she thought Rishi Sunak was a Muslim? It’s pure speculation that she’s assumed that based on his ethnicity.

What other reasons do you think would be behind her incorrect assumption about his religion?

She may


  • have been misinformed by someone else (fake news)

  • have confused him with someone else (mistaken identity)

  • have early dementia as women with poor MH are at high risk of developing it (intrusive thought with no filter)

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 22/07/2022 00:06

Berlinlover · 22/07/2022 00:05

Why?

I went into that upthread. The "serving a foreign master" trope.

Berlinlover · 22/07/2022 00:05

5zeds · 21/07/2022 23:55

A Catholic being prime minister is very much frowned on.

Why?

Swipe left for the next trending thread