Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what else to do with DM racist comment?

209 replies

FluffingMarvellous · 21/07/2022 21:29

I'm utterly shocked.

Sat watching the news with DM and she randomly comes out with "I hope Rishi Sunak doesn't get PM as it would be awful to have a Muslim PM".

I was so shocked I just stared at her and said "That's completely racist, you can't say that!"

She then said "No its not really. It's political. If he got it, the Muslims would take over the country".

I was completely appalled, told her never to say anything like that to me and certainly not to the children but she just didn't get it.

DM has MH issues so it's v hard to challenge her on anything or it can turn quite nasty. But I still feel like I should have done more, I just don't know what as she's still my DM but I'm so shocked. She's never said anything like that in front of me before although I know she does have some very strongly pro Brexit ideas which almost verge on being anti non British people, but never explicit and only in line with other strongly pro Brexit people (which I'm not here to start a debate about).

Haven't told DH as would literally ban her from ever coming in the house again.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 22/07/2022 13:37

"I hope no Muslim is exposed to you and your friends’ racism."

Yet we have to accept the sexism from Islam. As well as homophobia etc. As a woman I will defend my right to speak out against some of Islamic teachings. As I would fundamental Christians. It's irrelevant because Sunak is a Hindu, as said. It is political and it's fine to express concerns that any leader will be influenced by their religious beliefs. During Covid the Muslim council was under fire for not addressing that services for women stopped but not men, during Covid. There's been Muslim men standing for councils etc who didn't think that women needed to vote as an individual. Why should we ignore some of the issues within Islam?
It is wrong that she assumed his religion based on colour. The region his Parents/GPs are from are predominantly Christian.

SammyScrounge · 22/07/2022 13:32

phishy · 22/07/2022 13:08

This idea that Muslims always have to be respectful in the face of racism is very damaging.

Don’t hold Muslims to higher standards.

Who said they have to be respectful in the face of racism?

What I was commenting on is the awful proposed treatment of your own mothers and fathers eg banned from your house forever, thrown out into the street and so on. Some are competing to demonstrate the ferocity of their committment to anti racism feelings. That's just showy virtue signalling.
And that treatment of elderly relatives would shock a Muslim.

LadyKenya · 22/07/2022 13:30

phishy · 22/07/2022 13:20

@hattie43

MN is a different planet to the one I'm on , all this self flagellation for the most basic of statements . Mum says something you don't like / agree with hell just move on . Happens everyday of the week , no-one I know would bat an eyelid over such a thing .

Despicable. I hope no Muslim is exposed to you and your friends’ racism.

And this is why racism will always exist. Because too many people are not bothered by it, because it does not affect them, so they are ok with not challenging it when they hear such comments. Many are racist themselves anyway.

LadyKenya · 22/07/2022 13:27

Fairyliz · 22/07/2022 05:48

The hilarious thing about this is that most of MN would call Rishi ‘scum’ for being a Tory. Apparently that’s perfectly fine but being racist is appalling.
Perhaps everyone needs to be more tolerant and actually listen to other people and find out why they hold different views. Try and change their views by reasoned argument rather than immediately cut them off.

Having the view that black, or brown people are inferior is never ok, or understandable to me. Neither should it be to anyone else.

hattie43 · 22/07/2022 13:25

@phishy

I'm not referring to Muslims I'm talking about the OP turning herself into ridiculous knots about something her mum is supposed to have said .

crwnhgow · 22/07/2022 13:23

Discovereads · 22/07/2022 09:15

It’s speculation that she assumed his religion based on his race.
Yes she was mistaken, but she genuinely believed he was a Muslim.
Her objection was to the religion she thought he was, not his race
So she was definitely being religiously intolerant/Islamaphobic
We don’t know for sure if she is also racist.

Why would she assume he's a Muslim then?

phishy · 22/07/2022 13:20

@hattie43

MN is a different planet to the one I'm on , all this self flagellation for the most basic of statements . Mum says something you don't like / agree with hell just move on . Happens everyday of the week , no-one I know would bat an eyelid over such a thing .

Despicable. I hope no Muslim is exposed to you and your friends’ racism.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 22/07/2022 13:14

That should read to yourself, thanks autocorrect!
Although up yourself works too 😁

GoodJanetBadJanet · 22/07/2022 13:13

Happens everyday of the week , no-one I know would bat an eyelid over such a thing
Maybe you and your mates /family wouldn't bat an eyelid over such a thing, but some of us do care about racism.
I just don't want to fucking hear it, and if I do hear it I try and call it out as much as I can.
Not to be "self flagellating" 🙄 , have your opinions by all means, but if it's racist shit keep it up yourself.

phishy · 22/07/2022 13:08

SammyScrounge · 22/07/2022 00:05

Muslims would probably be more respectful of someone her age than many of you.

This idea that Muslims always have to be respectful in the face of racism is very damaging.

Don’t hold Muslims to higher standards.

BrettIsHot · 22/07/2022 13:02

zingally · 22/07/2022 12:16

My late dad would have probably said something broadly similar. Perhaps not as overtly racist, but very similar. His thing was always to dress it up in a joke, so people would never quite know if he was serious or not.

I actually find these types the most repulsive. What a cunt.

ilovesooty · 22/07/2022 13:00

no one I know would bat an eyelid over such a thing

Thankfully I know very few people who would find that sort of comment acceptable.

5zeds · 22/07/2022 12:46

His thing was always to dress it up in a joke, so people would never quite know if he was serious or not.
we all know.

zingally · 22/07/2022 12:16

My late dad would have probably said something broadly similar. Perhaps not as overtly racist, but very similar. His thing was always to dress it up in a joke, so people would never quite know if he was serious or not.

hattie43 · 22/07/2022 11:54

Jossfromtenko · 22/07/2022 09:32

This thread is so disingenuous. I do not believe for one minute the OP needed guidance. I do not believe for one minute the outpouring of hatred in return is genuine, it's just a way for people to feel like they are good people. Anyone who suggests this may not be the biggest deal since sliced bread is bullied and name called. No wonder the internet relies on these posters to make people.laugh about how sad and narrow people's lives are.

Totally agree .

MN is a different planet to the one I'm on , all this self flagellation for the most basic of statements . Mum says something you don't like / agree with hell just move on . Happens everyday of the week , no-one I know would bat an eyelid over such a thing .

FluffingMarvellous · 22/07/2022 11:45

Jossfromtenko · 22/07/2022 09:32

This thread is so disingenuous. I do not believe for one minute the OP needed guidance. I do not believe for one minute the outpouring of hatred in return is genuine, it's just a way for people to feel like they are good people. Anyone who suggests this may not be the biggest deal since sliced bread is bullied and name called. No wonder the internet relies on these posters to make people.laugh about how sad and narrow people's lives are.

How can you have disingenuity in an AIBU thread @JoJossfromtenko ? This wasn't posted on a "Help" thread asking for guidance. It was posted on an OPINIONS thread asking should I have reacted more strongly and done more. Because I kept going over the incident in my mind, felt really pretty upset by it and couldn't talk to my DH about it because, as stated, he would ban my DM from the house which I felt is inappropriate. No disingenuity there.

If you have a different opinion and believe people should be free to go around saying the type of thing my DM said, you're free to. Personally, I think it's sickening. However the angle of my question was to get perspective and reflect on if my reaction was the correct one or not. I've had some very helpful comments from posters giving perspective on how racism and religious fear are not necessarily the same thing, and also on other ways to approach this situation which I have acted on.

OP posts:
FluffingMarvellous · 22/07/2022 11:36

ImustLearn2Cook · 22/07/2022 03:28

@FluffingMarvellous I have read all your posts but not the full thread.

How does your mum feel about other religions that have elements of being the only true religion, a history of converting people and a history of influencing society to fit in with the core beliefs of that religion such as Christianity?

Some people strongly believe that religion and politics should be kept separate and that is completely different from racism.

Some people have a strong belief that religious and spiritual beliefs are a personal decision and should be kept to yourself and not forced onto other people who have their own beliefs.

And some people have had negative experiences of other people trying to convert them to such and such religion. So they develop a distrust of all fundamentalist religions whether they be Muslim or Christian etc.

Maybe get to the bottom of what she really believes before labelling her a racist. It is a very serious accusation to make. You could be right and she might be racist. But just make sure that that really is the case before you label her.

@IImustLearn2Cook My DM was previously involved with precisely such a strongly converting Christian movement herself. I know she would have no issue with a very devout Christian as PM

OP posts:
FluffingMarvellous · 22/07/2022 11:34

fUNNYfACE36 · 22/07/2022 02:22

I think op, that people are allowed their own opinions however odious you may find them.You are not the thought police

@fUNNYfACE36 Do you extend this logic to paedophilia?

OP posts:
LakieLady · 22/07/2022 09:35

Qwertysfine · 22/07/2022 03:00

Tony Blair was always open about being Catholic. His children went to a Catholic Secondary School.

They went to a Catholic school because their mother is Catholic. This is the case in most families where the parents are of different religious faiths.

While Blair may have lied about his religious faith, along with so many other things, he didn't officially convert until after he left office.

Jossfromtenko · 22/07/2022 09:32

This thread is so disingenuous. I do not believe for one minute the OP needed guidance. I do not believe for one minute the outpouring of hatred in return is genuine, it's just a way for people to feel like they are good people. Anyone who suggests this may not be the biggest deal since sliced bread is bullied and name called. No wonder the internet relies on these posters to make people.laugh about how sad and narrow people's lives are.

Discovereads · 22/07/2022 09:15

Namechanger355 · 22/07/2022 08:53

Isn’t that the point

he isn’t Muslim - she is just assuming he is because of his skin colour

she is making a value judgment based on the above

hence she is racist

It’s speculation that she assumed his religion based on his race.
Yes she was mistaken, but she genuinely believed he was a Muslim.
Her objection was to the religion she thought he was, not his race
So she was definitely being religiously intolerant/Islamaphobic
We don’t know for sure if she is also racist.

5128gap · 22/07/2022 09:10

Fairyliz · 22/07/2022 05:48

The hilarious thing about this is that most of MN would call Rishi ‘scum’ for being a Tory. Apparently that’s perfectly fine but being racist is appalling.
Perhaps everyone needs to be more tolerant and actually listen to other people and find out why they hold different views. Try and change their views by reasoned argument rather than immediately cut them off.

Can you really not see the difference between expressing negativity about someone based on their political values, attitudes and behaviour, and expressing negativity based on their race?
I have listened to Sunak and other Tories plenty thank you, and have not changed my view about whether I would want them governing the country. Nor do I believe the answer is for me to be 'more tolerant' of a value system, priorities and decisions I believe to be wrong.

Blossomtoes · 22/07/2022 09:09

phishy · 21/07/2022 22:24

What a horrid woman. I hope Muslims and other ethnic minorities give her a wide berth.

I expect that would suit her just fine.

Namechanger355 · 22/07/2022 08:55

Fairyliz · 22/07/2022 05:48

The hilarious thing about this is that most of MN would call Rishi ‘scum’ for being a Tory. Apparently that’s perfectly fine but being racist is appalling.
Perhaps everyone needs to be more tolerant and actually listen to other people and find out why they hold different views. Try and change their views by reasoned argument rather than immediately cut them off.

This comment makes no sense

tories Are scum based on their values and track record - ie based on fact

sunak’s colour (or implied religion because she thinks he is Muslim because he is Asian) will have no bearing on his performance as a PM - to think it would is based on prejudice and not fact - hence it is racist

no I don’t need to be tolerant of racism or homophobia or any other bigotry

Namechanger355 · 22/07/2022 08:53

Discovereads · 22/07/2022 08:09

Yes I know that. Your point?

Isn’t that the point

he isn’t Muslim - she is just assuming he is because of his skin colour

she is making a value judgment based on the above

hence she is racist

Swipe left for the next trending thread